Maleficent_Chick

Fingers crossed! 🤞🏻 🤞🏻 I plan to ask her this weekend at Comic Con! I'll report back! 😂 😂

She wasn't even aware that should could do that kind of thing until she and Robin were after the troll that broke the tower. Robin is the one that figured it out and convinced Alice that she created the troll. If she was conjuring things up in the tower, I'm sure at some point she would have realized that stuff was popping up somehow and eventually worked it all out. It's not like was stupid, so I'm sure she would have, not only put it all together, but practiced at least at little, and therefore wouldn't have been so surprised when Robin suggested she created the troll. Also, I'm not sure her abilities even kicked in until the whole troll incident. If she had, I assume she would have been able to escape much sooner.

I think it's more likely that when the pain of seeing her without actually getting to be close to her became too much for Hook and he went off to supposedly find a cure, that he hired someone to make supply drops in his absence. Going by the scene where he's gambling for a potential cure (or something like that), quite a few people knew about Alice, and at least one member of his pirate crew would have done anything Hook asked.

Obviously it's just a theory since the show failed to give even a hint of how it all worked, but looking back and going over a few select episodes/scenes, that's the theory that makes most sense to me. I over think everything though! 😂 😂