Bank investors' worry after Wells Fargo AML action: Who's next?

Michael Nagle/Bloomberg

A new enforcement action overWells Fargo's

NYSEWFCWFCWells Fargo & Company$52.78USD52.78USD1.21(2.35%)24.8mAs of:September 13, 2024 4:00 PM
anti-money-laundering guardrails has investors worried about whether other banks will be next.

The regulators' action on ThursdayagainstWells Fargodidn't include fines and lacked some of the teeth of most enforcement actions. But analysts worry Wells won't be the only bank facing scrutiny from the U.S. government, whose regulators are more closely eyeing whether the industry is doing enough to prevent money laundering.

And it comes months after severe lapses in those protections hobbled Canada's TD Bank, whose vast U.S. branch footprintreportedly proved easyfor drug traffickers to exploit as they sought to launder cash. The bank may have to paysome $3 billion in fines, and its plans for a U.S. expansion were shelved.

Lawyers, analysts and consultants expect more penalties against banks, from small community banks to larger institutions. But which companies will be subject to those penalties remains unclear, as does whether regulators will merely scold them or more forcefully crack down against worse offenders.

"There is an uneasiness," said Ed MIlls, a policy analyst at the firm Raymond James. "There is always an expectation that, when you see a regulatory action with one large bank, that usually forces an examination of other similar-sized institutions."

Bank investors are "trying to wrap their heads around the level of severity," said Scott Siefers, an analyst at Piper Sandler who coversWells Fargoand other larger banks.

"At this point, I would say no one really knows," Siefers said. "It's just out there as a discussion point and a concern."

The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, which flagged deficiencies atWells Fargoin Thursday's enforcement action, declined to comment further.

If banks are in for a new round of crackdowns, observers point to theseries of AML-related punishmentsthat regulators placed on them about a decade ago. U.S. regulatorsclamped down on London-based HSBC, JPMorgan Chase, Citigroup and several other banks at the time.

For its part,Wells Fargogot hit with an AML consent order from the OCC in 2015 and wasfinally releasedfrom it in January 2021.

Fixing the problems the OCC flagged was an early coup in CEO Charlie Scharf's efforts to improveWells Fargo'sstanding with regulators. Though the new enforcement action is a setback, analysts said it's merely a written agreement and doesn't carry the same legal weight as the 2015 order from the OCC.

The industry's overhauls took years, but analysts and consultants say the earlier crackdowns forced a massive improvement in money-laundering protections. Banks hired new teams, built data systems and put better safeguards in place for catching and reporting suspicious activity.

The problem is that multinational criminal rings innovated too, finding new ways to sneak past bank safeguards. The war in Ukraine has also escalated the risk that banks may be running afoul of U.S. sanctions against Russian individuals and companies.

Banks are throwing a "ton of money at these problems," said Sarah Beth Felix, a bank AML consultant and CEO of Palmera Consulting. But they still struggle to find the right talent and keep up with an always-evolving set of threats, she said.

"If you don't know what your threats are, then you can't really find all of the suspicious activity that's related to your bank, no matter how big or how small," Felix said.

Adding to the challenge is that government agencies also struggle to define what effective prevention looks like, she said, noting the frequent yet unfruitful chatter of the need to move beyond "checkbox exercises."

"No one ever says the next part, which is: then what do we look for? I think that's what we're seeing in thisWells Fargoorder," Felix said.

The order requires the bank to boost training for front-line employees and back-room officials who act as extra layers of defense, and it requires improvements in its databases. It also requires thatWells Fargotemporarily get formal non-objections from OCC officials before they expand into certain products and markets that present higher risks of violating AML or sanctions rules.

The restrictions pale in comparison to the asset cap thatWells Fargo has been operatingunder since 2018, and they're also tamer than regulators' directives during the last AML crackdown. Regulators prevented some banks with AML issues from merging, temporarily weighing on their ambitious growth plans.

AML issues were once again reportedly to blame in TD's failed merger with Tennessee-based First Horizon, with the Wall Street Journal reporting that AMLconcerns with TD helped killthe $13.4 billion deal.

While many hoped AML issues were in the past, TD's problems may have put it back in focus for regulators, said Edward Jones analyst Kyle Sanders.

"If the regulators find something at one company, that'll trigger an industrywide sweep," Sanders said.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article,click here.
Regulation and complianceIndustry NewsWells FargoMoney laundering

More from American Banker

Federal banking agencies extend comment period on bank-fintech risks

Banks now have until Oct. 30 to weigh in on potential risks of third-party fintech partnerships for banking products and services.

Sep 14, 2024

Turning community bank employees into AI enthusiasts

Community bankers have found that demonstrating efficiency, providing proper training and describing use cases can help get employees on board with AI products.

Sep 14, 2024

How banks can overcome challenges of cash flow underwriting technology

At a New York event, industry practitioners shared how they are addressing cultural, compliance and logistical objections to making loans based on bank account data.

Sep 14, 2024

BMO wins appeal in high-stakes Ponzi scheme case

The Canadian bank said it expects to recover hundreds of millions of dollars after a three-judge appeals panel found that it cannot be held liable in connection with a multibillion-dollar fraud. The ruling echoed a different appeals court's decision stemming from the collapse of Bernard Madoff's Ponzi scheme.

Sep 14, 2024

BNY acquires Archer, Old National drops 'interim' tag from its CFO

BNY has acquired managed-account software company Archer; Old National Bancorp has removed the "interim" tag from Chief Financial Officer John Moran; Royal Bank of Canada has done the same for Chief Financial Officer Katherine Gibson; and more in this week's banking news roundup.

Sep 14, 2024

Bank stocks stall amid new threat to profitability

Anticipated interest rate cuts could help stressed borrowers, but such a shift in monetary policy may curb lending income.

Sep 14, 2024