Democracy Dies in Darkness
Opinion

Trump’s security promise for Ukraine could risk war with Russia

An Article 5-style guarantee may be more dangerous than it looks.

5 min
Make us preferred on Google
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and U.S. special envoy Steve Witkoff in Berlin on Dec. 15. (Markus Schreiber/AFP)
By
and 

Samuel Charap is distinguished chair in Russia and Eurasia Policy at Rand. Jennifer Kavanagh is a senior fellow and director of military analysis at Defense Priorities.

As the Trump administration pushes ahead with intensive negotiations to end the Russia-Ukraine war, it has surprised even its harshest critics by reportedly putting on the table a set of security guarantees for Ukraine that are more far-reaching than anything proposed by prior administrations.

What readers are saying

The conversation explores the potential risks and benefits of the United States offering Article 5-like security guarantees to Ukraine, with a significant focus on skepticism regarding the reliability of such guarantees, particularly if offered by former President Trump. Many... Show more
This summary is AI-generated. AI can make mistakes and this summary is not a replacement for reading the comments.
Already a subscriber? Sign in
END OF YEAR SALE

2026 savings start here

Unlock The Post for just 50¢ USD a week.
  • Unlimited access on the web and in our apps
  • 24/7 live news updates
Monthly
50¢ USD
a week
Yearly
$29 USD
for the first year
Monthly billed as $2 USD every four weeks for first six months.
Cancel anytime.
paypal
Card
View more offers