We use cookies to tailor your experience and present relevant ads. By clicking “Accept”, you agree that cookies can be placed per our Privacy Policy
ACCEPT
Advertisement

An ‘Arab Nato’? Israel’s air strikes on Qatar give Arab militaries a reason to unite

A new military coalition is reportedly under discussion at an Arab-Islamic summit in a direct response to Israel’s attack

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
0
Listen
Advertisement
discover more stories from
Browse other locations
China
Asia
North America
Middle East
Europe
Russia and Central Asia
Oceania
Africa
Americas and Caribbean
NEWSLETTEREvery Monday
Pressing stories and in-depth analysis from the Asia region.  
By submitting, you consent to receiving marketing emails from SCMP. If you don't want these, tick here
By registering, you agree to ourT&CandPrivacy Policy
Before you go
scmp poll
Advertisement
Pakistani activists march in Islamabad on Wednesday to protest against Israel’s air strikes on Qatar. Pakistan has called for a joint task force in response to the strikes. Photo: AFP
When Israeli jets tore through Doha’s skies last week, striking a residential block that housed Hamas negotiators, they may also have set in motion something Israel has long feared: the birth of an Arab military alliance.

The proposal, under discussion at an emergency Arab-Islamic summit that opened in Doha on Sunday, marks the most serious push towards regional military integration in decades.

Diplomatic sources and Arab media reported that the summit was poised to endorse the creation of a joint military coalition on Monday.

Qatar’s prime minister and other regional officials at the emergency Arab-Islamic summit in Doha on Sunday. Photo: Qatar Ministry of Foreign Affairs/Reuters
Qatar’s prime minister and other regional officials at the emergency Arab-Islamic summit in Doha on Sunday. Photo: Qatar Ministry of Foreign Affairs/Reuters
Egypt, which commands the Arab world’s largest army, is pressing for a Cairo-based “Arab Nato”, while Pakistan – the world’s only nuclear-armed Muslim state – has called for a joint task force to “monitor the Israeli designs in the region and adopt effective deterrent and offensive measures in a synchronised manner to ward off Israeli expansionist designs”.

“Israel must be held accountable for war crimes and crimes against humanity,” Pakistan’s deputy prime minister and foreign minister, Ishaq Dar, declared at the summit’s opening session.

“It should not be allowed to get away with attacking Islamic countries and killing people with impunity.”

Explosions rock Doha as Israeli air strike targets Hamas leaders in Qatar

‘Endless cycle of bloodshed’

The summit builds upon a joint Egyptian-Saudi framework approved by the Arab League just days before the attack on Qatar, according to diplomatic sources.

On September 5, the 22-member body backed a plan for joint cooperation to combat terrorism, secure shipping lanes and shield strategic infrastructure “thereby strengthening the region’s stability”.

That plan is now being fast-tracked following Israel’s air strike on a residential compound in Doha where officials confirmed Hamas mediators were being housed.

What occurred was not merely a targeted attack, but an assault on the principle of mediation itself
Qatar’s Prime Minister Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al-Thani

“What occurred was not merely a targeted attack, but an assault on the principle of mediation itself and on everything diplomacy represents as an alternative to war and destruction,” said Qatar’s Prime Minister Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al-Thani at the opening of the summit on Sunday.

In remarks laced with frustration, Thani condemned the “international community” – in effect, the West – for its “inability” to hold Israel accountable. Instead of welcoming Qatar’s negotiations over a ceasefire and the release of hostages, he said, Israel had chosen escalation.

Thani urged Muslim countries to take “real and tangible measures” to curb further violence or “inevitably, we will find ourselves facing an endless cycle of bloodshed and destruction from which no one will be immune”.

(From left) US Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu visit the Western Wall, Judaism’s holiest prayer site, on Sunday. Photo: AFP
(From left) US Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu visit the Western Wall, Judaism’s holiest prayer site, on Sunday. Photo: AFP

Washington on the sidelines

The strikes cast a fresh spotlight on rising doubts about Washington’s reliability as a security guarantor. Officials have insisted Qatar’s security relationship with the United States is still intact despite Washington’s failure to intercept the missiles that struck Doha.

But some Arab governments appear to be losing patience, according to Hussein Ibish, a senior scholar at the Arab Gulf States Institute in Washington, who called the coalition proposals “yet another clear reflection of the alarm about the unwillingness and/or inability of Washington to serve as a security guarantor in the Middle East, especially for its traditional Arab military partners”.

“They [Arab countries] really feel they have no choice,” Ibish said, adding that if the US were to start making clear the terms on which it would be providing closer security coordination “then they would not feel the need to go forward with this uncharacteristic and uncomfortable effort at military integration”.

Egyptian soldiers march in a parade in 2023. Egypt commands the Arab world’s largest army. Photo: AFP
Egyptian soldiers march in a parade in 2023. Egypt commands the Arab world’s largest army. Photo: AFP

Paradoxically, the Arab world was moving towards the kind of cooperation Washington had long encouraged, he added, but the crucial difference was that the US had envisaged an Arab-Israeli alliance against Iran. Instead, Israel now finds itself named as the threat.

Barbara Slavin, a Middle East fellow at the Stimson Centre, told This Week in Asia that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had “gone too far in striking Qatar”.

“Whatever gains Israel has made regionally in the past two years … are jeopardised by its brutality in Gaza and overall hubris,” she said. “If the US won’t stop it, the region has to try.”

Qatar’s prime minister made his remarks days after dining with US President Donald Trump on Friday following talks with Vice-President J.D. Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio. Neither side offered a substantive statement following the engagements.
Washington will find that it comes at a huge cost to US influence
Hussein Ibish, security analyst
Meanwhile, Rubio flew to Israel on Sunday for a week-long visit, where he is expected to discuss with Netanyahu Israel’s plans to occupy Gaza and annex the West Bank.

Before his arrival, the US secretary of state reiterated that the Trump administration was “not happy” with Israel’s air strikes on Doha – wording that fell far short of outright condemnation.

The military coalition proposal served as a “plea to the United States to get re-engaged” with the Arab world, Ibish said.

“Washington will find that it comes at a huge cost to US influence,” he said, further cautioning that “the US may not like what ultimately emerges, but if they don’t move to stop it now, they won’t be able to later on.”

Advertisement
Tom Hussain
Tom Hussain is an Islamabad-based journalist who has spent his 35-year career covering South Asia and the Middle East.
Advertisement
Advertisement

Israel’s Qatar strikes force Gulf to re-evaluate US security guarantees

Qatar’s prime minister has called for a collective regional response to the strikes that Washington failed to prevent

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
41
Listen
Advertisement
Smoke rises from an explosion in Qatar’s capital Doha on Tuesday following the Israeli strikes. Photo: UGC/AP
The Gulf Arab monarchies have been left reeling after the United States, their decades-long security guarantor, seemingly did nothing to prevent Tuesday’s unprecedented Israeli air strikes on Qatar, home to the region’s largest American military base.
Describing the attack as a “pivotal moment” for the Gulf, Qatari Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al-Thani called for a collective regional response after Israeli jets targeted Hamas negotiators in Doha.

The strikes have exposed a deepening rift between Qatar and Washington at a time of acute regional volatility.

Advertisement
Advertisement

US State Department fires official who questioned pro-Israel policy

A State Department press officer was dismissed after a dispute with the US Embassy in Jerusalem over the forced relocation of Palestinians

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
0
Listen
United States of America Department of State logo. Photo: Shutterstock

The State Department has fired a press officer who was responsible for drafting Trump administration talking points about policy towards Israel and Gaza after complaints from the US Embassy in Jerusalem.

Officials said Shahed Ghoreishi, a contractor working for the Bureau of Near East Affairs, was terminated over the weekend following two incidents last week in which his loyalty to Trump administration policies was called into question.

Ghoreishi, who is Iranian American, also was targeted on Wednesday following his dismissal by right-wing personality Laura Loomer, who accused him of not being fully supportive of the administration’s policies in the Middle East.

According to Ghoreishi and two current US officials, Ghoreishi drew the ire of a senior official at the US Embassy in Jerusalem and then top aides to Secretary of State Marco Rubio for drafting a response to a media query last week. The question related to discussions between Israel and South Sudan about the possible relocation of Palestinians from Gaza to South Sudan.

The draft response included a line that said the US does not support the forced relocation of Gazans, something that President Donald Trump and his special envoy Steve Witkoff have said repeatedly.

A worker hangs a road sign directing to the US Embassy in Jerusalem. Photo: Reuters
A worker hangs a road sign directing to the US Embassy in Jerusalem. Photo: Reuters

However, according to Ghoreishi and the officials, that line was rejected by the US Embassy in Jerusalem, leading to questions about policy back in Washington. The officials spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss internal personnel changes.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x