Cookie policy

We use cookies for analytics, advertising and to improve our site. You agree to our use of cookies by hitting ‘Accept’ button, closing this message box or continuing to use our site. To find out more see our Privacy policy .

Accept
Ad
North East Issues

Why a nativist group is targeting Muslims in Arunachal Pradesh

The group is tapping into local anxiety about migrants. Its campaign has led to the sealing of two mosques.

On November 22, members of a little-known nativist group arrived at one of the oldest mosques in Arunachal Pradesh, a modest two-storied structure in Itanagar.

The men, belonging to the Arunachal Pradesh Indigenous Youth Organization, demanded to see documentary proof that the Itanagar Jama Masjid, built in 1979 on land donated by a tribal resident, was a legal construction. They were led by their president Taro Sonam Liyak.

Before you scroll further…
Get the best of Scroll directly in your inbox for free.

A mosque official, who is from Assam, told Scroll that he did not give in to their demands. “I did not show them any documents despite the threats and intimidation,” he said. “Why should I? Who are they?”

But the refusal led to violence. “They called me Bangladeshi and kicked the caretaker of the masjid.” The mosque officials have filed written complaints with the police, asking for the registration of a first information report.

The Itanagar Jama Masjid was not the sole target.

A member of the staff of another Naharlagun mosque, Capital Jama Masjid, told Scroll that the group turned up at their premises on November 15. “They intimidated us for over an hour,” he told Scroll, asking that he not be identified. “The police were there but they didn’t stop them,” he said.

A senior official of the masjid committee told Scroll that the mob damaged and vandalised the wazookhana, where ablutions are carried out before prayers, and broke taps. The mosque was built in 2009 at the initiative of Bengali Muslims, but is administered by a group of tribal Muslims.

Advertisement
Ad

Prayers are held in a makeshift tin shed, while the main mosque building is under construction. But APIYO vigilantes accused the mosque officials of building the structure without permission.

Five days later, Naharlagun authorities sealed the mosque, arguing that it was built without a legal permit from Itanagar Planning Authority or the town planning department.

Since October, the Arunachal Pradesh Indigenous Youth Organization has carried out a series of raids on mosques in the Itanagar Capital Region, comprising the two cities of Naharlagun and Itanagar.

Led by the outfit’s head Liyak, they have visited mosques, demanded to see documents, called the mosque officials Bangladeshis, demanded that they say “Bharat Mata ki Jai” and threatened to shut down the places of worship. All of this has been streamed on social media. On December 9, a bandh called by APIYO against “illegal mosques” led to Itanagar and Naharlagun shutting down.

Advertisement
Ad

Since the organisation began its raids, two of the eight mosques in the Itanagar Capital Region have been sealed.

The Masjid Welfare Committee of the region has written to the Bharatiya Janata Party led-state government, asking for action against the group and objecting to their harassment.

A senior member of the committee, who is a tribal Muslim, refuted that the mosques were illegal. “In some cases, documents like the construction permit might be missing,” he said. “But the land on which the mosques were built was given by the local people and they have given the permission.”

He added: “There are numerous unauthorised temples and churches in the state built without permission. But mosques are being specifically targeted.”

Police officials and mosque leaders Scroll spoke to said the anti-Muslim campaign was triggered by eviction drives against Bengali-origin Muslims in Assam, and the growing fear that the displaced “illegal immigrants” were taking over economic activity in the state.

Taro Sonam Liyak, the APIYO president, was seen asking the imam of a Naharlagun mosque to say "Bharat Mata Ki Jai". Credit: Rokibuz Zaman.

‘We do not want mosques’

Arunachal Pradesh has a minuscule Muslim population. According to the 2011 Census, only 27,045 residents or 1.95 % of the state’s population follow Islam.

Advertisement
Ad

Several mosques in Arunachal Pradesh were built on the initiative of Bengali Muslims from Assam, who work here as businessmen or labourers.

Many Muslims from Bihar and Assam’s Lakhimpur district, which shares a border with Arunachal Pradesh, have been trading in the state for decades. “Muslims have been doing business here since Independence,” said a 53-year-old Muslim shopkeeper, who set up business in Itanagar in 2004.

Many construction workers for Arunachal’s infrastructure projects come from Lakhimpur as well. “Over the years, the number of migrants have increased with the construction of roads, dams and buildings increasing,” the shopkeeper said.

Observers said the nativist group has been successful in feeding the anxiety about the growing presence of Muslim migrants in the state.

The outfit’s president Liyak told Scroll: “The migrants dominate in every sector, from construction to market and business. And then we see the mushrooming of mosques in the capital. So, we were alarmed.”

Advertisement
Ad

He said the organisation decided to raid the mosques to see if they had permissions. “We found that they were violating the government norms,” he said. “The mosques give shelter to both legal and illegal migrants.”

Senior police officials put the number of migrant Bengali Muslims, mostly workers and businessmen, at around 13,000 – an estimate that the APIYO agrees on.

Tapor Maying, the general secretary of APIYO, said they “do not want” any mosques in the Itanagar Capital Region. “At the most, we are okay if the authorities give permission to two mosques only,” he said.

Both Maying and Liyak claimed that the Muslim community was involved in the narcotics trade. “Because of them, the crime rate is increasing,” Liyak alleged.

Assam eviction fallout?

The APIYO has also been successful in drumming up fears by linking the presence of Bengali Muslims to evictions in Assam, police officials and observers said.

Advertisement
Ad

Since June, Assam has demolished homes of over 60,000 Bengali Muslim families, who were living on government land. “The local Arunachali people have genuine fears that those being chased away by evictions and demolitions in Assam may enter the state,” said T Amo, Itanagar deputy inspector general of police.

A leading Muslim representative from Itanagar, who does not want to be named because of fear of repercussions, told Scroll, “There has been no clarification from the Assam government that those who are being evicted during demolition drives are genuine Indians, not Bangladeshis.”

A large number of tribal people, he said, believe that the evicted “illegal immigrants” are moving to Arunachal.

Tapor Maying, the general secretary of APIYO, told Scroll: “Himanta Biswa Sarma is chasing illegal immigrants while our chief minister (Pema Khandu) is letting them come here.”

Advertisement
Ad

However, Amo, the senior police official, no illegal migrants or Bangladeshis have been detected in the state this year.

Arunachal Pradesh regulates the entry of “outsiders” to the state through the colonial-era Inner Line Permit system. An inner line permit is an official document issued by the government without which Indian citizens cannot visit or travel the state.

“Some ILP violators were caught and sent back,” Amo said.

Chukhu Apa, Inspector-General of Police, told reporters recently that since January, 8,936 ILP violators have been detected, “out of which 7,351 have been externed”.

The inner line permit is meant to protect the state from extensive migration, which could endanger the identity and heritage of the state’s 26 major tribes and over 100 sub-tribes. It denies voting and land rights to migrants, whether Muslims or Hindus.

Advertisement
Ad

Observers pointed out that the group has been able to tap into the widespread anxiety about the growing presence of migrants. “People rely on migrants but when workers or businessmen move in with their families even if they have individual permits, it triggers a deep resentment,” said journalist Tongam Rina of Arunachal Times.

An Itanagar-based political scientist, who teaches at Rajiv Gandhi University, said the APIYO is taking advantage of the sentiment of the indigenous people”, who believe “that there are too many illegal migrants in the state but the government is not doing anything”.

The sealed Capital Jama Masjid in Naharlagun. The main mosque building is under construction. Credit: Rokibuz Zaman.

The RSS’s old project

Others blamed the surge in anti-Muslim rhetoric and sentiment to an old Hindutva project in Arunachal Pradesh. Ebo Mili, a human rights lawyer based in Itanagar, said the people of state are being “influenced by the anti-Muslim hate orchestrated by the RSS-BJP”.

The APIYO’s drive has the support of the Indigenous Faiths and Cultural Society of Arunachal Pradesh or IFCSAP, an influential group backed by the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh.

Advertisement
Ad

Pai Dawe, vice president of the society, told Scroll that the “threat” posed by Muslim migrants is the “most pertinent” issue of the state. He alleged that Muslim workers, by agreeing to low wages, now dominate construction jobs and corner all economic opportunities. He accused them of “capturing” markets by opening shops and businesses.

“It threatens the very existence of the indigenous people,” Dawe said.

A deserted street in Itanagar during the December 9 bandh called by APIYO leaders. Credit: Rokibuz Zaman

Bengia Ajum, a senior journalist in Itanagar, explained that the “RSS has been active in the state for a very long time, and has made deep inroads into the everyday lives of tribal people”.

The “targeting of Muslims and mosques” is a fallout of the spread of their ideology and shows that “their project has now moved to the next stage.”

The second mosque in Naharlagun sealed after the protests. Credit: Rokibuz Zaman.
We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Get the app Get the app

We need your help

Your $5 a month helps us protect Indian democracy. Become a Scroll Member.

Already a subscriber? Sign In
artificial intelligence

Are ‘data embassies’ the future in era of conflicts, attack on tech infrastructure?

Risk mitigation could mean shifting away from easily identifiable hyperscalers and their gigantic data centres, and picking safer locations.

This article was originally published in Rest of World, which covers technology’s impact outside the West.

The drone strikes on Amazon Web Services data centres in the Persian Gulf, and Iran’s threats to target tech firms for their involvement in US attacks, underline the growing risks that artificial intelligence infrastructure faces in conflicts.

Iran named 18 companies including Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Nvidia, Palantir, and G42, the lead AI firm in the United Arab Emirates, as “legitimate targets.” For AI companies with data centres in the Gulf, risk mitigation could mean shifting away from easily identifiable hyperscalers, picking safer locations, or separating military systems from civilian systems.

None of these options is easy.

Global data centre capacity could reach 200 gigawatts by 2030, doubling capacity, to meet growing demand for AI. While more than half the capacity is being added in the US, data centres are also being built in Asia, Latin America, and the Gulf. AI data centres alone will require a total capital expenditure of more than $5 trillion, according to consulting firm McKinsey....

BOOK EXCERPT

These new volumes bring together selections from TS Eliot’s poetry, plays, and critical essays

An excerpt from TS Eliot’s ‘Essential Poetry’, ‘Selected Poetry and Prose’, and ‘Selected Plays.’

To the Indians who Died in Africa

A man’s destination is his own village,
His own fire, and his wife’s cooking;
To sit in front of his own door at sunset
And see his grandson, and his neighbour’s grandson
Playing in the dust together.

Scarred but secure, he has many memories
Which return at the hour of conversation,
(The warm or the cool hour, according to the climate)
Of foreign men, who fought in foreign places,
Foreign to each other.

A man’s destination is not his destiny,
Every country is home to one man
And exile to another. Where a man dies bravely
At one with his destiny, that soil is his.
Let his village remember.

This was not your land, or ours: but a village in the Midlands,
And one in the Five Rivers, may have the same graveyard.
Let those who go home tell the same story of you:
Of action with a common purpose, action
None the less fruitful if neither you nor we
Know, until the judgement after death,
What is the fruit of action.


Morning at the Window

They are rattling breakfast plates in basement kitchens,
And along the trampled edges of the street
I am aware of the damp souls of housemaids
Sprouting despondently at area gates....

urban development

How the retreat of wealthy Indians into gated townships is worsening urban inequality

Those who can afford to do so, are disengaging from civic governance, leaving the rest to pay a heavy price.

India’s top metros – Delhi, Kolkata and Mumbai, home to 75 million people – rank among the world’s 10 most populous cities. However, “population scale has not translated proportionately into urban productivity, liveability or global economic influence,” the Union government’s Economic Survey 2025-26 admits.

While calling cities “engines of growth, magnets for talent, and crucibles of innovation”, the Survey also labels them “sites of daily strain: long commutes, uneven services and shared spaces that often fall short of collective expectations”.

Indian cities score low in their liveability quotient despite allocations to urban local bodies by the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs and the XIV and XV Finance Commissions topping Rs 8.36 lakh crore in the last decade, according to a new report by Janaagraha and the Jana Urban Space Foundation, not-for-profits working to transform the quality of life in the country’s towns and cities.

The key reason for this lapse, experts say, is the fragmentation of urban functions across urban local bodies, development authorities, state line departments and parastatal agencies. Essentially, local governments haven’t been empowered to do whatever is expected of them....

BOOK EXCERPT

‘Everything changes / Everything remains’: Poems of love and longing in a city

An excerpt from ‘My Dead Flowers’, by Buku Sarkar.

Turn the Turn

We start the morning paralysed,
Like stone.

Then something turns –

Reminds us of all the practical things,
And that becomes our day.
And the day after,
And the day after that.

Until you wake up years later

To realise you’ve taken a wrong turn somewhere –
Lost your way,
So you try and start again,
Or so you say.


False Down

Six in the morning,
A bus to downtown;
Walk straight up 4th Street
To the corner of Second Avenue.

The sky deep blue,
The streets, pink.
Empty sidewalks, strewn cigarette ends,
And the bar lights off.

But I know,
As I knew twenty years ago,
That behind the drawn curtains
The ashtrays are out,
The lines cut neatly on the table,
And old friends

Laugh together
Until sleep turns
To something between dawn and dusk.

They will stay there until eight, I know,
Because where else will they go?

Never home,
Never to real nightfall,
Which only draws out all the things that remain
Hidden during the day.


You Make a Wish

Like snowflakes in July,
softly,
In case someone hears.
(It won’t come true.) ...

literary awards

Megha Majumdar’s ‘A Guardian and a Thief’ is a finalist for $150,000 Carol Shields Prize for Fiction

The jury said the novel ‘drags readers from complacency and forces them to face what can happen to our values when our dearest ones are stalked by disaster.’

The Carol Shields Prize for Fiction is awarded annually to women and non-binary writers for a work of fiction. The Prize is open to writers across the world but the book needs to have been published in Canada and the United States. The winning author will receive a cash prize of $150,000 and a five-night stay at Fogo Island Inn. The four finalists will be awarded $12,500 each.

The winner and four finalists will also participate in a group retreat residency in the Leighton Artist Studios, Banff Centre for Arts and Creativity in Alberta, Canada.

Indian-origin writer Megha Majumdar’s novel, A Guardian and the Thief, has been shortlisted for this year’s Prize. The novel is set in a near-future Kolkata beset by flooding and famine. Majumdar paints a kaleidoscopic portrait of two families, each operating from a place of ferocious love and undefeated hope, each discovering how far they will go to secure their children’s future as they stave off encroaching catastrophe.

The jury said that “[the] harrowing yet captivating novel fills us simultaneously with horror and compassion. Set in a dystopian Kolkata battered by poverty, starvation and severe climate change, it drags readers from complacency and forces them to face what can happen to our values when our dearest ones are stalked by disaster. Through trenchant images, deft character creation, and breathtaking plot-twists, Majumdar embroils us in the lives of Ma and Boomba until we are no longer sure who is the guardian and who the thief.”...

BOOK EXCERPT

In a new book, a nutritionist dispels myths about rice and shows how to consume it in moderation

An excerpt from ‘What, How Much and How to Eat: Simple and Sustainable’, by Amita Gadre.

Does eating rice cause weight gain?

The idea that eating rice causes weight gain is a common misconception. Both rice and wheat chapati are sources of carbohydrates. On its own, neither roti nor rice causes weight gain – unless you are eating copious amounts of it, and are loading it with fat. In reality, gaining or losing weight depends on the overall calorie balance – how many calories are consumed versus how many are expended throughout the day.

The real issue with rice is its portion size

No one eats just one or two spoonfuls of rice; typically, a whole bowl of rice is consumed. Eating large portions of rice increases our overall calorie intake.

Additionally, rice is often eaten with pickles, ghee, chips, papads and other accompaniments, which further increase the total calorie count.

A lot of people stop eating “rice” to lose weight, and some might even come back and tell you that they lost 2–3 kilograms simply by quitting rice. But the fact is that when they stop eating rice, they are cutting out significant calories, as they were not tracking the amount of rice they would take, plus the additional ghee, papad and pickle with it. When people stop eating rice to lose weight, they are actually reducing their total calorie intake, which leads to weight loss. ...

Labour rights

The workers who keep India’s cities running have a simple message – pay us living wages

The past few weeks of protests have shown just how little workers are paid and that even modest demands to sustain a dignified life are violently suppressed.

The protests by workers across Indian cities through early April are an urgent signal that survival is impossible on wages that hover around the bare legal minimum.

Domestic, gig and delivery workers to industrial labourers in the Delhi-National Capital Region protested demanding an increase in wages and overtime pay. Most of them are often migrant workers to India’s urban centres.

The spark was the increase in basic expenses following the shortage of cooking gas and economic uncertainty after the US-Israel launched military strikes on Iran in February, setting off a conflict which is now closing in on two months.

In Noida, protesting workers told the Indian Express that their monthly salaries ranged from Rs 13,000 to Rs 20,000 but expenses had increased, with rent costing Rs 5,000 and food Rs 4,000, and nothing to save. One factory worker in Noida told a news publication that his employer hiked his monthly pay by Rs 39. Worse still, workers report deductions as punishment for protesting and their wage demands were met with batons....

BOOK EXCERPT

A new book shows how the Partition changed India’s psychology and redefined intergenerational trauma

An excerpt from ‘Trauma Nation: Fighting India’s Silent Epidemic’, by Nishtha Lamba.

Ramaji’s house in Quetta stood on a lane that opened into a shared courtyard. The night before she and her family were to leave, the mob had reached the entrance of the courtyard. Her father had heard them approaching. While the mob was breaking down the entrance, her father took the entire family to hide in the farthest house on the street. They switched off the lights and lay face down on the terrace. Ramaji had curled up even more narrating this part of the story. Anjali, who had also learnt of this incident only the previous night, was captivated.

Thankfully, the mob that night had assumed that the houses on the lane were empty and left for the next street. It was clear to all, including Rama’s father, that staying back was not an option. They did not discuss it further. As soon as they reached home, the elders hurriedly started collecting all the cash. They gathered around Rs 22,000 (a significant amount in those days) and some precious jewellery. Rama’s mother made belts out of cotton cloth to conceal their valuables, which were worn by her elder brother and some other members of the family. They had no time or space to take more belongings. They were leaving behind a life built over decades. The men in the family, Ramaji mentioned, looked like “gore-chitte” (fair-skinned) Pathans. So they wore Pathani suits to mask their identity. Her brother hid the “Om” tattoo inscribed on his hand with an extra band of cloth. ...

Kashmir Report

One year after terror attack, Pahalgam remains off the tourist map

Most sightseeing spots remain closed to travellers. This includes the meadow where militants gunned down 26 people last year.

For most tourists heading to the picturesque meadows of Pahalgam in Kashmir, the first stop for many years has been a stone-paved pathway built along the banks of river Lidder.

Standing in its middle, a decorative frame of wooden beams with colorful letters saying “I love Pahalgam”, serves as a popular “selfie point” for travellers.

But now, just 200 metres away, a wall of black granite competes for attention. Two tricolours flutter on top of it. As you step closer, you see etched into stone the names of 26 people gunned down by militants on April 22 last year.

The memorial has come up about 6 km from the Baisaran meadow, the site of the terror attack.

As he stood looking up at the wall in mid-April, Manu Madhavan, a tourist from Kerala, described the experience as “a bit unsettling”.

“Until now, we had just heard about the Pahalgam massacre on television or read it in the newspaper,” said Madhavan, who was visiting Kashmir with his family. “Now, it feels real.”

But not many tourists are likely to share Madhavan’s experience – very few of them have been making their way to Pahalgam after last year’s terror attack....

Myanmar politics

Myanmar’s army controls less than one-fifth of the country but the civil war is at a stalemate

The junta still holds major towns while the National Unity Government’s forces are held back by disunity and Chinese-Russian interference.

Among the cruel ironies of the Myanmar civil war, now in its sixth year, is that for an army that is struggling to conscript soldiers, the Myanmar junta has repeatedly bombed its own troops held as prisoners of war.

In this garrison state, it appears everything may be sacrificed to keep the military and its civilian front government – recently installed following widely discredited elections – in power.

There has been some impressive progress by the National Unity Government’s People’s Defence Force and allied ethnic armies against the military’s front organisation, the Union Solidarity and Development Party.

But after so many years, the Myanmar civil war is now at stalemate.

How did we get here?

The civil war began in February 2021 when the armed forces staged a coup against the elected civilian government headed by Nobel laureate Aung San Suu Kyi.

The civilian-led government had been elected in 2015, following more than five decades of military rule.

The army claimed (without evidence) there were irregularities in the 2020 elections and staged a coup months later....

Ad