If it weren’t for this thread, I wouldn’t even know what Cuphead was…(coming from a late gen-xer/early millennial/whatever).
American HAS the chops to make “good” games; every single one I’ve played is pretty stellar in the shots/layout/geometry department, and I have high hopes for Ryan’s hand at design that this thing will be awesome.
Theming is fickle however. 15 year old me walked past new Baywatch in the arcades to go play old T2. And now I have a Baywatch, and no T2.
But I’m old now, and recognize that 15 year olds don’t BUY pinball machines, but PLAY them on location. And old enough now to recognize that the dynamic has changed and those once 15 year olds will buy them for their homes, if the game is good, and if their family likes it. If it’s a truly popular theme, they’ll earn on location, AND be bought by home buyers.
Time will tell, and I’m cheering for Ryan/American!