Democracy Dies in Darkness

Carolyn Hax: They were ethical vegans till husband flipped for meat

They met and married as ethical vegans, but spouse flipped and now he’s using their money for meat.

2 min
(Illustration by Nick Galifianakis/For The Washington Post)
Column by

Carolyn Hax is away. The following first appeared April 10, 2011.

Dear Carolyn: When my (now) hubby and I got together, we were both ethical vegans and shared many common interests about the issue. Recently, he decided he was “going back” to meat and has done so to an extreme. Over the years, we’ve had countless heartfelt discussions about why we don’t eat animals — the cruelty of factory farming and the moral imperatives — and now I feel duped. And seeing meat in our fridge hurts.

Subscribe for unlimited access to The Post
You can cancel anytime.
Subscribe

One final issue: He is not working, so it’s “my” money going to purchase a “product” I find truly abhorrent. How can someone I love not see the cruelty that was once so obvious to both of us — and still is to me? Do principles trump love?

— Anonymous

Anonymous: I can’t tell you what he’s thinking, nor can I decide for you where you need to stand.

I can point out, though, that for all your reverence for animals, you’re not showing much respect for the mammal you married. With my emphasis added, I’m going to give your words back to you: “How can *someone I love* not see the cruelty.” Your love determines how someone else thinks?

Skip to end of carousel
(For The Washington Post)
I’ve written an advice column at The Post since 1997. If you want advice, you can send me your questions here (believe it or not, every submission gets read). If you don’t want to miss a column, you can sign up for my daily newsletter. I also do a live chat with readers every Friday: You can submit a question in advance or join me live. Follow me on Facebook and Instagram.
End of carousel

I appreciate your passion and sympathize with your predicament — dramatic change in a spouse is difficult, no matter what form it takes — but you need to take a couple of rhetorical steps back to your side of the personal responsibility line. He is entitled to his own principles, which includes the right to revisit, revise or reject them.

You say you’ve had “countless heartfelt discussions” — but when you agree, it’s easy to trust and respect the other heart. Your job now is to see whether you’re willing to do the hard work and look for ways you can trust and respect someone whose views differ, and whether he’s willing to do the same.

Before you go in, I suggest you think carefully about “mine” vs. “ours” when it comes to money, because you could have a whole other, even more painful argument on your hands if you misspeak on that topic.

Also consider whether there’s any room for compromise in your views — say, for kosher meat or non-factory-farmed products. Pose the issue as the following question, to yourself first, then to your husband: “Is ‘ethical omnivore’ an oxymoron?” After all, our bodies are equipped to eat meat.