Fact Check: Does China Control the Panama Canal, as Trump Suggests?

Video
Related Videos
AD Loading ...
Video Player is loading.
Current Time 0:00
Duration 0:58
Loaded: 20.40%
Stream Type LIVE
Remaining Time 0:58
 
1x
    • Chapters
    • descriptions off, selected
    • default, selected
    Donald Trump Taunts Panama: 'Welcome To The United States Canal'

    President-elect Donald Trump has sparked controversy by suggesting the United States should reclaim control of the Panama Canal, citing overcharges for its use and alleged Chinese influence over the waterway.

    During the past week, Trump has criticized Panama for increasing fees, warning that if the issue doesn't improve after he takes office next month, he will demand the canal's return to the U.S.

    Trump's remarks prompted a strong response from Panamanian President Jose Raul Mulino, who stated in a video on Sunday, "Every square meter of the canal belongs to Panama and will remain so."

    The Claim

    On Christmas Day, Trump took to Truth Social to criticize China's involvement in the Panama Canal, raising concerns over Beijing's influence on the critical waterway.

    "Christmas greetings to all, including the wonderful soldiers of China, who are lovingly, but illegally, operating the Panama Canal," Trump wrote. He went on to reference the canal's history, saying that "we lost 38,000 people in its building 110 years ago," yet the United States continues to invest billions in repairs while having "absolutely no say" in its operation.

    The Facts

    The Panama Canal, a 51-mile waterway connecting the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans, has been under Panamanian control since December 31, 1999, following the 1977 Torrijos-Carter Treaties. These agreements guaranteed the canal's neutrality and access for global shipping, while transferring administrative authority to Panama.

    After Trump posted the remarks, Mulino denied allegations of Chinese control over the canal. "China does not control or administer the canal. When it comes to our canal, and our sovereignty, we will all unite under our Panamanian flag."

    Locomotives help guide a cargo ship as it passes through the Miraflores locks while transiting the Panama Canal near Panama City on May 24. President-elect Donald Trump, inset, has sparked controversy by suggesting the U.S.... Getty Images

    While a subsidiary of Hong Kong-based CK Hutchison Holdings manages two ports at the canal's entrances, with Chinese firms funding construction of a new bridge over the canal to the tune of over $1 billion, this does not equate to control of the canal's operations. The Panama Canal Authority, an autonomous government agency, oversees the canal's administration.

    Without directly naming Trump, Mulino defended the canal's operations, explaining that the canal's tariffs are determined transparently and are essential for its maintenance and expansion. He highlighted Panama's significant investments in expanding the canal to increase ship traffic.

    "The tariffs are not set on a whim," he said. "Shipping fee increases help pay for improvements."

    The Panama Canal is most frequently used by the U.S., China, Japan and South Korea. In October, the Panama Canal Authority reported earning nearly $5 billion during the last fiscal year.

    The Ruling

    False. While Chinese companies manage two of the five ports near the Panama Canal and have invested in related infrastructure, these activities are distinct from the canal's governance and operations. The Panama Canal Authority has maintained full control of the canal since 1999, when Panama regained sovereignty over the waterway.

    FACT CHECK BY NEWSWEEK

    For more information about this ranking please click on this LINK
    Newsweek Logo

    fairness meter

    fairness meter

    Newsweek is committed to journalism that's factual and fair.

    Hold us accountable and submit your rating of this article on the meter.

    Newsweek is committed to journalism that's factual and fair.

    Hold us accountable and submit your rating of this article on the meter.

    Created with Highcharts 11.4.8
    UnfairLeftleaning
    Mostly Fair
    Left leaning
    Fair
    Mostly Fair
    Right leaning
    UnfairRightleaning
    Click On Meter To Rate This Article

    About the writer


    Jesus is a Newsweek Live News Reporter based in New York. Originally from Bogotá, Colombia, his focus is reporting on ... Read more

    Conversation

    |
    Start a discussion, not a fire. Post with kindness. Read our guidelines here

    All Comments

      1. Comment by McIrish.

        "Every square meter of the canal belongs to Panama and will remain so." - Panamanian President Jose Raul Mulino

        'What's a meter?" - Donald J. Trump

        • Comment by Mjolnir.

          Trump needs an "other" for people to fear and hate. Immigrants are not going to work for four years, because they become his failing in less than a month, so he is working up their replacement, Gyna.

          • Reply by Mjolnir.

            Trump needs you to fear and hate someone. Like I said immigrants don't have staying power, as he becomes responsible for them in less than a month. You are already starting to equivocate and pivot to his new "other".

          • Reply by Uncle Boz.

            Like his wife?

        • Comment by z3_patriot.

          Things like giving back the Canal cemented Jimmy Carter as the worst President ever: up to Biden.

          • Comment by penta.magenta.

            You are naive if you think China is not using it's power and influence to control the decision making process of the Panama Canal Authority.

            • Comment by tmahoney.

              The likelihood of Trump being truthful is very, very small.

              • Reply by MichaelBMaxwell.

                Not only is this new *format* worse (no italics, no bold, hard to see what messages are replies to others because the lines connecting them are so faint, you can only edit your comment for two minutes after posting), but the censorship--which was always bad--is now over the top.

              • Reply by McIrish.

                True, given his long distance relationship with the truth.

            • Comment by Convent.

              Yes

              • Reply by tubbs2u.

                No. Duh.

            • Comment by dennis6422.

              Musk is the richest person on the world, apparently. But, Trump thinks that he, Donald, owns it. Quite the combination.

              • Comment by Bident100.

                Under Trump, America is at best #5 in the world behind Russia, China, India and Brazil. We do Excel in public school shootings and obesity and trading prisons on the stock market however. So that's nice.

                We're #5! We're #5! Gooooo Twump! 🤣🤡

                • Reply by web0623.

                  Strange. Trump is not in office. You are talking about Biden at the moment.

                • Reply by tmahoney.

                  An adult who doesn't demand a free lunch.

              • Comment by Lachlan Mackenzie.

                If the Chinese run ports at either end, they can exercise control over the flow of traffic. That is power over Atlantic/Pacific trade. If you were the Chinese Government - what's not to like?

                • Reply by z3_patriot.

                  Quit using logic and facts. Libs never waste a good narrative. Remember how they said Biden was cognitively fit. How about how Camela was going to win.

                • Reply by MichaelBMaxwell.

                  tubbs is not talking about libs, he's talking about Trump.

              • Comment by chuck8321.

                China is encroaching everywhere and I'm confident it's not for the good of the rest of the world.

                • Reply by chuck8321.

                  Prove it.

                • Reply by MichaelBMaxwell.

                  Tibet, Hong Kong, Uyghur land and now the entire South China Sea, no matter what other countries on that sea think. Oh, and low Earth orbit.