Menu
Menu
  • News
  • Real Estate
  • Health Care
  • Politics & Policy
  • Special Features
  • Awards
  • Data & Lists
  • CONTENT STUDIO
  • NOMINATIONS
  • EVENTS
  • PEOPLE & COMPANY MOVES
  • JOBS
News
  • Latest News
    • Latest Issue
  • Arts & Entertainment
  • Banking & Finance
  • Cannabis
  • Commentary
    • Latest Commentary
    • Editorials
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Op-Eds
  • Climate
  • Economy
  • Health Care
  • Politics & Policy
  • Real Estate
    • Retail
  • Restaurants
  • Sports & Recreation
  • Technology
  • Transportation
  • Workplace
Real Estate
  • Latest News
  • Commercial Real Estate
  • Residential Real Estate
  • Deals of the Day
  • Who Owns the Block
  • Real Estate Families of New York
Health Care
  • Latest News
  • Health Pulse
  • Top Earners
  • Who's News
Politics & Policy
  • Latest News
  • On Politics
Special Features
  • NYC Crossroads
  • The Book
  • Chasing Giants
  • Economic Outlook
  • New York's nonprofit shadow government
Awards
  • 20 in Their 20s
  • 40 Under 40
  • Best Places to Work
  • Diversity & Inclusion Awards
  • Hall of Fame
  • Women of Influence
  • Notables
  • Anthem Whole Health Heroes (sponsored)
  • 2023 New York ORBIE Awards (sponsored)
  • Nominations
Data & Lists
  • Data Center
  • The Book
  • Highest-Paid CEOs
  • Highest-Paid Hospital Execs & Doctors
  • Largest Private Companies
  • Largest Public Companies
  • Largest Residential Sales
  • More Lists
Skip to main content
Sister Publication Links
  • CONTENT STUDIO
  • NOMINATIONS
  • EVENTS
  • PEOPLE & COMPANY MOVES
  • JOBS
Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Login
  • Logout
  • Register for Free
  • Subscribe
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Banking & Finance
    • Cannabis
    • Commentary
    • Climate
    • Economy
    • Health Care
    • Politics & Policy
    • Real Estate
    • Restaurants
    • Sports & Recreation
    • Technology
    • Transportation
    • Workplace
    • Latest Issue
    • Latest Commentary
    • Editorials
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Op-Eds
    • Retail
  • Real Estate
    • Latest News
    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Residential Real Estate
    • Deals of the Day
    • Who Owns the Block
    • Real Estate Families of New York
  • Health Care
    • Latest News
    • Health Pulse
    • Top Earners
    • Who's News
  • Politics & Policy
    • Latest News
    • On Politics
  • Special Features
    • NYC Crossroads
    • The Book
    • Chasing Giants
    • Economic Outlook
    • New York's nonprofit shadow government
  • Awards
    • 20 in Their 20s
    • 40 Under 40
    • Best Places to Work
    • Diversity & Inclusion Awards
    • Hall of Fame
    • Women of Influence
    • Notables
    • Anthem Whole Health Heroes (sponsored)
    • 2023 New York ORBIE Awards (sponsored)
    • Nominations
  • Data & Lists
    • Data Center
    • The Book
    • Highest-Paid CEOs
    • Highest-Paid Hospital Execs & Doctors
    • Largest Private Companies
    • Largest Public Companies
    • Largest Residential Sales
    • More Lists
    MENU
    Breadcrumb
    1. Home
    2. Politics & Policy
    October 16, 2024 01:46 PM 33 minutes ago

    Controversial hotel bill softened again after owners protested

    Nick Garber
    • Email
    • Share
    • Tweet
    • Share
    • More
      Reprints Print
      Buck Ennis

      The City Council and the Hotel and Gaming Trades Council union agreed to soften a controversial licensing bill, exempting small hotels from new limits on subcontracted workers.

      A lawmaker and the city’s powerful hotel workers’ union agreed to further soften a bill that will impose a licensing system on New York City’s hotels, responding to outcry from small hotel owners. The bill, which supporters say is now final after three major revisions, could pass the City Council next week.

      At the heart of the Safe Hotels Act is a provision that would require hotels to directly employ public-facing workers like front desk staff and housekeepers instead of subcontracting them — a longtime priority of the Hotel and Gaming Trades Council union. Under a revised bill released on Wednesday, hotels with fewer than 100 guest rooms will be exempted from the subcontracting ban.

      Although the Hotel Association of New York City, which represents larger hotels, had previously given the bill its blessing earlier this month, HANYC approached the union HTC again last week to request the new exemption, two people familiar with the negotiations told Crain’s. Owners of low-cost, non-union hotels outside of Manhattan had expressed anger at HANYC for signing off on the legislation, which they feared would financially burden independent owners while having little impact on larger, well-resourced hotels that already employ unionized workers.

      Related
      Big hotels struck a deal on city’s licensing bill. Smaller hotels still hate it
      Hotel Association drops opposition to licensing bill that is roiling the industry
      Hotel bill battle exposes labor world rift

      The union, which had previously ignored loud criticism from national groups like the American Hotel and Lodging Association, agreed to make changes after last week’s outreach from HANYC, with whom HTC has a long working relationship, a union official said. Bill sponsor Julie Menin said the revisions were also influenced by testimony that small hotel owners made at the Oct. 9 hearing.

      “We landed the plane in a really great place and we also listened to mom-and-pops who wanted flexibility on seasonal hiring,” Menin said. “We were able to preserve all the core provisions, which I’m thrilled about.”

      It was not immediately clear whether the other groups that had opposed the bill, including the American Hotel and Lodging Association, were satisfied by the compromise.

      The latest bill will require all hotels to obtain a city license every two years in order to operate, with a fee of $350 — up from $200 in the previous version. Supporters say the bill aims to improve safety for guests and workers, and the legislation will also require owners to provide “panic buttons” to employees who enter guest rooms, maintain a continuous front-desk or security presence, hire a certain number of security guards, and meet certain cleanliness standards for guest rooms.

      With support from 37 members of the 51-person council, the bill is expected to pass as soon as the council’s next full meeting on Oct. 23. But that approval will come only after the bill was rewritten several times in response to criticism.

      After introducing the bill in July in hopes of passing it quickly, Menin and HTC were forced to hit pause after the restaurant industry revolted against a provision that could have essentially terminated the leases of businesses that lease space in hotels. That section was changed, and the council made further revisions weeks later by narrowing the subcontracting rule to apply to fewer jobs, and changing language that some feared could deter investors.

      RECOMMENDED FOR YOU
      Eric Adams Alex Spiro legal defense fund dolans
      Adams’ legal defense fund runs dry, despite help from Dolans
      Eric Adams fundraising
      Who’s still donating to Eric Adams?
      Chauncey Parker Eric Adams Deputy Mayor for public safety
      Mayor names new safety czar, replacing Phil Banks
      CUSTOM WeWork 10-14-24
      Sponsored Content: The Future is Flex: WeWork Survey Reinforces the Office is Critical for Profitability and Culture
      Most Popular
      1
      Who’s still donating to Eric Adams?
      2
      SoHo building at risk of collapse to be sold at auction
      3
      Empire State Building owner reports 'material weakness' in accounting
      4
      Mexican restaurant group’s chef-owner claims partner skimmed funds to revive Kellogg’s Diner
      5
      Mayor names new safety czar, replacing Phil Banks
      Get our newsletters

      Staying current is easy with Crain's news delivered straight to your inbox, free of charge. Click below to see everything we have to offer.

      Subscribe today!

      Don't miss the chance to get the biggest news first! Stay connected to New York business news in print and online

      Subscribe
      Connect with us
      • Facebook
      • Twitter
      • LinkedIn
      • Instagram

      Our Mission

      Crain’s New York Business is the trusted voice of the New York business community—connecting businesses across the five boroughs by providing analysis and opinion on how to navigate New York’s complex business and political landscape.

      Contact Us

      685 Third Avenue
      New York, NY 10017
      1-877-824-9379

      Contact us/ Help Center

      Staff directory

      Crain jobs

      Events
      • Submit Your Event
      • All Upcoming Events
      • Crain's Events
      • Past Crain's Events
      • Webcast Archives
      • Livestreams
      • Corporate Membership
      Resources
      • Advertise with Us
      • Crain's Content Studio
      • Crain's New York Business app
      • Newsletters
      • Reprints
      • AdChoices
      • Sitemap
      • Corrections and Clarifications
      Legal
      • Terms and Conditions
      • Privacy Policy
      • Privacy Request
      Crain
      Copyright © 1996-2024. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
      Close
      Crain's New York Business

      Afternoon 10 Newsletter: Our must-read daily update on New York’s top business stories to get you
      up to speed before you log off for the day.

      Sign Up

      Already a subscriber? LoginLogin

      To Continue Reading...

      Subscribe today and get access to this story and other breaking news. 

      Benefits:
      Digital article access across all devices
      Full online archives access
      Editorially-curated newsletters
      Basic Digital - Monthly
      $16.00 for 1 month, renews automatically
      Basic Digital - Annual
      save 27%
      $140.00 for 1 year, renews automatically
      Subscribe NowSubscribe NowGet a Corporate PlanGet a Corporate Plan
      Benefits:
      Digital article access across all devices
      Full online archives access
      Editorially-curated newsletters

      View all subscription optionsView all subscription options

      or

      Go to homepageGo to homepage

      Already a subscriber? LoginLogin

      View all subscription optionsView all subscription options

      Go to homepageGo to homepage

      notification icon
      We’d like to send you notifications for the latest news and updates.