Historical Trans Men

1. Dr. James Barry, 1789-1865, military surgeon

2. "One-Eyed" Charley Parkhurst, 1812-1879, stagecoach driver

3. Ralph Kerwineo, 1876-1932, clerk

4. Harry Allen, 1882-1922, vagrant and criminal

5. Amelio Robles Ávila, 1889-1984, military commander during the Mexican Revolution

6. Victor Barker, 1895-1960, restaurant proprietor

7. Zdeněk Koubek, 1913-1986, track athlete

8. Billy Tipton, 1914-1989, jazz musician

画像

9. Willmer "Little Ax" M. Broadnax, 1916-1992, jazz musician

画像

10. Jim McHarris, 1924-?, auto mechanic

プロフィール画像

My parents: “One day you and your little internet trends will fade, and you’ll become much more conservative!” Like no sorry I have the capacity for basic kindness

プロフィール画像

!!!! I read a book about One-Eyed Charlie once and it starts as this girl attending an orphanage and it seems like it is a normal horse girl book about this person loving horses but then it turns into a wild story about One-Eyed Charlie heading West

プロフィール画像

https://books.google.com/books/content/images/frontcover/afo9AAAAQBAJ?fife=w200-h300 Idk how TERF-y it was, this was like 2005 when I read it as a kid

プロフィール画像

Other names of note are Alan L. Hart (who helped with tuberculosis research) and Michael Dillon (who underwent the first recorded phalloplasty).

プロフィール画像

@voldemortymort I think you mean these men* because most of them did identify that way. It's true that language has changed, but a Harry Potter blog coming to say "these people aren't trans" on a post about trans history sets my teeth on edge. If you don't care enough about current trans people to change your blog theme, then don't comment on trans posts. Many of them didn't use any specific terms we know of because they just lived as men and were outed at deaths.

プロフィール画像

@theorangedead hi! This is my literal field of study. I know what I’m talking about. I’m not saying it’s necessarily “bad” to call these people trans, I’m just saying the language didn’t exist yet. Within queer academics it’s controversial to refer to them as “trans.” That’s it. I don’t have any real beef with this post. Trans people (men, women, genderqueer) are real people who exist and queer people in history are important to know/study about.

プロフィール画像

@king-al Hey! I'm an academic queer theorist too. You know there's a lot of academic discourse over that concept, right? I understand what you mean: the term transgender didn't exist at the time. As well, gender is a socially mediated construct. But, that's exactly the issue. These people were afab, and they not only lived as men, but personally identified themselves as such. It would be reductionist to say that they were not self-identified men, who opposed 1/1

プロフィール画像

@king-al 2/2 their assigned genders at birth. As such, it is not fallacious to assume that these men fit into the modern transgender male mold. I understand your fears of applying modern terms to those who did not use them. However, in this case, who is your argument serving? It isn't adding to the transgender discourse, so much as halting it. I don't wish to be rude, as I sympathize with your take here. I'm just opening up some academic discussion.

プロフィール画像

@xanderwithanx never said they shouldn’t/didn’t identify/exist as men in their society. Sorry if that’s how you interpreted my words. Just said they shouldn’t be identified as transgender bc that language did not exist for them. And identifying them as such erases history and part of their identity. Simple as that. I’m not trying to make any real argument here on a tumblr post, nor am I looking to write an essay about it, I just made a comment.

プロフィール画像

@xanderwithanx but if you’re interested to learn more about my thoughts on born this way/we have always been, which tie into this topic, I’ll link to a post I made about it. I’m on mobile, so idk if it’ll link to it correctly, but whatever. You can just search my page if you are interested. If not, it’s whatever. https://king-al.tumblr.com/post/643535597952221184/sentences-like-born-this-waywe-have-always-been

プロフィール画像

@king-al I'm also sorry for misinterpreting! Thanks. :)

プロフィール画像

they are all so handsome hello men.....

プロフィール画像

newspaper articles on harry allen from the time are hilarious. they do misgender him, but he was such a fiesty, woman-wooing bastard.

プロフィール画像

@aresdavros if I remember correctly it’s because his brother who also sung, was known as Big Ax! Where he got his name from I can’t tell you

プロフィール画像

Hello... my fellow historic handsome man

プロフィール画像

No picture rn because I’m not on my laptop but of course my role model, Dr Alan L Hart! :)

プロフィール画像

I am curious if all of these people transitioned because that is how they self identified or if any of them were solely going after male privilege. Bad ass either way, imo.

プロフィール画像

I'd love to see some proofs, sources etc. Especially because of possibilities of the then medicine.

プロフィール画像

@eirundevirot Just google their names. It's not hard.

プロフィール画像

The things I would do to dab up each and every one of these guys

Tumblrを利用している1億人以上のユーザーの一員になり、コミュニティを見つけ、友達を作りましょう。