Revealed: More than 1,000 patients a year have trans โtop surgeryโ on the NHS
Data reveal the extent of โmasculinisingโ mastectomies being carried out on the health service, despite calls to halt the surgeries
More than 1,000 patients a year are sent for transgender โtop surgeryโ on the NHS.
Data obtained by The Telegraph show for the first time the number of referrals for taxpayer-funded โmasculinisingโ mastectomies from specialised gender clinics.
As many as 80 per cent of people using those services are females between the ages of 17 and 25.
The 1,000-plus referrals could be the tip of the iceberg, because many people have transgender surgery privately to bypass long NHS waiting lists.
A search for โtop surgery UKโ on the GoFundMe platform brings up hundreds of results.
The NHS faces calls to halt the surgeries. Experts warn there is no evidence that removing healthy breasts is beneficial for those with gender dysphoria โ but there is evidence of harm.
A number of detransitioners have spoken publicly about their regret at rushing to have irreversible surgery, and the pain caused.
Zhenya Abbruzzese, co-founder and senior adviser at the Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine (SEGM), said: โWe are concerned that young people are being told that these procedures will relieve their distress when the research cannot find the benefits, but the harms of losing a functioning body part are certain.
โDoctors need an urgent memo about the actual state of the evidence. But this is a question primarily for health authorities to decide โ should the treatment be available given the risk-benefit ratio and the evident risk of harm?โ
The data, obtained using freedom of information laws, show that the NHSโs Gender Dysphoria National Referral Support Services (GDNRSS) referred 3,490 women for โmasculinising chest surgeryโ between 2021 and 2023.
The number has risen slightly each year, from 1,089 in 2021 to 1,164 in 2022 and 1,237 in 2023.
Of the 10 NHS hospitals carrying out the operations, North Manchester Hospital had the highest number of referrals. It was followed by Parkside Hospital in London and Castle Hill Hospital in Hull.
GNDRSS deals with all referrals for specialised gender surgery for people over the age of 17.
Over three years, it also sent more than 780 women for โmasculinising genital gender reassignment surgeryโ, also known as โbottom surgeryโ.
Concerns over specialised adult gender clinics were investigated by Dr Hilary Cass, who noted in her 2024 review that their patients were โ70-80 per cent birth-registered females under the age of 25โ.
A recent systematic review of mastectomies for gender dysphoria, led by McMaster University and published by the Journal of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, found there was โvery low certainty evidenceโ for their outcomes.
Ms Abbruzzese said: โIt is extremely unusual for there to be a surgical intervention when there are so many unknowns.
โWe donโt know why so many more young women are identifying as trans and we donโt know what the future holds for these young people if we just slow down.
โIn that situation, medical intervention that is so irreversible and with clear harms typically would not normally be offered.
โThe systematic review has found that despite several decades of doing this surgery, and over 1,300 studies published, there is no evidence that it improves mental health and overall functioning.โ
Concerns about the number of operations carried out by the NHS were also raised by parents of children who think they are transgender.
A spokesman for Bayswater Support Group said: โThere is a particular cruelty for parents in finding that taxpayers are funding mastectomies on thousands of women who have been misled into believing this will be the answer to their psychological distress.
โThe devastation of seeing your daughter harmed in this way is impossible to describe.โ
An NHS spokesman said: โMasculinising chest surgery is only available to adult patients who have a clinical diagnosis of gender dysphoria from a specialist NHS clinic.
โThe NHS is undertaking a wide-ranging review of adult gender services, which will inform a revised service specification to set out how we will support patients with gender dysphoria in future.โ