Copy
HAM-SEN-MP4/4

The University of Auckland Motorsport Club Accord: A.G.M. Part III (2023)


TERMS and CONDITIONS


The UoA-MSC Accord, in accordance with the Committee's express desire to seek not only the pathway for positive-sum precedent, but also the possibility of a globally optimal outcome, shall act as the de-facto – or 'hybrid' – Annual General Meeting (AGM-h) for academic years 2022/2023.


Retention of the Accord, being primarily prepared for UoA-MSC's Membership, indicates acceptance of the following:


  • The Club member (Member) is deemed to have attended the AGM-h digitally upon opening/read-receipt of the Accord in the contact method provided;

  • Read-receipt of the Accord is verifiable via the administrative console of the Club's Mailchimp account;

  • Member identity is verifiable by cross-referencing their personal information held by the Club with the minimal information uploaded to the Club's Mailchimp, for the Constitutional purpose of using said online service; and

  • The Club member accepts the content of the Accord as a true and accurate record the Club's hybrid Annual General Meeting.


Members who do not accept any of the terms and conditions should return the Accord to UoA-MSC immediately by way of return email or unsubscription from the Club's mailing list. Unsubscription further indicates the member's intent to cancel their respective membership status unless the Committee is otherwise advised.



A) DEFINITIONS


"Accord, The" and/or "UoA-MSC Accord" = This correspondence in full;

"AGM" = Annual General Meeting;

"AGM-h" = Hybrid Annual General Meeting;

"ANZ" = ANZ Bank New Zealand Limited;

"AUSA" = Auckland University Students Association

"AUT" = Auckland University of Technology

"AR-C-23" = Annual Report, Consolidated (2022 to 2023)

"CL" = Campus Life Directorate, The University of Auckland's;

"Committee, The" = Management Committee Members (unless stated otherwise);

"CSC" and/or "CSC-SG-CL" = Clubs Support Committee, UoA Campus Life's;

"Campus Labs / Engage" = SG-CL's student group/club/association support portal;

"ECU" = Electronic Control Unit;

"FIA" = Federation Internationale de'l Automobile

"fork-Club" = Splinter group formed by Problem-GEs;

"FSAE" = Formula student - Society of Automotive Engineers and/or UoA-FSAE;

"GE" = General Executive

"HDMP" = Hampton Downs Motorsport Park

"MSNZ" = Motorsport New Zealand

"MSC-GP" and/or "UoA-MSC-GP" = UoA Motorsport Club Grand Prix;

"OGGB" = The University of Auckland's 'Owen G. Glenn Building';

"S1" = Semester One;

"S2" = Semester Two;

"s267" and/or "ETA 2020" = Education and Training Act 2020, section 267;

"SG-CL" = Student Groups Team-Campus Life, The University of Auckland's;

"SMv1" = STATE of MOTION volume 1;

"STGP" = Spirit of the Times Grand Prix (retired title, see MSC-GP);

"Problem-GE" and/or "p-GE" = Problematic General Executives

"POA" = Playing Activities, Omissions, and Acts (SMv1 addendum);

"Te Tiriti" and/or "The Treaty" = Te Tiriti o Waitangi / The Treaty of Waitangi

"TL" = Team Lead;

"TMC" = The Motorsport Club Incorporated;

"UoA" and/or "the University" = The University of Auckland;

"UoA-CIE" = Centre for Innovation and Entrepreneurship, UoA's;

"UoA-FSAE" = The University of Auckland Formula SAE Team;

"UoA-MSC" and/or "the Club" = The University of Auckland Motorsport Club;

"UHCS" = University Health and Counselling, The University of Auckland;

"WRC" = World Rally Championship;

"WRC-RNZ" = WRC Rally New Zealand;



B) DISCLAIMER


The UoA-MSC Accord (the Accord) has been prepared by active Management Committee members (the Committee) of The University of Auckland Motorsport Club (the Club/UoA-MSC) and is copyright © The University of Auckland Motorsport Club. Report is Copyright © The University of Auckland Motorsport Club. All rights reserved. Branded materials' Copyrights are held by their respective owners and has been used for educational purposes – in good faith – under the Education and Training Act 2020 and the Copyright Act 1993. This correspondence has been written inclusively for The University of Auckland and Auckland's Academic Motoring Community for the purposes of retroactively fulfilling UoA-MSC's multivariate obligations to numerous parties, stakeholders, and each and every one of our members throughout its first Epoch (July 22, 2019 to Present Day).


Content presented in this correspondence – and associated dossiers, references and supplementary documents linked and/or attached via appendices – are not necessarily endorsed or otherwise reflect the views of the parties involved with preparing the correspondence, the University, our stakeholders, or any parties associated with UoA-MSC. Despite the Club receiving generalised guidance in areas of management, law, finance, health, information technology, cybersecurity, and motorsport; there are currently no members with professional registration in said fields that have engaged the Club directly for the purpose of the Accord's preparation.


As such, nothing in this correspondence constitutes legal, financial, medical, and/or professional advice. This correspondence does not purport to contain all information that any party interested in the playing activities of UoA-MSC may require. In all cases, interested parties should conduct their own investigation, analysis and verification of the information contained in this correspondence.


UoA-MSC's Management Committee, makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in this correspondence. None of UoA-MSC's members shall have any liability for any statements, opinions, information or matters (expressed or implied) arising out of, contained in or derived from, or for any omissions from, or failure to correct any information in this correspondence, or any other written or oral communications transmitted to any recipient of this correspondence in relation to The University of Auckland Motorsport Club.


In holistic accordance with the multivariate nature of operating as a student motorsport club at The University of Auckland (the University/UoA); the express indication of the Committee to continue collegiately engaging with UoA community members; and section 267 of the Education and Training Act 2020; the Accord is prepared to retroactively supercede all other correspondence from the Club as a collective exercise in building trust, competence, safety, good faith and excellence – through mastery – amongst our membership.

C) OPEN (MAIN)


Dearest <<First Name>>,


As an esteemed member of The University of Auckland Motorsport Club (UoA-MSC/the Club) you are receiving the Accord in acknowledgement of the heavily disputed nature of the 2023 academic year – potentially catalysed by the actions of some within the community since 2022 – with respect to outcomes for both individual members and collective groups within the University's motorsport community. As such, the Accord shall act as the de facto – or hybrid – Annual General Meeting for both academic years.


Good judgement has been exercised in the preparation of the Accord; with particular regard to the Club's unique position as a sporting community, whose members are socially and educationally situated in a tertiary learning institution, collectively governed by New Zealand Legislation. Academic freedom under the auspices of the Education and Training Act 2020 (ETA 2020)'s section 267 is procedurally explored with the Accord, given that the University has intimated a comparably uncodified position on the relatively new piece of legislation.


In addition, outcomes from a series of actions and omissions by members of industry the University, and the motorsport community – which are respectfully albeit robustly listed and explored in sequence via Section I) … Timeline of Key Milestones – appears to have potentially transformed the way which this Club operated in 2023 into a zero-sum academic exercise for the diverse motorsport demographic.


Let us then entertain the notion of academic freedom in tackling this 'wicked problem'  through the best-judged integrated application of the University's policies, New Zealand legislation, Mātauranga Māori custom, and – as permitted by UoA's affirmation of STATE of MOTION volume 1 (SMv1) – an unambiguous constitution, all of which falls within the scope internally defined by Club leadership's correspondences with Student Groups Team, Campus Life (SG-CL), UoA's Campus Life Directorate (CL), and University leadership; with all these parties appearing to have left just enough of a gap  for this Club to attempt the attainment of a globally optimal outcome which this Accord shall try to describe.


To our membership, members of the University, and members of the UoA student body who were very much looking forward to connecting with like-minded individuals over the past couple of years; the Committee must profusely acknowledge that no economically rational collective would have gone as far as our active executives went in trying to counteract the current zero-sum nature of campus culture; cultures which even the poster-institutions of academia were not immune to falling foul of.


Further to this, given the multiple instances over the past decade where the University and its agents' actions and/or omissions have called into question the consistent application of potentially ambiguous ethical standards resulting in the serious, grievous and even detrimental outcomes for the academic community at large, it would be prudent to keep in mind the power dynamics between this student-club and the educational-institution it resides in.


Thus, in accordance with the Terms and Conditions above, as well as the remainder of the Accord below, it shall follow – to the best of the Committee's ability – the checklist-heavy iteration of the Club's Constitution, which has been heavily inspired by executives' experiences in the social, educational and sporting fabric of The University of Auckland. The consolidated Section F titled "Annual Report… Consolidated" shall provide further information – and justification – for any potential deviations in any of the processes described prior.



D) APOLOGIES


Not Applicable



E) CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES OF PREVIOUS A.G.M.


Dated 21/ 12/21 to 12/01/22 (Digital/Online)



F) ANNUAL REPORT, '22-'23, CONSOLIDATED (AR-C-23) | INTRODUCTION


From the outset, it is of paramount importance that the following express statement be made:


The Club and its active Management Committee members never completely ceded the guardianship of UoA-MSC to any individual, party, or collective from the University of Auckland, the Auckland Learning Quarter and/or the New Zealand Motorsport Community, at any point since the publication and subsequent adoption SMv1 as an iterative and corrective foundational document for those who chose to remain in the Club's plenary.


To ensure that this report is as clear as possible, matters pertaining to the community collectively known as "The University of Auckland Motorsport Club" – and any iterations which have sprouted from membership's individual actions – shall be explored in sequence and is done in Section I) … Timeline of Key Milestones.


The following reasonable assumptions are also made to expedite this process:


1) Despite multiple governance-response-truncated academic years, the Club's activities were largely successful in fulfilling the entry-level vision which the Club had for its good-faith, positive-sum iterations of its then-unamended Constitutional Objects and Guiding Values in 2022.


These are supported by the collective content from go-karting, AUT crossovers, the virtual racing social (collaboration event @ UoA's Unleash Space), V8 Supercars, WRC Rally NZ spectating/volunteering, and the 2022 Red Bull HQ Virtual Race Final; which are then reasonable grounds for the Club to focus discussion of 2023 in greater detail.

2) The legal structure of the Club which is commonly communicated by delegates and staff of the Student Groups Team, Campus Life (SG-CL) to all other clubs inclusive as being "a separate legal entity" from the University may be a misrepresentation on the grounds that many of the principles and processes which other student groups are 'expected' to abide by are essentially loosely governed contracts that are impractical to enforce for a student group whose dynamic activities may be esoterically alien to some members of the campus community.


3) Actions, omissions, words, and conduct from those in the community are reasonable 'signals' for educated inferences. The grounds for this include the Club repeatedly indicating in documentation, publication and correspondences that litigation is not a collegiate and positive-sum course of action for this student group. Justifications with corresponding evidence which carry community interest connotation – and are deemed appropriate to discuss – shall be presented to support any inferences made.


4) Basic technical information about the University's services indicates that there are members of staff with a 'birds-eye' and/or 'God-mode' view of the University's digital and communication assets utilised by students and staff – the majority of whom carry @aucklanduni.ac.nz and/or @auckland.ac.nz suffixes.


Coupling this with the University's privacy policy and select instances of conveniently timed incidents – as covered in Section I) – which happened far too often to be a coincidence; it appears that the University community's implied position on New Zealand Legislation may be in line with the challenges posed by our collective statutory obligations toward Aotearoa's Tangata Whenua (as indicated by the Treaty of Waitangi [Te Tiriti / The Treaty]).


In other words, it appears that the multivariate nature of the Privacy Act 2020 is being 'applied' in accordance with the best-judgement of the University's support service, senior faculty, and senior executive staff, thereby suggesting that at the defined limit of what the Accord covers, there are decision-makers at UoA which are reasonably aware of what has transpired with the Club (much less the motorsport community in the Auckland Learning Quarter). These decision-makers naturally have the capacity to influence the operation of this Club by virtue of, and sometimes beyond, the powers conferred onto them as an educational institution trading in New Zealand.


In essence, The University may value outcomes resultant from novel choices and judgement calls made by the members of its community as opposed to a purely black-and-white interpretation of its written rules, regulations and – at the limit – legislation. Naturally, this needs to be tempered by a culture of safety  (https://auckland.campuslabs.com/engage/news/230353) and the Club has actively encouraged a proactive  culture around this idea (https://auckland.campuslabs.com/engage/news/260032), provided that Club members carry enough sound character to use good judgement in limiting the probability of irrecoverable-from harm in their actions and omissions.


5) The University – as indicated by media coverage, general voluntary guidance, and what's discussed above – has a significantly greater level of sophistication in key areas including (but not limited to) technology, management, legislature, media and general student body monitoring and guidance.


The sequential nature of the remainder of this report aims to allay in clear sequence what transpired during the problematic 2023 – and shall also be forwarded to appropriate decision-makers of the University community with respect to the Club's continued and uninterrupted operation. At the limit, the Committee has internally indicated this to reach no further than the Vice-Chancellor's office, and – in good faith – do not envision these matters to escalate that far.



G) AR-C-23 | SUPPLEMENTARY COMMENTS ON P.O.A. (Addendum to SMv1)


This was distributed to membership on good faith and has not been 'officially' forwarded to SG-CL on the grounds that the matters discussed within the Addendum were still not to the comprehensive standard desired by Club leadership.


However, words and conduct from both students and staff indicated their awareness of the document's existence. This addendum may have reached as far as the upper echelons of the University, where the Club's commentary on the severe disruption caused by SARS-CoV-2 on customary/historic student motorsport group events and management potentially received a collegiate and implied response from the University's press team. This commentary is quoted below for reference:


" ii) Further Rationale for Delays (as a byproduct of Process Innovation)

How Kiwis may have been deprived of the opportunity for true and timely public inquiry and discourse – with respect to how the massively disruptive lockdowns impacted everyone's lives since March 2020 – particularly with regards to the following factual algorithm:

  • See UoA Library due dates for November 2021 be shifted 4 weeks later to December 2021 (email-announced approximately 21st October, 2021);

  • Compare previous step with government announcement of new pandemic response on the 22nd October, 2021;

…"


A minor addendum must be about the Club's commentary on the pandemic saga, given that society en masse has foregone science' and academia's most fundamental principles.

Though any intent for a student motorsport Club to dictate public policy beyond its learned areas of commentary falls outside the Constitutional scope of what UoA-MSC covers, this does not justify the inaction of those in our – and the University – community to forgo said fundamental principles of academia, as legislated under s267 of the ETA 2020.


New Zealanders have witnessed first-hand the outcomes from this cultural decline, and hope that – at the minimum – our membership considers – and subsequently respects – taking a more learned position on all issues permeating Aotearoa's social fabric.


Nonetheless, we must thank the University for mostly making available the academic sources cited in Playing activities, Omissions and Acts (POA) and priming their actions in acknowledgement of the documents existence. Special mention must go to the University's New Zealand Asia Institute for providing recent research publication summaries which are consistent with behavioural psychology concepts, applicable to an organisational level.


Indeed, these are strategies which many organisations – and individuals – can take inspiration from in conducting their day-to-day running.


Further acknowledgements must be made to Aotearoa's tangata whenua for permitting the Club to – the best of the Committee's abilities – respectfully explore Mātauranga Māori concepts; something which leadership is still very much in the process of deeply understanding. The challenge of attempting to integrate the natural tensions between cultural customs with sporting pursuits is not lost on the Club. However, the Committee feels that this process is essential in the true appreciation of 'The Kiwi way of Life' from the perspective of our individual members and the Club collective as a whole.


Nonetheless, there are matters of academic and non-academic inquiry to further explore, and shall be conducted sequentially in Section I) … Timeline of Key Milestones.



H) STRUCTURE OF "CLUB AS SEPARATE LEGAL ENTITY [FROM UoA]".


The Committee's limited understanding of legislation must be taken into account in the following assessment of SG-CL's statements with regards to this section. This section is not legal advice and the Club shall seek to work with SG-CL to remedy the negative-sum 2023 outcomes for the Club and its membership, as intermittently described in Section I) …Milestones.


Further to this, SG-CL and the other sub-organisations nestled in the University's Campus Life Directorate (CL) – for the purpose of fulfilling their directives – lean toward the constantly self-iterated internal processes such as those in the University's Policy Hub – much less the Clubs Handbook – UNLESS a strong justification for deviating from these processes are put forward, such as those explored in the broad brushstrokes of the hastily published STATE of MOTION vol. 01 (SMv1). The goal is for the Accord to carry greater diligence in this process.


The Club's 'official' status – until such a time that an appropriate legal structure in accordance with say the Incorporated Societies Act 2022 is pursued – only extends as far as the University of Auckland's jurisdiction, given that said status is conferred to the Club by SG-CL via registration as a recognised student group in UoA.


The Constitution and/or Rules of each respective student group without official Incorporated Society or Registered Charity status can then be defined as generalised guidelines which the Club and SG-CL agree to be enforced by those authorised to do so by the Club (e.g. the Committee).


Given the University's pursuit of innovation and well-rounded graduates, much less the natural tendency of those in motorsport to lean toward the upper-bound of regulations, the Committee has opted to be lenient in the application and enforcement of what may be categorised as de facto informal social contracts between members, designed to see what the student body/campus community decides to do collectively amongst themselves. This already presented negative outcomes for the Club and its membership as described in previous publications such as SMv1 and POA. Conduct that intentionally breached University policies, regulations, and statutes – some of which reportedly being designed to have a dual-purpose for the achievement of an ulterior motive – is considered from an 'impact-on-the-Club's-peaceful-and-uninterrupted-enjoyment-of-rights-conferred-to-any-individual-in-the-country' lens (the majority of these being of a seriously grievous and detrimental nature).


At the opposite end of the scale, the Committee – as indicated by the generalised guidelines above – is not immune from legislative responsibility, particularly when engaging with service providers such as financial institutions. In other words, the Club's relationship with say ANZ Bank is then more stringent than with SG-CL, or the relationships between individual members. The Club's primary contact within the bank has been difficult to reach, and the problems experienced with the Club's bank account since the 24th of February, 2023 – along with inactive Committee members not having had their respective signatory status transferred to the current Committee since leaving – may stem from this. However, the bank's other staff, engaged at a personal capacity, have informally communicated a willingness to solve for the conundrum.


Ultimately, the insight – and potential value – to be derived from this formerly inarticulated aspect of student groups in The University of Auckland is its abstracted use case in the context of New Zealand's foundational document i.e. Te Tiriti / The Treaty of Waitangi. This is worthwhile exploring in reasonable depth in a later section given that – recursively – it has direct application to the unarticulated Constitutional term of 'The Kiwi way of life'.


I) AR-C-23 | TIMELINE OF KEY MILESTONES


As indicated in the sections prior, the primary focus of this section shall be how Club leaderships' decisions were influenced on the run up to the 2023 academic year, and the subsequent outcomes resultant from the corresponding decisions made by SG-CL (without matters being extended to a legislative level by either the Club and SG-CL at the any one time). The date of the key milestone shall headline the event/incident discussed, followed by discussion on what the event/incident entailed.


Given that there is no desire from leadership to escalate matters toward litigation, relevant information and evidence shall be presented, and – should it be deemed appropriate – conclusions and/or course of actions may make constructive use of the evidence put forward for the purpose of fulfilling the 'solution-seeking' dimension of the University's graduate profile on top of fulfilling our articulated obligations – as per Section F to H – to you, our membership.



17 January 2022:


SG-CL affirmation of SMv1 as a working document for the Club to explore via their approval of the Club's reregistration in 2022.


Process to onboard new core executives into their respective roles and responsibilities as senior Committee members well underway. Indicated Club bank account signatory status to be pursued at the discretion of new Committee members (in acknowledgement of their stature and maturity).


Please keep in mind what was stated in Section G: regarding pandemic disruption on customary club practise, despite the surface-level perception of freedom of movement as pandemic restrictions were sequentially and systematically lifted throughout the previous Government's final year in their previous Parliamentary term. Note how the Club's operations have been heavily disrupted since the nation's lockdowns since 2020, with our Rush Sim Racing promotions request being approved at virtually the same time that the government announced the requirement for the entire country to forgo large swathes of in-person events and engagements.


Consider this with the fact scenario from POA which shall be inserted below for ease of reference:


ii) Further Rationale for Delays (as a byproduct of Process Innovation)

How Kiwis may have been deprived of the opportunity for true and timely public inquiry and discourse – with respect to how the massively disruptive lockdowns impacted everyone's lives since March 2020 – particularly with regards to the following factual algorithm:

  • See UoA Library due dates for November 2021 be shifted 4 weeks later to December 2021 (email-announced approximately 21st October, 2021);

  • Compare previous step with government announcement of new pandemic response on the 22nd October, 2021;

…”



19 February 2022:


$950 granted for FTN Motion 'Streetdog' application (adjusted from $7,950 RRP). Potentially misplaced expectation for motorcycle-focused members of the community to be able to engage with this major grant provided by Student Groups on the grounds that the Club Secretary has a heavy PhD course load. Pandemic restrictions are still impacting Club operations.



24 April 2022:


Meeting at Hooncorp's "shed" with their 24 Hours of LeMons/NaZCAR crew. Idea to have NaZCAR Calendar as way to engage membership proposed. Workshop BBQ's to be the big drawcard.


Attended by Club President, Club Secretary and first Motorsport Club Grand Prix entrant/General Executive.



30 April 2022:


First crossover event with AUT Racing at Extreme Indoor Karts East Tamaki ('stones throw' away from Hooncorp workshop). Enjoyable intra-university competitive event with circuit management communicating incorrect race result to attendees.


AUT Racing President kind enough to invite remaining attendees over to personal home, view their project EV go-kart, and compare/contrast motorsport/motoring scenes between UoA/AUT. Hope is for the Auckland Learning Quarter to become a vibrant hub of motorsport culture in Tāmaki Makaurau.


Attended by Club President and two Motorsport Club Grand Prix entrants/General Executives (GEs).



2 to 14 May 2022:


Google Team Drive created for all executives to encourage teamwork, collaboration and transparency. Noted that Club Grants for Semester 2 (S2) are due on 30 May and – given that the country is beginning to return to 'normal' – may make the transition toward more in-person events challenging.


$10 membership fee proposed to subsidise Club's financial health.

NaZCAR May Mayhem 3-day event forwarded to potential entrants for brief intro into the series.


Word of mouth event communication format proposed to ensure that intake of GE's are managed well re: training and development.



29 May 2022:


Major Grant 2 application sent. Affectionately borrowed NZTA's Te Ara ki te Ora road safety campaign title on grounds that the budget request sought Club President's subject matter experience with the two line items (virtual motorsport and physical, closed course driving).


Potential for these funds to be integrated into the Motorsport Club Grand Prix format in light of application indicating potential pivot of the Drive Rush: Stunt Driving Experience toward Tracktime Driving Academy's services.

Subsequently approved on the 27th of June 2022.



10 to 12 June 2022:


Armageddon Lifestyle Expo invitation extended to membership. Friends of the Club from Hooncorp, Red Bull and Ping Zero in attendance.


More incorrect event results – from a virtual-reality race this time – communicated to membership (which was ultimately remedied by Red Bull during S2, 2022). Event staff studying in UoA expressed interest in contributing to Club affairs. Informally onboarded as GE's on 'good character' grounds.


S2 Club Expo preparation well underway. Window which President may have been poisoned opens.



27 June 2022:


Major Grant 2 application approved. Total application of $2,000 for 'virtual/reality' line items granted.



29 June 2022:


First UoA City Campus meeting for majority of executives. General business discussed re: S2 expo presence. Club Secretary indicated that they may be on extended leave due to PhD commitments. Club Treasurer to continue the bank account signatory onboarding process. GEs indicated interest in pursuing initiatives consistent with the now articulated Guiding Values (focus being the FIA's #PurposeDriven initiatives on equity). Eavesdropped on by Unleash Space/City Campus Engineering Building/UoA staff during café-style chat.



1 July 2022:


SG-CL Meeting re: S2 Club Expo agenda (Hampton Downs Motorsport Park (HDMP) Lamborghini, FTN Motion 'Streetdog' display/test-rides, Ping Zero simulator).


Possible to have Lamborghini at John Hood Plaza pending multiple conditions re: safety, property management, security and insurance (e.g. no engine start). Indicated comparison of having display vehicle on-campus to 2014, 2019 and 2021.


SG-CL team lead (TL) pressed for exact details of the rented Mazda RX-8's 2019 expo approval, despite their suborganisations greater access to documentation sent to them by any and all student clubs/organisations (see 17 October 2022 entry and UoA policies – at the limit – on data retention). TL also indicated lack of legal expertise re: road/footpath use as loading bays.


GE floated Unleash Space proposal for Club members to use Maker Space, with eyes set on making grassroots radio-controlled cars.



7 to 12 July 2022:


Lamborghini out of commission (mechanical issue, requires overseas-sourced parts). HDMP Business Development Manager connected Club with director of Racer Products Ltd.


Outdoor static and dynamic displays for S2 expo in limbo. Ping Zero simulator presence still in cards. Hampton Downs virtual livery created in Gran Turismo 7 in lieu of (as seen in membership form).


In light of the 'challenges' experienced in attempt to receive approval for a display-vehicle on-campus; Executives receive passive-aggressive email from SG-CL staff member who, upon further inquiry, had management responsibilities with AUSA. Further commentary on the Student Association later.


Go Kart & Hotlap vouchers donated to Club by Hampton Downs. Parties who were unable to support further during Club Expo indicated interest in further engagement in the future. Racer Products interested in exploring how students may be onboarded in technical motorsport roles.



18 to 19 July 2022:


Clubs Expo. Circa ~50 new members (47 according to the count by one GE). Five members opted to pay upfront for financial membership and additional raffle entries via bank transfer.


Investment in student extracurriculars appear considerably low compared with levied memberships from prior motoring communities. Have Parliament's actions made its impact on the spending capacity of New Zealanders known?


Issues included:

  • Executive attendance in stall inconsistent,

  • GEs driving potential members away with statements about the Club which did not instil confidence in operations,

  • Expo attendees acting in a manner which may cause permanent damage to Club equipment,

  • GEs storing new signed-up members' personal information in their own data channels,

  • Former executives who may be categorised as having potentially irreconcilable differences with the current Committee and who have family members still enrolled in campus had aforementioned family members approach and reengage with executives in attendance. Welcomed to join the Club in name of collegiate inclusion,

  • Convenient movement of student groups related to the point above in comparable manner to previous years, i.e. Motorsport Club stall placed next to group(s) which may have views in express contradiction of the personal, religious and/or political views of executives (to potentially test for how they react to being placed in very close proximity with University-favoured and/or statutorily-protected collectives). No mind given by the Club and its representatives on all occasions beyond acknowledgement of the situation. Questionable tactical conduct by management?

20 July 2022:


'Inkling' of concerns with 'soundness of character' of certain collectives in the campus community made more or less obvious to eagle-eyed Committee members.


Two of the Club's GEs begin potential insubordination ramp. 2022 Grafton campus presence foregone to accommodate their requests from yesterday. 'Problematic GEs' (Problem-GEs) start making further unreasonable and inarticulate demands from the Committee with regards to Club's relationship with the Motorsport New Zealand (MSNZ)-affiliated Auckland University Car Club.


Shadowed by small collective of students from groups described in final two points of prior milestone date (18-19 July) during the brief and informal exchange.



29 July 2022:


Treasurer's attempts to create bank account with ANZ for the purpose of signatory transfer still ongoing.



3 August 2022:


Shadows Bar follow-up email from informal conversation with new 2022-2023 management (sent to manager@shadows.co.nz email).


General content includes livestream and watch-parties for local and international motorsport events such as Formula 1, MotoGP, WRC, etc. No response as of the Accord's publication.



6 August 2022:


EV Go-Karting at Game Over Auckland. Attended by a good mixture of members and friends of the Club – including presence from UoA-FSAE. Advised that some GEs are attending their 2022 tech night.


Brief dinner at Denny's Restaurant in Auckland's North Shore. Members present communicate Rally New Zealand (WRC-RNZ) leadership getting in touch with them after completing the volunteer form shared with the rest of the Club later in the semester.



7 to 10 August 2022:


GEs with potential leadership capacity provided access to more of the Clubs digital assets for the purpose of further task delegation, e.g.  https://auckland.campuslabs.com/engage/organization/UoAmotorsportNZ


Current and new GEs with past experience in motorsport volunteering – via 'The Motorsport Club Inc.' (TMC), WRC-RNZ – communicate participation opportunities for Club membership. Supported by active Committee members to increase the diversity of activities offered during academic year. Problem-GEs still poking and prodding leadership for emotional response.


Ideation session held between Club President, eSports Club chair, and FistBump co-founder for 'Fastest Collab' inter-Club event.



13 August 2022:


Go-Karting 'encore' with AUT Racing @ Blastacars Drift Karts, Henderson.



16 August 2022:


General Executives reached out about opportunities with Racer Products, MSNZ and the FIA. Gene from Racer Products – among other motorsport businesses and organisations – subsequently re-contacted regarding employment and career opportunities from the 13th of September.



20 August 2022:


First entrant in UoA-MSC Grand Prix executive selection format competes in BMW Race Driver Series Scholarship competition. President's symptoms from potential poisoning still being managed.



22 to 25 August 2022:


FIA Seminar correspondences.



25 August 2022:


Club Mailchimp account access provided to a problem-GE in good faith to evoke trust and confidence in Club management of affairs. Account access provided with knowledge of said problem-GE's prior positions in campus and motorsport extracurriculars. Positions suggest a level of exchange and coordination between problem-GEs and the internal(UoA)-external(FIA et al) parties described.


Note that the Club Mailchimp account contains all member emails, and access was provided in confidence, much less is governed by privacy policies and legislation.


The University's de facto culture suggests this may not be the case in practise, as potentially indicated in the upcoming timeline milestones, with smoking guns in the 30th of January and 18-20 of April 2023 entries.



30 to 31 August 2022:


Finance and succession strategy workshop attended by President and GEs with leadership potential. Secretary still away, Treasurer on mid-semester break holiday and has reportedly not had any success with onboarding themselves with ANZ. Welcomed to workshop along with other attendees by two SG-CL administrators.


Shadows visited once again to follow up on unreturned event request email from the 3rd of August, 2022. Other student groups supposedly were accommodated prior. Worthwhile noting the venue's ownership structure moving forward.

1 September 2022:


Meeting with MSNZ CEO and their IT/comms lead. Explored educational and social opportunities between Auckland Learning Quarter student groups, MSNZ and potentially the FIA. Meeting touched on UoA hosting a livestreamed FIA 'roundtable' on campus.


First instance of "merge" narrative surfaces where a larger umbrella organisation is formed within UoA, encompassing the motorsport industry in its entirety (communicated that they are also in touch with FSAE student leadership). This is a big undertaking and deserves its own section further in the Accord (see Section J).

Noted that no express statement was made regarding the sporting aspect of the industry during the meeting beyond an entry level – and potentially 'one-dimensional' – eSport pathway.



4 September 2022:


Small retreat to Hampton Downs Motorsport Park for first round of 2022/2023 season motorsport events.


HDMP Go Kart Centre staff expressly indicate to executives in attendance (President, 2x GEs) they have remote ECU access to the go-karts performance. Raises some concern with how this may impact UoA-MSC Grand Prix format (latest iteration discussed in its own section).


President forgoes casual racing opportunity at the centre due to health condition from potential poisoning getting worse. Difficulties in dealing with University Health and Counselling / other campus-based services acknowledged. Matter external to Club but impact of personal situation described cannot be dismissed out of hand.

Supercars Volunteer packs from TMC Inc. picked up from HDMP venue.



10 to 11 September 2022:


Final V8 Supercars race in Pukekohe Park Raceway. Attended in spectator/volunteer capacity by many in the community.



20 September 2022:


FIA-MSNZ-WRC roundtable event preparation expressly begins.



21 September 2022:


'Fastest Collab' event @ Unleash Space completed with great success. Many thanks to members of campus community who attended and the support provided by UoA eSports, Fistbump and Red Bull.


Exchanges and coordination with MSNZ/Rally NZ delegates and Club volunteers for FIA-WRC visit well underway. FIA 'Roundtable' event discussed.


Must be reiterated that despite the large volunteering contingent at UoA – which includes networking interest and engagement from staff – the organisations are still technically external to both the Club AND the University.


Further expressions of interest from attendees re: General Executive roles. Onboarded inclusively in earnest to help manage Club social media, operations, and administration.


Minor issues include problem-GEs making potential intentions expressly known by conduct. Two of them were escorted by the President during preparations for the event above. Campus ground detours which lead to 'happenstance' exchanges with family members of inactive – potentially irreconcilably different executives – and faculty staff noted.



27 September 2022:


FIA-MSNZ-WRC roundtable event withheld on scheduling conflict grounds. Multiple attempts to get this going again to no avail.



28 September 2022:


Members with @aucklanduni.ac.nz email domains have their access to Club communications restricted with no justification from organisation administrators. In complete ignorance of the prior fact, SG-CL team lead redirects executive to dead ends in attempting to remedy the issue.

29 September 2022:


WRC Rally New Zealand Demo @ Auckland Domain. Merchandise sales volunteer indicates that a discreet, special access tour of the Auckland Waterfront Rally Village/Service Park was held for a select group of students was held earlier in the week.



30 September 2022 to 2 October 2022:


WRC stages culminate in Jack's Ridge final.


Administration for Bathurst 1000 and Japanese F1 Grand Prix 'watch party' underway. Simple on-campus event utilising lecture theatres to watch the racing. SG-CL beginning to implicitly press against Committee under the auspices of 'supporting' the Club, with particular attention paid to campus service access. Later indicated to the Club that PhD students and general staff may have these privileges available.


Workarounds to this were identified but it must be reiterated that the precarious position of any and all fledgling student groups – including this one – during the pandemic were largely handled on non-bespoke grounds i.e., other student groups without a significant reliance on dynamic, in-person events were happy to accept the questionable governance of the previous government given that they may not be as heavily impacted by policy decisions made (which the University and the groups operating within it ultimately having to comply with).



5 October 2022:


Earliest recorded instance of the "UoA Clubs" Instagram Group Chat

7 to 9 October 2022:


"Motorsport Club Café" promo and activation at the UoA General Library. @aucklanduni.ac.nz email domains can once again connect with Club correspondence. Comparable attendance to other events of its kind from 2019 onwards.


Executives with financial responsibilities oblivious to the fact that the reregistration process for 2023 begins tomorrow. This should not be a cause for concern given there's a reasonable window for this to take place, and in edge cases, worthwhile discussing with SG-CL.


Must further be noted that due to the Secretary's absence, the President's state of health (including challenges dealing with the medical service providers described above on grounds which fall outside the scope of the Accord), and the potential issues with parity identified during the visit to HDMP, the Motorsport Club Grand Prix' organisation, administration, promotion and activation became – in retrospect, and in the Committee's eyes – an even larger challenge to complete.


This does not take into account the Club's membership list potentially being mishandled – from a privacy perspective – by problem-GEs, as appears to have been "customary" in the communities handling of personal information by others in industry (among other instances, during WRC Rally New Zealand's volunteer coordination emails).



10 to 13 October 2022:


Finance tab issue from 2021 resurfaces. Nothing technically preventing SG-CL team from restricting access to certain services they provide. Collegiate nature of activating these powers at such a "convenient" time questionable at best. President attends pro-bono consult with Dealan-Dé Ltd. after extended 'chit-chat' with student-owner of business as far back as Rally New Zealand volunteering. Derived early insight into globally-optimal Club structure.



17 October 2022:


SG-CL works around the arbitrary finance tab restriction by forwarding all copies of grant applications made by the Club, including commentary and decisions made by SG-CL and the Clubs Support Committee during it's entire first epoch. We extend our thanks to them for facilitating this.


FSAE launches novel "Summer Sign Up" initiative for 22/23; with entries 'closing' on the the first of November 2022. Note that there have been no public indication of this initiative being pursued again in summer '23/'24.



18 October 2022:


Motorsport Club Constitution template as drafted by prolific New Zealand volunteer is uploaded to the Executive Shared Drive as per SMv1.


21 October 2022:


Earliest recorded official instance of problem-GEs manuevering between groups as indicated by UoA-FSAE alumni.



26 October 2022:


Potential deliberate omissions of information regarding reregistration process during back and forth with UoA Student Groups. Committee indicated intention to pursue "prior precedent" with this Club – which later turns out to ultimately be a case of positive-sum process contract completion.



4 November 2022:


First recorded instance of Constitutional amendments as per SMv1 (uploaded .docx file in Club Google Drive). Contents of document iterations appear to have been picked up by members of the motorsport and campus community as per posts in their respective external forums.



1 to 5 November 2022:


FSAE Summer Sign-Up announced as per 5 October 2023 subheading.



8 November 2022:


FSAE Summer Sign-Up interviews begin.


Meeting between President and potential successor to Club operations held from the morning to the early afternoon. Cleantech event held at Unleash Space visited afterwards by both as President's exploratory visit to the FSAE workshop was not until 8pm.


Points of note:


  • Problem GE had reasonable background knowledge, potentially including personal information, about the President.

    Motorsport content discussion of meeting with student/staff-GE sound. Natural differences in opinion about Club management structure emerges. Worthwhile stating in the context of feedback from Problem-GE's significant other (who was an operations lead with
    UoA's Rainbow Business) that a sporting Club is in no way, shape or form comparable to say the Supreme Court of the United States; much less has it been conducive to the motorsport and the greater campus community seeing a live-action imposition of their desired processes toward the Committee (and potentially further) in 2023.

    In acknowledgement of the student body's capacity to seek information and problem-solve – on the grounds that no parties from the Committee deems it positive-sum to litigate – this may be a worthwhile milestone date to begin being constructive about the content presented in the Accord. We shall leave it to membership and the audience to decide for themselves if the outcomes resultant from the collective actions of the University's statutorily-favoured groups took were collegiate, ethical, and/or justified.

  • Aside from every University community members' interest in career development opportunities; exploratory visit to Newmarket campus was made to derive insight into the new FSAE facilities and operations. Possible crossover events discussed online prior (and somewhat elaborated on during visit). Of interest were potential synergies in doing so such as attracting greater support from motorsport bodies and prominent motorsport brands, e.g. Red Bull.



9 November 2022:


Utterly disparaging letter forwarded to entire executive team from student/staff member who met with President the day prior.


'Feedback' arguably within the limit of academic freedom; however, unsubstantiated attacks on personality, coupled with the Committee's current position in enacting the process contracts in accordance with the Club's current legal status as per Section H above was not something value-adding to the Club with regards to the reregistration process.


Also contained elements of duress and potentially blackmail. Despite the concerning correspondence, providing the individual with the benefit of the doubt suggests that – as we may see in other timeline subheadings – it may have been a customarily poor attempt to elicit an offer with respect to the Club's social contract as described in Section H (which in itself may be misguided on the grounds that it has not been articulated with the depth of Section H until the Accord's publication).


Reasonable to presume word of mouth amongst members of UoA staff, much less the letter being hosted via the student/staff-GE's @aucklanduni.ac.nz email is now something SG-CL would have been aware of in practise (as per Section F, point 4: https://www.auckland.ac.nz/en/about-us/about-the-university/policy-hub/university-governance/privacy/privacy-policy.html).


Other Club GEs understandably distanced themselves from the matter, with the other problem-GEs continuing to ramp the bad-faith statements and maliciously inconsistent conduct which extended well into 2023, summarised by the following quote:


"[We're] just supporting the club and whoever is moving it forward as [our student volunteers]'d stay as a neutral party."


A hypocritical and nonsensical statement given that this discreetly malicious conduct directed toward the Committee extended throughout the 2023 academic year. As of writing, this – and the other incidents with a serious, grievous and detrimental impact on the Club and its membership – has  not been formally escalated to any University party, given that those who these matters may be escalated toward have historically had the capacity to be complicit in this collective conduct.


Behaviour thus permitted to continue in order to identify the root cause of these academically questionable actions. Worthwhile noting that these GEs were faithfully granted General Executive status.


In addition, please be reminded that the then current Club Treasurer was not provided with adequate opportunities by the bank to onboard herself as signatory; the Club Secretary has doctorate-level commitments on campus, and the President's health and wellbeing situation already having its impact in the 7th to the 9th of October milestone discussed.



10 November 2022:


Communicate problematic situation above to SG-CL without divulging sensitive details. Upon further inspection, the correspondence sent their way may not have been clear enough in what information was provided; though given what we already know about the University's implicit and/or de facto position on privacy in the context of this student group – much less the further information in the other milestone dates discussed below – is a redundant exercise.


A semi-formal meeting between the President and a senior SG-CL team member was subsequently held on the 8th of February, 2023 beginning at approximately 2pm.

The purpose of the meeting was to briefly discuss the matters of insubordination by the problematic GEs, with the SG-CL team being expressly made aware of the issues with these GEs as early November 2022.



12 November 2022:


Duress-laden executive resignation accepted. | Return correspondences 30 and 31 January respectively.



14 November 2022:


Communicate to membership that a large internal audit of Club affairs is to take place (in light of what's discussed in the Accord).



15 November 2022:


Executives and membership interested in role(s) of responsibility – including those who put themselves forward for MSC-GP  format – asked to help conduct interior audit prior to proposed handover procedure à la SMv1. Largely non-committal, given the ulterior outcomes sought by the problem-GEs, potentially acting as conduits for parties internal and external to the University.



18 November 2022:


Hampton Downs still reached out to for STGP. Return email on the 24th of November 2022 due to the Club's contact with HDMP having to take care of a personal matter.



20 November 2022:


"Extension" [of reregistration procedures] 'granted' by SG-CL communicated to membership via uoamotorsportnz@gmail.com. Use of new email expressly implies by conduct to all in the community that work which makes the Club consistent on all fronts continues in earnest.



21 November 2022:


In light of macro-concerns about a reasonable proportion of the community described above – which appears to have expressly manifested itself in 2023 – the Committee communicates to Student Groups what now appears to be reasonably clear signals that an "overarching management challenge" was thrown the Club's way in the 2022 academic year; and is something potentially endemic within and around industry and community. No follow-up about this correspondence is received until the 27th of January 2023.



22 November 2022:


Club receives Red Bull Flugtag & Virtual Race Final invite. Inactive foundational Committee member recommended for Red Bull mic-controller role during Virtual Race Final.



24 November 2022:


Hampton Downs indicates that potential educational/sporting format discussed earlier in the year not feasible due to scheduling conflicts, though team happy to assist where they can.



26 November 2022:


Soundness of character test proposed for not just members of the Club but the campus community at large interested in the Club's Playing Activities in light of concerns flagged as early as July, reaching fever pitch this month.



27 November 2022:


First recorded instance of Club Instagram page suspension, no reason provided.


University of Auckland Alumni Facebook Tracking – coupled with the University's express capacity to leverage their professional industry network – suggests they are more than able to contact Meta Platforms Inc. to disrupt any Student Group with a comparable legal structure as this Club. Further dates of interest include the 1st of December 2022 subheading all the way to the Vroom social media accounts expressly stating the University's suborganisations ‘constructively’ discriminating against our segment of the motorsport community.



1 to 2 December 2022:


Second recorded instance of Club Instagram page suspension. No reason provided outside of a vague mention of Meta's 'Community Guidelines'. Suspension challenged via a basic procedural checklist where certain Club – and personal executive information – was forwarded to Meta.


Suspension subsequently overturned on the 11th of December, 2022; with Meta stating  that the "account was disabled by mistake".



6 December 2022:


Grant receipt submissions notification (due 31/12/22)



16 December 2022:


Problem-GE which leadership freely permitted to make their way around the Club's apparatus – including access to sensitive personal and contact information about membership; as well a good-faith extension of professional opportunities (see 16th of August 2022 milestone) – briefly queried about verifying their logging out of the Club's Mailchimp as per the 25th of August 2022 subheading.


Inconsistencies with statement compared with the technical truths about the platform [Mailchimp did not have a 'log out of all devices' function at this point in time, hence the request for log out verification] ultimately warranted a wholesale shift of Club affairs in the manner actioned by leadership after the University's 2022 Important Dates.  Inconsistencies comparable with the actions, statements and omissions by other Problem-GEs; with their forgoing basic requests at the potential guidance of other segments of industry.


The Club similarly can't verify if – and what – correspondences this member may have communicated to the email addresses of Club members. Giving them the benefit of the doubt as a best case scenario, they communicated incorrect information about the nature of the access provided to them. In the worst case, they may have – arguably unlawfully – forwarded member email addresses to other University parties, much less communicated with membership directly without express permission from senior Club leadership.


17 December 2022:


Red Bull Virtual Race Final



JANUARY 2023:


Entire series of correspondences – upon further assessment as per the Accord – indicates a month-long saga of problem-GEs getting Club leadership to forgo the radical Motorsport Club Grand Prix format.


This, coupled with noteworthy facts below (as constructively indicated by Cross-referenced dates and content of SG-CL's contact with the Club) reasonably validates the problem-GEs being delegated 'cats paws' for groups which the University and/or the Campus Life Directorate have an interest in having a good-faith commercial relationship with. Further worth noting that the dates of these correspondences are so consistently AND conveniently timed with the 2023 Clubs Handbook 'Deadlines';  which they in themselves are fairly negotiable depending on the case or situation.



5 January 2023:


Outreach received from Bread Supercar Rally Trustee.



12 January 2023:


Major Club Grants Q&A Webinar held between 5-6pm. Organised by members of SG-CL and the Clubs Support Committee.


Primary Contact of Student Groups Team smirked as the President entered and exited the virtual meeting. Repeated entry and exit attempts reportedly actioned to remedy technical difficulties which has plagued his accounts, devices and other apparatus at convenient times before, during, and after the lockdowns.


SG-CL primary contact's smirk made apparent during the virtual meeting entry attempt where President's Zoom username changed to implicitly notify meeting administrators of 'technical difficulties' again being experienced ("[AWAY]" temporarily appended on his Zoom username). Technical issues included the unconsented muting of local audio, thus requiring the activation of captions in order for the President to derive value from attendance.


These 'tells' are seemingly consistent with the SG-CL Primary Contact's body language and facial expressions when they are executing a series of actions designed to elicit a response of insecurity from a particular member of the community, and can be validated by two other exchanges between the President and said Primary Contact (one before the 2022 S2 Club Expo, and another in-person one on the 8th of February, 2023 to discuss the challenges presented by the more problematic GEs as described above, much less the status of the Club in light of what's discussed thus far).

17 January 2023:


Clubs Leadership Training information re-extended to students who expressed interest in Club affairs, despite displaying bad faith – and potentially discriminatory conduct – toward the peaceable and uninterrupted operation of the Club.


Actioning a culture of inclusivity may be redundant on the grounds that other student groups on campus have specific clauses in their respective Constitutions which permit the forgoing of the University's policies surrounding inclusion – and by extension,  diversity, equity, etcetera. In the scope of the Accord, it may be worthwhile for the reader to explore the Constitutions of the other motorsport-themed groups on campus in detail in the context of this milestone date.



23 January 2023:


Redundant follow-up from new staff member from SG-CL on the grounds that the process contract in SG-CL's affirmation of SMv1 (Motorsport Club Grand Prix, etc.) was potentially maliciously disrupted by multiple parties, as above.



27 January 2023:


Receive reply from SG-CL about "overarching Management Challenge" email. Reply a continuation of the [purposely?] ignorant structure of this University suborganisation toward the Club. Further correspondences up to the 29th of January suggest that they are working very closely with the problem-GEs; which we've already reasonably established are agents for this University subunit, and continue to attempt to elicit an offer which gets Club leadership to forgo the MSC-GP (and potentially the finances granted to activate said flagship event).


Further credence to claim about the highly integrated nature of the problem-GEs, SG-CL, and arguably the other associated organisations with Campus Life made even more apparent with other conveniently timed correspondences which – if included in this Accord – will add further complexity to an already atrocious window into the worst facets of the 'Kiwi way of life'. This overarching theme will be explored in Section J).



30 January 2023:


In the unsurprising lack of any reasonable cooperation and commitment from active members of the community (see problem-GEs acting with ulterior motives above) to see through the multivariate – and ideally value-added – outcomes from the MSC-GP process, it was rational to explore other avenues which may help facilitate the completion of.


The UniGuide Volunteers staff – having comparable access to SG-CL in Engage – were approached to more or less explore how their volunteer pool may help with Club oðperations, and by extension, completion of the delayed MSC-GP. This collegiate call-to-action extended as far as the Club sharing the opportunity for students to join with said larger volunteering group as this has a positive spillover effect on participation in other voluntary pursuits.


Nonetheless, there was a lack of reciprocated acts of good faith from said voluntary collective, despite entertaining their voluntary desires from 2022 (executives appearing in their social media stories, promoting the initiatives of their favoured student groups as per 5 October 2022 subheading, etc.).


If anything, what engaging with this heavily-supported University suborganisation revealed was the validation of how integrated groups and collectives in the active members of the community (at every level of the University) can act for the purposes of forgoing/stymieing radical innovation, true diversity in thought, and real academic courage in the context of freedom of expression. Please find below evidence verification via a publically available statement from the aforementioned 'significant other' described in the 8 November 2022 milestone subheading.

Advance knowledge of details between the Club and SG-CL prior to any official statements being made by an appropriate representative of the Club indicates that:


a) SG-CL and/or the Clubs Support Committee is indeed working a lot more closely with individuals who identify in favoured equity groups (commenter, upon further inspection, is an operations lead for one of the said groups);


b) Said commenter – despite being a reasonably active member of The University Community – isn't even a member of The University of Auckland Motorsport Club when the comment was made, further suggesting – if not outright indicating – that SG-CL and/or the Clubs Support Committee was more than happy to forgo any cultures of confidentiality with how this specific student group is being engaged (the culture potentially being non-existent in de facto practise anyway).



FEBRUARY 2023:


Aside from exploring the options available for the Club in light of what's already been described above, the President hedged preparations for the 2023 academic year with respect to the physical challenge of recovering from the potential poisoning incidents, coupled with upholding a culture of prioritising professional and educational commitments among Club members (by example or otherwise).



2 February 2023:


The University discreetly publishes a webpage for their 'Love Bomb' campaign, which is only publically shared by AUSA. This is shortly followed by reporting from 95bFM two weeks later.


There are inconsistencies with the University's publication – which it did not share in its official social media channels until Semester 2, 2023 – and the 95bFM podcast

which discussed the matter directly with AUSA. Plural descriptors are used in the written publications, but the Student Association President referred to a singular religious student group in the audio interview.


The cloak-and-dagger nature of this campaign suggests there is more to it than meets the eye. Perhaps the remainder of the Accord can help the reader shed light on what this matter may be. It may be worthwhile noting that the Club since its earliest years has been listed under multiple organisation categories – such as Sport, Volunteering, Academic, Religious and Cultural – on the grounds that a human-centric student group would naturally occupy multiple fields of the campus experience (particularly one as diverse as the motorsport discipline).

How does this relate to the Club? At face value there is no direct link. However, upon deeper analysis – which this Accord conducts – educated inferences can be made in the context of the University's recent history with respect to this cultural issue.



3 February 2023:


Preliminary reregistration documents submitted, primarily consisting of a very condensed description of what's transpired thus far, superimposed on a copy of SMv1.



4 February 2023:


Potential instance of executives with Facebook page administrative access deleting and/or editing posts (Mount Panorama lap of Red Bull F1 car, 2023 RB19 launch, etc.). Comparable behaviour to the conduct described in SMv1, p28, paragraph 3.



6 February 2023:


Return correspondence was sent to a trustee of the Bread Supercar Rally who reached out to the Club last month, with respect to what appears to have been an attempt to elicit an offer regarding the management of the Club.


On the reasonable assumption that the University once again used its extensive professional network to connect the Club with parties of interest, the trustee was engaged in good faith and a counter-suggestion was made in light of Club Expo's proximity.


Given the outcome of the S1 2023 Club Expo application, nothing short-term came of this exchange. The trustee however has indicated their interest in discussing opportunities for collaboration in the future.



8 February 2023:


A meeting between the President and the Senior SG-CL Contact was held on the 8th of February, 2023 beginning at approximately 2pm. The purpose of the meeting was to briefly discuss the matters of insubordination by the problematic GEs, with the SG-CL team being expressly made aware of the issues with these GEs as early November 2022. This meeting devolved into a metaphorically masturbatory exercise for the SG-CL Contact to once again potentially retaliate for any personal biases they may have against the President under the auspices of fulfilling the already incompatible nature of some of SG-CLs processes in relation to the Club.


It must be added that this meeting provided UoA's higher Campus Life Offices – such as the Proctor's Office – with fuel to further waste the President's already limited time and energy in 2023 given the potential instances of poisoning he is still recovering from today. Keep in mind that the SG-CL Contact reminded the President of the process-contract nature of SMv1 during this meeting, with Constitutional amendments requiring to be passed by the Club's management committee as part of the process. Upon review it appears that these amendments communicated to all committee members were preliminarily passed on the day of this meeting in accordance with what was communicated by the SG-CL contact.



9 February 2023:


Confirmation of reregistration application received from SG-CL at 4:14pm. Glaringly incomplete financial report submitted by those delegated to complete this. Clubs Expo stall application submitted. Problem-GE indicated that they submitted an application on behalf of the Club as well (as per POA).



10 February 2023:


Preliminary confirmation of Clubs Expo stall allocations to all Clubs on the 10th of February, 2023; along with the AUSA Tender expressing financial and non-financial support for Clubs during their themed event weeks throughout the academic year.

Unsurprising lack of motorsport community presence in light of what's transpired since the end of 2022, including UoA-FSAE's absence from this list. It would later turn out that a separate Engineering Clubs Expo event will be held during the second week of Semester 1.



18 February 2023:


Arguably redundant – on the basis of SG-CL annually moving the goalposts on subjective processes which, as the Accord shows, they don't consistently adhere to themselves – extended to the remainder of membership who indicated interest in Club involvement. Clear at this point that Committee members have taken the statement of the President 'carrying' the Clubs affairs on his own almost literally. Nonetheless, Constitution continues to be developed; with instances of these developments being communicated to Committee members on the 8th, 16th, and 27th of February respectively.



24 February 2023:


Frivolous and vexatious formal complaint from Problem-GE collective forwarded to Club lead via Senior SG-CL contact; with the content communicated by the contact containing irrelevant reference to the Han Cultural Club. Content of complaint nonetheless integrated into the codified amendments in the Club's processes and structure; which anybody acting in good faith toward the Club – and the diverse motorsport community – would have identified had they been transparent in their intentions in interacting with this student group.


Unexplained $57.00 withdrawal from Club bank account dated today at 7:52pm; which was discovered at 5:45am the next day, the 25th of February, 2023. Former Treasurer and signatory admitted to withdrawing the funds for no sound reason, and promptly returned the $57.00.



27 February 2023:


Publication of "SQUAD. UP. MONDAYS (Extended Club Expo Edition!)" article – https://auckland.campuslabs.com/engage/news/275934 – in The University of Auckland's publically available Student Group online portal on the first day of Semester 1, 2023 in lieu of in-person expo presence from Club officials (retrievable from the https://archive.is family of websites via personal devices).



3 March 2023:


President cordially greets UoA-FSAE team members at their Engineering Clubs Expo stall. Conversation revolved around broad outlook for the team in 2023 in light of their FSAE-Australasia win the year prior.


President then confronted by extremely outspoken Problem-GE from prior academic year and had threatening remarks directed his way about having matters about the Club escalated to the Proctor's Office (which is a University sub-unit in Campus Life). There doesn't appear to be grounds for this outside of the Constitutional iterations briefly referring to seeking guidance from the University Proctor should the Club be unable to resolve matters internally. This draft was only sent to Committee members using the @aucklanduni.ac.nz email domain.


Incident was witnessed by FSAE team members present, majority of the engineering-focused student groups in attendance at the expo, and two staff members from the Student Development and Engagement team from Campus Life (with a third making their way to the general stall manned by said two staff) "Vroom" posters begin populating the Quad, followed by their social media pages’ publication shortly after.

6 March 2023:


Motorsport Club promo posters begin to be defaced. Initially redacted to overly comply with University confidentiality policies surrounding equity groups who also participated in questionable conduct (with particular note to be made about the member of University [Business School?] staff who shadowed the UoA-MSC executive in OGGB Level 0; and the students who did the same in Symonds Street level of the Engineering Building).


Ultimately worthwhile addressing who these groups are on the grounds that no group, individual, and/or collective should be bullied, harassed, discriminated, and/or have an offense committed against them by virtue of their peaceable rights conferred by the Crown.


Identifying within these equity groups on campus should in no way, shape or form grant those acting on behalf of these groups with a license to engage in conduct that expressly goes against the University's commitment to every member of the campus community; regardless if they are privileged enough to carry statutorily protected status.

7 March 2023:


Fork-Club news "update". Printed posters of the same content from splinter-group also begin to appear on campus grounds and are largely left to their own devices, along with the defacing posters from the milestone date prior.


Communicative intent of splinter-group unclear, though it carries comparably parallel – but fundamentally different – connotations to the historical relationship between Māori and Pākeha; a 'Kiwi' issue which served a noteworthy grounding in the Club's multiple publications.


Nature of posters – besides carrying comparable quality to the work forwarded by problem-GEs to the Club in the past – suggested branching outcomes in how the interaction among the motorsport community on campus would turn out.


Optimistically, an intent to find common ground with the Club-main is being sought. Pessimistically, kindly consider reading on.



16 to 18 March 2023:


Exchanges between President and UoA Case Club's Specialised Events Team – and members of UniGuides who also participated in the Energy Case Competition – very discreetly suggests an attempt to elicit an offer regarding how the Club should be conducting its affairs; with particular attention paid to the MSC-GP.


This position on Club management is consistent with some of the problem-GEs and those involved with the fork-Club. May be worthwhile noting the affiliations of said group's primary contact in the context of what's transpired thus far; much less the online (30 January 2023 milestone) and in-person (8 November 2023 milestone) exchanges between the interconnected parties in the University community.


The Club however must make it abundantly clear – in the following express statement of differentiation against parties who may or may not have affiliation with the politically motivated groups within the University – that it harbours no malicious will toward any  individual(s) and/or groups on campus. We only ask that they respect the individual and collective positions of all students, and greater University community members; and for any loss and/or damage to be remedied in an equitably positive-sum manner. This is an expectation the Club and its active Committee has, not just for those in our membership, but also for the greater motorsport and academic community who claims to champion the Guiding Values which the Club has integrated into its amended Constitution.



30 March 2023:


A series of incessant correspondences from a representative of the Proctor's office is supposedly received with respect to the 8th of February meeting with the Senior SG-CL contact. Correspondences indicate how potentially inadequate, bias-laden, and functionally inequitable the University's equity and wellbeing policies are.



31 March 2023:


Supposedly confidential correspondence from Senior SG-CL contact on behalf of the Clubs Support Committee (CSC-SG-CL) communicated to President at 1:41pm. Completely forgoes the very first tests required to be passed as described in their very own Clubs Handbook (see "frivolous / vexatious"). Further breaches of University policies occur as described in the 3 April 2023 subheading.


Follow-up correspondence from one person of the Problem-GE collective received by the Club at 2:41pm which carried the same title as the correspondence received by the President.


The contents of the two separate correspondences carrying the same title is not identical to each other, however, the intent of both appear to be – as alluded to membership as early as POA's initial publication (14 July 2023) – the absorption of the Club's assets, membership, and the narrative (POA, p4, paragraph 2). This is further supported by the fork-Club's social media publications on the same evening.

Worthwhile noting the further convenient timing of these correspondences relative to the Clubs calendar in the 2023 Clubs Handbook.  


"Mabuhay!" article posted to promote Melbourne Grand Prix watch party. Consider the basic themes in the context of what the Club represents.



3 April 2023:


Senior SG-CL contact once again acted on poor Campus Life decision-making processes with their improper assumption of hierarchical power by communicating to [reportedly] senior members of other student groups of outcomes from the flawed 31st of March CSC-SG-CL correspondence. The President is a member of these groups in The University's Student Group Portal.

It would later appear that this may have been done for the purposes of justifying a sophisticatedly discreet breach of – among other student-University agreements – the University's Campus Life directive; potentially to deceptively restrict the President's access to executive privileges in the University's systems.

There have been other instances of this conduct directed toward him on either side of this decade. However, this falls outside the scope of the Accord and shall not be explored beyond this brief acknowledgement.


The nature of the correspondence from the Clubs Support Committee which pertains to Club affairs is reasonably nullified on the grounds above alone, and it has been communicated to the parties above that their actions have continued to add to the already heavily impacted delivery of the Club's Constitutional Objects and Guiding Values to membership.


SG-CL and the Campus Life Service Division are to be followed up with to identify appropriate remedies for the multivariate losses experienced by the Club and its membership, including those which have not been adequately addressed as of this Accord's publication.


Between this date and the splinter-group's next series of online publications, the Club and the Committee receive an incessant barrage of asset handover requests, and goes as far as to suggest that the President seek other avenues for motorsport career pathways, external to that of the University. There are parallels between this suggestion and other interactions between and among the motorsport and business school community. Again, this falls outside the Accord's scope, but it would be remiss to not take note of this aspect of campus culture.



18 to 20 April 2023:


Senior SG-CL contact continues flawed line of actions born from the disclosed confidential correspondence from the 31st of March 2023; with particular respect to a statement said contact made about the Club's Instagram account. Supposedly acting on behalf of Problem-GE – and other students of questionable character in tow's – "new" Club.


Again worthwhile noting the timing of the exchanges between UoA-MSC, SG-CL, and the fork-Club relative to the 2023 handbook deadlines. Please note intently how this fork-collective repeatedly pressed for leadership to unjustly transfer asset and member information over to them.


All of these uncollegiate and unjustified requests from the fork-Club foregone on the grounds described thus far; with the SG-CL contact being advised that engagements and correspondences are now being formally investigated on the Club's end.

Correspondence also communicates to the SG-CL contact that those who are party to the President's unsavoury campus experience in 2023 thus far should refrain from direct engagement with the Club lead. Very intriguing to note that students from the President's property classes – who are also members of the property student association – heeded and honoured this request; potentially validating the University's failure to uphold their confidentiality policies in light of UoA-MSC.


Key dates from the handbook include "New" clubs being notified of the outcome of their new club applications – from the 3rd to 15th of March – on the 31st of March 2023; followed by new club information requiring submission by the 26th of April in order for the April small grants to be submitted by the 28th of April.


Both SG-CL and the Vroom fork repeatedly called for transparency and the adherence to process while they negotiated for UoA-MSC's assets in a completely contradictory manner; including the express appropriation of "The University of Auckland Motorsport Club" title.


Further inspection of the fork-Club's event frequency, format, club documentation, and their reported and sighted correspondences with the Club's service providers (such as Meta and ANZ which shall both be explored further later) indicate both the fork and SG-CL displaying incredible bad-faith sophistry; and with both clearly acting in a manner seriously grievous and detrimental to an existing UoA Motorsport Club which they for one reason or another refused to provide justified bespoke support.



4 May 2023:


Club lead speaks with Shadows management about a 'motorsport' event being held at the venue next Wednesday. Worthwhile noting again that – on top of said bar being owned by AUSA – UoA-MSC never received any significant return correspondence about the Club-main's proposed events from 2022.


It may be argued that the fork-Club collective is being favoured by this association-owned venue due to their leadership identifying with over-defined equity groups which – as we've seen from the 6th of March 2023 subheading – may feel emboldened to expressly display unsavoury characteristics because of their statutorily-protected status.



10 May 2023:


Fork-Club quiz held at Shadows.


Upon the complete internal assessment of incidents during the writing of the Accord;  the conduct of venue staff and patrons prior to and during the evening appeared to be consistent with the potentially unarticulated intent of the University's Student Association – and its partners – toward this Club.


Noted that members of UoA-MSC also attended this event, including MSC-GP entrants who appear to have had no intention to follow through with the innovative MSC-GP process.



11 May 2023:


Further correspondence from Senior SG-CL contact re: social media. Jurisdiction here is potentially flawed on the grounds already described above all-inclusive.


Virtually all parties aside from the Club proper acted seriously and grievously against the Club in a bad faith interpretation of their multiple respective terms, conditions and policies.



19 May 2023:


Despite all the maliciously placed roadblocks in the Club's direction since late-2022; marketing for the Club's proposed activities in 2023 continue in earnest with the Publication of the "One Last Ride" promo campaign à la Top Gun.



25 May 2023:


ANZ informally queried about what transpired with the Club account. Club advised that "a stop" was requested on the 19th of May at approximately 12pm; which is shortly after the 'One Last Ride' marketing campaign beginning in earnest. Inactive signatories followed up on the matter.


No signatories claimed responsibility, despite ANZ indicating that only one of the signatories can activate this (unless of course there are other mandated agreements between UoA-SG-CL and financial service providers that student groups with the Club's current legal structure as per Section H) are subject to).


In other words, this was a serious, grievous and massively detrimental action taken toward the Club. President also visited at place of employment by an elderly gentleman on the 19th of May 2023 who appeared to indicate a knowledge of what transpired above (which wouldn't be the first time an incident external to Club affairs took place).



1 June 2023:


Engage relay email to Club Executives Re: S2 Clubs Expo, In-Campus Wednesday BBQ's, and a novel announcement about the Student Services levy (which was discussed in detail in SMv1, p24-25).


Announcement communicates two key things. The first of these – potentially being consistent with the Committee's position toward the Campus Life Directorate in Section F) point 4 – is that the malicious removal of the President's administrative privileges in its Clubs portal was not actioned in full.


The second is that the University may have proactively considered – if not outright incorporated – the Club's commentary about the Student Services levy in their value-seeking decision-making processes.

2 June 2023:


Final day of semester one classes. Stalwart social event historically attended by many in the community (Armageddon Lifestyle Expo at ASB Showgrounds) publically communicated with membership via Instagram.

President followed by senior fork-Club executive around campus grounds – who appeared to have been receiving direction from an individual and/or group in the student union buildings via mobile phone call when crossing the Princes Street intersection in front of the Alfred Street construction site (for the new Student Commons / Recreation Centre). Fork-Club executive was wearing a red hoodie and sported a pride lanyard.


Maliciously ignorant statement made by fork-Club socials at 6:33pm on the same day. Grounds for this descriptive position include at least two prior posts earlier in the year where an express reference to the Club-main were made.



3 June 2023:


Meta conveniently disables the Club Instagram account a day after the end of classes, with very little reason provided outside of a now potentially outdated set of community guidelines as per Section G. Retrieval not currently top of mind, given the other matters already described above; including the fact that the University appears to be leveraging it's bargaining strength against this fledgling student group (as per 11 May 2023 subheading).


Instagram posts reshared via Facebook (another Meta platform).



21 June 2023:


10:47am: 2nd Clubs Update for the semester two Clubs Expo sent to student group executives via the Engage email relay (as per 1 June 2023 subheading).

Includes expo stall application form which – deviating from historic practise comparable to semester 1, 2023 – permitted a no-login stall application. Application deadline indicated to be on the 26th of June at 11:59pm.



26 June 2023:


Despite the 'fanfare' of the first semester, including – on the balance of probabilities – a discreetly integrated, multi-organisational collective campaign featuring behaviour teetering on the edge of harassment of active Committee members (primarily the President, in-person and online) just before and during the exam period, the publication of the fork-Club's University website is recorded for the first time.

27 June 2023:


In light of a token application for the Semester 2 Club Expo – the content of which the fork-Club appears to have at least taken inspiration from – the Senior SG-CL contact states that the UoA Motorsport Club is "not a registered organization" with the University of Auckland, despite their knowledge AND involvement with what's transpired thus far. Further to this point, official University publications on their very website indicates that the fork-Club was expressly permitted to append the "UoA Motorsport Club" title to their name during Clubs Expo.



29 June 2023:


Constitution v7 distributed @ 11:47pm as per SMv1. Still requires further detail in accordance with the T&C's.



30 June 2023:


Fork-club lead replies to UoA-MSC email sent to membership the day prior.


Continued correspondence potentially suggests an interest from SG-CL to find out more about the work that the Club is putting into the community (despite hypocritically getting in the way at virtually every step of the MSC-GP process).



3 July 2023:


Earliest recorded instance of further Engage student portal access interference and manipulation. Carries comparable hallmarks to internal email deletions from the Club's initial email channel (motorsportclubuoa@gmail.com), on top of the 3 April 2023 entry.

9 July 2023:


Instance of potential technical vandalism of the Clubs' 7th Constitutional iteration recorded in Committee members' networked devices.


Unclear whether the Clubs assessment of this on the 9th of October 2023 is accurate or whether this can be traced to the 2023 Clubs Handbook with a larger file-size (and requested full-screen access to user devices) which may have been scrubbed from web archive records.


14 July 2023:


Part II: The UoAMSCGP (2023) / POA v1: https://mailchi.mp/46a1768aae5a/uoa-msc-gp-2023 / Constitution v7.1 set out tentative dates for the event to be held between the 26th of August 2023 to the 10th of September 2023.



17 July 2023:


President explores Club Expo preparations on the first day of Semester 2 in a collegiately investigative capacity in the Owen G. Glenn Building. Surprised to see the fork-Club use the primary Club's signage from prior expos.

Other student group executives present are engaged in chit-chat; with two Problem-GE's arriving in the vicinity shortly afterwards. President has an informal conversation with them nonetheless.


SG-CL primary contact also turns up very early to OGGB Level 0; who appeared to have implied knowledge of the SMv1 addendum which made reference to how the fork-club was permitted to appropriate the "University of Auckland Motorsport Club" title in appending it to their online and in-person presence. Further to this, the contact's conduct toward the President remained consistent with the unsophisticatedly infuriating application of their hierarchical power displayed earlier in the year.

President leaves the area briefly to prevent any further escalation and calls University Security to advise of what's just transpired. University Security Control Room opposite the Science Building also visited by the President to ensure that all parties were on the same page about the situation. This was reportedly done in light of the irresponsibly negative-sum back-channel chatter – that has become normalised in campus culture the world over – which expressly extended as early as April to May 2023 from SG-CL's agents' end.


Fork-Club arbitrarily has signage adjusted later during the day.



18 July 2023:


Fork-Club stall rotated away from OGGB atrium line of sight, deviating away from the University's published stall locations.


Two SG-CL members of staff which the President has engaged with reasonable frequency since 2022 make an appearance, with President indicating that fork-Club delegates – despite their expressly discriminatory attitude toward Club leadership – are doing a reasonable job in carrying out some of the Club's constitutional functions.

Further worthwhile noting that the constitutional amendment to the main Club's nomenclature technically permits the fork-Club to appropriate the Club's title; as per quoted prior Constitutional section:


" 1. Name

The University of Auckland Motorsport Club Inc. shall be the official name of the Club frequently referred to by the following titles; including but not limited to

  • Motorsport Club

  • UoA Motorsport

  • @UoAMotorsportNZ

  • UoA-MSC "


Fundamentally, the fork-Club has been implicitly granted a license by the Committee to append any and all iterations of the University of Auckland Motorsport Club nomenclature until such a time that this implied license is expressly revoked; which the Accord technically does.


Ultimately, these two days have indicated the level of sophistication the fork-Club's supporters and benefactors have in applying their powers to achieve their respective ends, arguably at the detriment of membership and the greater motorsport community at the University. Staff from Recreation Centre with a stall in OGGB's John Hood Plaza indicated that they had some knowledge of matters with this Club.


President reportedly made their way to the Shadows around the afternoon and was advised by management that a restriction had subsequently been placed on their access to campus retail services. AUSA – as we've already established prior as the owner of said venue – was visited by the President out of convenience to inquire about what this so-called restriction may be about.


Junior AUSA executive and reception staff suggested that the President leave his personal details down, smirking just before the President put pen to paper. President reportedly indicated that he would like to inquire with other appropriate parties on campus first, indicating that other AUSA agents should have access to his personal contact methods should they need to get in touch with him anyway.



24 July 2023:


Follow-up email sent to SG-CL staff about the fork-Club, including the mention of their gaming night on the 26th of July. SG-CL primary contact defiant in their upholding of their decisions and biased support toward the fork-Club, in complete ignorance of the values which members of the campus community are implicitly expected to uphold.


A further mention of getting the Proctor's office involved in the matter is included in the exchange which, as we've already established from the 30th of March 2023 entry, is a fruitless exercise in bureaucracy, and can ultimately be corroborated by the consistently low-ROI outcomes from the President's prior engagements with said suborganisation from the previous decade.



26 July 2023:


Club's first Treasurer and current President have happenstance, and thus impromptu, meeting at the AUT City Campus' Refuel Café over breakfast.


Motorsport naturally discussed; including matters surrounding the Club's formation in 2019, the Constitution reportedly coming from a generic template used by the heavily embedded volunteering contingent in the University, and the gaming night event held later that day by the fork-Club.


Also briefly explored how commercial partners may be onboarded on a more substantial basis by the Club; with the former Treasurer indicating that a local automotive retailer – which the President by virtue of his professional and career pursuits have engaged with recently – was initially approached for entry-level support (keychains as membership tokens).


Ultimately worthwhile cultivating the commercial relationships which the Club has formed in the past, but requires effort as with anything of value.



1 August 2023:


Hampton Downs Motorsport Park and Ace Motorsport reached out to for the fledgling Motorsport Club Grand Prix; with the Club now tentatively aiming to schedule this event for the mid-semester break. Ace Motorsport also reached out to. Potential for the adversarial nature between fork-Club and Club-main to be cannibalising each others' membership pool and driving other attendees away becoming apparent.



4 August 2023:


Explored patenting/copyrighting of MSC-GP format as sustainable income stream for Club via UoA UniServices / UoA-CIE; with a brief meeting held for Club UniServices representative to state their respective positions on the concept. May require further legal opinion on the grounds that – based on the reasonable assumption that the University has adopted a defensive post-pandemic posture – the Clubs diverse membership fundamentally challenges the University's current strategic commercial position.


Value of format ultimately lay in how it gets activated, with UoA being the potential first-mover in this space. Committee depth of knowledge may be key to this. Parties that can help shall be contacted in earnest for 2024. However, this process exists at the upper-most-bound of what can be achieved with this event concept.



8 August 2023:


Gran Turismo Film Promo. Fork-Club undercuts this date as they've been doing by all means throughout the year. Club's proposed calendar ultimately being weaponized in 2023. Other instances to be discussed below and includes MSC-GP cannibalisation with Fork-Club's event in the same vicinity as discussed in Constitution iteration 14 July, 2023.


Other instances of film promo ultimately – and rationally – discreetly relegated to personal exchanges amongst members for their privacy and safety given – among other instances throughout the month AND the now reasonably held presumption that the University community is now just waiting for the bad-blood within the motorsport subsegment to blow over – the next timeline milestone.



11 August 2023:


Fork-Club continues to engage in behaviour that contradicts the Club-main's Guiding Values and the University's numerous community behaviour guidelines with the post below (and on Facebook). The photo their social team shared utilises a relatively clear and prominent image of the President; with some of those who 'liked' the post either being one of the Problem-GEs, a member of the Club proper, or is acquainted with the President being a long-standing member of the University of Auckland Community.

Worthwhile noting the fork-Club's prior posts in the context of this posts' caption.

"Other" motorsport-themed group on campus begins to have technical difficulties with their external forums and wiki websites.



14 August 2023:


President contacts SG-CL Clubs Support Committee (CSC) Member in good faith – along with Student Groups, the Proctor's Office, and Campus Life leadership – to ensure that everyone is on the same page with what's transpiring on campus regarding this student group; much less the incidents since the 6th of March.

President also extends notice of the potentially malicious nature of his poisoning to the parties above – much less the arguably hypocritical nature of campus culture during his time there since the prior decade – given that no formal introductions have been made between some of the parties in this channel of inquiry.


Responded to on the 21st of August 2023; with the nature of the response potentially being the minimum required response an employed Clubs Support Committee member of staff are obligated to give i.e., given the reasonably articulated position of those with management capacities in SG-CL, the CSC members' response is still consistent with said position (despite the initial evidence provided).



15 August 2023:


HDMP's business development manager replies regarding the MSC-GP. Challenging for them to hold this event in the requested window (2023-08-26 to 2023-09-10; 14 July 2023 update) as they have arranged a series of winter events which engages the greater Auckland-Hamilton-Te Kauwhata region (Race Track Run, etc.)



18 August 2023:


Film night's postponement communicated publically in light of recent developments as described above.


"Other" motorsport-themed group on campus' external forum is active again. Upon updating his contact email, President trips an automated access restriction on his account. Subsequently reaches out to last contact person with the group to solve for the matter, with the Gran Turismo social event simultaneously being extended their way.


Fork-Club begins their activation efforts for a grassroots community staple, spanning from today until the 6th of September.

Worthwhile noting that the Problem-GEs who are now running the fork-Club continued to receive club-wide correspondence from the Club proper, reasonable to presume that they are aware of the tentative dates for the MSC-GP as per 14 July 2023 club update (with this information potentially figuring in their event scheduling as revealed in their 25th of August 2023 post).


21 August 2023:


Senior CSC member replies to the 14th of August correspondence. Matters pertaining to the Club's bespoke nature have, in essence, entered a de facto negotiation phase.

It is now challenging to take statements made by parties employed by the University at face value in light of what's covered thus far; much less take any advice from this collective Campus Life (CL) sub-unit on the grounds that they, by statements and/or conduct, have inequitably and uncollegiately acted in favour of obnoxiously loud, statutorily privileged, and or socioeconomically desirable collectives such that the zero-sum targets from their myopic position on the Overton window continues to see the University follow the same unbelievably incoherent path 'more developed' academic institutions have ended up pursuing.


The content of the CL delegates' reply is thus largely – and justifiably – dismissed on the multiple objective, subjective and collegiate grounds; ultimately summarised by this heuristic. This position which UoA-MSC's active Committee members have stated in this timeline milestone in retrospect is an appropriately consistent position which – Constitutionally, in good faith – is made on behalf of the underrepresented students and alumni in our membership.


The only key takeaway from this correspondence is the CSC members claim that the Motorsport Club is not currently a recognised club on campus.



23 August 2023:


House-keeping: https://mailchi.mp/2eeb547a0d79/house-keeping-uoa-msc-2023


Proposed MSC-GP dates are now redundant due to reasons already outlined.



28 August 2023:


Mid-semester break officially begins.


President makes collegiate visit to the Clubs office opposite the eSports Centre to have an informal chat with SG-CL staff about the matters detailed above, regardless of natural personal predilections resultant from the campus culture already outlined.

The primary matter which needed discussing was the registration status of "The University of Auckland Motorsport Club"; where the primary SG-CL contact and a senior member of the Clubs Support Committee both indicating by conduct that they would like to step away from their desks to discuss.


President gently counters by stating that it was not necessary for them to do so for such a trivial and straightforward question, and expressly states that he only wanted to confirm The University of Auckland Motorsport Club's registration status on campus for the 2023 academic year.


Both expressly deny the registration status of a Club with said name; DESPITE the apparent registration of the fork-Club with the University as "Vroom – The University of Auckland Motorsport Club"; with their online presence representing this to be the case as early as April.


President thanks the staff in the Clubs Office for their time. Aside from those already described, there were at least a handful of other SG-CL staff witness to the affair above which the President recognised (and has been communicated internally with the relevant parties).


President then makes a detour to AUSA house given its proximity to the prior location. Purpose was to potentially discuss a comparable thread as above with their Advocacy team. Advised by a staff member that all advocates were away, despite coughing emanating from an advocates locked office. Staff member thanked for their time nonetheless.


Crucial firewall upgrade email begins circulating on campus email domains with the University's digital officer delegate forgoing the blind-carbon-copying of catch-all email address (i.e. "all staff / students @ aucklanduni.ac.nz)  in the message.


Campus' chief digital officer reached out to on the 30th of August and advised of potential for this outage to once again impact Club communications as per the 28 September 2022 entry.



31 August 2023:


Follow-up email about the in-person exchanges from the 28th of August 2023 sent to Campus Life. Problematic situation warranted the President propose a set of initial solutions that mirror the administrative academic process. The perceived limit of said process is the Vice-Chancellor; and her offices were also [redundantly?] carbon-copied into the addressees.


This is shortly followed by the President finally receiving return correspondence from delegate of "other" motorsport group on campus. Linguistic content comparable to a hypocritically indignant Campus Life Directorate, Proctor's Office and/or SG-CL.

Reasons for this may include a failed – potentially as a result of the President's collegiate 28th of August 2023 visit to the Clubs Office, as summarised in the email earlier in the day – attempt to achieve whatever external industry and/or the University may have tasked the delegate to action toward the Club (potentially as far back as 2022). Other potential reasons fall outside the report's scope, though it may be worthwhile considering the interconnectedness of the motorsport community in this timeline milestone.


Delegate and "other" groups' leadership gently requested to fulfil their official obligations with respect to privacy and campus community commitments. Rolling temporal basis for a remedial response to the requests implied on the grounds of good faith.



1 September 2023:


Follow-up email sent to AUSA Advocacy as per 28th of August 2023 visit. Automated response email received.



6 September 2023:


Club-wide hold on affairs communicated to membership in light of what's transpired thus far, reason for which being the underarticulated nature of potentially malicious actions of some in the campus community toward:

  • The peaceable, uninterrupted and timely delivery of the Club-main's Objects;

  • The potentially delegated, sophisticated, AND integrated harassment of active Committee members throughout the past two years as already outlined;

  • The natural motorsport community members' aversion from this space as a result of a negligently managed social, educational, and sporting communal fabric.



8 September 2023:


Mid-semester break officially ends the Friday before classes resume. Campus-wide firewall update actioned. Archive website instances from archive.is and web.archive.org inaccessible from University of Auckland devices.


Campus' chief digital officer reached out to on the 30th of August and advised of potential for this outage to once again impact Club communications as per the 28 September 2022 entry.



10 September 2023:


Tentative MSC-GP window lapses (26th of August 2023 to the 10th of September 2023).


Correspondence sent to members on the 6th of September 2023 further clarified to be a positive-sum seeking exercise, despite the potentially zero-sum game which other groups have engaged in.



11 September 2023:


Semester Two classes resume.  


September historically represents the month of the academic year which student groups are encouraged to begin their reregistration process with SG-CL. Different this year as per 2023 Clubs Handbook, where the recommended internal deadline for this process is now on the 17 November 2023.

Bespoke reregistration format for this Club – and other groups who feel the need to follow suit – may now be warranted in light of what's discussed in this section and Section H) inclusive.



19 September 2023:


President runs into one of the Problem-GEs in the University sport and recreation centre. Brief collegiate exchange about matters around student life and affairs with the Club-proper.


President reportedly indicates mentioning first the first time an underdeveloped and underarticulated process of Taonga Tuku Iho for the Club-proper. Also expressed reservations about having a traditional city-hall style AGM in light of everything presented in the Accord thus far.


Auckland University Engineering Society sweater-donning students of comparable descent to Problem-GE appear to have eavesdropped on the conversation as President made his way out of the 'Rec Centre'.



20 September 2023:


Fork-Club publicises double-header weekend with UoA-FSAE, slated to take place on the 23rd of September 2023, featuring a minimum viable iteration of what was discussed between MSC-President, UoA-FSAE student management, and MSC-junior executive(s) – who have since transferred over to UoA-FSAE – as far back as last year (1 September 2022 to 8 November 2022).


Also coincides neatly coincides with the second Red Bull Energy Station event at Sweatshop Brew Kitchen (among other Red Bull-branded events during the 7th week of Semester 2).


Worthwhile noting that:

  • The marketing and promotion campaign for a student event with these many moving parts typically warrants a greater lead time (as indicated by the fork-Club's departure from consistently having greater than three (>3) days of promo before this specific event) to drive attendance up;


  • Nonetheless, this is a noteworthy example of Red Bull, UoA-FSAE, and other members of the community's capacity to innovate and deliver on short notice if/when called upon;


  • However, it is also worthwhile considering this on balance in the context of what's discussed in the Accord all-inclusive. The integrated nature of the University's motorsport social fabric sees natural interest from faculty and the more active – and thus, visibly represented – large voluntary groups on campus (the largest of these being the local student association, which the University has historically engaged as a de facto collective third party, combatively or otherwise). Further discussion in Section J).



28 September 2023:


Club Awards evening held.


Intriguing to find out that the fork-Club – upon investigation – did not appear to have attended this event. Attendees are typically invited and/or are recipients, with the Club-main's past and present Committee members having attended this in-person event as far back as 2019.



3 October 2023:


Tuesday, Week 10. Fork-club advertises AGM at 6:30pm on 3 October 2023; scheduled circa-14 days later for the 17th of October 2023.



17 October 2023:


Tuesday, Week 12. Senior member of Clubs Support Committee and SG-CL briefly reached out to inform and clarify – in light of the increasingly apparent dual-purpose nature of the fork-Club's actions throughout the semester – of matters which may have been ambiguously communicated approximately 12 months ago. Automated responses from both contact points, indicating either being out of office or having a busier than usual schedule. Kindly note that the problem-GEs continued to receive – and respond to – the publications from the Club, despite their conduct as indicated in all of the above.


Worthwhile noting that no follow-up meet the candidates post being shared prior to the 17th of October, much less having a complete lineup of core executives in their roster to redundantly satisfy the structural framework for any student group committee. Content of promotion including the event's format suggests – on the reasonable assumption that a deep level of knowledge of the Club's prior and present constitutional iterations; e.g. " You must have attended at least one of our events [to be part of the leadership team]." *


* Compare with the Constitution and Rules of The University of Auckland Motorsport Club; section 7, e, i-iii; Rights, responsibilities and duties: Special membership statuses.



20 October 2023:


Final day of 2023 undergraduate lectures.


Senior Clubs Support Committee member conveniently returns correspondence – seemingly on behalf of SG-CL – during President's only scheduled lecture for the day. Completely forgoes responding to the 31st of August 2023 email thread and instead continues to express conduct that is consistent with CSC and SG-CL's minimum face-value obligations described in the 14 August 2023 subheading (in favour of the fork-Club, and potentially against this Club). By virtue of what's described in this entire document; no record of any agent, delegate, or active Committee member from the Club has replied to anyone from Campus Life since. This is to be addressed appropriately upon the promulgation of the Accord.


Later in the day, after some mild apprehension from the student bar staff, a number of community members informally congregated in Shadows after their respective classes. Those who partook in this customary and de facto end-of-semester practise acknowledged that a serious, grievous, detrimental and – among other matters of a legislative nature – an arguably unethical miscarriage of the University's values transpired in 2023; with these being discretely and mostly directed at active members of the Committee.


This utter failure of those tasked to proactively ensure that all members of the University community are free from discrimination, bullying and harassment points toward a more sinister state of affairs in New Zealand academia. Indeed, what's been presented in this Timeline of Key Milestones (Section I) suggests that the University's own policies, rules and regulations may have been discreetly and sophisticatedly applied by some high-level decision makers on campus to achieve an outcome from this Club which the Committee believes they failed to obtain during an academic-year-long display of hypocrisy, decadence, negligence, and a general level of implied malice toward members of this Club who did not share their politically manipulated, commercially driven, arrogantly myopic, and hypocritically solipsistic worldviews.


It is only reasonable then for the Committee to stand by it's position that until the root causes of an atrociously inconsistent, negligently incompetent, and maliciously biased application of ethical standards in academia are rectified, the social outcomes from our tertiary learning institutions will continue to generate – over a long enough time horizon, without the feedback afforded by academic freedom, in aggregate – an inequitably negative return on taxpayer contributions made by Kiwis to New Zealand Universities.



26 October 2023:


Exam period begins.


Officially scheduled from the 26th of October to the 13th of November, 2023.In practise, this ended the evening of November 11, 2023 (as this marks the Saturday of the last undergraduate exam's completion, which is also the de facto end to Semester 2).



27 October 2023:


Club-main extends invitation to large motorsport community event being held at Mt. Smart Stadium. Early articulation of the Accord's content in the post.



28 October 2023:


Fork-Club acknowledgement of de facto end to any level of sustained in-person contact among community members (outside of their respective social circles) due to exams via brief social post.


Extremely intriguing to note that they were unable to identify a Treasurer – returning or otherwise – despite having the capacity to hold events at multiple different venues requiring, at the very least, an integrated effort between the financial, managerial, and executives head(s) of a Club.



4 November 2023:


Large constitutional iteration – internally titled UoA-MSC-CV8 – communicated to membership.



11 November 2023:


De facto end of exams and by extension, of Semester Two, 2023.



12 November 2023:


Facebook follow-up for the final Red Bull Energy Station event of the year at Sweatshop Brew Kitchen is shared at 3:26pm.


The Club's digital assets under the Meta Platforms Inc. umbrella has once again received a level of interference akin to how less progressive nations apply their powers against political opponents. Links shared – even those within the Facebook website – no longer auto-generate an in-post preview, and required a level of website navigation reserved for the "persistent" page administrator.


On the balance of probabilities, this is a continuation of what the University, its partners in industry, and the diversity/equity/inclusion groups it has naively favoured may have implicitly actioned against this Club. Other instances of comparable situations extend as far back as the timeline milestones discussed about the Club's Instagram account stretching as far back as 2022, with one further potential validation of this assumption on the 5th of January, 2024.



13 November 2023:


Fork-Club follows up with a promo campaign for the same event in their social platforms.


First instance of an express financial offer [to the world] by the fork-Club made apparent with this campaign ("Join our subsidized food group for $5", "We've reduced prices to $5!").


As a reminder, given that active Committee members have consistently indicated their aversion toward escalating matters relating to the Club – and this community at large – toward any form of litigation; we can be somewhat constructive in this milestone dates' context.


This conduct is very comparable to the manner which the student association engaged in for their respective AGM this year (p4, s6, "Marketing as branded [their AGM] as an 'AUSA party (+agm)' ").


No images indicating attendance levels from said event in the fork-Club's socials shared on the 19th of November.



29 November 2023:


Formal appeal against Meta Platform Inc.'s hard suspension of the Club's Instagram account is submitted via their respective channels.


External distribution version of POA forwarded to Instagram support; with an agent for the Club citing miscarriages in the way the University's delegates handled its affairs with this Club [as described in all of the above], and Section 267 of the Education and Training Act 2020. Appeal further indicates that appropriate parties within the University are being engaged to remedy outcomes from the decision the platform made.



12 December 2023:


University [of Auckland] Sport honours Club's request to have its primary contact email updated via UNIM8s.



5 January 2024:


Instagram replies at 11:08a.m. to the appeal, suggesting that the Club reach out to the party who reported the post.


This correspondence from Instagram indicates that the Club is on an appropriate line of inquiry with respect to the contents of POA, which is subsequently further articulated, iterated, and expanded on with the Accord.


Further to this, on the balance of probabilities, the way anybody from Club leadership is being interacted with is most likely no longer a coincidence, and many of the timeline milestones with convenient timing – and content – is comparably not a coincidence in the scope of the timeline above.

These matters need to be remedied for 2024.



6 January 2024:


No posts from fork-Club since a couple of Facebook content shares from last year. FSAE forgos Summer Sign-Up format for '23/'24 calendar break in lieu of generic Business Team recruitment campaign.



11 January 2024:


Fork-Club shares UoA-FSAE's Business Team recruitment campaign.



25 January 2024:


The University of Auckland Motorsport Club publishes The Accord.


J) SUMMARY (AND / OF THEMES)


A [Familiarly] 'Wicked Problem':


Club leadership has not shied away from utilising Section 4 of the Constitution vigorously throughout its first epoch to counteract the impact of the negative-sum aspects of University culture which has been explored in this document. Naturally, this entailed respectfully pulling from – and parsing through – all the available resources from our interconnected campus, community, and social fabric's cultural customs. Couple this with an integrated 'challenge' from members of the very cultures and communities which the Committee is seeking a globally optimal outcome with and it is of no surprise what the collective outcome for the motorsport community at the Auckland Learning Quarter turned out being in 2023 (losses in organisational momentum, 'top-of-mind' brand equity, and contribution to a vibrant campus culture to name a few).


The Accord then is an articulated abstraction – and representation – of active Committee members' fearless pursuit of encouraging, exemplifying and mastering all areas of life; with this integrated activity being – in the Committee's opinion – prerequisites for excellence. In the context of motorsport, this connotates a physical, tactile, and/or dynamic dimension where active Club executives can recursively apply its Constitution's Guiding Values in identifying and/or creating a global 'killer app' to do so. However, as we saw from Section I) Timeline of Key Milestones above; parties within and outside the Club, the University, and the Motorsport Industry may have restricted the Club's opportunity to achieve this in 2023; à la Tangata Whenua's  spillover outcomes from historic colonialism.


Ultimately this means that – via this Accord – the Club is justified in requesting a reciprocated and reasonable remedy for the loss in opportunity incurred in 2023 (from all of those who did and/or may have had a part to play in the zero- and/or negative-sum actions from the prior academic year).


At best, any inferences made are nothing more than hearsay. At worst, the University and its delegates have exercised a highly sophisticated internal campaign of due diligence which is sufficiently closely connected to the negative-sum outcomes from the Club in 2023.



Parties (Definition of Internal and/or External):


What constitutes as an 'external party' needs to be clearly defined in the context of this Club. This is challenging on the grounds that any community with a loosely governed level of 'social osmosis' will see students and Club members float in and out of certain groups within – and outside of – the motorsport 'family' (née 'Hapū').


Thus, it may be worthwhile expanding on this Mātauranga concept and, via analogy and/or abstraction, applying a form of 'decolonisation' (née 'deconstruction') inwards. In other words, the spirit of academic freedom – particularly tangata whenua  – should urge members of the University community to consider difficult and arguably taboo concepts such as 'individualisation' in pursuit of greater outcomes for our respective peoples. This means that in the context of the Club, individual community members – as discussed in Section H) – are their own 'sovereign' beings, with their own individual agency to make choices for themselves.


To simplify, any express member of the Club is an internal party; any member of the University community – depending on context – may be an internal OR external party; and any individual or collective that cannot be designated in the prior two groups shall be considered external (and this includes those from industry and our AUT neighbours in the Auckland Learning Quarter). We'll let the reader mull through the Accord and determine for themselves what the impact of these parties have been on the Club's interrupted operation in 2023.



Impact of Environment:


Arguably the largest party whose presence permeated all of the Clubs affairs. Aside from the impact that the pandemic had on individual and collective decision-making, it is best to be less abstract in describing the impact of the environment – political, economic, sociocultural, technological or otherwise – on the Club.


The reasonable assumption that there are those in the academic, motorsport and volunteering communities who had deliberate and active engagements with the Committee in the timeframe covered in Section I makes it appropriate to discuss these parties in some detail below.


The overarching outcome from select individuals/groups said parties who vociferously communicated their desire and intent for the community is one of a grievously detrimental nature for the Club i.e. zero-sum/asymmetric in their favour.



Impact of External Parties:


A bird's eye view of the environment suggests that the party which ultimately had the largest impact in the way which the Club operated in 2022/2023 was the 53rd New Zealand Parliament. Decisions made by this Labour-led government, who took a comparable series of regulatory and governance actions similar to other authoritarian governments willing to forgo fundamental human liberties in the falsely-supported pursuit of safety and security.


Let's not forget that the University was aware of these actions that said government was going to take in advance (see Section G); and on the balance of probabilities, given their commercial position on the matter as well as the nature of relationships between academia and the country's respective industries – in this case, the medical/healthcare sector – the University of Auckland at least was more than willing to play their part in the stripping away of the basic human liberties of the majority of Kiwis during the 'convenient' SARS-CoV-2 pandemic period.


To reiterate what's already been discussed, this matter is now something which the current government has taken upon itself to explore. Both they and the public may be better suited to do so than the Club is.


Nonetheless, the public should reassess how much attention it gives to academic institutions because these groups – along with the commercial sector – have massive influence on public policy; and as such, affairs which transpire in University campuses – such as those covered in the Accord – should be a matter of significant public interest. This does not take away from the value which external parties which the Club has directly engaged with, and is something worthwhile for Committee members to continue doing in earnest.



The University of Auckland (as an educational institution in trade):


There is no running away from the commercial realities of the world, regardless of which economic ideal one subscribes to.


At the same time, universities must retain their status as the de facto conscience of society; and they are struggling with this.


The Club cannot be both restricted by the University's risk-averse post-pandemic commercial messaging AND have its Committee forgo pointing out that the University executive's 'textbook' strategy may actually be doing more harm than good.



Campus Life Directorate, Student Groups, University Health and Counselling, A.U.S.A. (& large student experience service providers):


It is not a stretch to presume that process-driven subunits within (and in the case of the Student Association, among) the University carry greater influence, and have greater access to resources – human, financial, commercial, or otherwise – than the Club. By extension they are also naturally favoured by both the University and external parties which may want access to the circa-42,000 persons on campus.


Perhaps the reader can do basic fact-finding and arithmetic in how the Club's restricted customary access to 2023 services on the false premises these groups have acted on has impacted the Club in general. Further to this point, in a comparable manner to how the Clubs Support Committee (which includes members – or receives guidance – from the described parties) willingly engaged in questionable conduct, and/or acted maliciously on incomplete information, and/or have been very discreet in how they've actioned their statutorily obligated and/or protected biases against the University of Auckland Motorsport Club's leadership; it may be worthwhile to complete the remedial process described earlier in this document (one which is foreseen to not go beyond the Vice-Chancellor's office) upon its distribution to membership.


It may also be worthwhile noting that in the context of organisational management, structure and strategy; AUSA's current fundamental value-proposition is that of a de facto third-party between students and the University. There have been multiple instances over the past decade where this standard relationship was jeopardised, whether it by way of New Zealand legislation or incidents with student groups who don't subscribe to the comfort of uniformity (in opinion).


Expanding on this is beyond the scope of the Accord, though it is advantageous to consider that no large countermoves – on principle – should be taken by the campus community or the University in 'returning' things to how these parties interact with the student body (and among each other) without first satisfying an inclusive and representative assessment of the quorum threshold. Given that the last series of recorded participation from students – by way of plenary or otherwise – suggests that this current community structure may not be completely representative of student views.


Further to the above, cross-referencing the timing of correspondences between members of the Committee and these parties indicate that in practise – as per Section F), point 4 re: technical and regulatory realities – matters of confidentiality are typically foregone in favour of seeking a desired outcome by any party involved (until of course one of these parties chooses to escalate matters to litigation, at which point, the very same technical and regulatory realities become a defensive tool). In other words, the inequitable and asymmetric access to knowledge and resources permits the groups external to the Club to exercise a sophisticatedly discreet level of 'active measures'  toward the Clubs membership and executive.


This does not detract from the positive-sum seeking actions which these subunits engage in – or are otherwise obligated to do – on behalf of the student body. The Club only asks that those with the legitimate and collegiate authority to remedy the outcomes for our membership throughout and after the pandemic actually get around to doing so before their agreed deadlines for 2024.



Fork-Club ("Vroom"): A crash course in Tikanga?


Notwithstanding the probability of the fork-Club being analogous to the University executives' yearning to have a[n implicit] conversation with the Committee as per section 267 of the Education and Training Act 2020 (the fork-Club's documentation carries many parallels with certain University and motorsport volunteering organisation policies), a significant amount of consideration has been given to 'Vroom'; express examples of which include the main Club extending multiple peaceable offers to subsidise their activities (prior to SG-CL having a field day with exponentially removing/interfering the Club's access to University and non-University systems).


Fundamentally this fork-Club is potentially a physical, digital, and arguably a spiritual manifestation of the University's commitment to the future, communicating Tikanga  and Mātauranga Māori concepts to Club leadership. The Committee did not get in the direct way of this, in reciprocal protest against the way that this Rangatahi-led collective – and their benefactors – did to the Club.


This peaceable and largely silent protest on the consistently uncollegiate and arguably manipulative and misleading behaviour (see 8 November 2022, 30 January 2023, 31 March 2023, April 2023 and 2 June 2023 entries in Section I) to name a few) manifested in discoveries about the nature of:

  • The fork-Club;

  • The high-participation members of the University community; and

  • If the Committee's assessment of staff movement/rotation in the University, Campus-Life Directorate, Students Groups, AUSA and other external parties;


The outcomes resultant from the formation and supposed SG-CL recognition of the fork-Club was zero-sum. This is even more concerning given that at times, the influence of both internal and external parties to the Club extended well beyond the UoA student groups domain where Committee members repeatedly received unsolicited engagements and correspondences in their personal lives and places of employment.


The opposite side of this coin is the Committee's continued acknowledgement of the quality of the fork-Club's work; which, in the context of acquiring requisite skills not only valuable in motorsport, but potentially in any field which members of the community choose to find themselves in. This 'mihi' has been informally intimated to Student Groups (18 July 2023 entry in Section I), former members of the Committee, and student-body-embedded members of industry throughout the fork-Club's even more nascent formation.


In the pursuit of a globally optimal outcome – regardless if this is attainable, or even definable – the first step is acknowledging economic realities of the nation's current social framework (something which was naively used as ammunition against the Club proper). Aside from the cultural drivers that favoured the creation of this fork-Club – and the corresponding 'marginal economic wins' from attempting to serve narrative-favoured demographics – the economic pie in our increasingly technical society requires the bravery and confidence to embrace radical change in process, perceptions and standards, all grounded in the fundamental laws of nature (née physics).


The fork-Club, its executive, and their benefactors from University and industry should know at least half of this equation in the areas of, at the minimum, sustainability and reciprocity. The challenge then is addressing the sociocultural inertia from unaddressed traumas which ultimately prevents not just the University motorsport communities from "meeting halfway" but, in the extrapolation of this idea at a national – and arguably a global – level, the forgoing of the synergies in permitting the spirit of youthful entrepreneurial curiosity from young or old, Māori or Pākehā to flourish in a positive-sum deviation from process. A practical application of the 'hard heads, soft hearts'  mantra may then be called for from everyone involved, given that it is arguably an everyday part of the Kiwi way of life.


K) VALUE-ADDED INSIGHTS AND PROPOSALS


A summary of the Accord at the end of this section warrants that the themes discussed in the prior Section need not be discussed in unnecessary length. They are but a way for the member reading this to get back on track with what is the worthwhile baseline for the Club.


Taking into account the paradigm shift resultant from the chaos of the pandemic, coupled with the University's potentially discreet and extremely sophisticated active management of the community environment on campus (with smoking guns described as early as the 2nd of February 2023 entry in Section I); the Club's 'ahi kā' may have only been kept alight by the most doggedly stubborn and comparably sophisticated members of the Committee, ultimately at zero-sum detriment to the community by virtue of 'workload vectors' cancelling each other out in the delivery of the Clubs Objects and Guiding Values.

Had the pandemic – and all corresponding governance decisions – not come into fruition, then the natural order of student group affairs would have ensured that no significant disruption to the community's customary calendar of annual events would have taken place (and by extension, skewed the indicators for the ill-informed managerial class to justify the poorly thought through – and potentially malicious – decisions they ended up taking in 2023). It's further worthwhile noting that the relatively open-sourced calendar of 2023 gave the statutorily-favoured collectives on campus a reference point to undercut what the main-Club had in store for the year. This 'event war' if you will was ultimately a futile exercise in attendance cannibilisation which drove more traditional/less radical members of the student body away from potentially attending events and/or getting involved. The New Zealand motorsport community has had comparably repeated challenges to the use and occupation of its spaces in the past, so it is of no surprise to the Committee to see such a politicised academic environment shoot itself in the foot and subsequently infect its stakeholder communities with the culture it has encouraged in recent history.


This level of disruption and lost opportunity for the community may as well yield a higher-return – on investment or otherwise – outcome in the form of flagship events and process innovations such as the continued delays to the UoA Motorsport Club Grand Prix AND and the corresponding alternate executive selection format which distances itself from the very culture which permitted the atrocious outcomes from the past three years to manifest in the first place. Such a target may require a level of collaboration between existing members of the community on campus, though let it not be forgotten that those with the greatest influence on the political, economic, sociocultural and technological environment had a very large part to play in outcomes for this community over the past three years (at the least). What would this entail? Please read on for your consideration.



"Merge" Narrative:


This proposal is the most challenging to achieve in the context of this community as the current environment which this is being proposed in does not satisfy the sensibilities of all from campus and industry. The 'merge' narrative – as expressly floated to Club leadership by a voluntary student delegate of the University, industry, and potentially less independent members of the student body from the 1st of September 2022 – included meetings and exchanges between the Committee and senior Motorsport New Zealand executives in 2022.


The synergistic value that this concept may generate for all parties is not being dismissed, however the current zero-sum format where the campus motorsport collectives with enthusiastic support from the University receiving an assymmetric voice on this community's governance table – as potentially entertained throughout the 2023 academic year via Vroom and UoA-FSAE's discreet collaborative effort (starting from the 20th of September, 2023) – goes expressly against the globally optimal target which this Club is seeking.


Committee members have expressed to the more social-weighted industry partners (e.g. Red Bull) that the Club favours the potential positive outcomes from initiatives such as this, provided that it is done with holistic care. On the other hand, more technical members of the University motorsport community have indicated that their past efforts to integrate the different dimensions of motorsport has been a challenge to commercially justify for some in industry (i.e. title sponsorship for events/initiatives with lower market saturation).


To see this proposal begin to take shape would entail UoA-MSC's executive being provided a fair and present opportunity to realise the proposed globally optimal iteration of the UoA Motorsport Club Grand Prix – a sporting flagship which may see educational and social elements incorporated in its design – before any merge narrative is entertained. This concept can be extrapolated as far in any direction as the proponents of the proposal would like to take it; but it has to be comprehensive, and may require an equitable consultation period where students/members/alumni from the social, educational, AND sporting segments of the community are incorporated into the decision-making process.



Hypothesis Testing (UoA Motorsport Club Grand Prix):


To have SG-CL – via the Campus Life Directorate or other appropriate party – remedy the negative outcomes from 2023 by way of reversing the restrictions which their self-conferred powers have permitted them to enact on the Club, its Committee and its membership is a no-brainer in getting this idea to begin.


The three existing motorsport/motoring collectives on campus (UoA-FSAE, Vroom.UoA, and UoAmotorsportNZ) are fundamentally analogous to the educational, social, and sporting pillars of the community. To merge these three at the current state of the campus environment, as discussed throughout the Accord, is not a reasonable – nor is it a managerially sound – pathway to identify the globally optimal outcome for the diverse motoring community and student body.


The organisational format by which both UoA-FSAE and Vroom – as prescribed by SG-CL and largely followed by the majority of other UoA student groups – are essentially the null hypothesis. The UoA Motorsport Club Grand Prix – where core executives are selected on merit, good character, and a faithful pursuit of the motorsport industry's guiding initiatives is a worthwhile 'alternative hypothesis' to pursue.


There is comparable precedent for this format in multiple disciplines including the America's Cup Deed of Challenge, Nissan PlayStation's GT Academy (which plucks talent from the eSport athlete pool and throws them in real racing cars), and a whole host of other initiatives from industry which sought to lower the barriers to motorsport competition (Formula 1,  iRacing, Kartsport).



Summary: Motorsport, a Language Conversation


On the very reasonable assumption – via the balance of probabilities – that the University has activated its internally conferred powers to 'teach the club from a distance à la ETA 2020 s267, the Committee humbly requests that those in the University who participated in the actions and omissions which resulted in the zero-sum outcomes for the University of Auckland Motorsport Club in 2023 do their utmost to 'right' the wrongs directed by words and/or conduct toward the Club. Said piece of legislation – as with any law in our land – is ultimately a tool which, by process of first principles, is enforced and enacted by people. If the people tasked with upholding those contracts are not of good character, then what's the incentive for each individual to abide by them in good faith?


What the Accord ultimately does is highlight the issues from Te Tiriti* via parallel issues with The University of Auckland Motorsport Club, beginning with the ambiguous original Constitution; subsequent challenges experienced as a result of an 'alien' black swan in the form of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic; and the 24-month long incubation period to present a recursively educational process; where the relative complexity of the Accord as a potential 'true' foundational document encourages the attainment of requisite skills for excellence in our increasingly complex and interconnected society.


Like unfurling a Koru's Fibonacci structure, this process starts with one (i.e. the individual member) exercising the process toward mastery; for only the individual can make the incremental leaps toward excellence via that path. The Club seeks to show them this path and support them in taking it via cocreation and collaboration with the University of Auckland community.


*Applying first principles thinking to New Zealand's Treaty of Waitangi suggests that it was an oversimplified and ambiguously applied contract relying on multicultural technicalities that permitted Her Majesty's subjects to forgo Tikanga Maori – and by the process of extrapolation, temporal or otherwise – the 'Kiwi way of Life' (something which every New Zealander largely practises on a day-to-day basis).


Protections provided by a monarchical partner should have been grounded in benevolence, good faith, and good character; regardless of any formalities. This was clearly something that the then Queen Victoria – and all of her subsequent successors – failed to manage with any level of detail or duty of care as conducted by their delegates to Aotearoa from 1840 onwards.


The Accord provides an opportunity to revisit – and ultimately reimagine an alternative hypothetical outcome via The University of Auckland Motorsport Club – the shortcomings of how The Treaty (of Waitangi) as a foundational document for Aotearoa-New Zealand was never a wholehearted agreement in good faith between the Tangata Whenua and the then Queen Victoria of the United Kingdom (on the grounds that the delegates tasked by Her Majesty with upholding Te Tiriti's ambiguously understood dual-nature acted in accordance with their worldview, at the zero-sum expense of the then – and still-present – inequities resultant from a widespread misunderstanding of Mātauranga Māori's untapped potential for value-creation and capture).


L) ADOPTION OF ANNUAL REPORT


As per T&C's.



M) TREASURER'S STATEMENT


https://drive.google.com/file/d/1t8g169F5dQecYcklagHO9DKfXc9V6SHd


Note that Vroom Constitution made reference to the content of this statement of financial position; including "wish list" line items which were a consolidaton of past and present Committee members' ideation processes. Some of these line items were approved in part or in full by the Clubs Support Committee.



N) THE UNIVERSITY OF AUCKLAND MOTORSPORT CLUB GRAND PRIX


To be actioned, pending appropriate event activation measures (marketing, venue reservation, etc.).



O) THANK YOU TO OUTGOING EXECUTIVE


To be resolved. Interested members who did not expressly participate with the problem-GE's antics have been discouraged to participate given what transpired in 2022 and 2023 as covered in Section I) Timeline of Key Milestones.



P) DETERMINATION OF ANNUAL MEMBERSHIP FEE


Accounted for in Constitution. Rolling iteration on this (sliding scale, $1 to $10) was explored. It may not be financially appropriate at this stage and may be more suited when the Club has the capacity for incorporated society/charitable trust status.



Q) NOTICE/S OF MOTION


To be appended (if any).



R) URGENT GENERAL BUSINESS



With the blessing of those in our plenary who chose to stay aboard the Club's membership, remaining active Committee Members shall:

1. Consolidate administrative documents for SG-CL delivery (and follow-up), including:

  • Membership list confirmation and validation (including identifying members who are now alumni);

  • Statement of Financial Position finalisation;

  • Prime 'The Accord' as hybrid-AGM documentation (with respect to the next point of business);


2.  Given the articulated detrimental outcome for the majority of the motorsport community outlined in significant detail in Section I, begin a systematic remedial process in earnest, including but not limited to the following action points:


  • Have the restrictions which SG-CL placed on the Clubs digital assets such as those placed on Meta Platforms Inc. (i.e. Instagram, Facebook), LinkedIn, etc.;

  • Have the questionable restrictions which SG-CL placed on Committee members University of Auckland systems remedied and righted to the way they were prior to their team's collective conduct being actioned (as outlined on the 3rd of April, 1st of June, and 3rd of July 2023 Timeline of Key Milestones entries in Section I);

  • Have any and all other restrictions which have – or may have – serious, grievous, and detrimental potential impact on the Club's operation removed moving forward.


3. Retrieve Club bank account access.


4. Consider exploring other service providers who may provide the Club with an on-ramp toward having redundancies/back-ups and/or outright alternatives to what it has utilised previously.


5. Follow up with parties that we were not able to follow up with properly in 2023 (Red Bull, Hampton Downs Apartments Manager, Ace Karts, etc.).


6. In failing any of the above, active Committee members shall enter into negotiations with any party deemed to embody the positive-sum outlook requisite of this Club's globally optimal outcome target. This includes proposing a bespoke format for this Club's presence on campus by way of a memorandum in good faith and/or contract with no further personal outlay from the Committee.


S) CLOSURE


First 'lap' of this AGM-h's digital segment provisionally closed this 25th of January, 2024.


In the instance of broken links, consider accessing them from the following archive databases:


Wayback Machine (Internet Archive): https://web.archive.org/

Webpage Archive (archive.today): https://archive.is/

Web Gyotaku (Megalodon citation service): https://megalodon.jp/


UoA-MSC ACCORD: CONSTITUTION AND RULES OF THE UNIVERSITY OF AUCKLAND MOTORSPORT CLUB (2024+)


1. Name


(a) The University of Auckland Motorsport Club shall be the official name of the Club frequently referred to by the following titles–


i. Motorsport Club

ii. UoA Motorsport

iii. @UoAMotorsportNZ

iv. UoA-MSC


(b) For the purposes of this Constitution; The University of Auckland Motorsport Club shall be referred to as “the Club.”


2. Objects


The Club shall have as its objects the following, namely –


(a) To promote safety in the operation of motor vehicles;


(b) To advocate for motorsport within the University;


(c) To facilitate the participation of students in motorsport-related events and competitions;


(d) To promote knowledge and understanding of the nature of motorsport to students, faculty, and the general public alike, as being a pursuit enjoyed by many New Zealanders and part of the ‘Kiwi way of life’;


(e) To provide moral instruction, intellectual improvement, and enrichment of members’ physical, emotional, social, interpersonal, and spiritual life through the mutual enjoyment of and affection for motorsport;


(f) To render contributions on behalf of the University and members to the quality, discipline, sportsmanship, and esteem of motorsport in New Zealand;


(g) To render contributions to the sporting reputation and general esteem of the University of Auckland; and


(h) To represent the sport of motorsport to University students, faculty, and staff in a positive manner conducive to the aforementioned Objects (a) – (g) by applying the Guiding Values held by the Club as delineated in section (3).


3. Guiding Values


The Club holds as its’ guiding values the following –


(a) Sportsmanship;


(b) Mastery, as attained through personal dedication, sacrifice, and resilience;


(c) Integrity and Fairness, as embodied by the individual and organisation;


(d) Courage, fearlessness, dedication, and fortitude in attaining the highest virtues of character and personal development in all areas of life; and


(e) Good faith, whereby –


i. The express definitions within the Club’s Constitution;

ii. The University of Auckland’s statutes, regulations and policies;

iii. The Fédération Internationale de l’Automobile (F.I.A.)’s #PurposeDrivenMovement;

iv. Initiatives comparable to the F.I.A.’s #PurposeDriven Movement from, but not limited to –


a. The Fédération Internationale de Motocyclisme (F.I.M.),

b. Motorsport New Zealand (M.S.N.Z.),

c. Motorcycling New Zealand,

d. Other (inter)regional motoring and/or transport-themed organisations’ corresponding initiatives that align with the Club’s Objects under section (2), and


v. The unintended misalignments – and subsequent loopholes – within and between the foregoing subsections under section (3) above, with respect to New Zealand Legislation;


Are applied and engaged with in a manner that promotes the Objects of the Club as delineated in section (2).


4. Attainment of Constitutional Terms: Extraordinary Circumstances


During periods of extraordinary circumstances, including but not limited to –


(a) Circumstances defined as emergencies under the Civil Defence Emergency Management Act, S4;


(b) Instances of force majeure not defined by section (4), subsection (a);


(c) Egregious acts and/or omissions from internal and/or external parties which have a serious, grievous, and/or detrimental impact on the Club;


i. Serious, grievous, and/or detrimental may be defined as any act or omission – unlawful or otherwise – which prevents the Club from peacefully and uninterruptedly pursuing its Objects and Guiding Values as delineated in section (2) and (3) respectively.


(d) Motions to activate section (18) Dissolution and cumulative motions which alter the Constitution to reduce the barrier to activating section (18);


The Club shall be empowered to appoint a Founding, Life Member and/or a Foundational Life Member to support the pursuit of the terms of this Constitution; who shall be empowered to benevolently do all things which are incidental to and necessary for the attainment thereof – as described in Prepare To Win, Chapter 13, p158 by Carroll Smith c1975 (“ORGANIZATION” subheading, paragraph 1).



5. Property of the Club


(a) The property of the Club shall be defined as any asset – legally held under the Club’s legal title – with an assignable ‘book value’;


(b) All of the Club’s property must be recorded in the Club’s asset register;


(c) The Club shall apply all of its property – and income – for the purpose of attaining the Objects delineated in section (2), with respect to the following –


i. No part of that property or income shall be paid or otherwise distributed, directly or indirectly, to members of the Club or any other person or entity, except in good faith in the promotion of the said Objects;


6. Powers of the Club


The Club – in accordance with its Objects, Guiding Values, and New Zealand Legislation – confers on itself the following powers, including but not limited to –


(a) The acquisition, holding, dealing with, use, and disposing of any real, personal and/or intellectual property;


(b) To open and operate bank accounts;


(c) To borrow money upon such terms and conditions as the Club thinks fit;


(d) To invest its money in any security in which trust moneys may be invested or any other manner authorised by the rules of the Club;


(e) To give such security – via the Club’s property or otherwise – for the discharge of liabilities incurred by the Club as the Club thinks fit;


(f) To appoint agents and employees to transact any business of the Club on its behalf – for reward or otherwise – in the promotion of its Objects;


(g) To build, construct, erect, maintain, alter, and repair any premises, building, or other structure of any kind and to furnish, equip and improve the same for use by the Club;


(h) To accept donations and gifts in accordance with the Objects of the Club;


(i) To print and publish any information by approved physical or digital media including – but not limited to – newsletters, newspapers, articles, leaflets, websites, social media and/or campus marketing for promotion of the Club;


i. Media approval is at the discretion of the Management Committee and must uphold the Clubs' Objects and Guiding Values; with particular consideration given to section (2) subsection (e) in order to protect our membership;


(j) To provide gifts and prizes to members for the promotion of the Club, in accordance with the Objects and Guiding Values of the Club;


(k) To organise events of a social, sporting, and/or educational nature for members and the promotion of the Club; and


(l) To enter into any other contract the Club considers necessary or desirable.


7. Membership


(a) Membership shall be open to – in accordance with The University of Auckland’s Clubs Support Committee’s prescribed membership ratio of at least 70% University of Auckland students – any student, faculty member, staff member, affiliate, and/or friend of The University of Auckland, being of good character, who wishes to further the interests of the Club; and who subscribes to this Constitution; and abides by the Club’s Objects and Guiding Values, as set out in sections (2) and (3) respectively.


(b) Any person seeking membership shall complete the appropriate membership application form as indicated by the Club;


(c) Membership Categories


i. Ordinary Member


Any person who is a financial member of the Club is entitled to enjoy the privileges of the Club, and – after having the soundness of their character confirmed in accordance with section (12) subsection (a) – hold any office they are deemed capable of holding with the Club in accordance with section (12) all-inclusive.


ii. Sporting Member


Persons who are interested in the in-person playing activities of the Club may become a Sporting Member. These persons enjoy the privileges of Ordinary Members at a greater membership levy to account for incidentals – including but not limited to –


a. Licensing (with appropriate governing body)

b. Registration (with appropriate governing body)

c. Insurance

d. Maintenance/Upkeep (of Club Assets)

e. Miscellaneous


iii. Life Member


Life Membership is gifted to individuals who have given outstanding service to the Club. These members are exempt from Financial Membership obligations in section (8) to recognise their contribution to the Club and its Objects.


Life Members, Foundational Life Members, and/or Management Committee may elect any member who has been a member of the Club for at least four (4) financial years who –


a. Has been a contributing member of the Executive; and/or

b. Has given outstanding service to the Club.


Any member may nominate a person to Club Executive for Life Membership consideration. Unless expressly described otherwise; Life Members shall have all the rights, privileges, and duties of other members.


iv. Foundational Life Members


Foundational Life Members – having been instrumental in the formation of the Club – carry the same rights, privileges, and duties as Life Members. These members shall be:


a. Those who have voluntarily held Management Committee roles at any point during the Club's first epoch and wish to be assigned Foundational Life Member status; and/or


b. May include members who are instrumental in aiding with the Club’s pursuit of a desirous legal status, including but not limited to incorporated society and/or charitable trust registration.


v. Management Committee Member


Management Committee Members are as described in section (10). These persons are exempt from Financial Membership obligations in section (8) to recognise their desire and competence to contribute to the Club’s Objects.


(d) Member rights, responsibilities, and duties: Unless expressly described in this Constitution; each person admitted to membership shall be –


i. Bound by the Constitution of the Club;


ii. Come liable for such fees and subscriptions as may be fixed by the Club; and


iii. Entitled to all advantages and privileges of the relevant membership category.


(e) Rights, responsibilities and duties: Special membership statuses –


i. Foundational Life Members shall have their special Management Committee privileges – including but not limited to deliberate statuses and casting votes – activated upon participation in one (1) playing activity with the Club during the past twelve (12) months. They are considered ‘active’ upon special status activation;


ii. Life Members shall have their special Management Committee privileges – including but not limited to deliberate statuses and casting votes – activated upon participation in one (1) playing activity with the Club during the past twelve (12) months. They are considered ‘active’ upon special status activation;


iii. For the purposes of this Constitution, a playing activity shall be defined as any activity which may be expressly categorised as a social, sporting, and/or educational event; that the Club has either organised or has been invited to; that does not exist solely for the purposes of Club business and administration.


(f) The Management Committee shall appoint a member of the Management Committee to maintain an up-to-date register of members of the Club.


(g) A member may at any reasonable time inspect the non-sensitive and non-confidential records and documents of the Club.


8. Membership Fees, Subscriptions & Financial Membership Term Lengths


(a) Membership fees must be levied by the Club in order for members to fulfil their financial membership obligations under section (7) subsection (c);


(b) Prospective financial members of the Club may obtain the aforementioned membership status with respect to the following term lengths –


i. Semester: A five-dollar ($5.00) membership fee received in advance – or during a specific academic semester – will see a person’s financial membership status be carried through to the end date of that semester,


ii. Annual: A ten dollar ($10.00) membership fee received in any date of a calendar year will see a person’s financial membership status be carried for 12 months, starting from the date which the levy was received by the Club;


(c) A person’s financial membership status terminates upon the completion of their specified membership term unless otherwise renewed – in advance or at the discretion of the Club Officer or Executive managing that particular membership account (with approval from the Management Committee).


(d) A financial member with a Semester or Annual membership status may receive a full refund of their membership fee should the Club receive a notice of their desire to terminate their corresponding membership status –


i. During the first two (2) weeks of the academic semester which their membership levy was paid, or


ii. Within seven (7) days from the date which their membership fee was received by the Club.


(e) A financial member with an Annual membership status may receive a partial refund of their membership fee should the Club receive a notice of their desire to terminate their corresponding membership status –


i. After the terms described in the foregoing section (8) subsection (d), and/or


ii. On the Sunday before the following University of Auckland Club Expo,


(f) In exceptional circumstances – including but not limited to financial and/or personal hardship – the Club Officer or Executive managing a particular membership application may reduce or waive the applicant’s financial membership obligation in order for the member to partake in the Club’s playing activities (with approval from the Management Committee).


i. Members who have had to utilise this subsection may enjoy the privileges of holding office upon either fulfilling the financial obligation OR volunteering to become a General Executive.


(g) Subscriptions for non-members may be levied by the Club by approval of the Management Committee. Approval of said subscriptions shall be by way of resolution of the Committee.


9. Dispute Resolution & Membership Suspensions/Expulsions


Any financial member of the Club may be suspended or expelled at the discretion of the Management Committee should the conditions in the following subsections be satisfied;


(a) In accordance with the Club’s Guiding Values in section (3); the Management Committee reserves the right to suspend or expel – by unanimous resolution of active Founding and/or Life Members – any financial member of the Club for –


i. False or inaccurate statements made in the member’s application for membership with the Club,


ii. Serious and grievous breach of any rule or regulation of the Club during the period of time which the member has been categorised as a member of the Club in accordance with sections (7) and (8), as determined by the Management Committee,


iii. Any act or omission significantly detrimental to the Club,


iv. The determination of what act or omission is “significantly detrimental” or constitutes a “serious and grievous” breach, for the purposes of subsection (8, a, ii), is vested in the discretion of the Management Committee, in accordance with the principles of natural justice, precedent, and Guiding Values.


(b) Suspensions under subsection (a) shall occur should the Management Committee deem that permitting the member(s) to continue to enjoy the privileges of membership poses a serious, grievous, and/or significantly detrimental impact to the Club;


(c) No suspension shall be valid unless the member who is expelled is notified in writing of the Management Committee’s resolution by the Secretary or other appropriate Club officer, executive or correspondent not less than two (2) working days subsequent thereto;


(d) Suspended members may discuss their suspension with the Management Committee by way of a Management Committee meeting – or a sub-committee formed for this purpose – with the aim of having their suspension passed or overturned, followed by the reasons for the decision clarified. Upon having their suspension passed, members may utilise this subsection up to three (3) times, with the process for expulsion to be set in motion after their third suspension;


(e) Expulsions under subsection (a) and (b to d) shall occur only after due inquiry has been undertaken; with The University of Auckland’s policies, rules, and regulations being mirrored by the Management Committee – and if deemed necessary – with guidance from a Life and/or a Foundational Life Member in accordance with section (4).


(f) No expulsion shall be valid unless the member who is expelled is notified in writing of the Management Committee’s unanimous resolution by the Secretary or other appropriate Club officer, executive or correspondent not less than two (2) working days subsequent thereto;


(g) Any member who is expelled, shall have the right to appeal against their expulsion by presenting their case to a Management Committee meeting called for such purpose, and the decision of the Management Committee meeting shall be final;


(h) A Management Committee Meeting for the purpose of subsection (g) shall in no case take place more than three months subsequent to notice being given to the appellant pursuant to subsection (f);


(i) Appeals against expulsion must be notified in writing to the Secretary of the Club not less than seven (7) working days after the date on which the member is notified in writing of the said resolution in accordance with subsection (g).


10. Management Committee


(a) Management of the Club shall be vested in – in good faith – the Management Committee; who are entrusted to uphold the Club’s Objects and Guiding Values. These persons shall consist of;


i. Life Member and/or Foundational Life Member,

ii. President or Co-President (gifted or voluntary),

iii. Secretary or Co-Secretary (gifted or voluntary),

iv. Treasurer or Co-Treasurer (gifted or voluntary),


(b) No person – aside from a Life Member or Foundational Life Member exercising their obligations under section (4) Attainment of Objects: Extraordinary Circumstances – shall hold more than one position on the Management Committee at any one time.


(c) Management Committee members (gifted or voluntary) may volunteer to uptake one more term – for a maximum of two terms – in their respective role; should they feel – in accordance with section (2) subsection (d), and section (3) subsection (b) – that this is necessary for the Club to attain its Objects.


(d) Persons in their voluntary second terms must ensure that they are co-creating with; and guiding their peers in their respective roles, with the same acts of good faith being extended to them by said peers.


(e) A person who has utilised the foregoing subsections (c) and (d) – aside from a Life Member or Foundational Life Member – shall cease to be a member of the Management Committee at the conclusion of the subsequent Annual General Meeting which follows their reception. They will be eligible to partake in the Committee onboarding process as delineated in section (12), Executive Screening, Determination, Reception, Role Descriptions, and Duties.


(f) A quorum of the Management Committee shall be half of its members in whole plus one. In the absence of at least five (5) Committee Members in attendance and/or a tied vote is probable (i.e. 6, 8, etc. attendees); a Life Member or a Foundational Life Member shall be entitled to a deliberate and casting vote.


(g) Provided that no instances of disruption – including but not limited to technical difficulties; emergencies as defined under the Civil Defence Emergency Management Act, S4; and other unforeseen circumstances such as force majeure/Acts of God – impact the attendance of a President or Co-President, then a chairman nominated by the meeting shall chair that meeting.


(h) Should it be found that the non-exhaustive list of disruptions above has not been considered prior to a chairman being nominated, then the Management Committee meeting shall not be valid.


(i) A member of the Management Committee, with the exception of Life and Foundational Life Members, shall cease to be a Management Committee member in the event of their absence from three or more meetings without leave/apology.


(j) In the absence of a quorum by virtue of disruptions resultant from but not limited to those described throughout this Constitution; section (4) becomes active.


11. Powers of the Management Committee


(a) The Management Committee shall carry out the day-to-day running of the Association and – in accordance with sections (2), (3) & (4) – shall have the power to –


i. Adjudicate on all matters brought before it which in any way affect the Club;


ii. Cause minutes to be made of all proceedings at meetings of the Committee and General Meetings of members;


iii. Administer the finances, appoint bankers, and direct the opening of banking accounts for specific purposes, and to transfer funds from one account to another, and to close any such account;


iv. Fix the manner in which such banking accounts shall be operated, providing the Management Committee passes all payments;


v. Fix fees and subscriptions payable by members and decide such levies, fines, and charges as is deemed necessary and advisable, and to enforce payment thereof;


vi. Make/amend/rescind rulings (and Bylaws, after the appropriate special/legal status has been obtained by the Club, should it be deemed desirous to obtain any aforementioned special/legal status);


vii. Have the power to form and appoint any sub-committee/s as required for specific purposes, with particular attention paid to the Guiding Value subsections in section (3), including but not limited to the F.I.A.s Purpose Driven movement and/or M.S.N.Z.’s commissions;


viii. May at their discretion employ a person or persons to carry out certain duties required by the Club, at salaries or remunerations for such period of time, as may be deemed necessary or desirable;


ix. Should a vacancy occur on the Management Committee during an appropriate season, calendar year, and/or epoch cycle (4 years), the Management Committee shall tender for a successor until the next Annual General Meeting;


x. Select officer(s) and/or agent(s) of the Management Committee to have custody of the Club’s records, documents, and securities.


12. Officers: Screening, Determination, Reception, Role Descriptions and Duties


(a) Executive Screening: Soundness of Character


i. Members desirous of holding any office must lodge their interest in writing to the Club, or via expressing their interest to a member of the Executive/Management Committee (who shall then direct them to the appropriate expression of interest channel);


ii. These members – upon Management Committee approval – are subsequently eligible to be an official part of the General Executive pool.


iii. General Executives must endeavour to support the Management Committee in their obligations to fulfil the Club’s Objects and Guiding Values;


iv. General Executives are deemed to have displayed Soundness of Character after having completed the two recommended Leadership Training Modules provided by UoA Student Groups (Creating Cultures of Consent and Respect & Addressing Bullying, Harassment, and Discrimination) and/or – at the discretion of the Management Committee – having partaken in three (3) events of the Club in the role of General Executive.


(b) Management Committee: Sports-based Selection


i. Members desirous of being a part of the Management Committee must lodge their interest in writing to the Club via the appropriate expression of interest channel;


ii. Expressions of interest for a Management Committee role shall be by way of the UoA Motorsport Club Grand Prix application form;


(c) UoA Motorsport Club Grand Prix


i. The UoA Motorsport Club Grand Prix (MSC-GP; formerly Spirit of the Times Grand Prix) – in accordance with STATE of MOTION volume 01 – will determine which members desirous of holding Management Committee roles – outside of Founding and Life Membership – are gifted their desired roles;


ii. The MSC-GP shall typically be held during the Club’s Annual General Meeting;


iii. The MSC-GP will see a team-based ‘race-off’ competition between all members who have completed the appropriate application form for the corresponding role they are desirous of holding;


iv. Entrants must exercise the Club’s Guiding Values – with particular attention paid to Sportsmanship – during this event;


v. Should instances of unsportsmanlike conduct be made apparent to the organisers or the Management Committee, the conduct shall be investigated in detail and the Management Committee shall exercise its powers to remedy the instance. The decision of the Management Committee – with respect to sections (2), (3), and (4) – shall be final;


vi. The team-based race-off format will be by way of an in-person, time and/or finishing position-based, competitive, motorsport-themed event; with the person(s) with the best/fastest and second best/second fastest time and/or race-off metric deemed as winners and runners-ups respectively;


vii. Should an individual format for this event – with members either seeking to enter with their peers or seeking to be connected with a like-minded group of potential executives – be deemed desirous in the pursuit of the Club’s Objects and Guiding Values, the Club reserves the right to develop the event in accordance with said sporting format;


viii. During instances of disruption – including but not limited to technical difficulties; emergencies as defined under the Civil Defence Emergency Management Act, S4; and other unforeseen circumstances such as force majeure/Acts of God – the Management Committee reserves the right to rerun, postpone and/or activate the other powers conferred to the Management Committee by the Club’s Constitution;


ix. The winners and runners-up for each corresponding role are to be gifted the privilege of their respective roles by current and/or outgoing Management Committee members, with respect to section (10);


x. In the absence of two candidates competing for any role in the Management Committee, an active Life and/or active Foundational Life Member will be tasked with determining the competence and suitability of the sole candidate for the role;


xii. In the absence of candidates making applications for Management Committee roles and/or an active Founding and/or active Life Member deems the sole candidate incompetent and unsuitable for the role; the active Founding and/or active Life Member(s) are empowered to promote a suitable person into the Executive role(s) in question for the upcoming calendar year.


xiii. Pursuant to section (4); Attainment of Objects: Extraordinary Circumstances; the foregoing subsections are transfixed to sections (2) and (3) which are the Club’s Objects and Guiding Values respectively, along with further collegiate justification as described in S3.4.3 of STATE of MOTION vol. 01.


(d) President Role Description


i. The President manages and oversees the affairs of the Club – in good faith – on behalf of the membership;


ii. The President is responsible for the broad-outlook planning and organisation of the Club;


iii. The President establishes long-term and short-term goals in cooperation with the other officers, who cooperates with the General Executives; and all inclusively cooperates with any appointed sub-committees and parties which the Club deems desirous to engage with;


iv. The President presides at meetings and directs the team in meeting the members’ needs in accordance with the Clubs Objects and Guiding Values;


v. During a calendar year in which a Co-President is present via being a runner-up in the MSC-GP; the MSC-GP winner carries the majority of Presidential obligations, with the Co-President being expected to support the President in fulfilling these obligations;


vi. In the absence of the President, the Co-President shall preside over the President’s responsibilities;


vii. The voluntary Co-President – on their voluntary second term – shall have the same rights, privileges, and obligations as the runner-up Co-President; and in the absence of both, shall preside over the aforementioned responsibilities.


(e) Treasurer Role Description


i. The Treasurer – in good faith – manages the Club’s financial health on behalf of the membership;


ii. The primary responsibilities of the Treasurer include but are not limited to –


i. Handling finances

ii. Collecting membership fees

iii. Maintaining an asset register

iv. Collecting receipts and invoices

v. Paying bills

vi. Preparing an annual financial report for AGM presentation

vii. Reconciling University grant expenditure

viii. Articulated financial affairs under section (15)


iii. During a calendar year in which a Co-Treasurer is present via being a runner-up in the MSC-GP; the MSC-GP winner carries the majority of the Treasurer’s obligations, with the Co-Treasurer being expected to support the Treasurer in fulfilling these obligations;


iv. In the absence of the Treasurer, the Co-Treasurer shall preside over the Treasurer’s responsibilities;


v. The voluntary Co-Treasurer – on their voluntary second term – shall have the same rights, privileges, and obligations as the runner-up Co-Treasurer; and in the absence of both, shall preside over the aforementioned responsibilities.


(f) Secretary Role Description


i. The Secretary – in good faith – co-manages the overall record-keeping of the Club with the President/Co-Presidents and Treasurer/Co-Treasurer;


ii. The Secretary will support the Presidents and Co-Presidents in the public and confidential correspondence of the Club;


iii. The Secretary will ensure that the Constitution is kept up to date, and remains vigilant of changes in the regulatory and governance environments the Club operates under (which may have a notable impact on the fulfilment of the Club’s Objects and Guiding Values);


iv. The Secretary records minutes of meetings and distributes the minutes to the Management Committee and/or membership;


v. During a calendar year in which a Co-Secretary is present via being a runner-up in the MSC-GP; the MSC-GP winner carries the majority of Secretarial obligations, with the Co-Secretary being expected to support the Secretary in fulfilling these obligations;


vi. In the absence of the Secretary, the Co-Secretary shall preside over the Secretary’s responsibilities;


vii. The voluntary Co-Secretary – on their voluntary second term – shall have the same rights, privileges, and obligations as the runner-up Co-Secretary; and in the absence of both, shall preside over the aforementioned responsibilities.


(g) Sub-Committee Leads and Delegates


i. Sub-Committee Leads – in good faith – are mandated to explore and advise of the corresponding section (3) Guiding Value initiatives which the Management Committee deems desirous to fulfil the Club's Objects;


ii. Sub-Committee Delegates – in good faith – shall support and co-create with their Sub-Committee Leads in their chosen Guiding Value initiatives;


iii. Sub-Committee Leads and Delegates – on top of their mandates – carry the same rights, responsibilities, and duties as General Executives.


(h) Legal Obligations


i. All roles with the Club – until such a time that the Club obtains a legal status it deems desirous in the pursuit of its Objects – are only legally binding within the context of New Zealand Legislation, Common Law, and Statute.


13. Meetings


(a) Annual General Meeting


i. The Annual General Meeting (A.G.M.) of the Club should typically be held during the University of Auckland’s inter-semester break; with the Management Committee endeavouring to fulfil this obligation in each academic/calendar year;


ii. A.G.M.’s should typically be held in person with respect to section (12) subsection (c, iii);


iii. The Secretary – or other appropriate Management Committee member – shall give no less than fourteen (14) days notice of the date and agenda of the A.G.M. to financial members;


iv. All financial members may attend the A.G.M.;


v. No Annual General Meeting shall be valid unless the following subsection’s procedures have been activated in cumulative part or in full –


a. The President, Treasurer, Secretary (and/or delegated official for one or all three core executive roles) are present,


i. For the purposes of this subsection, in the instance that irreconcilable differences between the core executive positions and delegates have transpired during the calendar year, a selected Management Committee Member or Life/Foundational Life Member – in accordance with section (4) – are entitled to be deliberate delegated officials for the three (3) core executives.


b. A plenum – minus apologies in advance – should typically be sought during any A.G.M. in order to be as inclusive of the financial membership’s collective views as possible,


c. In the absence of a plenum, an 80% majority must be sought during any A.G.M. in order to be as inclusive of the financial membership’s collective views as possible,


d. In the absence of an 80% majority, the quorum – with respect to section (13) subsection ((a),v.,a.,(i.)) – at the A.G.M. shall be a minimum of 20% of financial members,


e. If, at the end of 20 minutes after the time appointed in the notice for the opening of the Meeting, there is no quorum; The financial members present – with respect to section (13) subsection ((a),v.,a.,(i.)) – shall:


i. Be deemed competent to discharge the business of the meeting,

ii. Initiate the meeting agenda,

iii. Record the minutes of the meeting,

iv. Make the results available to the rest of financial membership online via official Club channels for the purposes of resolution.

v. If there are no substantive objections to the recorded outcome of the meeting after twenty (20) working days from the date of the meeting; the meeting shall be considered valid.

vi. The agenda for an Annual General Meeting shall be;


a. Opening of Meeting

b. Apologies

c. Confirmation of Minutes of previous A.G.M.

d. Presentation of Annual Report

e. Adoption of Annual Report

f. Presentation of Treasurer’s Statement

g. UoA Motorsport Club Grand Prix

h. Vote of thanks to outgoing Executive

i. Determination of Annual Membership Fee

j. Notice/s of Motion

k. Urgent general business

l. Closure


(b) General Meetings


i. Upon assessment of the merits in holding any General Meeting, a General Meeting may be called by –


a. The Management Committee,


b. At the request of the President and Secretary,


c. Written requests – with proof of identification – of twenty (20) financial members of the Club.


ii. The merits for which the meeting is called for lay at the discretion of the Management Committee, with respect to upholding the Club’s Objects and Guiding Values from sections (2) and (3) respectively;


iii. Upon approval of the General Meeting being deemed to have merit; the Secretary shall give at least seven (7) days notice, in writing, of the date of the General Meeting to the members.


iv. Notice of General Meetings shall set out clearly the business for which the meeting has been called. No other business shall be dealt with at that General Meeting.


v. The quorum at the General Meeting shall be a quorum of the Management Committee plus twenty (20) financial members.


vi. The quorum requirement for special and/or bespoke General Meetings shall follow the process for achieving an A.G.M. quorum as outlined in section (13) subsections ((a), v, a.).


(c) Management Committee Meetings


i. The Management Committee shall endeavour to meet at least once every two weeks.


14. Voting


(a) Voting powers at the Annual General Meetings –


i. Pursuant to section (13) subsection (a), each individual financial member present shall have one (1) vote.


ii. In the event of a tied vote; an active Founding Member shall exercise a casting vote.


iii. In the event of a tied vote where an active Founding Member is absent; an active Life Member shall exercise a casting vote.


(b) Voting powers at Management Committee Meetings;


i. Pursuant to section (10), each individual Committee Member present shall have one (1) vote.


ii. In the event of a tied vote; an active Founding Member shall exercise a casting vote.


iii. In the event of a tied vote where an active Founding Member is absent; an active Life Member shall exercise a casting vote.


15. Finance


(a) All funds of the Club shall be deposited into the Club’s accounts at such bank and/or recognised financial institution as the Management Committee may determine necessary or desirable.


(b) All accounts due by the Club shall be paid by an appropriate method – including but not limited to cheque, bank transfer and/or an appropriate electronic transaction – after having been passed for payment at the Management Committee Meeting and, when immediate payment is necessary, account/s shall be paid, and the action endorsed at the next Management Committee Meeting.


(c) An assignee shall not spend more than a set amount Petty Cash without the consent of the Management Committee and shall keep a record of such expenditure in a Petty Cash Book (analogue or digital).


(d) A statement showing the financial position of the Club shall be tabled at each Management Committee Meeting by the Treasurer.


(e) A statement of Income and Expenditure, Assets and Liabilities shall be submitted to the Annual General Meeting. The auditor’s report shall be attached to such financial report should this be deemed necessary by the Club.


(f) The financial year of the Club shall commence on 31st of March each year. The accounts, books and all financial records of the Club shall be audited each year.


g) The signatories to the Club’s account/s will be the Treasurer and can be any one (1) from the following –


• President

• Secretary

• Founding/Life Member


(h) All property and income of the Club will apply solely to the promotion of the Objects of the Club and no part of that property or income shall be paid or otherwise distributed, directly, or indirectly, to members, except in good faith in the promotion of these Objects.


16. Common Seal


(a) The Common Seal of the Club – stylised “M” with racing lines meeting halfway inside a roundel – shall be kept in the care of the Secretary or an appropriate custodian from the Management Committee.


(b) Conditional to section (20) – i .e. after it’s repeal – the Common Seal shall not be used or affixed to any deed or document except pursuant to a resolution of the Management Committee and in the presence of at least the President and two members of the Committee, both of whom shall subscribe their names as witnesses.


17. Alterations to the Constitution, Bylaws & Special Resolutions


(a) Conditional to section (20) and pursuant to sections (2), (3), (4), (13,b,vi); no alteration, repeal or addition shall be made to the Constitution except at the Annual General Meeting, or General Meeting, called for that purpose and notice of all motions to alter, repeal or add to the Constitution shall be given to members at minimum fourteen (14) days prior to the Annual General Meeting, or seven (7) days prior to a special General Meeting called for such purpose;


(b) Conditional to section (20), the Secretary – or other appropriate Management Committee member – shall forward such notices of motion to each Management Committee member at least fourteen (14) days prior to the Annual General Meeting or seven (7) days prior to a General Meeting;


(c) Bylaws – after the appropriate special/legal status has been obtained by the Club – can only be altered during Management Committee Meetings; provided that notice of the proposed alteration/s has been duly notified to Committee Members;


(d) Pursuant to sections (2), (3), (4) and (17,a); such motions, or any part thereof, shall be of no effect unless –


i. The motions satisfy sections (2), (3), (4) and (17,a);


ii. Are passed by seventy five percent (75%) majority (Special Resolution) of those entitled to a vote at an Annual General Meeting or General Meeting, as the case may be; OR


iii. Are passed by of 75% of financial members (with identity verification); consistent with but not legally subject to Subpart 5.4, S89-92 of the Incorporated Societies Act 2022: Resolutions in lieu of meeting.


(e) Conditional to section (20), the Secretary – or other appropriate Management Committee member – shall notify the relevant University authority of the amendment, if appropriate.


18. Dissolution


(a) Pursuant to section (4) of this Constitution – Attainment of Constitutional Terms: Extraordinary Circumstances – dissolution of the Club will be at the discretion of the Management Committee by unanimous vote;


(b) If, on the winding up of the Club, any property of the Club remains after satisfaction of the debts and liabilities of the Club and the costs, charges and expenses of that winding up, that property shall be distributed to –


i. Another incorporated association having objects similar to those of the Club; or


ii. For charitable or benevolent purposes, which incorporated Club – or purposes as the case requires – shall be determined by plenary resolution of the members.


19. Empowerment of Foundation President


(a) Expired in accordance with STATE of MOTION volume 1 (SMv1);


(b) To be repealed pursuant to section (20).


20. Accorded Empowerment of Foundational Life Members


(a) Given what has transpired during the Club’s First Epoch thus far (22 July, 2019 – Present) as described in the report above, and in accordance with:


• Section 4 of the Constitution (4. Attainment of Objects);

• STATE of MOTION (vol. 01);

• UoA Motorsport – Annual General Meeting Minutes (2021)


A sub-committee consisting of Foundational Life Members as described in  section (7, c, iv) shall be empowered to –


i. Retroactively adopt, ratify and promulgate the recommended constitutional amendments articulated in this Constitution, with respect to S3.3.0 to S3.3.1 of STATE of MOTION volume 1 (SMv1) AND in accordance with the original iteration of Section 4: ‘Attainment of Objects’, whereby the Club is “empowered to do all things which are incidental to the attainment (of its corrected Objects and Guiding Values);


ii. The purpose of section (20), subsection (a) inclusive is to ensure that the multiple existing iterations and interpretations of the Club’s Constitution are upheld in a manner of good faith, consistent with the multivariate policies, rules, and regulations of The University of Auckland;


iii. Section (20) subsection (a, iii) is included to provide further context for this aforementioned sections’ purpose; whereby –


• It is fundamental to the prior iteration of Section 4. Attainment of Objects that those empowered to fulfil the Club’s Constitutional Obligations are to action reregistration as a recognised group in campus for the 2023/2024 season – with respect to the Constitutional corrections and synthesis above;


• Thus – in accordance with a globally-optimal precedent – the Club actions the former iteration of Section 4: ‘Attainment of Objects’ one final time in the creation of section (20) to actively correct for the ‘community co-created learning errors’ during the Club’s first epoch.


• Nothing in the foregoing subsections prevents Foundational Life Members from exercising the former iteration of Section 4: ‘Attainment of Objects’ to make amendments for the purposes of correcting errors prior to section (20) subsection (b).


(b) Section (20) of the Constitution – along with all sections which are conditional on section (20) eventually being amended for – expires and is repealed upon either;


i) The sports-based selection of officers at an in-person segment of A.G.M. Part II, and/or III, or


ii) The acknowledgment of The Club's cumulative 2023 A.G.M. as a process of Taonga Tuku Iho for the purpose of the protection, reinvigoration and revitalisation of the social, sporting and educational motoring communities in The University of Auckland.


PROMULGATED FOR THE UNIVERSITY OF AUCKLAND MOTORSPORT CLUB—AND THE AUCKLAND LEARNING QUARTER’S CONSIDERATION—FROM THIS, THE 25th OF JANUARY, 2024.

Senna, Ayrton