Executive Summary

This report presents a detailed history and analysis of the transformation of MSF (Doctors Without Borders) into a leading source of false accusations and demonization targeting Israel. The comprehensive study traces initial MSF involvement in Gaza and the introduction of politicized commentary and bias into “testimonies” from staff and volunteers, and in reports on medical and health services. 

Following the October 7, 2023 Hamas atrocities, MSF joined other influential NGOs in the intensive advocacy campaign that labeled the Israeli response as “genocide,” based on manipulated and distorted evidence to support a predetermined conclusion. The accusations rely on invented criteria and unverified evidence, while blatantly omitting essential details and context: large-scale militarization of hospitals and military requirements for neutralizing a terror organization with a massive underground network embedded in civilian infrastructure. The political campaign, including in social media, parroted invented legal arguments applied exclusively to Israel, and incorporated blatant hypocrisy and double standards in comparison to responses in other conflicts. 

In particular, this report highlights MSF’s repeated silence regarding the extensive Hamas presence in the hospitals in which MSF personnel maintained an active presence, and were clearly aware of closed and off-limits sections. In addition, the evidence confirms systematic and blatant erasure of  the conditions in Gaza, including  exploitation of schools, mosques, and other civilian facilities for terror. This report also highlights the ways in which MSF’s accusations were amplified by the international media including professional medical journals, in university frameworks, United Nations agencies, and used as evidence in proceedings before international courts. 

Recommendations include:

1. Comprehensive, independent, and public investigations to document how MSF International and its national branches – specifically MSF USA and MSF UK – became central participants in demonization campaigns involving unsubstantiated claims of starvation and genocide, and steps to restore the principles of political neutrality and integrity of medical personnel. 
2. Immediate end to the “genocide” accusation, as well as intentional starvation, famine, war crimes, ethnic cleansing, and similar unsupported allegations.
3. All MSF personnel and volunteers must be externally vetted to prevent the inclusion of individuals who support or have links to terrorist organizations. 
4. Removing sources of bias, and implementing accountability mechanisms to prevent weaponizing medicine to marginalize Jews and Israelis or provide cover for extremist ideologies. 
5. Review of the grant charitable status for MSF branches in their respective countries. 

Click Here for Full Report