Reporting Global Tech Stories
China E-commerce Chinese Temu sellers use fake U.S. postage labels to boost their profits
China Outside China

Chinese Temu sellers use fake U.S. postage labels to boost their profits

Some vendors have figured out how to maintain ultralow prices: Trick the U.S. postal service into delivering products for free.

A brown envelope with a red VOID stamp and scraps of paper featuring USPS-related text and designs scattered on it. The background is a solid blue color.
iStock / Rest of World
iStock / Rest of World
  • Some Temu sellers use fake shipping labels to avoid delivery costs within the U.S.
  • Scammers advertise counterfeit USPS postage on Chinese social media, charging as little as 60 cents to deliver packages in America.
  • USPS loses millions of dollars a year to counterfeit postage and is cracking down.

Some Chinese Temu merchants are padding their profits by using counterfeit postage labels to trick the U.S. Postal Service into delivering packages for free. Posts on Chinese social media openly promote fake labels for as little as 60 cents, and the scam costs the USPS millions of dollars a year, Rest of World has found from interviews with sellers, logistics operators, and USPS employees.

Learn more
0:00/8:31

A de minimis exemption, which previously allowed parcels valued under $​800 to enter the U.S. duty-free, drew millions of Americans to Chinese e-commerce platforms such as Temu and SheiniSheinFounded in China in 2008 and headquartered in Singapore, Shein is a fast fashion brand that grew rapidly through exposure on social media.READ MORE. President Donald Trump briefly revoked the provision in early February. Merchants have tried to evade the de minimis crackdown, first proposed by the Biden administration, by storing goods in bulk in the U.S. But others are turning to illegal methods such as counterfeit postage to keep costs low.

Creating, distributing, and buying fake USPS labels is a crime, and overseas warehouse operators also risk significant jail time by processing parcels with these labels. It is likely that only a small minority of merchants use counterfeit labels, but these numbers could rise as logistics costs increase. Shipping is a major cost for e-commerce sellers, with USPS charging up to $10 for a parcel weighing about 2 pounds (around 1 kilogram).

It’s millions upon millions of dollars. … It’s a huge problem.

“It’s millions upon millions of dollars. … It’s a huge problem,” a person familiar with the investigations by the U.S. Postal Inspection Service (USPIS), which is responsible for cracking down on postal crimes, told Rest of World, referring to losses caused by counterfeit shipping labels. The person requested anonymity because they were not authorized to speak to the media. “The sheer amount of loss is astronomical,” they said.

Chinese merchants using counterfeit postage labels tend to work with small warehouses in the U.S. that are willing to bear the legal risk of processing such packages, three people in the logistics industry told Rest of World. The merchants send digital files of the counterfeit labels — which have details of the shipper and recipient, a tracking number, and a barcode — to the warehouses. Workers there print out the labels, affix them to the packages, and drop them off at post offices.

One Temu merchant has been purchasing 1,000 to 2,000 fake labels daily, and sending them as PDFs to a U.S.-based warehouse since November, he told Rest of World. The labels would typically cost more than $8 each, but the fake ones cost only 5 yuan (68 cents) each, he said, requesting anonymity as his activity is against platform policy.

“With the [low] prices listed on Temu, I would never be able to make money if I paid for legitimate shipping,” said the merchant.

A spokesperson for Temu told Rest of World that fake labels are “strictly prohibited” on the platform. 

Merchants who engage in fraudulent practices could face account suspension, penalties, and potential legal action, as they violate the platform’s policies, the Temu spokesperson said. The spokesperson did not respond to charges by some merchants that there was too much pressure to keep prices low on the platform.

With the [low] prices listed on Temu, I would never be able to make money if I paid for legitimate shipping.

“We encourage merchants to compete on product quality, innovation, and customer service, not through deceptive or illegal tactics,” the spokesperson said in an email.  

The use of fake shipping labels precedes the de minimis crackdown. In May 2023, authorities arrested a California logistics operator who pleaded guilty to defrauding the USPS out of more than $150 million by using counterfeit postage to ship millions of packages for Chinese businesses. Her co-defendant developed a computer program to create counterfeit postage shipping labels in China. The operator faces up to 10 years in prison.

A large percentage of e-commerce suppliers to the U.S. are based in China. While individuals in the U.S. and other countries also make counterfeit postage, the USPIS is aware that a large share of the labels come from China, the person familiar with its investigations said. In 2024, U.S. postal officials held discussions with Chinese authorities in the U.S. about combating the crime, and the Chinese officials “responded positively,” the person said, without providing details.

A spokesperson for USPIS said it is working to “continuously identify counterfeit postage.” Recently, it intercepted packages affixed with counterfeit postage from entering the U.S. from ports in New York and Los Angeles. USPIS did not respond to Rest of World’s questions on the prevalence of the crime and loopholes in the postal system.

A workspace featuring a pink mechanical keyboard, a computer mouse, a compact printer with white paper unrolling from it, various bottles, and a partially opened box on a dark wooden desk.
George Etheredge for Rest of World

Two postal workers in New York City told Rest of World they had encountered shipping labels they suspected to be fake, but the packages were still sent out for delivery. 

“If the packages were not intercepted at the previous stages, it was not on us to do anything,” one of the USPS employees said, requesting anonymity because he was not authorized to speak to the media. “It costs a lot of manpower to inspect the packages.” 

Counterfeit labels are easy to access. On Chinese social media network Xiaohongshu, also known as RedNote, dozens of users were recently peddling fraudulent labels using euphemisms like kejidan, which means “tech label,” and paoshuidan, meaning “running-water labels.” When Rest of World inquired about the rates, three vendors offered to sell labels at 60–80 cents each, saying they could be used anywhere in America. A few vendors also advertised fake UPS shipping labels.

Some sellers are scammed into buying counterfeit postage. Elena Wang, owner of Shanghai-based contact lens company MoMoLense, bought hundreds of USPS shipping labels at $3 each from a warehouse operator in 2024, she told Rest of World. About a month later, one batch of her Temu shipments was seized by postal authorities, costing her more than $10,000 in lost products and a penalty from Temu for failed deliveries, she said.

If I can turn 70% of my costs down to 10% by cheating … it’s a pretty good deal.

She realized the labels were fake and has since switched to using legitimate postage. “We want to do long-term business,” she said. “We didn’t want to profit from the loopholes.” 

Still, fraudulent shipping likely accounts for a very small percentage of the industry, driven by an incentive to cut costs, Matthew Hertz, chief executive officer at Third Person, a platform that connects businesses with fulfillment partners, told Rest of World. For commercial customers, USPS charges about $4–$5 to deliver a small parcel that weighs less than 1 pound, and $8–$10 for an item weighing 2–3 pounds, Hertz estimated. 

Preview of newsletter on mobile device with protective case that looks like a bunny
Get The Global, our (free) newsletter Sign up for our weekly newsletter and we’ll send you our latest stories, dispatches from our staff, what we’re reading, and more. A world of tech, right in your inbox.

About “60% to 70% of the total logistics cost is small package shipping,” he said. “If I can turn 70% of my costs down to 10% by cheating … it’s a pretty good deal.” 

Suppliers of unbranded products sometimes resort to illegitimate methods, including counterfeit postage and brushing schemes, in order to make more money out of thin margins, according to Lin Zhang, an associate professor at the University of New Hampshire, who studies the Chinese e-commerce industry. Brushing scams involve sellers creating fake buyer accounts to pump up product reviews. 

Such practices add to the regulatory risks Temu faces in the U.S., Zhang told Rest of World. “China is providing what American consumers need, but it’s provided at a cost,” she said. More measures targeting the cross-border Chinese e-commerce industry could follow. 

“Given the administration’s overall attitude on tariffs, manufacturing, and tech competition with China … [shipping fraud] will inevitably become part of the collective evidence against Chinese platforms,” Zhang said.

The Temu merchant who buys thousands of fraudulent postage labels said he was aware of the risk of his goods getting seized, and of Temu imposing a penalty on his business. But since most of the fake labels have led to successful deliveries, the risk was worth it, he said. 

“I can accept paying some fines, because I’m making more in profits,” he said.

China Outside China

U.S. tariffs on China can’t slow the impact of Chinese imports worldwide

New tariffs on China imposed by Trump — and an end to direct e-commerce shipping to U.S. consumers — could impact Shein and Temu, but their influence extends globally.

White e-commerce packages from China against a red background
Alejandra Rajal for Rest of World
Alejandra Rajal for Rest of World

When do the U.S. tariffs on Chinese goods go into effect?

The Donald Trump administration imposed new tariffs on China this week, with an additional 10% levy on all Chinese imports coming into effect on February 3. Officials said they would also close a loophole that allows companies to avoid tariffs on packages valued at less than $800 shipped directly to U.S. consumers. Chinese e-commerce giants Temu and SheiniSheinFounded in China in 2008 and headquartered in Singapore, Shein is a fast fashion brand that grew rapidly through exposure on social media.READ MORE have used this provision to ship to millions of U.S. consumers in recent years.

Over the last 10 years, the number of shipments entering the U.S. under the de minimis exemption increased by more than 600% from about 139 million a year in fiscal year 2015 to over 1 billion a year by 2023, according to U.S. Customs and Border Protection. Last year, that figure was over 1.36 billion. The proposed changes “would make certain products ineligible for the exemption,” as the practice is unfair to American businesses, the CBP said. 

But the U.S. is not the only country that is slapping tariffs on Chinese goods. India, Turkey, and Vietnam are among the countries that have imposed tariffs on Chinese goods in recent years to protect local industries, with more countries doing so in 2024. The tariffs have targeted everything from cheap clothes in Indonesia to e-bikes in the EU, EVs in Canada, solar cells in South Africa, semiconductors in India, and wind turbines in Mexico.

How has Beijing responded to Trump’s new tariffs? 

While China’s initial response was notably muted compared to fiery rebuttals from Canada and Mexico, Beijing responded on February 4 with a series of retaliatory steps. China announced tariffs of its own, ranging from 10% to 15% on a selection of American imports including coal, crude oil, and a list of critical minerals, to be effective immediately. In addition, China filed a formal complaint to the World Trade Organization, and said it has added American garment maker PVH Corp and American genomics company Illumina to its unreliable entity list. At the same time, Beijing’s market regulatory watchdog said it would kick off an anti-monopoly investigation into Google — a case that first came to light back in 2020.

What makes Chinese e-commerce companies so compelling — and so effective?

China has been “the world’s factory” for decades, with made-in-China goods reaching global consumers through foreign brands, shops, or sites like Amazon. The country already had a vibrant domestic e-commerce sector, with companies like Alibaba and JD.com growing into juggernauts. But Chinese-owned shopping platforms then began looking beyond China’s borders. Companies including Temu, ultrafast-fashion platform Shein, and TikTok Shop heralded a new, global era for Chinese e-commerce

What makes these platforms so compelling is that the shopping apps all have some social networking built into them. They feature livestreamed videos of shopping influencers, and robust chat and photo-sharing functions. With algorithms designed to spark impulse buys among users, China has become the global leader in social commerce. Nearly half the respondents in a 2024 McKinsey survey reported that they’d recently made purchases directly through social media apps.

Just how much of an impact do cheap Chinese imports really have worldwide?

The rise of Chinese e-commerce has changed how consumers shop and work around the world. In Nigeria, traders who used to import secondhand designer and sports clothes from Europe and the U.S. now simply buy them on Chinese e-commerce platforms, selling them in the local market as “fake originals.” While in New York, Los Angeles, and Philadelphia, Chinese immigrants are offering up their living rooms and garages as “family warehouses” to cross-border sellers on Temu, Shein, and TikTok.

But perhaps the biggest impact of Chinese e-commerce platforms can be seen in Latin America, where the cheap imports dominate consumer trends, and have brought about new jobs and shaped entire industries. In Mexico, low- or middle-income housewives sell Temu and Shein items door to door, contributing to the platforms’ rapid rise in the country. Also in Mexico, hundreds of gig workers have ditched local delivery apps to deliver packages for Temu and AliExpress because the work is faster, and offers them greater flexibility. Street markets in Mexico and other Latin American countries, which once sold secondhand clothes cheaply, now sell surplus goods from manufacturers who produce clothing for Shein.  

It isn’t just Shein’s cheap clothes that are a hot commodity in Latin America. The plastic bags they are packaged in have their own resale market, and have created a new packaging category named after the brand: Shein-style bags. 

China Outside China

DeepSeek’s rise shows why China’s top AI talent is skipping Silicon Valley

Young Chinese engineers focus on homegrown innovation, drawn by fewer visa hurdles and the chance to build a future on their own terms.

A rendering of the DeepSeek logo of a blue whale is playfully depicted as winning a race against an orange rabbit, and a green turtle on a black racetrack with white lines and scattered gold stars in the background.
Joanne Lee/Rest of World
Joanne Lee/Rest of World
  • DeepSeek has recruited recent graduates and interns from China’s top universities.
  • Facing visa hurdles and high living expenses, more of China’s AI researchers are choosing opportunities at home rather than abroad.
  • U.S. chip restrictions have forced Chinese companies to accelerate innovation.

At the end of his internship at Nvidia in 2023, Zizheng Pan, a young artificial-intelligence researcher from China, faced a pivotal decision: stay in Silicon Valley with the world’s leading chip designers or return home to join DeepSeek, then a little-known startup in eastern China.

Learn more
0:00/6:38

Pan chose DeepSeek without much hesitation, Zhiding Yu, a senior research scientist at Nvidia and Pan’s mentor during the internship, recalled on X last month. “I am still very much impressed,” Yu wrote, adding that cases like Pan’s are increasingly common. “Many of our best talents come from China, and these talents don’t have to succeed only in a U.S. company.”

Less than two years after Pan joined DeepSeek, the company catapulted to global fame when it released two AI models that were so advanced, and so much cheaper to build, that the news wiped nearly $600 billion off Nvidia’s market value.

Pan’s choice reflects a growing trend among China’s AI elite to reject Silicon Valley jobs for the AI industry in China, which offers lower living costs, proximity to family, and the opportunity to take on significant roles early in their careers, people in China’s tech industry told Rest of World. DeepSeek filled its ranks with young graduates and interns from elite Chinese universities, such as Tsinghua University and Peking University.

DeepSeek is an outlier in China’s AI industry, as it is fully funded by founder Liang Wenfeng’s trading firm, High-Flyer. The young, passionate tech workers behind DeepSeek are working to catch up with Silicon Valley tech giants, despite the U.S. barring China from accessing advanced chips. 

What has surprised me is many Chinese students are not that interested in full-time jobs in America.

“[DeepSeek] highlights the strength of China’s AI talent pool, supported by a large number of highly capable and skilled software engineers,” Angela Zhang, a professor at the University of Southern California who studies tech regulations in China, told Rest of World. “I believe this talent advantage positions China strongly for the next phase of AI development.” 

Nearly half the world’s top AI researchers completed their undergraduate studies in China, according to a 2023 report on global AI talent published by Chicago-based think tank MacroPolo. Chinese universities, state-backed labs, and research arms of American tech giants, such as the Beijing-based Microsoft Research Asia, have helped groom a large group of local researchers.  

For example, Junxiao Song, a core contributor to DeepSeek’s latest R1 model, studied automation at Zhejiang University before obtaining a Ph.D. in electronic and computer engineering at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology in 2015, according to his Ph.D. adviser Daniel Palomar. Song was persistent and “very mathematically oriented,” Palomar told Rest of World.

Daniel Palomar

When Palomar posted about Song’s work with DeepSeek on LinkedIn, another former student commented that Song used to have the nickname dashi (great master). “Somehow, [DeepSeek] managed to get the best of the best,” Palomar said.  

American companies hire Chinese interns with strong engineering or data-processing capabilities to work on AI projects, either remotely or in their Silicon Valley offices, a Chinese AI researcher at a leading U.S. tech company told Rest of World. “Chinese students do very solid work,” said the researcher, who asked to remain anonymous because he was not authorized to speak to the media. 

But when given full-time offers, many of them have chosen to go back to China, he said. “What has surprised me is many Chinese students are not that interested in full-time jobs in America,” the researcher said. Worries over anti-immigration policies have also deterred some Chinese engineers from moving to the U.S. in recent years. 

Although earlier generations of elite Chinese tech workers preferred Silicon Valley jobs for higher salaries and a chance to work alongside the world’s top innovators, a growing share of young AI engineers are choosing to stay home. There are also more opportunities for them as China’s domestic AI industry expands, with tech giants like Alibaba, and also startups such as StepFun, Minimax, and 01.AI. 

Somehow, [DeepSeek] managed to get the best of the best.

DeepSeek has a unique way of wooing talent. The firm pays staff more than ByteDance, according to a recent report from Chinese tech outlet 36Kr. And unlike many Chinese tech firms that foster internal competition and make engineers work grueling hours, Liang told 36Kr in a July 2024 interview that he lets employees find their own tasks and access computing power freely. 

“We are working on the most difficult problems, so we are attractive to them,” he said. 

In the same interview, Liang said making research open-source gives employees a stronger sense of pride and boosts the company’s reputation. Over the past few weeks, some DeepSeek researchers have gained tens of thousands of followers on X, as they discussed research methods and shared their excitement. 

“Beyond words right now,” DeepSeek researcher Deli Chen wrote on X on January 24, as the R1 model ranked number one on a popular chatbot leaderboard. “All I know is we keep pushing forward to make open-source AGI a reality for everyone,” said Chen, who graduated with a master’s degree from Peking University in 2021.

“This moment is absolutely phenomenal to me,” Pan, the former Nvidia intern, wrote two days later. 

Yu Zhou, a professor at Vassar College who has studied the evolution of China’s high-tech industry, told Rest of World the enthusiasm of DeepSeek’s young researchers reminded her of what she had observed at the first internet startups in Beijing in the early 2000s. At the time, graduates from China’s top universities were inspired by the likes of Google and Microsoft, and ended up creating a tech industry at home with less money and fewer top engineers, she said. 

“America thinks China’s trying to unseat America, but the truth is that young people were inspired by new technology developments such as OpenAI,” said Zhou. 

Today’s AI entrepreneurs in China have no choice but to grapple with a shortage of the most powerful Nvidia chips, she said. “When you don’t have resources, all you have is your brain power.”

China Outside China

The secret sauce of Chinese social media apps

Addictive algorithms fuse social networking with shopping and entertainment.

A flat lay of multiple smartphones on a vibrant blue background, displaying app logos including TikTok and Lemon8, as well as text in red and yellow that includes "小红书" (Little Red Book) and "lemon8."
Rest of World
Rest of World
  • In China, social commerce is a key driver in the design of apps that surface viral trends, keeping users hooked.
  • Chinese apps have made social shopping mainstream, in contrast to Western social networks which focus on advertising.
  • Experts say the logic of the TikTok ban could outlaw many Chinese apps, media outlets, and websites, creating a “Great Firewall” of the U.S. over time.

In the days leading up to the January 19 deadline for TikTok, users in the U.S. scrambled to find alternatives. But instead of YouTube, X, or Instagram, the so-called TikTok refugees flocked to Chinese apps such as XiaohongshuiXiaohongshuXiaohongshu, which translates to “little red book” in Chinese, is a lifestyle e-commerce and social media platform.Read More On Xiaohongshu, and another ByteDance product, Lemon8, which uses a recommendation algorithm similar to that of TikTok.

Learn more
0:00/7:21

In trying out Chinese apps as a form of protest — language barrier be damned — many of TikTok’s 170 million American users discovered the same features that had made TikTok so appealing: an infinite scroll of hyper-targeted recommendations, and interactions with friendly strangers. Xiaohongshu, one of China’s most popular lifestyle social networks, quickly became the most downloaded app on Apple’s U.S. App Store, followed by Lemon8.

A key driver behind the success of Chinese apps is that they have integrated e-commerce into their platforms, blending entertainment and networking with sales to monetize their famously addictive algorithms, according to Chinese social media experts and marketing firms. The platforms also continually surface fresh, engaging content, not only fueling binge-watching but also exposing users to new trends and shopping opportunities. 

Western apps are going to be playing catch-up for a very long time, no matter what happens to TikTok.

“TikTok’s algorithm is so good and so influential that it became a very powerful social media platform that attracted a lot of people,” Mandy Hu, director of the Centre for Consumer Insights and associate professor at the Chinese University of Hong Kong, told Rest of World. “[Their e-commerce] business model was a way to cash in on the popularity.”

All of China’s major social platforms have a component of shopping built into them, known in the industry as shoppertainment or social commerce. Xiaohongshu was launched in 2013 as a guide for Chinese travellers looking for shopping recommendations. The model has delivered: In 2023, TikTok’s Chinese sister app, Douyin, said its platform sales exceeded 2 trillion yuan ($2 billion). Xiaohongshu doesn’t disclose detailed figures, but the app’s aggressive expansion into social commerce in 2023 coincided with the first year it turned a net profit to the tune of $500 million.

At the same time, social networking is built into the most popular Chinese online shopping platforms, like Taobao, Tmall, and JD.com. They feature livestreamed videos of shopping influencers, and robust chat and photo-sharing functions, blurring the lines between social media and e-commerce.

With algorithms designed to spark impulse buys among wide swathes of users, China has become the global leader in social commerce, with nearly half the respondents in a 2024 McKinsey survey reporting they’d recently made purchases directly through social media apps.

Western social networks, on the other hand, remain focused on advertising revenue, and their algorithms tend to prioritize accounts that users have opted to follow, MaryLeigh Bliss, chief content officer at YPulse, a New York-based research firm that studies consumer trends among young people, told Rest of World

TikTok’s powerful search function and For You recommendation algorithm surfaced videos on anything that was trending, creating a heightened discovery experience, Bliss said. “It is kind of ironic considering [concerns about Chinese government influence], but truly, it democratized content in a way that no other app had.”

Although TikTok only launched TikTok Shop in 2023, American users’ social commerce content helped boost ByteDance’s non-China revenue by 60% last year, despite regulatory pressures. Last year, TikTok said it topped $100 million in Black Friday shopping revenue in the U.S. 

Without a ban, TikTok could one day rival Amazon, Ryan Broderick, a tech journalist and commentator, told Rest of World.

“Overwhelmingly, Chinese social apps are competing with traditional e-commerce platforms,” he said. “The fact that U.S. lawmakers aren’t talking about this signals that Western apps are going to be playing catch-up for a very long time, no matter what happens to TikTok.” 

CFOTO/Getty Images

Western platforms have tried to mimic some of TikTok’s functionality, such as through Instagram Reels, but have been criticized for issues that include an alleged lack of authenticity, Brett Dashevsky, founder of Creator Economy NYC, a networking group for online creators, told Rest of World

“Instagram feels like a stage where everyone’s watching and judging. But TikTok felt like a casual hangout where you could just be yourself,” Dashevsky said. “On Instagram, the algorithm amplifies your content to your followers — friends, family, and everyone you know — making [posting] feel more like a statement.”

“But on TikTok, the algorithm throws your content into the mix for anyone to see,” he said. “Your content stood on its own, and if it flopped, it just disappeared. No grid, no pressure. Just vibes.”

Many TikTok users have posted videos in recent days bashing Western media platforms. “I love TikTok, it doesn’t typically criticize what [people] look like, where they’re coming from. They want to know what you’re saying. It’s an actual community,” user Jason Finds said

The prospect of a TikTok ban still looms, as lawmakers have doubled down. A ban would have far-reaching legal implications for other Chinese platforms, Milton Mueller, a professor at the Georgia Institute of Technology and co-founder of the Internet Governance Project, told Rest of World. Lemon8 would be subject to the same ban because it is owned by ByteDance, and the legislation could cover multiple companies and entities, potentially creating a “Great Firewall of the United States” over time, he said. 

“The logic of this ban is indeed a slippery slope,” said Mueller, adding that it could extend not only to Xiaohongshu but also to any Chinese newspaper or website seen to be influenced by Beijing.

Could Western companies emulate Chinese apps’ approach to shoppertainment? Meta tried, then backed off, closing down a shopping function for Instagram in early 2023, and said it was focusing on AI services. E-commerce platforms like Amazon have not been able to successfully integrate social content. YouTube has explored shopping features in some regions, recently tying up with an e-commerce platform in Southeast Asia. The companies did not respond to requests for comment.

Preview of newsletter on mobile device with protective case that looks like a bunny
Get The Global, our (free) newsletter Sign up for our weekly newsletter and we’ll send you our latest stories, dispatches from our staff, what we’re reading, and more. A world of tech, right in your inbox.

There are also political factors in play. In China, the government encourages consumer spending through online platforms as it promotes their importance as an economic engine, while in the West, social media companies face relatively more regulatory scrutiny for designing algorithms to be addictive, or showing potentially harmful content.

“I think it’s just a matter of priorities,” Broderick said. “American social platforms were born as extensions of our TV or newspaper industries. Chinese tech platforms seem much more influenced by e-commerce. They’re playing different games.”