We use cookies to tailor your experience and present relevant ads. By clicking “Accept”, you agree that cookies can be placed per our Privacy Policy
ACCEPT
Advertisement

Will ‘one-man model’ work for Vietnam as To Lam looks set to consolidate power?

The Communist Party’s general secretary is already behaving as if he ‘expects a mandate’ to add the presidency to his portfolio, experts say

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
1
Listen
Advertisement
discover more stories from
Advertisement
Browse other locations
China
Asia
North America
Middle East
Europe
Russia and Central Asia
Oceania
Africa
Americas and Caribbean
NEWSLETTEREvery Saturday
Hear directly from our newsroom on the biggest social, political and economic stories from China and how they impact the world.
By submitting, you consent to receiving marketing emails from SCMP. If you don't want these, tick here
By registering, you agree to ourT&CandPrivacy Policy
Before you go
scmp poll
Advertisement
Communist Party General Secretary To Lam delivers a speech at the party’s congress in Hanoi on Monday. Photo: Vietnam News Agency/EPA
Vietnam’s Communist Party five-yearly congress is set to consolidate more power for General Secretary To Lam, whom observers say has behaved like he “expects a mandate”.

But term and age limits on the leadership are expected to remain, they add, leaving Lam as just a “first among equals” when the conclave concludes on Sunday.

The congress – where the one-party state’s highest decisions are made – opened on Monday and will set key economic targets for the country as well as pick new leaders.

Leadership selection includes its most powerful position of general secretary, currently held by Lam, who was first named to the post in August 2024.

Addressing the nearly 1,600 delegates at the congress on Tuesday, Lam pledged an annual economic growth of more than 10 per cent for the remainder of the decade.

Pointing to external challenges such as security risks, fierce strategic competition and major disruptions in energy and food supply chains, Lam said Vietnam needed to cut red tape and expand global trade to protect its national interests.

Communist Party General Secretary To Lam (centre) and President Luong Cuong (centre right) pay their respects at the Ho Chi Minh mausoleum in Hanoi ahead of the party congress on Monday. Photo: Vietnam News Agency/AFP
Communist Party General Secretary To Lam (centre) and President Luong Cuong (centre right) pay their respects at the Ho Chi Minh mausoleum in Hanoi ahead of the party congress on Monday. Photo: Vietnam News Agency/AFP

“Infrastructure must be developed to adapt to climate change and ensure strong regional, inter-regional and global connectivity,” he added.

The former head of state security is said to be seeking to retain his role as party chief and take on the state presidency as he looks to consolidate control over the Communist Party in one of Asia’s fastest growing economies.

Nguyen Khac Giang, visiting fellow at the Singapore-based ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute, said that over the past year, Lam had behaved like one “who expects a mandate” by travelling to over a dozen countries.

Recent high-profile visits include a major Eurasian tour in May to Kazakhstan, Azerbaijan, Russia, and Belarus, focusing on strategic partnerships, alongside visits to South Korea in August and North Korea in October.
There will be enough pluralism at the top to keep him strong, but not unchecked
Nguyen Khac Giang, visiting fellow at the ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute

“[This has] considerably outscored the president, whose role is intended for such diplomatic responsibility, and the state-media choreography has followed suit,” he said, referring to incumbent Luong Cuong.

“But consolidation in Vietnam rarely means a clean sweep. [Lam] will probably pay for extra authority by accommodating other factions in the politburo and central committee. So there will be enough pluralism at the top to keep him strong, but not unchecked.”

‘Strong leverage’

Ha Hoang Hop, chairman of VietKnow, a Hanoi-based think tank focusing on political risks, said Lam’s chances of further power consolidation were high as he had deep roots in the security apparatus and anti‑corruption campaign. “[This] gives him strong leverage going into the congress.”

Deeply linked to anti-corruption efforts, Lam was the main executor of the country’s sweeping “blazing furnace” campaign while serving as minister of public security.

Though the composition of the politburo could vary, Lam’s allies dominated key portfolios in internal security, party organisation, ideology and economic management.

“Vietnam could move closer to a dominant‑leader model,” Hop said. But if balances were preserved, collective leadership norms would constrain Lam as “first among equals”.

Following US-Vietnam agreement, China says it opposes deals that hurt its interests

While the revolutionary founder of modern Vietnam and its first president, Ho Chi Minh, briefly held unified top roles, the post-Ho era emphasised collective power.

However, periods of consolidation have occurred, notably under late leader Nguyen Phu Trong, who also served as both general secretary and president.

Carlyle Thayer, a Southeast Asia specialist and emeritus professor at the University of New South Wales in Canberra, said Lam’s power consolidation would streamline Vietnam’s approach to foreign affairs – especially since the party general secretary’s decisions had recently “usurped” the president’s.

But “Vietnam is not China”, Thayer said, predicting that the party would retain its two-term limit on leaders and continue to set a mandatory retirement limit of 65. In a rare exception, Trong was granted a rare third term at 76 in 2021.
“Vietnam’s party central committee is a much more powerful check on the party leader than it is in Xi Jinping’s China,” Thayer said.
Honour guards march past a billboard advertising the Communist Party congress in Hanoi on Wednesday. Photo: AFP
Honour guards march past a billboard advertising the Communist Party congress in Hanoi on Wednesday. Photo: AFP

A clearer hierarchy with a party chief who is also head of state could “reduce diplomatic ambiguity” and give Lam the “political runway” to push through reforms quickly, Giang said. But it risked a drift towards a “one-man model” that Vietnam had “historically struggled with”.

It remains to be seen whether Lam will use the consolidated power to strengthen institutions and bring about better coordination, or entrench “factional control and repression”, according to Hop. “The former could support high-quality growth and strategic agility; the latter would increase long-term vulnerability at home and abroad.”

Moderate consolidation could help Vietnam in the short term by speeding decisions on infrastructure and industrial policy and signalling political stability to investors, Hop said.

However, over-centralisation around a “security-centric leader” risks narrowing strategic debate at a time when Vietnam must strike a fine balance between the US and China while managing growing social and economic pressures.

“If policy becomes more risk-averse, punitive and inward-looking, it could stifle innovation, bureaucratic candour and reform, ultimately undermining resilience despite near‑term order,” Hop said.

Advertisement
Maria Siow
Maria Siow is a long-time China-based correspondent and analyst with keen interest in East Asia. Maria has a masters degree in international relations.
Advertisement
Advertisement

3 killed in shooting in Australia, manhunt under way

Shooting comes on a National Day of Mourning as Australia remembers 15 people shot dead in Sydney at a Hanukkah celebration on December 14

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
1
Listen
Emergency services were called to a Lake Cargelligo address, a town of about 1,500, after reports of a shooting, police said. Photo: ABC News Australia

A gunman was at large after a shooting in a town in Australia’s New South Wales state on Thursday left three people dead and another wounded, police said.

Emergency services were called to two locations at Lake Cargelligo, a town of around 1,500 people, after 4pm. Two couples, a man and woman, had been shot in each location within minutes, Police Assistant Commissioner Andy Holland said.

Both women and a man died. Another man was taken to hospital in serious but stable condition, he said.

Police knew the identity of a suspect, but did not know his relationship with the victims, who were all Lake Cargelligo locals, Holland said. The suspect’s name has not been released.

State police were working to locate the suspect and had sent resources from neighboring districts to the town, including heavily armed tactical police, Holland said. The town had been cordoned off to prevent the suspect’s escape.

Police urged the public to avoid the area and local residents to stay inside. The Commercial Hotel, a local pub, was closed by 6 p.m.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x