Britain | Bagehot

Sir Keir Starmer is a prisoner of the politics he pledged to end 

When rigmarole becomes reality

Surreal collage of Keir Starmer holding his mouth open with chaotic scribbles inside
Illustration: Nate Kitch
|5 min read

Of all the distortions and deceits that Sir Keir Starmer deployed in order to reach Downing Street, one stands out. It was not the promise of free tuition fees offered to left-wing Labour members, ditched after the leadership contest was over. It was not the solemn pledge to forgo tax rises on income, vat or national insurance made at the last election, which will be smashed in the budget on November 26th.

This article appeared in the Britain section of the print edition under the headline “When rigmarole becomes reality ”

From the November 15th 2025 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition
Snails on lettuce

A slimy scheme to avoid property tax

From snail farms to sham churches—the British will do anything to dodge taxes

Blighty newsletter: Labour retreats to its comfort zone

What might a broken promise tell us about Sir Keir Starmer’s party? 

The BBC’s boss quits over a “doctored” Trump speech

Shifts in politics and the media business are making the broadcaster more crisis-prone