United States | Fluid identity

How stable are the gender identities of younger children?

A study finds that one in five who switch gender change their mind

A row of paper dolls with one cut off.
Illustration: Ben Hickey
|NEW YORK|5 min read

WHEN KRISTINA OLSON began studying children who had transitioned from one gender to another in the early 2010s, there were not a lot of them. Social transition (living in a new gender, with no medical intervention) was still controversial for minors. A new understanding was taking hold, however: that trans children know who they are, and that there is therefore little reason to delay. An increasing number of parents followed suit and socially transitioned young children—in some cases, as young as three.

Explore more

This article appeared in the United States section of the print edition under the headline “Fluid identities”

From the September 20th 2025 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition
Charlie Kirk Memorial

After Charlie Kirk’s murder, conservatives hope for a religious revival

At his memorial in Arizona, top Republicans hailed him as a martyr

A new NextGen Amtrak Acela train sits at the station as passengers board the original model Regional Acela train

Rail travel is booming in America

More trains mean more riders


A megaphone getting unplugged by Donald Trump.

The Donald Trump guide to DEI on campus

The administration is picking its own favoured students and boundaries for speech


Is the far left to blame for more political killings in America?

Opinion polls probably overestimate public support for violence

What this year’s Ryder Cup says about America’s duffers

More local governments own courses and the demography of players is changing

In Washington, the obvious thing is probably true

Deploying hundreds of federal agents probably cut crime