What Is the Secrecy Power Trump’s Aides Are Using to Stonewall a Federal Judge?
The administration is invoking an extraordinary national security power, the state secrets privilege, under highly unusual circumstances.
Escalating a standoff with the federal judiciary, the Trump administration invoked national security secrecy powers on Monday night to avoid complying with a judge’s demand for information about its transfer of migrants to a prison in El Salvador despite a court order.
The administration, as justification, pointed to the so-called state secrets privilege. Here is a closer look at the scope and limits of that power and the unfolding confrontation between two branches of government.
What information does the judge want?
The judge is asking for basic data about two flights by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement contractor on Saturday, March 15.
The flights took detained Venezuelan migrants from Texas to El Salvador after President Trump issued a proclamation invoking a wartime deportation law to assert the power to summarily remove people the government suspects of being members of a gang, Tren de Aragua, without individual due process hearings.
The judge has asked the following questions: “1) What time did the plane take off from U.S. soil and from where? 2) What time did it leave U.S. airspace? 3) What time did it land in which foreign country (including if it made more than one stop)? 4) What time were individuals subject solely to the proclamation transferred out of U.S. custody? and 5) How many people were aboard solely on the basis of the proclamation?”
Why is he seeking these details?
The judge is trying to assess whether administration officials violated a court order, and if so what the consequences — like whether to find them in contempt — should be.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
Charlie Savage writes about national security and legal policy. More about Charlie Savage
Our Coverage of U.S. Immigration
A City’s Split: President Trump has made Aurora, Colo. synonymous with the supposed scourge of Venezuelan gangs, but some wonder if his immigration raids are damaging the city more than the migrants ever did.
Attempts to Deport Columbia Undergraduate: A federal judge ordered the Trump administration to halt its efforts to arrest and deport Yunseo Chung, a legal permanent resident who immigrated from South Korea as a child, after she participated in pro-Palestinian demonstrations.
Judge Maintains Block on Deportations: A federal judge kept in place his ruling barring the Trump administration from using a powerful wartime statute to summarily deport Venezuelan immigrants accused of being members of a violent street gang.
Migrant Children: Aid organizations were notified by the Trump administration that it would cancel a contract that funds the legal representation of more than 25,000 children who entered the United States alone, a decision that leaves them vulnerable to swift deportation.
Watchdog Agencies Shut Down: The civil rights branch of the Department of Homeland Security and two ombudsman offices were shut down by the Trump administration, gutting the offices responsible for conducting oversight of President Trump’s immigration crackdown.
Related Content
Eric Lee/The New York Times
Mikayla Whitmore for The New York Times
Helen H. Richardson/MediaNews Group/The Denver Post, via Getty Images
Haiyun Jiang for The New York Times
Craig Hudson/Reuters
Vincent Alban for The New York Times
Editors’ Picks
Stephanie Zambrana
Illustration by Tomi Um
Matt Chase
Trending in The Times
Illustration by The New York Times; photograph by Carlos Barria/Reuters
Chugach National Forest Avalanche Information Center
Desiree Rios for The New York Times
Rafiq Maqbool/Associated Press
Graham Dickie/The New York Times
Chris Haston/Disney
Image by Christian Medica, via Storyful
Joe Rondone/The Republic, via USA TODAY NETWORK, via Imagn Images
Amy Sussman/Getty Images
Advertisement