Square Enix has a plethora of RPG series under its belt, but of all of them, SaGa is certainly its most experimental, unique, and the hardest to crack into.
Starting life on the Game Boy, and initially marketed as a Final Fantasy spin-off in the West, the SaGa series is known for ditching traditional levelling mechanics and storytelling for something a bit more open. While earlier games have you selecting characters and classes as blank-slates, later entries had a set cast with their own individual storylines.
These are not easy games to get into — but those who love them really love them. And we applaud Square Enix for sticking with this series over the years to give us a whole different kind of turn-based RPG. But the real question — what is the best SaGa game?
We've asked you lovely readers to rank every single SaGa game you've played that launched on a Nintendo system. That's 10 titles — including Collection of SaGa, which contains the three GB games, on Switch. This list doesn't include the mobile games or the two PlayStation exclusives, SaGa Frontier 2 or Unlimited SaGa.
The results are glimmering for you down below, but remember: this ranking is governed by User Ratings for each game on our database and is subject to real-time fluctuations, even after publication. That means it's still possible to influence and alter the ranking below. To do so, simply click on the game you wish to rate and assign a score on the Game Page.
So then, let's find out what your favourite SaGa game is, dear readers:
11. The Final Fantasy Legend (GB)
Makai Toushi Sa・Ga, given the Final Fantasy label in the West, is the very first game in the SaGa series. It's an incredibly complex game for its time, but often obtuse by today's standards.
While its two sequels improve upon the template laid down here, RPG traditionalists will still find much to like in the original game. Although it was designed to be a shorter experience more suited to a portable machine, it’s a tough little game and still worth a look all these years later.
10. Romancing SaGa -Minstrel Song- Remastered (Switch eShop)
Romancing SaGa – Minstrel Song – Remastered's ambitions and achievements still feel fresh today.
The open-world system is remarkably well-implemented and the multiple-protagonist approach feels modern even in a game that has been on the market for decades, but control issues, the vague nature of the game, and a slow progression system drag it down.
Unfortunately, this is a cult classic JRPG that is less than the sum of its parts.
9. Romancing SaGa 2 (Switch eShop)
Romancing SaGa 2 is a really intriguing JRPG. The combat system has a great sense of depth thanks to its distinctive take on levelling, the inclusion of formations and how the player is held accountable for each party member.
The kingdom management aspects also provide a greater sense of player agency and help set it apart from conventional role-playing games. Due to this design, the story and character development – including the dialogue throughout – aren’t quite as refined as other Square Enix titles.
Regardless, the entire concept has aged surprisingly well, even by modern standards.
8. Final Fantasy Legend III (GB)
Final Fantasy Legend III is a fitting end for the trilogy of Game Boy games; a very solid RPG experience that features a surprising degree of depth
If you like your quests long and your combat systems very basic and traditional in design, you’ll find much to like, although you might find it a little tedious if you've got used to more modern RPG trappings.
However, RPG enthusiasts are old hands when it comes to flirting with tedium in classic titles, and there’s still plenty to enjoy in this game – the final in the SaGa series to carry the 'Final Fantasy' moniker in the West.
7. Collection of SaGa Final Fantasy Legend (Switch eShop)
Is Collection of SaGa Final Fantasy Legend for you? Well, that really depends on one huge factor: Did you play these games as a kid? If so, then this compilation may be worth the punt for a nice trip down memory lane. If you don’t fall into that camp, however, it’s difficult to recommend picking this up.
Without the prism of nostalgia, these three games are 'okay' when at their best and rather disappointing when at their worst. The hard truth is that both your time and money are much better spent on the mountain of new or old RPGs you can buy for the Switch.
Make no mistake, there are worse games out there! But there are much better ones, too, and Collection of SaGa Final Fantasy Legend really only has value as a curiosity or nostalgic piece.
6. SaGa Frontier Remastered (Switch eShop)
SaGa Frontier Remastered sees Square Enix's cult classic JRPG looking and playing better than ever, with a lovely HD lick of paint and lots of restored content and quality of life improvements providing hardcore fans with an experience they'll doubtless enjoy.
However, this is still a game that's aged quite poorly in many respects; an idiosyncratic, eccentric and infuriating experience that refuses to guide you or help you in any way, and one that, in the end, is quite hard to recommend to anyone who isn't already a fan.
5. Final Fantasy Legend II (GB)
Final Fantasy Legend II improves on every single aspect compared to its predecessor. A brand new playable race — robots — was added, it was easier to get spells on mutant characters, and humans now needed to gain stats and not just buy them.
This is also the most clearly defined story of the first three SaGa games and of the trilogy — all available via the Collection on Switch — this is probably the easiest to get into.
4. SaGa Emerald Beyond (Switch eShop)
SaGa Emerald Beyond has a deep and satisfying combat system that gets its hooks into you from the jump. There's a lot of narrative content across its five adventures, as well as a diverse collection of characters, but very little that truly grips the attention.
Still, as ever with SaGa, fans are bound to love this one, and the combat is so rewarding that if you love tinkering, you might just fall for it too.
3. Romancing SaGa 3 (Switch eShop)
It’s both easy and difficult to recommend Romancing SaGa 3 as it’s a title that you’ll either love or hate with very little room in the middle. We would recommend RPG newcomers pass on it and circle back later on, as this is a game that assumes a certain baseline knowledge of RPGs and it seldom explains mechanics to you in a satisfactory fashion.
If you’re more experienced with RPGs, we’d give it more of a recommendation, but with the caveat that this demands patience and careful study to fully enjoy. Either way, Square did a great job of prettying up this delightfully obscure RPG for Western audiences.
2. SaGa Scarlet Grace: Ambitions (Switch eShop)
As the first brand new SaGa game since 2002's PS2 exclusive Unlimited SaGa, SaGa Scarlet Grace: Ambitions absolutely delivers. The combat is thrilling, the music is fantastic, and it still has all of those SaGa quirks you know and love — or don't love.
The story could be better, but overall, this is the most approachable SaGa game to date and the easiest recommendation we can give in this series.
1. Romancing SaGa 2: Revenge of the Seven (Switch)
Romancing SaGa 2: Revenge of the Seven is a bit of an underwhelming RPG that has some unique gameplay mechanics. The open-ended world narrative structure feels freeing, but the characters are boring. The glimmer mechanic is fun, but the battle system lacks a strategic hook. Each of its gameplay systems is a double-edged sword, as we’d find a particular aspect enticing while another was baffling.
It feels like a slight step back from the other recent SaGa games, then, but if you’re a fan of the series, Revenge of the Seven might resonate with you more than it did with us.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which SaGa game should I play first?
Good question! Like lots of RPG franchises, none of the SaGa games are connected. That means you can play the SaGa series in whatever order you like. Even Romancing SaGa and Final Fantasy Legend, while sharing titles, are not related between numerical entries.
If you're looking to start somewhere, however, we'd recommend the two newest entries in the series — SaGa Scarlet Grace: Ambitions or SaGa Emerald Beyond. Both are available on the Switch eShop and present a more streamlined version of the SaGa series formula, albeit with all of the tropes and trappings. So you're getting a cleaner, more refined experience.
If you want to go a bit older, Romancing SaGa 3 is also a great place to start. Of the SNES games, it's the most polished and most accessible. But don't go in expecting any of the games to be easy.
Are the SaGa games difficult?
Difficult isn't perhaps the right word for it, but they're certainly a little hard to get into. The SaGa series forgoes traditional experience points and most of the games don't follow a linear story. They also don't really do a lot of hand-holding. So aside from the games that have set character stories — think SaGa Frontier or the two Switch titles — they're very non-linear and you have to work out a lot of different things.
Is SaGa related to Final Fantasy?
Not really, but you could argue that Final Fantasy sort-of gave us SaGa.
Akitoshi Kawazu, creator of the franchise, worked on Final Fantasy II — the second NES/Famicom entry — as the game designer, coming up with many of the newer battle and levelling mechanics. While many working on Final Fantasy didn't enjoy these new mechanics, they live on in the SaGa series.
As for Western naming conventions, Square decided to name the first SaGa game The Final Fantasy Legend to try and draw more eyes to the game. Simple as that. Otherwise, the two franchises are unrelated.
Is SaGa Frontier 2 coming to Switch?
Probably! Well, nothing is definite yet, but series creator Kawazu has long been teasing a remaster of the PS1 RPG. Which would make sense given that SaGa Frontier Remastered is on Switch.
In fact, as recently as 1st April 2024, Kawazu told fans to "Please be patient." (via Gematsu) In the same breath, he also said that this is not a remaster announcement" but it's about as close as you can get without saying "here is the announcement", right?
Are you itching to dive into SaGa? Do you want more people to get into the franchise? Let us know in the comments and share your favourite SaGa game with us.
Comments 22
Really surprised by seeing Romancing SaGa Minstrel Song only as the 6th.
One of my favorite rpgs in general I've played in years.
@Hinade if only a few people have given the game a rating, and if from those few several have given it a lower rating, then it falls down.
These ratings are not always indicative of quality.
There’s one important game missing here (or so my nostalgia says), though for entirely understandable reasons - in Japan, Saga 2/Final Fantasy Legend II got a full-3D remake on the DS back in 2009 - SaGa 2: Hihou Densetsu: Goddess of Destiny! It improved on a lot of the original game’s systems, the soundtrack got hella updated (when it was already rather excellent), and overall looked really great as a game (the character designs were redone by the same artist who designed the characters in The World Ends With You, so, yeah). Unfortunately, it never got a western release, so most people with huge nostalgia for Legend II in particular have no idea that the game essentially got a complete remake/remaster 15 years ago. It’s gotten unofficial English patches on the yar-har-fiddlee-dee scene (since that’s effectively the only way to experience it at this stage), but there’s also playthroughs up on YouTube for any interested!
@Daniel36 Fair enough haha
@Nanoline52
That is one of those games i wish did make it west, would love to see it get a remaster of some kind (feels unlikely but then a good few years ago i would have said the same thing about a bunch of rpgs including several SaGa games)
iirc wasnt there a similar remake for FFL3 which ended up reworking it into more of a SaGa game wheres the original felt closer to one of the NES FF games.
@Daniel36
I guess that would explain the "collection of SaGa" being lower than FFL2 and 3.
unless there was some change to the games in the collection, though from what i gather despite the message at the start of the game, in the western release the changes were mainly some mistranslated words (such as the infamous L and R confusion with some japanese translations) and there wasn't really any script changes, the bananas are still illegal.
Argh! I am very torn. By reading, SaGa Scarlet Grace Ambitions seems like the wisest choice and i will probably purchase Romancing SaGa 3 as well.
They are both on sale, so i think i’ll buy both, dive into SSGA first, and then try RS3 as recommended.
This was all very helpful and thank you to Alana and all those who provided rankings, and to those who replied to my initial post with recommendations.
Update: Bought SaGa Scarlet Grace Ambitions and a buncha SaGa tracks in Theatrhythm.
Every write-up:
This game made some bold decisions and really innovated the genre. But most of you will probably end up hating it.
And boy, if that doesn't describe the SaGa series to a T...
Let me qualify my previous comment by saying that it's very possible you will be one of the ones to love the SaGa series. I am too! But it takes a certain kind of player- and I don't even know what specific kind of player that is- to be charmed by its innovations instead of repelled by them.
Whew, I don't like up with the community at all. My list is almost completely the reverse of that. But that's kind of the cool thing about SaGa, everyone has their own favorites and they usually are die hard for them.
These games look fantastic but just not my bag, I am almost envious of those who can play these genres.
@Nanoline52 very happy to see someone else spread the word about these oft forgotten remakes! We need them released in the west!
@Bomberman64
Nowadays it does feel like almost anything could happen given all the games weve seen localized for the first time in the past few years, such as the third mana game not only getting a remake but the original being localized in the collection, romancing SaGa 2 and 3, scarlet grace coming west, live a live remake, even outside of square-enix we have things like the Marl kingdom collection, trails from zero/azure and other such localizations.
not getting my hopes up but not ruling anything out completely, it would be a nice surprise at the very least.
@Diogmites
Both of them offer a unique experience which is nice so if you dont get on with one of them you may enjoy the other.
Scarlet grace for example has a heavy emphasis on the combat side with exploration largely being on an overworld map where's RS3 has your more traditional RPG dungeons and towns to walk around in.
for me my most played game on switch is SaGa frontier, it kind of feels more of a successor to the gameboy ones than the romancing SaGa games with its wacky setting and different character races.
i am hoping SaGa frontier 2 gets a remaster, it was extremely different from the first frontier and very linear but i loved the locations in it and the art style and music gave it a very cozy vibe (iirc the series producer has heavily hinted that its coming)
@Mgalens I am sensing there is a disparity in value that different fans of this series spread amongst the various games(a common occurrence). It seems a consensus as to which is the best SaGa is unattainable(but for the evidence above) and i wish i could try them all, as perhaps there’s one for me, but i am contented with just trying a couple for now.
Your assessments are helpful, and they reinforce my hunch that Romancing SaGa 3 is for me, but i feel that it would be foolish of me not to try and start with Scarlet Grace, as it is recommended as a starting point and scores well. Emerald Beyond looks more appealing than Scarlet Grace to me, but at its current price, is too risky an endeavor.
Before continuing this comment i snapped a look at SaGa Frontier Remastered and i dig the art style and am now thinking of grabbing it as well.
I have seen others writing highly of Frontier 2 and hope it is indeed coming to Switch as i would like to try it.
Thank you for all the info and recommendation!
Good list. Another thing that can make people flee from many SaGa games is that the thought of grinding to become stronger in order to have an easier time is usually not a thing. Often the enemies will become stronger as you do too.
Also the LP system with permadeath can be painful.
Still it's an underrated franchise and I really look forward to SF2! That game is not just fun to play (and can also be very hard) but the original is so aesthetically beautiful too
@Diogmites
oh yeah i definitely recommend giving scarlet grace a go, the combat is considered some of the best in the series.
i would say the one oddity of the series would be FFlegend 3, ironically the game is "odd" because its the most "normal" one of them, playing closer to one of the nes FF games than a SaGa game, not saying its a bad game, i loved my time with it. (it did get a remake on DS which made it more like a traditional SaGa game but that was sadly unlocalized)
but yeah, the series has a good amount of variety to it.
Of the ones I have played, I had ambitions as top dog pretty easily.
The Game Boy SaGa games were my introduction to RPGs. My local grocery store sold electronics, so I used to ogle the boxes for Adventure, Legend, Legend II, and Legend III, reading the descriptions and marveling at the tiny screenshots. I saved up and eventually got them all. Yes, I'm a longtime SaGa and Mana fan.
SaGa Scarlet Grace number 1! Purists took the L!
Thanks for the explanation, a long time ago I was quite confused about what game I could get in the future and because of the name change depending on the region, that confused me even more.
@Hinade Same, and I've played 'em all. Minstrel's Song towers over the other, IMO. Hell, it'd deserve to be in the top three for its soundtrack alone.
After spending 50+ hours on SaGa: Emerald Beyond during the last two weeks, right now I feel like that is my favourite SaGa game. I of course understand that it is too early for it to make the absolute top on a list like this, but I expect it to rise high in the ranks among fans during the coming years.
I have always liked the series, but none of the games have been a real masterpiece (for me). Emerald Beyond might not be a masterpiece either, but it´s extremely addictive and have a gameplay and progression loop that just really works for multiple playthroughs. There is so much more for me left to see, do and accomplish.
In previous SaGa games the "multiple protagonist" angle have mostly felt like a gimmick. Playing through a 40 hour rpg 7 times as different protagonists with minor differences...no. And this has kind of made that approach a bit misguided - sounds intriguing, but only the real hardcore would ever play the game that many times. But in Emerald Beyond they have made it a part of the whole experience, with smaller campaigns and a better shared progression system.
(And yes, SaGa Frontier had 7 (8 in Remastered) smaller campaigns, but also recycled content more heavily than Emerald Beyond)
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...