HISD parents, staff describe district's return to school under TEA control: 'A real mess'

For the first time since the Texas Education Agency appointed new leadership to the largest district in Texas, students recently returned to classrooms for Houston ISD's first day of school. The Houston Chronicle asked the HISD community to share how things are going now that the district is under state control.

Some responded that they had a relatively normal return to school, and that they approved of and even welcomed the extensive reforms at campuses under the district's "New Education System." But a majority of the responses decried the takeover, namely the NES reforms and policies under the district's state-appointed superintendent, Mike Miles. Some staff and parents described their school environments as "depressing and scary," while some teachers said they are already considering leaving the district. Yet others said their expectations have been exceeded already, and that they feel teachers have elevated their efforts to improve the quality of education for students.

Superintendent Miles has said the changes are necessary to closing achievement gaps and raising student proficiency.

“We can have good instruction, because that's what we need, and have some level of rigor, even the first week, because we're behind, and kids can have fun,” Miles previously told the Houston Chronicle Editorial Board.

“We have to shift our concept of fun a little bit to say, it also includes when kids are learning, because when kids are learning and they get it, they're happy.”

Editor's note: Some responses have been edited for clarity.

Filter responses:

Teacher/Staff

I have never felt so anxious and unsure of what I was doing in my 10 years of teaching. Even at a Non-NES school, I am constantly policed, surveilled, and micromanaged. I am not trusted to make decisions that are in the best interest of children.

Teacher/Staff

They did not pay a bunch of employees correctly again and no one has the answers to when they will pay us correctly. It’s a mess.

Teacher/Staff

There is a lot of frustration, and many feel like there is a new toxic culture coming from the top.

Parent

Superintendent Miles has to go. The students are overwhelmed, crying, and complaining as the teachers were giving tests on the first day and enormous loads of nightly homework. Superintendent Miles has to go. My child loved school before - this is untenable.

Teacher/Staff

How many hard, concentrated, audaciously degrading slaps from a tyrant like Mike Miles must public educator and HISD employees endure before we start to do walkouts, strike, and occupy Capitol buildings like we did in 2018?

Parent

My kids go to Heights area schools. Miles seems to understand that treating kids like prisoners might not go over well for him in affluent areas. Our schools are resisting, holding on to positive elements from before, but how long will this last? I’m more fearful everyday, and so are my kids.

Teacher/Staff

This pace isn’t sustainable even short term.

Teacher/Staff

The kids are the reason I am going to get up and go back to work tomorrow. I do not even work at an NES school, but the culture of anxiety and fear on our campus today to play the game created by “leadership” in this district is not okay.

Teacher/Staff

I am drained. Completely. At the end of the school day, I could have just fallen asleep in a chair at any desk in my room if that was allowed. I am stressed beyond… well… everything. I am already burned out. This was Day One.

Parent

It feels like we are being pushed out of the public school option by treating students, parents, and teachers poorly.

Teacher/Staff

This will definitely be my last year in HISD. There was so much pressure to be teaching to this new standard that I didn’t even get a chance to really get to know my kids. We were told content must taught the first day (meaning we had to begin teaching reading, math, science, etc. on day 1). This will definitely be my last year in HISD. I feel like I’m working under a dictatorship.

Teacher/Staff

I’m spending my lessons trying to find the information I’ve been teaching for 5 years in these train wrecks of a lesson. Although I am a person who appreciates clear accountability and guidance in a job, It’s a real mess.

Teacher/Staff

You can feel the pressure coming from the top.

Teacher/Staff

Everyday they gave us something new that we had to implement. On top of it the doors were kept open I felt very unsafe wondering if I could protect my students. Being observed on the first day was over the top. One of the teachers quit and another had a breakdown.

Parent

Two kids two schools - they were happy. Nice teachers, interesting reviews of coursework. Orderly day. Same as before.

Parent

My daughter did not enjoy her day. She’s a sophomore. She said the vibe on campus was just different overall. From the teachers to the students. Her exact words were, “I can tell the new sup left his mark, and I do not like it.” They had assignments, which she said she didn’t mind, but the teachers did not really try to get to know them.

Parent

I would say that the first week, as far as first weeks have gone in the past, was depressing and scary for the future of elementary education in Houston.

Teacher/Staff

COVID was a walk in the park compared to this. My admin are incredibly stressed out and that is a huge indicator how micromanaged they are experiencing from their superiors. THIS IS NOT SUSTAINABLE. Not at all. What we went through with COVID was a walk in the park compared to this.

Parent

The current model at my kids' school doesn't allow for them to discover things through interesting lessons on stuff they care about. It's just drill and kill.

Parent

Not only will grades and performance suffer, but the students’ emotional state will suffer.

Parent

Great. My sons were thrilled to be back at school and their teachers exceeded all expectations. As expected, all of their teachers complained about the takeover but just sounds like a normal job to the rest of us.

Advertisement

Read more

Credits

Editing

Jennifer Radcliffe • jennifer.radcliffe@houstonchronicle.com

Production

Brady Stone • brady.stone@houstonchronicle.com

The sign in service is not functioning right now.

Please try again in a few minutes

If the issues continue, please contact our customer service at

Phone:

Email:

Please log in to view your profile.

You must be signed in to comment