MicroSD cards give you control over your data.

Search This thread

Hendrix7

Senior Member
Nov 18, 2023
205
54
I often see people in Internet comments falsely assuming that MicroSD is obsolete now that smartphones have high internal storage capacity.

While I am glad that we have moved past the days where 32 GB of internal storage was considered normal (remember the Galaxy S7 with its tiny 32 GB in 2016?), many people don't seem to understand that the main benefit of MicroSD is not storage capacity anymore, but durability and control over your data.

Any data in internal storage it is at the mercy of the operating system of the device. As history has shown, it can be broken by bogus updates or at worst be remotely disabled:


The internal storage is also more vulnerable to physical damage. If your USB port breaks or you drop your phone and it breaks (you should use a protective case anyway) or the water protection fails, you can no longer access its internal storage. Then you are at the mercy of the repair shop.

However, you can immediately retrieve a MicroSD card from the device and read it from another device or a computer. If you hold the power button and the screen stays black, you can rest assured that your data is still there.

Facilitated backups​


Creating backups is easier thanks to MicroSD. Using a file archiving utility (ZIP64, 7z, TAR, RAR, or whatever is supported by existing apps), you can dump the entire content of the internal storage on the MicroSD card. It is much faster than cloud storage and requires no internet connection.

Some people might also be uncomfortable with uploading their entire internal storage to a cloud service for privacy reasons. A memory card can't spy on you (obviously).

Without the MicroSD card, you would have to create the archive file on the internal storage itself, which wears down the irreplaceable internal flash memory and also requires that less than half of the internal storage is in use. (USB OTG may be another option, but it is uncomfortable to use and has no traditional mount point since Android 7 but uses some strange interface by Google, but rooted users can bypass this.)

You can simply insert a MicroSD card into the computer and bypass the slow and buggy MTP (Media Transfer Protocol) or even slower cloud syncing.

Memory cards also give you control over your data. If you have a music library on your MicroSD card, you can bring that music library to a new phone within one minute by switching cards. You don't have to bother with hour-long file transfers. It's with you in an instant, everywhere, even in locations where no Internet connection is available.

I hereby release this text under the Creative Commons 4.0 Attribution Share-Alike International license. Attribute this text with an URL to this post or with "Hendrix7 from the XDA Forums".


  • Edit 2024-06-14: clarified benefit for backups; added Creative Commons license.
 
Last edited:

Ultramanoid

Senior Member
Apr 24, 2011
3,989
1
7,104
東京都 Tokyo Metro

Indeed. People pay more attention to devices than to their data. And guess what, it's only the data that really matters, funny and sad how most don't recognize this.

Devices are replaced, broken, stolen, they fail, and you move on, as long as your data is safe ( AND backed up ), who cares. If the photos are lost, now, that's a loss. Or the music, or the legal documents, or whatever it is that cannot be replaced. You can buy a new device but you cannot buy the memories or valuable data lost forever. Still people attach data to devices as if they were one and the same, when their data does not have to die with the hardware at all.

Keep data independent and safe.

Never mind if you're a developer working with multiple OSes and devices. You don't want anything stuck on a piece of hardware and inaccessible to the rest.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hendrix7

blackhawk

Senior Member
Jun 23, 2020
15,988
1
7,210
Samsung Galaxy Note 10+
Meh, 1tb V-30 rated SanDisk Extreme is down to $89. One reason I still run N10+'s and not an S24U, etc.

Get a name brand card that's V-30 from a known good vendor only.
Format in phone and then leave it there.
NEVER encrypt or password protect a data drive!!!
Never clone a data drive; copy/paste.

Protect from ESD when handling and storing.
Avoid temperature extremes during use and storage. Do not touch the contacts.
Do not share it with other non Android devices ie cams etc. Best to not remove it at all.

Redundantly and regularly back up the SD card to at least 2 other drives that are physically and electronically isolated from each other and the PC! Protect all drives from near lightning strikes ie a Faraday cage.
All critical data goes on the SD card ie the data drive. Everything you need to do a complete restore should be stored there. Put some thought into this and organize it well.
There can only be one folder on the phone with "dcim" in its name! So rename any copies you make without it.

One if the Beasts, a 1.25tb dual drive.
Screenshot_20240421-121309_My Files.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hendrix7

Hendrix7

Senior Member
Nov 18, 2023
205
54
Another benefit: MicroSD is an excellent medium for exchanging data in countries with slow or censored Internet, and with authoritarian governments. Think Iran for example.
People can, for example, swap memory cards in a bathroom. That's potentially 256 GB transferred in one minute.

Unlike USB-OTG, a memory card is hidden inside the phone and does not reserve the USB port.

Besides, MicroSD is a miraolous piece of technology. It would seem too good to be true in the days of floppy disks. Not implementing it is a waste of opportunity.
 

Hendrix7

Senior Member
Nov 18, 2023
205
54
More benefits of micro SD:
  • Hot swapping: You can immediately get free storage without hour-long file transfers.
  • Changing needs: If you need more storage than you anticipated at the time of purchase, you can upgrade.
  • With modifications, it can be treated as mass storage. It can bypass MicroSD.
This video shows how difficult it is to recover data from a damaged phone.


With MicroSD it would take mere seconds. This is not only useful for water damage (water resistance can fail like the video above shows), but also for things like plane crashes. If people record videos onto MicroSD inside the plane, it is far likelier to be recovered than from internal storage.

I think a major reason phone manufacturers refuse to implement MicroSD is that people buy cheap off-brand MicroSD cards that don't perform well, and then blame the phone for being too slow. An off-brand MicroSD card is probably not fast enough for 8K video recording that modern phones have. Also, internal storage has no physical size constraints like MicroSD has, so they can make faster chips. But again, the solution for this would be a full-sized SD card slot.
 

Hendrix7

Senior Member
Nov 18, 2023
205
54
MicroSD cards also let you play videos taken with sports cameras and drones (GoPro, DJI, ...) in your phone without annoying bulky adapters or file transfers.
Given that those sports cameras usually record on MicroSD, you can simply take out the MicroSD card and insert it in your phone.
 
Last edited:

Hendrix7

Senior Member
Nov 18, 2023
205
54
MicroSD cards also reduce wear on the internal memory. This is useful if you want to take huge video files with you to watch on the go without wearing down your phone's internal memory.

Besides internal storage, the options are MicroSD, USB OTG, and cloud storage. USB OTG adds physical bulk and prevents you from connecting a power bank, and streaming from cloud storage requires persistent Internet connection that can cut out the second the train you sit in moves into a tunnel, if your data plan works abroad at all. For these reasons, MicroSD is the best option here.

Google added a storage chip health meter to Android 15, which I am glad to see.

Storage-Status-in-Component-Health-e1713506461619.jpg

(source: Beebom)

Unfortunately, both smartphone makers and Google lose from allowing MicroSD cards. As a cloud storage service provider, Google wants you to pay Google, not SanDisk. And phone vendors want to sell higher storage options.

The high prices for the higher storage options are somewhat understandable given that smartphones require high-quality reliable UFS (Universal Flash Storage) memory, but it's best to have both internal storage and MicroSD options. Or even better, full-sized SD cards for these reasons, though that's a bit of a stretch. Phone makers who eliminated MicroSD card slots won't make full-sized SD card supporting smartphones anytime soon.

Keep in mind that Google at its core is an advertisement and cloud service business. They don't profit from giving something out to the world for free, unless it gets more people in their ecosystems. This is also why Google in 2014 decided to lock down MicroSD write access, formerly a major selling point of Android-based smartphones, as usual excused with "protecting the user". Indeed, it "protects" the user in the same way a muzzle does.

Google does want you to give your money to SanDisk. While Android is "open source", access to Google Play services requires strict compliance with Google's decisions (source). This is why Android vendors have to bow down to Google's demands if they want access to Google Play services.

I am not against cloud storage, but against lack of options.

See also: You Can't Control Your Data in the Cloud by Karl Voit.

[This post is in the public domain, CC0 1.0.]
 
Last edited:

Top Liked Posts

  • There are no posts matching your filters.
  • 2
    I often see people in Internet comments falsely assuming that MicroSD is obsolete now that smartphones have high internal storage capacity.

    While I am glad that we have moved past the days where 32 GB of internal storage was considered normal (remember the Galaxy S7 with its tiny 32 GB in 2016?), many people don't seem to understand that the main benefit of MicroSD is not storage capacity anymore, but durability and control over your data.

    Any data in internal storage it is at the mercy of the operating system of the device. As history has shown, it can be broken by bogus updates or at worst be remotely disabled:


    The internal storage is also more vulnerable to physical damage. If your USB port breaks or you drop your phone and it breaks (you should use a protective case anyway) or the water protection fails, you can no longer access its internal storage. Then you are at the mercy of the repair shop.

    However, you can immediately retrieve a MicroSD card from the device and read it from another device or a computer. If you hold the power button and the screen stays black, you can rest assured that your data is still there.

    Facilitated backups​


    Creating backups is easier thanks to MicroSD. Using a file archiving utility (ZIP64, 7z, TAR, RAR, or whatever is supported by existing apps), you can dump the entire content of the internal storage on the MicroSD card. It is much faster than cloud storage and requires no internet connection.

    Some people might also be uncomfortable with uploading their entire internal storage to a cloud service for privacy reasons. A memory card can't spy on you (obviously).

    Without the MicroSD card, you would have to create the archive file on the internal storage itself, which wears down the irreplaceable internal flash memory and also requires that less than half of the internal storage is in use. (USB OTG may be another option, but it is uncomfortable to use and has no traditional mount point since Android 7 but uses some strange interface by Google, but rooted users can bypass this.)

    You can simply insert a MicroSD card into the computer and bypass the slow and buggy MTP (Media Transfer Protocol) or even slower cloud syncing.

    Memory cards also give you control over your data. If you have a music library on your MicroSD card, you can bring that music library to a new phone within one minute by switching cards. You don't have to bother with hour-long file transfers. It's with you in an instant, everywhere, even in locations where no Internet connection is available.

    I hereby release this text under the Creative Commons 4.0 Attribution Share-Alike International license. Attribute this text with an URL to this post or with "Hendrix7 from the XDA Forums".


    • Edit 2024-06-14: clarified benefit for backups; added Creative Commons license.
    1

    Indeed. People pay more attention to devices than to their data. And guess what, it's only the data that really matters, funny and sad how most don't recognize this.

    Devices are replaced, broken, stolen, they fail, and you move on, as long as your data is safe ( AND backed up ), who cares. If the photos are lost, now, that's a loss. Or the music, or the legal documents, or whatever it is that cannot be replaced. You can buy a new device but you cannot buy the memories or valuable data lost forever. Still people attach data to devices as if they were one and the same, when their data does not have to die with the hardware at all.

    Keep data independent and safe.

    Never mind if you're a developer working with multiple OSes and devices. You don't want anything stuck on a piece of hardware and inaccessible to the rest.
    1
    Meh, 1tb V-30 rated SanDisk Extreme is down to $89. One reason I still run N10+'s and not an S24U, etc.

    Get a name brand card that's V-30 from a known good vendor only.
    Format in phone and then leave it there.
    NEVER encrypt or password protect a data drive!!!
    Never clone a data drive; copy/paste.

    Protect from ESD when handling and storing.
    Avoid temperature extremes during use and storage. Do not touch the contacts.
    Do not share it with other non Android devices ie cams etc. Best to not remove it at all.

    Redundantly and regularly back up the SD card to at least 2 other drives that are physically and electronically isolated from each other and the PC! Protect all drives from near lightning strikes ie a Faraday cage.
    All critical data goes on the SD card ie the data drive. Everything you need to do a complete restore should be stored there. Put some thought into this and organize it well.
    There can only be one folder on the phone with "dcim" in its name! So rename any copies you make without it.

    One if the Beasts, a 1.25tb dual drive.
    Screenshot_20240421-121309_My Files.jpg