(Topic ID: 356080)

Dear Stern: The Official Pokemon Hype Thread and Wish List!

By 80sMan

1 year ago


week 19 May 8th '24
week 07 Feb 14th '26
Topic Heartbeat

Topic Stats

  • 1,799 posts - Hot topic!
  • 327 Pinsiders participating
  • Latest reply 4 minutes ago by wlf_
  • Topic is favorited by 101 Pinsiders

You

Linked Games

Topic Gallery

View topic image gallery

att.pzUSdXYafEMWpm3MzRF4Yu3qezaF3GS8VvTOb3W2xAY (resized).jpeg
IMG_0718 (resized).png
IMG_4154.jpeg
stern pokemon (resized).JPG
IMG_9547 (resized).jpeg
images(1).jpg
IMG_4164.jpeg
IMG_4165.jpeg
pokemon love flip n out pinball ad (resized).png
IMG_4157.jpeg
IMG_4158.jpeg
IMG_4154.jpeg
IMG_7323 (resized).jpeg
pokemon (resized).png
king_kong (resized).png
vebnom (resized).png
There are 1,799 posts in this topic. You are on page 35 of 36.
#1701 12 hours ago
Quoted from bjorg:

Has anyone reviewed it that wasn't a guest on Media Day? I wouldn't want to bite the hand that feeds me.
Did you watch the Premium Gameplay yet? It's terrible. If you know of a video that shows gameplay that is not repetitive and boring, please let me know. I really want to like this game.

More

I know a guy who was there, but not a media person. He said the game is a blast.

#1702 12 hours ago

Congratulations to all Pokemon buyers.

10
#1703 12 hours ago

Some wild takes. We are living in the golden age of pinball with great theme immersion on massive IPs (Pokemon, Harry Potter, Dune as of recent). Congrats to everyone who purchased Pokemon, those that are excited to play it, and for those that aren’t interested congrats on keeping your money! Everyone wins

#1704 11 hours ago
Quoted from Wiggles:

Serious question, how can you say a game sucks if you've never played it? Watching someone else play a game in a video is way different than getting hands on time yourself. Did you play it and that's why you have that opinion?
Gameplay is king for me, and I've never been able to judge a game until I've had ample time with it to learn at least most of its quarks, rules, shots, and so on.

More

Fair point, but I will say that I have evaluated other games based on how someone played them to decide if I wanted one. It's a reasonable way to assess if a game resonates. I really wanted to like "Pokemon by Stern Pinball" but so far, I'm not impressed from the many videos I've checked out.

Quoted from drtone:

I know a guy who was there, but not a media person. He said the game is a blast.

I'm really hoping that is the case. I will probably end up buying an LE and just putting it into storage until I they fix the gameplay or I get tired of waiting.

#1705 11 hours ago
Quoted from bjorg:

Fair point, but I will say that I have evaluated other games based on how someone played them to decide if I wanted one. It's a reasonable way to assess if a game resonates. I really wanted to like "Pokemon by Stern Pinball" but so far, I'm not impressed from the many videos I've checked out.

I'm really hoping that is the case. I will probably end up buying an LE and just putting it into storage until I they fix the gameplay or I get tired of waiting.

More

Fix the code? It’s at .75 man. LEs are sold out. could be wrong but I don’t see these going down in value anytime soon

-3
#1706 11 hours ago
IMG_7323 (resized).jpegIMG_7323 (resized).jpeg
#1707 11 hours ago
Quoted from Darkstar_otbco:

Fix the code? It’s at .75 man. LEs are sold out. could be wrong but I don’t see these going down in value anytime soon

When the FOMO wears off they will drop. Don't think it will take very long.

-2
#1708 11 hours ago
Quoted from Fancy_Feast:

When the FOMO wears off they will drop. Don't think it will take very long.

Just finished a game of King Kong. Now that is some epic code and geometry. I don't see how Pokemon can compete here. I was expecting them to put their best foot forward, but instead we got this?!? I will grant that it's better than Venom, but it also has none of the acerbic charm of Venom either.

I don't understand where this game fits in the grand scheme. The license will carry it, without a doubt, but then what? Will any pinheads care about it? Right now, I doubt it, but I hope I'm wrong. Keep in mind, I really wanted this game! I'm a HUGE fan of IC save progression, which is why I have D&D and Venom. As it stands, aside from saved progression, there is NOTHING that moves pinball forward in this machine.

It blows my mind when comparing the Pokemon LE to a Harry Potter Wizard Edition. Pokemon is barely a doormat in comparison. Our money is literally spent better on almost any other game by any other manufacturer. AND THIS IS THE MOST VALUABLE IP IN THE WORLD!!! What utter embarrassment. Nintendo should have gone with JJP, Barrels of Fun, or Spooky. These guys would have bent over backwards to make this a pin for the ages.

Maybe my love for theme blinds me at the potential, but I'm very, very disappointed at what they revealed today (in the extremely unlikely case that hasn't come across yet).

#1709 10 hours ago
Quoted from bjorg:

Nintendo should have gone with JJP, Barrels of Fun, or Spooky. These guys would have bent over backwards to make this a pin for the ages.

But Stern will make Nintendo much more money than any of these other companies because Stern can produce and sell 100x the amount of machines the others can. Unfortunately that's just how things work with capitalism.

#1710 10 hours ago
Quoted from Wiggles:

Saying Pokemon only appeals to children is a good way of saying you don't know what the hell you're talking about without actually saying it directly.

You'll notice I said "most". I've played a lot of Pokemon games on Nintendo Switch 2 and when our regular babysitter went to Japan, she went to a Pokemon plushie store for her and her boyfriend, and brought back some rare plushies for my kids. So, yes, it's a massive IP with lots of fans.

However, if you notice, the actual Pokemon fans on this thread (there's another further up) were excited for this pin and are a bit disappointed so far by the layout and gameplay footage. I had hoped Elwin would be the designer.

The reality is that it looks great for location play (and for very rich people who love Pokemon and haven't bought a pin before) but, if you've played a lot of pinball, you know this has the layout of Junkyard and you're likely to spend most of the game shooting up the middle. Given the theme, I suspect the middle area is the Pokemon Battle Arena and you're going to be hitting the arena walls over and over to battle/catch Pokemon - the amateur Premium footage confirms this is what looks to be happening.

As such, it would need to have absolutely cracking code to maintain home interest. Based on footage so far, you would have to be a n00b, have extreme FOMO or be buying explicitly for young kids to purchase this when King Kong exists.

Sorry for raining on everyone's parade. Unfortunately, the 'criticism' thread seems to be missing in action so the 'hype' thread it is.

#1711 10 hours ago
Quoted from gnocchi_pesto:

But Stern will make Nintendo much more money than any of these other companies because Stern can produce and sell 100x the amount of machines the others can. Unfortunately that's just how things work with capitalism.

I fully agree with your take. Nintendo, and the rest of the stakeholders, would be crazy to roll the dice on anyone else, except maybe JJP. JJP has been crushing it for a while. Not everything resonates with everybody, but none of their games I have is a stinker: Harry Potter, Avatar, Toy Story 4, and even The Hobbit. They are all solid and won't be leaving my collection anytime soon.

#1712 9 hours ago
Quoted from Veemonroe:

You'll notice I said "most". I've played a lot of Pokemon games on Nintendo Switch 2 and when our regular babysitter went to Japan, she went to a Pokemon plushie store for her and her boyfriend, and brought back some rare plushies for my kids. So, yes, it's a massive IP with lots of fans.
However, if you notice, the actual Pokemon fans on this thread (there's another further up) were excited for this pin and are a bit disappointed so far by the layout and gameplay footage. I had hoped Elwin would be the designer.
The reality is that it looks great for location play (and for very rich people who love Pokemon and haven't bought a pin before) but, if you've played a lot of pinball, you know this has the layout of Junkyard and you're likely to spend most of the game shooting up the middle. Given the theme, I suspect the middle area is the Pokemon Battle Arena and you're going to be hitting the arena walls over and over to battle/catch Pokemon - the amateur Premium footage confirms this is what looks to be happening.
As such, it would need to have absolutely cracking code to maintain home interest. Based on footage so far, you would have to be a n00b, have extreme FOMO or be buying explicitly for young kids to purchase this when King Kong exists.
Sorry for raining on everyone's parade. Unfortunately, the 'criticism' thread seems to be missing in action so the 'hype' thread it is.

More

It’s more than just about layout. When Jaws released people were complaining the same way on the layout. The reason it has such staying power and rates consistently high is it’s thematic and feels like you’re hunting sharks.

That’s the same reasoning here for Pokémon, it’s simply thematic. You get to discover new Pokémon, hit the Pokédex, hit more shots and then catch that Pokémon on a hurry up. There’s rhyme and reason to each shot of those. When code comes around we’ll be able to evolve and battle more (and love how you can switch Pokémon for a type advantage just like the video games or card game to defeat the Pokémon and gain more points). I think there’s a lot to love here on such early code and looking forward to Stern keeping up and adding more in the coming months/years.

I digress, but anyways, as a pinball player for two years I’m no N00b, have a 4 year old that it’s not explicitly for (but it’s a plus that she can grow into this), and this isn’t FOMO b/c I’ve been on the list since getting into pinball 2 yrs ago. I discovered that theming is important to me, but may not be enough for some.

I LOVE Kong’s layout as the top of the playfield plays literally like a 2nd pinball game and its jampacked with shots that are very satisfying, but thematically it doesn’t really do anything for me, thus I’m buying this instead that I feel will have staying power for years to come.

#1713 9 hours ago
Quoted from bjorg:

Has anyone reviewed it that wasn't a guest on Media Day? I wouldn't want to bite the hand that feeds me.
Did you watch the Premium Gameplay yet? It's terrible. If you know of a video that shows gameplay that is not repetitive and boring, please let me know. I really want to like this game.

More

It does more than a card of paper does and one of those cards sold for almost 6 million. Pokemon people are different (I’m not one. Don’t understand it at all - just offering an alternate opinion).

-3
#1714 9 hours ago
Quoted from Waldo:

It does more than a card of paper does and one of those cards sold for almost 6 million. Pokemon people are different (I’m not one. Don’t understand it at all - just offering an alternate opinion).

But that is one very rare card, that will hold value, which pokecollectors have interest in. Pokemon card collectors have zero interest in pinball. It’s not rare at all. $tern will make as many as you like. LE version is not rare ether. Plenty will be for sale all the time after the temporary FOMO wears off.

-1
#1715 9 hours ago

Has there ever been a good implementation of the toilet bowl? My first encounter with one has been in FOTE. I know it's been around for a while, but that ridiculous bowl is a game killer. I can almost go to the bar, wait in line, order a new beer, chat with the bartender, check on some Slack and email messages, use the bathroom, catch up with some regulars, and then walk back to the pin to finally see the ball drop out of the bowl. It's the worst game mechanism I've ever seen. Not that I have much experience, mind you, but from my limited experience, it's terrible.

-1
#1716 9 hours ago
Quoted from Waldo:

It does more than a card of paper does and one of those cards sold for almost 6 million. Pokemon people are different (I’m not one. Don’t understand it at all - just offering an alternate opinion).

That's pretty much the reason I would consider buying an LE and put it into storage for a while. Not because it's a good game, but because there are n00bs who will pay ridiculous money to get one once they find out it exists!

That said, I'd much rather be that guy who holds onto it in his collection and enjoys it. I really, really want to like this pin. Stern is just making it ridiculously hard right now. Hoping that changes quickly.

#1717 8 hours ago
Quoted from bjorg:

Has there ever been a good implementation of the toilet bowl? My first encounter with one has been in FOTE. I know it's been around for a while, but that ridiculous bowl is a game killer. I can almost go to the bar, wait in line, order a new beer, chat with the bartender, check on some Slack and email messages, use the bathroom, catch up with some regulars, and then walk back to the pin to finally see the ball drop out of the bowl. It's the worst game mechanism I've ever seen. Not that I have much experience, mind you, but from my limited experience, it's terrible.

More

Gomez spoke at length about the whirlpool plastic. The team heavily modified it after receiving feedback (negative) about FOTE. It has speed bumps around the bowl walls and cut outs around the drain to ensure that the ball will not spin forever. Further, the diverter will only send the ball to the whirlpool on rare mode-based occasions.

#1718 8 hours ago
Quoted from bjorg:

Just finished a game of King Kong. Now that is some epic code and geometry. I don't see how Pokemon can compete here. I was expecting them to put their best foot forward, but instead we got this?!? I will grant that it's better than Venom, but it also has none of the acerbic charm of Venom either.
I don't understand where this game fits in the grand scheme. The license will carry it, without a doubt, but then what? Will any pinheads care about it? Right now, I doubt it, but I hope I'm wrong. Keep in mind, I really wanted this game! I'm a HUGE fan of IC save progression, which is why I have D&D and Venom. As it stands, aside from saved progression, there is NOTHING that moves pinball forward in this machine.
It blows my mind when comparing the Pokemon LE to a Harry Potter Wizard Edition. Pokemon is barely a doormat in comparison. Our money is literally spent better on almost any other game by any other manufacturer. AND THIS IS THE MOST VALUABLE IP IN THE WORLD!!! What utter embarrassment. Nintendo should have gone with JJP, Barrels of Fun, or Spooky. These guys would have bent over backwards to make this a pin for the ages.
Maybe my love for theme blinds me at the potential, but I'm very, very disappointed at what they revealed today (in the extremely unlikely case that hasn't come across yet).

More

The team explained that they were under the directive to make Pokemon “accessible.” In doing so, they modeled much of the fundamental aspects of the gameplay after monster bash, medieval madness, and attack from mars. Then layered additional code depth and complexity—with a lot more to come—for advanced players. If you view Pokemon as a modern, but different, version of those three inspirations, are you still disappointed?

-1
#1719 8 hours ago
Quoted from bjorg:

That's pretty much the reason I would consider buying an LE and put it into storage for a while. Not because it's a good game, but because there are n00bs who will pay ridiculous money to get one once they find out it exists!
That said, I'd much rather be that guy who holds onto it in his collection and enjoys it. I really, really want to like this pin. Stern is just making it ridiculously hard right now. Hoping that changes quickly.

More

After it's in storage for a couple years pokemon 30th anniversary comes out with even better cabitnet art, foil, and powdercoat.

#1720 7 hours ago

I was concerned about the layout but after watching some gameplay the game looks like a blast. Really excited to get it hands on

#1721 7 hours ago

So what is the topper on this? Distributors got to see it

#1722 7 hours ago
Quoted from Svenop:

Just like pinmonk I turn down eject and mylar is enough. I saw you posted the same product push in the next stern thread. Seems like your affiliated pushing the product and saying eject power and mylar wont work.....

It’s the only shooter lane protector I recommend, based on experience. No affiliation in any way, but I’ll take that as a compliment. Just a fan, and a fan of keeping nice games mint and pristine as much as possible. Don’t tell the newbies mylar works, and promise them their brand new Stern shooter lane won’t chip and crack, when it eventually will without something like this:

https://pinside.com/pinball/shops/shop/1537-volcano-pinball/09650-shootershield-tpu-stern

ProtectorProtector

Again, my motivation is I genuinely plan on buying a used LE, unless the clear coat is already chipping and cracking on it.

I know most don’t care, but protecting your brand new game is a nice way to keep its resale value up. Just cover the shooter lane and most Sterns won’t have other issues with low plays

10
#1723 7 hours ago

Ok I'm in too!

Gotta say based on the initial leaks and reveal video, I was underwhelmed. I think most of us hardcore pinheads just want to see more more more, all the time, and better than last time. But I get that they had to keep this within accessible bounds, as per Nintendos directive but also to reach the biggest possible market, especially on site. Achilles comparisons to AFM makes a lot of sense.

Having said that, it'll almost certainly be super fun to play, for the same reasons - so that it absolutely kills it in the arcades. Reports from distros in the US is that there has been a ton of interest, so like, what do we know?

Business hat on - Mods incoming!

#1724 6 hours ago

Attack from the Junkyardians of the Galaxy!

#1725 6 hours ago
Quoted from stumblor:

Ok I'm in too!
Gotta say based on the initial leaks and reveal video, I was underwhelmed. I think most of us hardcore pinheads just want to see more more more, all the time, and better than last time. But I get that they had to keep this within accessible bounds, as per Nintendos directive but also to reach the biggest possible market, especially on site. Achilles comparisons to AFM makes a lot of sense.
Having said that, it'll almost certainly be super fun to play, for the same reasons - so that it absolutely kills it in the arcades. Reports from distros in the US is that there has been a ton of interest, so like, what do we know?
Business hat on - Mods incoming!

More

Sign me up. HAHA

#1726 5 hours ago

Where is the Stern gameplay video? Those are usually much better with real-time explanation of rules and shots. Usually those hit by now, at least the pro / premium videos.

I also heard (Gomez on Loserkid I believe) that the LE armor and shooter rod were not final in the trailer video.

OR they just wanted to give the "influencers" some soak time with their content before Stern puts out the videos.

#1727 5 hours ago
Quoted from Svenop:

So what is the topper on this? Distributors got to see it

Can’t say yet but it’s done and being approved.

#1728 4 hours ago
Quoted from kermit24:

Where is the Stern gameplay video? Those are usually much better with real-time explanation of rules and shots. Usually those hit by now, at least the pro / premium videos.
I also heard (Gomez on Loserkid I believe) that the LE armor and shooter rod were not final in the trailer video.
OR they just wanted to give the "influencers" some soak time with their content before Stern puts out the videos.

More

George said the Masterball shooter comes with the LE, and the accessories package shooter will be the poke ball. He also mentioned the LE armor in the videos has decals on it, but in the final product I believe he said it would be painted on.

They showed the longer trailer with George and Jack talking about the game in the seminar, so I suppose it should come out soon enough.

#1729 4 hours ago
Quoted from Svenop:

So what is the topper on this?…

Quoted from beltking:

Can’t say yet but it’s done and being approved.

These go hand in hand

Balloon and SubBalloon and Sub

I’d wager an LE deposit, if I had one, that we’ll be seeing something fishy

MagikarpMagikarp

Not a distributor, but makes a lot of sense, to go along with the balloon.

#1730 4 hours ago
Quoted from bjorg:

Has there ever been a good implementation of the toilet bowl? My first encounter with one has been in FOTE. I know it's been around for a while, but that ridiculous bowl is a game killer. I can almost go to the bar, wait in line, order a new beer, chat with the bartender, check on some Slack and email messages, use the bathroom, catch up with some regulars, and then walk back to the pin to finally see the ball drop out of the bowl.

More

You’ve never played Whitewater? It’s great in that game, and it drains fast. I’m not sure what went wrong with FOTE - but yeah, on the one I’ve played it just hangs…like it just rocks back and forth for 20 seconds or so before finally falling in the hole.

#1731 3 hours ago

Ss

#1732 3 hours ago

Are there gym battles that we know of?

#1733 3 hours ago
Quoted from Rarehero:

You’ve never played Whitewater? It’s great in that game, and it drains fast. I’m not sure what went wrong with FOTE - but yeah, on the one I’ve played it just hangs…like it just rocks back and forth for 20 seconds or so before finally falling in the hole.

More

anyone complaining about the FOTE bowl needs to just stick a small flap of packing tape inside the bowl slightly to left of the hole on the side closest to the flippers, drains in a quarter of the time… it’s aint rocket science.

#1734 3 hours ago
Quoted from mpdpvdpin:

anyone complaining about the FOTE bowl needs to just stick a small flap of packing tape inside the bowl slightly to left of the hole on the side closest to the flippers, drains in a quarter of the time… it’s aint rocket science.

Stern mailing anyone with the game a piece of mylar with instructions in a “service kit” feels like it’d buy some good will.

#1735 2 hours ago

i suppose this have been said more than few times already (didnt read the previous pages), it's GOTG vs JUNKYARD

meanwhile having 0% interest in the POKEMON universe, i'm a pinball enthousiast, than if it's fun playing it, why not ?

#1736 2 hours ago

If the topper is done already then we are getting accessories fast lol

#1737 2 hours ago
Quoted from Achilles:

The team explained that they were under the directive to make Pokemon “accessible.” In doing so, they modeled much of the fundamental aspects of the gameplay after monster bash, medieval madness, and attack from mars. Then layered additional code depth and complexity—with a lot more to come—for advanced players. If you view Pokemon as a modern, but different, version of those three inspirations, are you still disappointed?

More

And this is exactly what I wanted Pokemon to be. I've debated picking up a Cactus Canyon or one of the other CGC games for a long while now. I've wanted a two flipper pin with all the classic features that I could drop new players into and use as my own palette cleanser in between something more complex and challenging. I just wanted something that would resonate with my family a little more, so Pokemon really fits the bill.

I do hope that the team is given the resources they need to bring in some hidden depth to the code for those that look for it, in ways that resonate both with pinball players and Pokemon fans.

#1738 2 hours ago

The thread has the story arc of every new Stern release thread with the power of Pokémon behind it.

#1739 2 hours ago

Squirtle Squad?

15
#1740 2 hours ago

The topper is one of the first things I dreamt up when concepting the game. It's huge, awesome, and a bit of a callback for pinheads.

#1741 2 hours ago

Follow Your Heart This Valentine's Day...

pokemon love flip n out pinball ad (resized).pngpokemon love flip n out pinball ad (resized).png
#1742 2 hours ago
Quoted from DeadFlip:

The topper is one of the first things I dreamt up when concepting the game. It's huge, awesome, and a bit of a callback for pinheads.

Thanks Jack, now no one will take my bet

Fish TalesFish Tales

Again, am guessing, but anxious all the same

Team RocketTeam Rocket

Have any more of them LE’s DeadFlip

#1743 2 hours ago
Quoted from DeadFlip:

The topper is one of the first things I dreamt up when concepting the game. It's huge, awesome, and a bit of a callback for pinheads.

Has to be snorlax.

#1744 2 hours ago
Quoted from 10redzr1:

Has to be snorlax.

That would be awesome.

#1745 2 hours ago
Quoted from chuckwurt:

That would be awesome.

I agree 100% he's top 3 favorite Pokémon

#1746 2 hours ago

Bought pro sight unseen. There are few themes as an operator that require no thought. Toy Story was the same for us and I don’t particularly like playing that game. But kids that visit us sure do and it’s all that matters. Hell I’d probably buy a Taylor Swift game if they ever made one.

#1747 2 hours ago
Quoted from MiniPinHead:

Thanks Jack, now no one will take my bet
[quoted image]
Again, am guessing, but anxious all the same
[quoted image]
Have any more of them LE’s DeadFlip

More

that would be so perfect. Combines nostalgia for pinheads and the new ip perfectly.

#1748 1 hour ago

Not a defense or attack on Stern, but it’s hard to win with everyone with a single machine.

Their runs need to be small enough that everyone has FOMO, but large enough i can get one

They should be cheap today so I can afford one but expensive next year because i think pinball is an investment

I want deep code and tight shots but not TOO hard

I don’t want kids themes like Pokémon that 40 year olds could dig. I want adult themes like… transformers and he-man?… that 50 year olds can dig.

What a great time to be in this hobby! Diverse manufacturers and themes and a new game every few months. Each of us could drop $20k a year on games that we’ll like (if we had the funds).

I have no affinity to Pokémon other than through my kids, but catching 175 of them or whatever on my insider connected sounds fun.

Hopefully it expands the market, further increases the number of manufacturers and diversity of games, keeps arcades open, supports leagues, etc.

It’s a great week for pinball!

#1749 1 hour ago

I hope a lot of you got a LE that wanted one from the first come first serve on Stern website

#1750 1 hour ago

Less than 10 seconds. Crazy

IMG_9547 (resized).jpegIMG_9547 (resized).jpeg
Promoted items from Pinside Marketplace and Pinside Shops!
Pinball Machine
Classic Game Rooms
 
$ 9,499.00
Tools
Performance Pinball
 
$ 10.00
Playfield - Protection
Duke Pinball
 
$ 50.00
There are 1,799 posts in this topic. You are on page 35 of 36.

Reply

Wanna join the discussion? Please sign in to reply to this topic.

Hey there! Welcome to Pinside!

Support Pinside

Loving Pinside? We've kept it ad-free for years with help from our supporters! Consider joining Pinside+ to support the site and get exclusive member benefits!


This page was printed from and we tried optimising it for printing. Some page elements may have been deliberately hidden.

Scan the QR code on the left to jump to the URL this document was printed from.