The Theme Of Guilt In Robertson Davies's Fifth Business

Superior Essays
Guilt is “an unpleasant feeling of remorse or sadness regarding a past action” (GoodTherapy). Guilt that occurs because of a wrongdoing can lead one to experience greater sympathy for others, and take responsibility for their actions. In Robertson Davies’s Fifth Business, the guilt of Dunstan, Percy, and Paul begins with an incident in which a snowball thrown by Percy misses Dunstan and instead hits a pregnant Mrs. Dempster. As a result of this, Mrs. Dempster gives premature birth to her baby, Paul, and goes insane. This guilt plays a major role in their lives. Firstly, guilt shapes the course of Dunstan’s life, as he devotes his whole life caring for Mrs. Dempster, has troubles forming relationships with others, and becomes Fifth Business. …show more content…
Firstly, he devotes his whole life caring for Mrs. Dempster. Dunstan’s guilt stems from the snowball incident, “I was contrite and guilty, for I knew that the snowball had been meant for me, but Dempster’s did not seem to think of that” (Davies 3). When Dunstan approached Percy about the situation, Percy rejects it, and Dunstan is left, “alone with [his] guilt” (Davies 15). Dunstan’s guilt grows further as he keeps believing that he inadvertently caused Mrs. Dempster to go insane. This forces Dunstan to look after Mrs. Dempster. He would, “chop and pile wood, sweep away snow, cut the grass, weed the vegetable path […] keep an eye on the baby” (Davies 19). For Dunstan, taking care of Mrs. Dempster was no longer a moral obligation, but rather a sense of commitment. He commits himself to her again when he returns from war. When Mrs. Dempster’s caretaker, Miss. Shanklin, dies Dunstan assumes control of Mrs. Dempster’s guardianship. He feels happy after her death as he states, “I experienced a remarkable rising of my spirits, which I can only attribute to the relief of guilt” (Davies 148). Dunstan is happy to be the guardian of Mrs. Dempster as he feels it is another way to atone for his wrongdoings in his childhood. He believes that his leg was not a, “full and fair payment for an evil action” (Davies 148). So the only way to fully make amends for his sins was to take control of Mrs. Dempster’s care. Secondly, he has troubles forming …show more content…
Firstly, guilt is the reason Boy became such a successful person. In his childhood, Boy tried to repress his guilt about the snowball incident. Even when Dunstan confronted him about the premature birth of Paul, and Mrs. Dempster’s simple-mindedness, he completely ignored the situation stating, “I threw a snowball at you, and I guess it gave you a good smack” (Davies 14). This contributed to his growing shadow. When Boy goes to war, he changes his name, “Percy, somewhere in his Army experience, had thrown aside that name and had lopped the “d” off the name that remained. He was now Boy Staunton” (Davies 99). As Dunstan explains, “he was the quintessence of the Jazz Age, a Scott Fitzgerald character. It was the characteristic of Boy throughout his life that he was the quintessence of something that somebody else had recognized and defined” (103). Boy’s new identity had allowed him escape from his life in Deptford, and start a new one. He used his denial of guilt as a means to become “a very rich man-richer than his father by far” (Davies 101). His success also allowed him to forget about the snowball incident, and further grew his shadow. Secondly, his guilt led to the death of his first wife, Leola. When Boy returned from war, he married Leola. He wants Leola to be “the perfect wife for a rising young entrepreneur in sugar” (Davies 114). However she could never live up to Boy’s expectations, “She was trying hard, but she

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    He feels so much shame that he no longer has the capacity to forgive himself for his mistakes. Shame also stems from his fear of damaging his good, just, moral name. As I mentioned early, his shame leads to his death. However, it does not lead to his death in the way one would assume. John is so familiar with this feeling of shame that he will not doom himself to that again.…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Touching Spirit Bear Essay

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages

    I got mad at you ‘cause I was really mad at myself. I thought my dad beat me because I was worthless.”” Cole paused. ““ The dances, carving the totem, carrying the ancestor rock, touching the spirit bear, it was all the same thing-- it was finding out who I really was.” “““That person is you, Stanley. You're the reason you are here. You're responsible for yourself.…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dunstan Ramsay and Percy “Boy” Staunton have a disjointed relationship throughout the novel Fifth Business. Boy is Dunstan’s oldest friend, however, Dunstan never forgot an incident in which Boy meant to hit a stone covered in snow at Dunstan. It changed Dunstan’s life negatively, as he carried guilt for the damage done to the life of the person that the stone hit. Mary Dempster gave birth prematurely, and as a result the child, Paul Dempster, was born with deformities. While, Dunstan sees Boy as a terrible person with only a few redeeming qualities, there are three similarities between both individuals that prove they have more in common than these friends/enemies may want to admit.…

    • 1792 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hester Prynne’s sin was revealed, Rev. Arthur Dimmesdale’s sin was concealed, and Roger Chillingworth’s sin was purposeful, and each person’s sin impacted their lives in a different way. The different sins affects each character differently depending on how the character chose to face their sin. Revealed sin, committed by Hester Prynne, could be hard at first to face was the best to face because the guilt did not eat away at them. Concealed sin, committed by Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale, was not the best way to face sinning, because the guilt destroyed his self and his self conscious over powered him.…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dexter marries Irene and settles—this settling is not bad because he finally gave up on a delusional winter dream. That dream was the pursuit of a woman, who was spoiled so rotten that even in her youth, would abuse her nurse, which turned into the hearts of men. Dexter always questions if he made the right decision by marrying Irene, who is less passionate than Judy. They…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jay Gatsby, the main character in The Great Gatsby, was born to a poor farm family but always desired to be rich. He met Daisy and entered into a relationship with her by an accident solely because he was wearing an officers uniform, which usually means that the wearer is from a rich family. He goes off to war and when he comes back Daisy is married to a rich Yale graduate named Tom. Throughout the novel, he unsuccessfully tries to turn back time and relive his relationship with Daisy. Daisy represents Gatsby’s dream because she symbolizes a life full of wealth, however he is never able to achieve it because five years have passed and for him the American dream is just an unobtainable illusion.…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The irony is that he chooses a life of immoral and illegal behavior to get a woman, who in the end, he never gets. In fact, he loses everything, including his life. Gatsby has people all around him, going to his parties, yet no one truly knows him. Born a poor man and son of a farmer, James Gatz desires living the "American dream". Because of this dream, he creates a false identity, Jay Gatsby, "he invented just the sort of Jay Gatsby that a seventeen year old boy would be likely to invent, and to this conception he was faithful to the end"(104).…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We know the importance of these promise because Lupin states: “Sorry I will never know him…but he will know why I died and I hope he will understand. I was trying to make a world in which he could live a happier life” (Deathly Hallows 700). Lupin tells this to Harry after his death – while they are walking in the forest – which shows that Lupin’s love for his son and desire to give him a better life was worth his early death and leaving Teddy…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Through Leon’s psyche, we get his disgust of the human “great big brain” (9), his love for his mother and guilt ridden mind about crimes he deems himself guilty of committing. “When I was too young to know any better, my father had made me his co-conspirator in driving my mother away forever (279). This powerful statement gives us a glance into the essence of how Leon Trout felt about his mother. Like Jimmy/snowman in Margaret Atwood’s Oryx and Crake, Leon Trout’s mother became a great influence as he got older. When Leon was sixteen, he ran away from home in search of his mother because he was ashamed that he and his father had driven his mother away.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Secret Closet Analysis

    • 1891 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The poor minister suffered from unbearable guilt and shame at having consciously committed a crime and worst, not publicly confessing his sins as Puritan law requires. A guilty conscious burdens him; relief can only be found in severe punishment. Dimmesdale feels this is necessary since his crime would have gone unpunished otherwise. He believes himself to be more despicable now that he has kept the public and his devoted followers in the dark about his own sins. Worse, he thinks himself a hypocrite for deceiving people into thinking he embodies goodness and purity.…

    • 1891 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays