The Ethicist
The magazine’s Ethicist columnist on what it means to be a customer of someone who espouses a radically different political perspective.
For 18 months, I’ve taken a weekly lesson at a stable that specializes in therapeutic work. The team here helps disabled people experience horseback riding and nonmounted equine exercises; they also have a kids’ program. The barn is truly my happy place, so much so that I have volunteered at its events and made small financial contributions to the program.
I’m very fond of the stable’s director; riding under her expert tutelage has helped me become stronger, happier and more confident. Recently, I drove up to the barn to drop off my granddaughter for the last day of her riding camp there. Draped over the director’s front porch, adjacent to the stable and visible to all, was a large Trump banner.
Gut-punch time. I can’t imagine anything more horrifying than a Trump presidency. There’s no point in talking to the director — I remember on my first day there, she told me that politics and religion were taboo topics among the barn family. (Now I get why!)
I guess I could go elsewhere, but I don’t really want to start over with someone new. Quitting means giving up something I love; staying means feeling nauseated and untrue to myself. How do I navigate this situation? — Name Withheld
From the Ethicist:
Your world is full of services provided by people who, amid this neck-and-neck election, favor Donald Trump’s candidacy; you just don’t know this about most of them. Let’s figure that they helped write the software that runs your smartphone, fixed your leaking faucet, trucked produce to your supermarket and might even have treated your granddaughter’s ear infection. I trust you’re not committed to avoiding the presence or services of all such people.
Maybe, though, you’re bridling not so much at this woman’s support for Donald Trump as at her expression of that support. She does seem to have broken her own rule: A large Trump banner violates the idea that this is a politics-free zone. If you express a political thought, you’re inviting people to respond with political thoughts. And citizens ought to feel free to talk to one another about who would — and would not — make a good president. So I hope you’re feeling untrue to yourself only because you haven’t told the director what you think about our former president. Instead of silently bailing on this place, why not ask her about her enthusiasm for a second Trump administration (and, yes, then listen to her before sharing your views)? If she somehow thinks that signage isn’t the same as discussion, you can come to your lessons wearing your candidate’s merch.
Subscribe to The Times to read as many articles as you like.
Kwame Anthony Appiah is The New York Times Magazine’s Ethicist columnist and teaches philosophy at N.Y.U. His books include “Cosmopolitanism,” “The Honor Code” and “The Lies That Bind: Rethinking Identity.” To submit a query: Send an email to ethicist@nytimes.com. More about Kwame Anthony Appiah
The Ethicist’s Answers to Your Moral Quandaries
Kwame Anthony Appiah helps readers handle life’s trickiest situations.
I work in data security. Is it a problem that my boss believes in lizard people?
My partner keeps returning purchases she has worn for months. Is she exploiting the store’s return policy?
I’ve been unemployed for months. Now, I’ve been offered a role in a predatory industry. Would it be wrong to take this position?
The director at the stable where I take lessons started displaying a Trump banner. I find the idea of a Trump presidency horrifying, but I don’t want to quit. How do I navigate this situation?
To submit a question to the Ethicist, send an email to ethicist@nytimes.com.
More from the The Ethicist Newsletter
The Ethicist
Advice on life’s trickiest situations and moral dilemmas from the philosopher Kwame Anthony Appiah. Sends twice a week. Get it in your inbox.
Recent issues from this newsletter
Explore our newsletters
Build your routine with some of our top newsletters or view them all here.
Advertisement