Early History
of the Knights of Pythias
 
 
        This history
appears in Chapter XCI of "History of South 
        Dakota"
by Doane Robinson, Vol. I (1904), pages 526-533 and was 
        scanned,
OCRed and edited by Joy Fisher, jfisher@ucla.edu.
 
        This file may be freely copied by
individuals and non-profit 
        organizations
for their private use. 
 
        Any other
use, including publication, storage in a retrieval 
        system, or
transmission by electronic, mechanical, or other 
        means
requires the written approval of the file's author.
 
        This file is
part of the SDGENWEB Archives. If you arrived here inside
        a frame or
from a link from somewhere else, our front door is at
 
       
http://www.rootsweb.com/~usgenweb/sd/sdfiles.htm
 
 
CHAPTER XCI
 
PYTHIANISM IN SOUTH DAKOTA.
 
BY CHARLES N. HERREID, P. G. C.
 
        The order of
Knights of Pythias was organized in Washington, D. C., on the 
19th day of February, 1864, by some eight or ten gentlemen
who met by previous 
agreement. A ritual, previously prepared, largely by J. H.
Rathbone, who is 
recognized as the founder of the order, was reported and
adopted and Mr. 
Rathbone was duly elected worthy chancellor, the first
chancellor of the order 
in the world.
 
        More than twenty centuries ago, in ancient
Syracuse, were enacted the 
thrilling historical incidents which form the basis of the
magnificent and 
impressive ritualistic ceremonies which once seen can never
be forgotten.  The 
sublime exemplification of true friendship on the plains of
Sicily by Damon and 
Pythias,-two illustrious disciples of Pythagoras,-is the
cornerstone of the 
splendid and colossal temple of Pythianism. The lofty
principles, tenets and 
usages of this great organization tend to make men better,
more friendly, 
charitable, benevolent and patriotic and promote the highest
and best interest 
of mankind.
 
        "While
the operations of the Pythian pioneers in the territory of Dakota," 
says William D. Kennedy, the distinguished Pythian and
historian of the order, 
"extended to both the northern and southern portions,
yet the initial sod was 
turned in what is now South Dakota. First official mention
is made by Supreme 
Chancellor Davis in 1875, when he intimates that members of
the order that had 
strayed into that then comparatively unknown country we re
pressing the 
appointment of a deputy, and that he had made none, but,
Diogenes-like, awaiting 
the finding, as he says, 'of some worthy member' whom he
could appoint."  In 
1876 Jervis W. Carter, of Nebraska Lodge, No. 1, of Omaha,
was appointed deputy 
supreme chancellor for Dakota. Under date of July 14, 1876,
Mr. Carter reported, 
writing from Canton, Dakota territory, that he instituted a
lodge at Yankton 
"about February 20, 1876, with sixteen
members."  It appears several of
the 
members migrated to the Black Hills, weakening the lodge,
and a second meeting 
of this lodge was never held.  All efforts to revive this lodge having proved 
futile, the remnants of the lodge properties were secured by
Arthur C. Phillips, 
grand keeper of records and seal, and on October 30, 1889,
he instituted Phoenix 
Lodge, No.34, turning over to it the relics of the first
Pythian lodge in Dakota 
territory.
 
        Yankton's
loss appears to have been Deadwood's gain. 
On April 13 1879, 
the second lodge of the Order of Knights of Pythias in
Dakota territory was 
instituted in Deadwood by L. B. Schoenfield and named Marco
Bozzaris, No.3, with 
a membership of sixty. On September 26, 1879, the lodge
room, with all records 
and property, was destroyed by fire, but meetings were
resumed on November 24, 
1879.  A member of
this lodge, writing to W. D. Kennedy, under date of November 
5, 1897, thus describes these pioneer days:  "The deputy lived many hundred 
miles away and we were a hundred miles from the
railroad.  For several years the 
only way we received the password was by getting it while I
was in the east on 
business." Commenting on this situation, Brother
Kennedy says : "Such was its 
isolation-but it fought the good fight and is one of the
best in the domain."
 
        During
the  following years  seven 
other lodges were instituted in that 
portion of the territory which now constitutes the grand
domain of South Dakota, 
before the organization of the grand lodge of Dakota
territory, to-wit:
 
        General
Custer Lodge, No. 4, Central City, instituted by Deputy Supreme 
Chancellor A. S. Stewart, of Deadwood, July 2, 1880, with
fourteen members.  
This lodge had the misfortune to lose all its records by
fire on April 25, 1888.
 
        Dakota Lodge,
No. 6, of Lead, instituted October 22, 1880, by Deputy 
Supreme Chancellor Stewart, of  Deadwood,  with  nineteen members.
 
        Gate City Lodge, No. 8, of Rapid City,
was instituted by Hon. John R. 
Brennan, deputy supreme chancellor, on January 10, 1883,
with thirteen members.
 
        On December
4, 1883. Ivanhoe Lodge. No. 9, of Huron, was also instituted 
by Deputy Supreme Chancellor Brennan, with twenty- four
members.  This lodge 
was, on April 14, 1886, declared defunct, and the name
Ivanhoe given to Lodge 
No.41, at Dell Rapids.
 
        Castle Lodge.
No. 10, of Chamberlain, was instituted December 28, 1883.  
This lodge also became defunct, but in January, 1886, a new
lodge was instituted 
by Deputy Supreme Chancellor A. H. Daniels, who reported as
follows: "It was 
really a new lodge, as I declared the lodge defunct, and
proceeded to institute 
the new one."
 
        Damascus
Lodge. No. 11, of Mitchell, was instituted March 31, 1884, by 
Deputy Supreme Chancellor A. H. Daniels, with twelve
members.
 
        Dauntless
Lodge, No. 13, of Brookings, was instituted February 6, 1885, 
but on record of its membership is available.  The only relic among the archives 
is an old ledger, and on the fly-leaf, in the handwriting of
Arthur C. Phillips, 
then grand keeper of records and seal, is the following
legend:  "This lodge was 
declared defunct by Grand Chancellor J. F. Edmonds, on July
26, 1889."  On May 
22, 1894, an effort was made to organize as a successor to
Dauntless Lodge. 
Peerless Lodge, No. 61, but, like its predecessor, it soon
became defunct, and 
was so declared on December 24, 1900.
 
        These were
the lodges.-nine in number,-together with four lodges existing 
in that portion of Dakota territory which now constitutes
the state of North 
Dakota, which through their representatives, in the city of
Huron, on April 30, 
1885, met and organized the grand lodge Order of Knights of
Pythias for the 
domain of Dakota territory. 
While Dakota was under the direct supervision of 
the supreme lodge the deputy supreme chancellors in charge
of that territory 
were as follows, in the order named Jervis W. Carter, a past
grand chancellor 
from Nebraska Lodge, No. 1, of Omaha;  D. 
J. Tallant, a member of Grand Forks 
Lodge, No. 2  John R.
Brenman, who by historian W. D. Kennedy is described as 
follows :  "John
R. Brenman, who came from Colorado, was a faithful, earnest and 
efficient officer. 
To him was due the salvation of the order in Dakota at that 
time." Continuing, Mr. Kennedy says : "Brother
John Westdahl, of Huron, was the 
last deputy, and he also did good service.
 
        The
convention was called to order in Castle Hall of Ivanhoe Lodge in 
Huron, at three o'clock P. M., by Deputy Supreme Chancellor
John Westdahl, who 
introduced Hon. John Van Valkenberg, of Iowa, supreme
chancellor of the world, 
to preside. 
(Souvenir History of the Knights of Pythias, by Arthur C. Phillips, 
grand keeper of records and seal.)  The organization was completed by the 
appointment of the following officers of the Lodge of
Emergency:  J. E. Elson,  
past  supreme chancellor;  John 
Van Valkenberg,  supreme
chancellor; John 
Westdahl, supreme vice-chancellor ; W. T. Collins, supreme
prelate; C. B. 
Ambrose, supreme master of exchequer; D. H. Metcalf, supreme
keeper of records 
and seal; J. W. McDonald, supreme master-at-arms; R.
Sturgeon, supreme inner 
guard; R. W. Cutts, supreme outer guard.
 
        The committee
on credentials reported the following representatives 
entitled to seats in the grand lodge: 
 
Grand Forks Lodge, No.2, W. T. Collins, R. W. Cutts; 
Marco Bozzaris, No. 3, J. F. Edmonds, L. Council ; 
General Custer, No. 4, J. W. McDonald, C. H. Kamman; 
Dakota, No.6, P. Cohen, L. May (by proxy) ; 
Gate City, No.8, J. S. Gantz, W. T. Coad; 
Ivanhoe, No. 9, George J. Love, A. W. Wilmarth; 
Castle, No. 10, K. Sturgeon, A. Ingliss; 
Damascus, No. 11, A. H. Daniels, C. W. Emerson; 
Myrtle, No. 12, A. G. Clark, J. W. Carroll; 
Dauntless, No. 13, H. P. Finigan, George W. Hopp; 
St. Elmo, No. 15, W. L. Black.  
 
They also reported the past chancellor certificates of C. L.
Davis and George A. 
Mathews, of No. 13, as being correct.
 
        After
conferring the grand lodge rank, the following officers were elected 
and duly installed : 
Past grand chancellor, Russell W. Cutts, of Grand Forks; 
grand chancellor, George J. Love, Huron; grand
vice-chancellor, J. F. Fdmonds, 
of Deadwood; grand prelate, W. T. Collins, of Grand Forks;
grand master of 
exchequer, A. H. Daniels, of Mitchell ; grand keeper records
and seal, C. L. 
Davis, of Brookings; grand master-at-arms, W. Laird Black,
of Bismarck ; grand 
inside guard, R. Sturgeon, of Chamberlain ; grand outside
guard, J. S. Gantz, of 
Rapid City; supreme representatives, John Westdahl, of
Huron; Albert G. Clark, 
of Steele.
 
        Constitutions
for the grand and subordinate lodges were adopted at this 
meeting.  The secret
work of the order was exemplified by the supreme 
chancellor, after which the first grand lodge, Knights of
Pythias, of Dakota 
territory, duly adjourned.
 
        The second
grand lodge convened June 15, 1886, in Rapid City.  Six new 
lodges had been instituted during the year, viz : Kimball,
No. 14, at Kimball 
(charter surrendered February 10, 1892); Tristocotyn, No.
17, Watertown; 
Granite, No. 18, Sioux Falls; Wahpeton, No. 20, Wahpeton;
Fidelity, No. 21, 
Woonsocket; Calanthe, No. 22, Miller.  During the year the lodges at Casselton, 
Fargo and Huron became defunct. The following officers were
elected for the 
ensuing year: Grand chancellor, Lawrence Connell, Deadwood;
grand vice-
chancellor, A. H. Daniels, Mitchell; grand prelate, Frank E.
Ketchum, Huron; 
grand keeper of records and seal. C. L. Davis, Brookings;
grand master of 
exchequer, Jay Wellman, Chamberlain; grand master-at-arms,
W. R. Arnold, 
Watertown; grand inner guard, J. A. Ebel, Wahpeton; grand
outer guard, J. S. 
Gantz, Rapid City.
 
        The third
meeting of the grand lodge was held in Watertown, commencing 
Juhe 21, 1887. The grand chancellor reported continuing
interest and activity 
within the order and four new lodges: Ivy, No. 23, Redfield;
Cyprus, No. 24, 
Alexandria; Armour, No. 
25, Armour; and Malta, No. 26, Faulkton.  The officers 
elected at this session were:  Grand chancellor, H. E. Gates, Kimball; grand 
vice-chancellor, W. R. Arnold, Watertown; grand prelate, E.
W. Murray, Redfield; 
grand keeper records and seal, J. B. Wineman, Grand Forks;
grand master of 
exchequer, Arthur C. Phillips, Sioux Falls; grand
master-at-arms, W. S. Arnold, 
Alexandria : grand inner guard, J. P. Cutting, Miller grand
outer guard, J. H. 
Bottum, Faulkton.
 
        The fourth
grand lodge, being an adjourned meeting, was held at Wahpeton 
(now North Dakota), August 21, 1888.  During the year Damon Lodge, No. 5, at 
Fargo, had been reorganized and two new lodges instituted,
Gettysburg, No. 27, 
at Gettysburg, and Harmony, No. 28, at Plankinton. The
election of officers 
resulted as follows: 
Grand chancellor, W. R. Arnold, 
Watertown;  grand  vice-
chancellor, George D. Swaine, Wahpeton; grand prelate, R. D.
Martin, Mitchell; 
grand keeper of records and seal, Arthur C. Phillips, Sioux
Falls; grand master 
of exchequer, Frank H. Bean, Huron; grand master-at-arms, M.
P. Springer, 
Faulkton; grand inner guard, George A. Knight, Grand Forks;
grand outer guard, 
D. O. Root, Woonsocket.
 
        The fifth
convention of the grand lodge was held in Sioux Falls July 16, 
1889.  The grand
chancellor reported having instituted two lodges, viz: Crystal, 
No. 29, at Valley Springs, March 27, 1889, and Minot, No.30,
at Minot (N. D.), 
June 7, 1889.  With
approaching statehood for South and North Dakota, 
preliminary steps were taken towards the organization of
separate grand lodges 
for the new states. 
The grand officers elected and installed were: Grand 
chancellor, J. F. Edmonds, Deadwood; grand vice-chancellor,
F. R. Bangs, Grand 
Forks; grand prelate, Alexander Jacobson, Huron; grand
keeper of records and 
seal, Arthur C. Phillips, Sioux Falls; grand master of
exchequer, F. H. Bean, 
Huron ; grand master-at-arms, D. O. Root, Woonsocket; grand
inner guard, W. E. 
Tipton, Armour grand outer guard, W. J. Hall, Alexandria.
 
        The sixth and
last convention of the grand lodge of Dakota was held in 
Mitchell June 17, 1890. 
Grand  Chancellor Edmonds  reported an era of unusual 
activity during the past year, having traveled over seven
thousand miles on 
Pythian work," having personally "conferred over
five hundred ranks."  In this 
work he was ably supported by Grand Keeper Records and Seal
A. C. Phillips.  
Eleven new lodges had been instituted during the year, being
"about seventy per 
cent." increase in the membership of the order.
 
        In this brief
account it is neither necessary nor proper to dwell upon the 
controversy relating to the legality of the dissolution of
the grand lodge of 
Dakota and the formation of the two new grand lodges.  On June 18th, "after a 
progressive career of five years, one month and twelve days,
the grand lodge of 
Dakota was formally declared dissolved by the grand
chancellor."
 
        At 4 :30
o'clock P. M., on June 18, 1890, "in accordance with the 
directions and by the authority of the supreme chancellor,
Knights of Pythias of 
the World," a provisional supreme lodge was called to
order by A. C. Phillips, 
past grand keeper records and seal, and Past Grand
Chancellor John R. Brenman 
was requested to preside. The following lodges in South
Dakota were represented 
by past chancellors: 
 
Marco Fozzaris, No.3, Deadwood; 
General Custer; No. 4, Central City; 
Dakota, No.6, Lead City; 
Gate City, No.8, Rapid City; 
Castle, No. 10, Chamberlain ; 
Damascus, No. 11, Mitchell ; 
Syracuse, No. 16, Huron; 
Trishocotyn, No. 17, Watertown; 
Granite, No. 18, Sioux Falls ; 
Fidelity, No. 21, Woonsocket; 
Calanthe, No. 22, Miller;, 
Armour, No. 25, Armour; 
Harmony, No. 28, Plankinton; 
Crystal, No. 29, Valley Springs; 
Minnekahta, No. 32, Hot Springs; 
Vermillion, No. 33, Vermillion; 
Phoenix, No. 34, Yankton; 
Mystic, No.40, Madison; 
Ivanhoe, No.41, Dell Rapids; 
Hesperian, No. 42, Elk Point.
 
        On June i9th
the following officers, having been duly elected, were 
installed by acting Supreme Chancellor Brenman : Grand past
chancellor, W. C. 
Graybill ; grand chancellor, Arthur C. Phillips ; grand vice-chancellor,
Frank 
Abt; grand prelate, C. A. Maxon ; grand keeper of records
and seal, W. E. 
Tipton; grand master of exchequer, F. H. West ; grand
master-arms, A. D. Keller; 
grand inner guard, W. H. Munroe ; grand outer guard, George
A. Silsby; supreme 
representatives, John R. Brenman and B. R. Howell; grand
trustees, C. M. Runkle, 
Julian Bennett and D. O. Root.  Whereupon the grand lodge of South Dakota was 
declared legally instituted.  According to the official reports for the term 
ending December 31, 1889, the membership of the order was :
South Dakota, 783; 
North Dakota, 213; total, 996.
 
        The second
annual convention was held at Madison, commencing June 2, 1891.  
During the year a vast amount of work for the good of the
order had been 
performed by the grand chancellor.  Two new lodges were instituted: Myrtle 
Lodge, No.43, at Clark, with a charter list of twenty, and
Tin Center, No. 44, 
with twenty charter members.  The Uniform Rank of the order was reported in a 
flourishing condition. 
During the preceding thirteen months, six divisions were 
organized, while preliminary steps were taken for many
others.  The number of 
lodges in good standing at this time was thirty-one. The
following officers were 
installed for the ensuing term: Grand chancellor, W. E.
Tipton; grand vice-
chancellor, A. D. Kellar; grand prelate, C. A. Maxon; grand
keeper of records 
and seal, U. S. G. Cherry; grand master of exchequer, J. A.
Trow; grand master-
at-arms, W. H. Timerhoff; grand inner guard, J. C. Calder;
grand outer guard, A. 
E. Witting.
 
        The
third  annual convention  opened 
in Pierre June 7, 1892, at the 
capitol building, in the hall of representatives. Like his
predecessor, Grand 
Chancellor Tipton had been called upon to render a large number
of decisions on 
points raised under the new constitution.  The order was fortunate in having 
during the early days of its existence, in the most
prominent positions, men who 
were so pre-eminently qualified to discharge their duties
with enthusiasm, 
fidelity and great ability. 
During the year lodges had been established as 
follows : Danion, No. 45, Bryant; Apollo, No. 46,
Springfield; Tyndall, No. 47, 
Tyndall; Security. No. 48, Scotland; Triangle, No.  49, 
Howard;  Monte  
Christo,  No. 50,
Beresford; Malta, No. 26, Faulkton; Ivy, No. 23, Redfield, - 
the last two named being reorganization of lodges that had
practically become 
defunct. For the ensuing year the following officers were
elected and installed:  
Grand chancellor, U. S. G. Cherry; grand vice-chancellor, W.
H. Timmerhoff; 
grand prelate, J. C. Calder; grand master of the exchequer,
J. A. Trow; grand 
keeper of records and seal, A. E. Witting  grand master-at-arms, D. P. Cree; 
grand inner guard, J. W. McDonald; grand outer guard, C. E.
Warner.
 
        The fourth
aunual convention was held in Chamberlain June 6, 1893.  Grand 
Chancellor Cherry reported the following additions to the
roster during the 
year: Fanner, No. 51 ; Canton, No. 52: Menno, No. 53;
Centerville, No. 54; 
Aberdeen, No. 55; 
Gettysburg,  No. 27  reinstated; Columbia, No. 56; Monitor, 
No. 57; Fureka, No. 58. 
Never had the grand lodge of this state, or its 
predecessor, the grand lodge of Dakota, met under such
favorable financial 
conditions.  The
receipts of the past year were reported largely in excess of 
the receipts of any previous year in the history of the
order.  The total 
membership of the order, December 31, 1892, was 1,763, and a
gain of 411 during 
the year.  For
the  ensuing year the  following officers were elected and 
installed: Grand chancellor, A. E. Witting; grand
vice-chancellor, F. C. Walton; 
grand prelate, J. W. Riley; grand master of exchequer, J. A.
Trow; grand keeper 
of records and seal, J. C. Calder, grand master-at-arms, J.
W. McDonald; grand 
inner guard, F. E. Davol, grand outer guard, S. Winter.
 
        In the city
of Aberdeen, on June 21, 1894, the officers and 
representatives of the order convened for the fifth annual
session of the grand 
lodge. The postponement from June 5th, the day fixed by the
constitution, was 
for the purpose of enabling Supreme Chancellor Blackwell to
attend the grand 
lodge in this domain. 
Since the last meeting of the grand lodge the following 
lodges had been organized: Star Lodge, No. 59, Wakonda;
Pythias, No. 60, at 
Salem; Peerless, No. 6i, at Brookings (reorganized). For the
ensuing term the 
following officers were installed:  Grand chancellor, Charles T. Howard; grand 
vice-chancellor, William M. Lyon; grand prelate. Rev. Henry
Wilson; grand keeper 
of records and seal, C. E. Warner; grand master of
exchequer. J. A. Trow; grand 
master-at-arms, F. E. Davol; grand inner guard, F. L.
Jackson; grand outer 
guard, William S. Mitchell.
 
        The sixth
annual session convened in Chamberlain June 4, 1895.  The grand 
chancellor, among other things. reported as follows :  "At the commencement of 
my term the discouraging financial conditions of the state
were such that it 
seemed almost impossible to add to the roster of lodges in
this domain.  *  * 
*  
Much time and labor has been expended."  The grand keeper of records and seal 
says:  "The year
just closed has been a remarkable one. 
The general financial 
depression of the country, together with the almost total
failure of crops 
throughout our state, has been a clog upon the wheels of
Pythian enthusiasm that 
has much retarded the rapid pace we have been making for the
past few years." 
However, two new lodges bad been instituted, Hudson Lodge,
No. 62, at Hudson, 
and Edgemont, No. 63, at Edgemont. The condition of the
Endowment Rank of the 
domain was reported as follows :  Number of sections, 20; number of members, 
144; amount of endowment, $240,000, being an increase during
the year of 84 
members.  Shortly
after the close of the grand lodge session of 1894, Major 
General James R. Caruahan, of Indianapolis, Indiana, visited
the state and 
organized the First Regiment, Uniform Rank, Knights of
Pythias. The increase in 
membership was reported "very fair during the year, hut
we have lost heavily 
from suspensions from non-payment of dues. This is but
natural in a year like 
this."  The
following officers were installed: Grand chancellor, A. D. Keller; 
grand vice-chancellor, F. E. Davol: grand prelate, J. Carl
Southwick; grand 
keeper of records and seal, C. E. Warner; grand master of
exchequer, J. E. 
Platt; grand master-at-arms, William Mitchell  grand inner guard, E. H. 
Benedict; grand outer guard, G. B. Enos.
 
        The seventh annual
session was held in Yankton, commencing June 3, 1896.  
During the year Cotean Lodge, No. 64, at Wilmot, was
instituted.  Speaking of 
the prevailing conditions throughout the country, the grand
chancellor said :  
"The state of the order in this domain is as good as it
could possibly be 
expected. The past year has been one of the hardest years
financially that this 
county has ever experienced, or as it probably will ever
experience again.  It 
seemed that it was all many of us could do to keep soul and
body together, and 
that every dollar that could he secured in any manner was
necessary for our 
families.  *    * The order has at least held its
own.  That is to say, we have 
gained as many, if not more, in membership than we have
lost."  The report of 
the grand keeper of records and seal for the year ending
December 31, 1895, 
showed total number of members 1,898: loss during the year
95. During the year 
the following lodges surrendered their charters: Star,
No.59, at Wakonda; Menno, 
No. 53. at Menno; Apollo, No. 46. at Springfield; Tyndall,
No. 47, at Tyndall.  
For the ensuing year the following officers were elected and
installed by Past 
Grand Chancellor C. T. Howard: Grand chancellor, Charles N.
Herreid; grand vice-
chancellor, F. E. Davol; grand prelate, E. H. Benedict;
grand keeper of records 
and seal, C. E. Warner; grand master of exchequer, J. E.
Platt;  grand master-
at-arms, William  S.
Mitchell; grand inner guard, G. B. Enos; grand outer guard, 
Charles M. Caton.
 
        The eighth
annual session convened in Sioux Falls June 2, 1897.  The 
official record notes the fact that before the formal
opening of the grand lodge 
"prayer was offered by Rev. W. H. Jordan, pastor of the
First Methodist church 
of Sioux Falls,"-the first instance of the kind of
which a record had been made 
in the history of the order in this domain. The report of
the committee on 
credentials showed an unusually large attendance.  The grand chancellor, among 
other things. 
reported :  "In view of the
terrible financial depression the 
growth of the order in new membership during the year has
been remarkable.  
There are several places ripe for the institution of new
lodges.''  During the 
session the grand chancellor presented to Malta Lodge, No.
26, at Faulkton, a 
beautiful large silk banner in token of excellence
manifested by this lodge 
during his term.  The
new grand lodge officers were installed by Past Grand 
Chancellor Keller: Grand chancellor, F. E. Davol; grand
vice-chaucellor, E. H. 
Benedict; grand prelate, C. H. Cassill ; grand keeper of
records and seal, C. E. 
Warner; grand master of exchequer, J. E. Platt ; grand
master-at-arms, Charles 
M. Caton ; grand inner guard, G. B. Enos; grand outer guard,
F. S. Emerson.
 
        On the first
day of June, 1898, the ninth annual session convened in 
Watertown.  During
the year two new lodges had been organized: Webster, No. 65. 
at Webster, and Reservation, No.66, at Sisseton. The grand
keeper of records and 
seal reported : 
"We have sustained a net loss during the year of ninety 
members, but included in this loss is the membership of
Rathbone Lodge, No. 39, 
whose charter was suspended."  Past Grand Chancellor Herreid presented the 
following resolution : 
"Whereas, the Order of Knights of Pythias is of all 
orders the most thoroughly American ; it represents 'one
country, one language, 
one flag' ; its principles are most thoroughly in touch with
the spirit of our 
free institutions ; it is most appropriate that as an order
we should 
conspicuously honor the flag of our country.  Therefore, resolved, that every 
subordinate lodge in this grand domain is hereby directed to
display the 
American flag at every regular meeting of the
lodge."  The resolution was 
unanimously adopted. 
The following officers were installed by Past Supreme 
Representative W. E. Tipton:  Grand chancellor, F. S. Emerson; grand  vice-
chancellor,  E.  H. Benedict; grand prelate, C. M. Caton;
grand keeper of 
records and seal, C. E. Warner; grand master of exchequer,
J. E. Platt; grand 
master-at-arms, H. C. Burch; grand inner guard, G. B. Enos;
grand outer guard, 
H. F. Cutting.
 
        The tenth
annual session of the grand lodge was held at Sioux Falls, 
commencing June 7, 1899. 
The grand chancellor reported: "As a rule the lodges 
under your jurisdiction are in a healthy condition.  I have had correspondence 
in relation to organizing new lodges, but in each case, the
failure to organize 
could be attributed to hard times."  The grand chancellor reported the following 
new lodges: General Terry, No. 67, at Terry; Gold Center,
No.68, at Keystone; 
Spearfish Lodge, No. 69, at Spearfish, and that a warrant
had been issued for 
the institution of a lodge at Hazel.  During the year ending December 31, 1898. 
there was a net gain of 169 members.  During the year considerable interest had 
been manifested in the Uniform Rank.  The following officers were installed :  
Grand chancellor, J. E. Platt; grand vice-chancellor, C. M.
Caton; grand 
prelate,  H.  C. 
Burch; grand keeper of records and seal, J. Carl Southwick; 
grand master of exchequer, C. H. Cassill; grand
master-at-arms, J. A. Beck; 
grand inner guard, W. J. Markham; grand outer guard,  J. 
E. Patten.
 
        The eleventh
annual session was held in Huron, commencing June 6, 1900.  
The grand chancellor reported an increase to January 1,
1900, of about sixteen 
per cent.  Also the
following new lodges: De Morris Lodge, No. 71, Belle 
Fourche; White Rock, No. 72, at White Rock; Bowdle, No.73,
at Bowdle; Century, 
No. 74, at Vienna. 
"Their membership," says the grand chancellor, "is
composed 
of the best citizens of the towns in which they are
located," - a statement 
which applies to every lodge of the Order of Knights of
Pythias in this domain. 
During the year Cypress Lodge, No.  24, at Alexandria, experienced a revival.  
Edgemont, No. 63, voluntarily surrendered its charter. This
lodge, in 1898, lost 
all of its property by fire and it never revived from the
shock.  The followiug 
is a list of the officers for the ensuing year:  Grand chancellor, Charles M. 
Caton; grand vice-chancellor, H. C. Burch; grand prelate, J.
C. Kuney; grand 
keeper of records and seal, J. Carl Southwick; grand master
of exchequer, C. H. 
Cassill; grand master-at-arms, W. J. Markham; grand inner
guard. J. E. Patten; 
grand outer guard, C. C. Bras.
 
        The twelfth
annual session was held at Lead, commencing June 5, 1901.  The 
grand chancellor reported that he had found it necessarv
"to suspend the 
charters of six lodges who had not met for from three to
five years, viz: 
Fidelity, No. 21, Woonsocket; Calanthe, No.22, Miller;
Gettysburg, No.  27, 
Gettysburg; 
Security, No. 48,  Scotland;  Peerless, 
No. 61, Brookings and 
Edgemont, No. 63. Edgemont." The number of members in
good standing December 31, 
1900, was 2,305, being a net gain during the year 1900 of
eighty-five members. 
The following officers were installed for the next year
:  Grand chancellor, H. 
C. Burch; grand vice-chancellor, C. E. Warner; grand
prelate, W. J. Markham; 
grand keeper of records and seal, J. Carl. Southwick; grand
master of exchequer, 
C. H. Cassill; grand master-at-arms, W. H. Disney; grand
inner guard, George D. 
Adamson; grand outer guard, J. F. Barry.
 
        The
thirteenth convention of the grand lodge convened in Canton June 4, 
1902.  The grand
chancellor reported that while there had been "no gains in 
lodges and no great gains in membership, on the whole the
subordinate lodges had 
made a good healthy growth."  In strong contrast with the reports of the former 
officers, the grand keeper of records and seal, J. Carl
Southwick, in his report 
for this year. makes the following cheerful statement:  "It is a matter for 
congratulation that our members are enjoying material
prosperity to an almost 
unprecedented extent." 
The officers for the ensuing year are as follows:  Grand 
chancellor, C. H. Cassill; grand vice-chancellor, W. J.
Markham; grand prelate, 
W. H. Disney; grand keeper of records and seal, J. Carl
Southwick: grand master 
of exchequer, C. A. 
Fountain; grand master-at-arms, George D. Adamson ; grand 
inner guard, F. S. Randolph; grand outer guard. W. A.
Roberts.
 
        The
fourteenth and last annual convention of the grand lodge convencd in 
Yankton June 3. 1903. 
The grand chancellor reported the local lodges as a rule 
in flourishing condition and Pythianism is looking
upward.  The plan of holding 
district meetings has resulted in much good to the
order."  Two new lodges were 
added to thc order during the year, Charles Mix Lodge, No.
75, at Geddes, and 
Blunt, No. 76. at Blunt, while Damon Lodge, No. 45,
surrendered its charter.  In 
the Endowment Rank there were, on the 1st of April, 1903,
nineteen sections in 
this domain, with one hundred and one members, and insurance
in force, $158,000.  
For the ensuing year the following officers were duly
elected and installed:  
Grand chancellor, J. Carl Southwick; grand vice-chancellor,
Einer Johnson; grand 
prelate, W. H. Disney; grand keeper of records and seal, F.
S. Randolph; grand 
master of exchequer, C. A. Fountain; grand master-at-arms,
A. Ericson; grand 
inner guard, W. H. Schellinger; grand outer guard, J. J.
Urquhart.
 
        The following
statement from Major General James R. Carnahan shows the 
following condition in the Uniform  Rank in good standing in this domain:  
Diamond, No. 2, Lead City, Captain H. L. Howard; Deadwood,
No. 5, Deadwood, 
Captain C. L. Chiniquy ; General Custer, No. 6, Central
City, Captain Thomas 
O'Connor; Apollo, No. 13, Terry, Captain F. J. Robinson.
These compose the First 
Battalion, Second Regiment.
 
        The following
statement shows the number of lodges and their aggregate 
membership on December 31st of each year in the history of
the grand lodge of 
South Dakota:  1890,
30 lodges, 1,168 members; 1891, 31 lodges, 1,352 members; 
1892, 39 lodges, 1,762 members; 1893, 44 lodges, 2,020
members; 1894, 47 lodges, 
1,993 members: 1895, 49 lodges, 1,899 members; 1896, 45
lodges, 1,770 members; 
1897, 45 lodges, 1,751 members; 1898, 46 lodges, 1,920
members; 1899, 51 lodges, 
2,220 members; 1900, 47 lodges, 2,305 members: 1901, 45
lodges, 2,207 members; 
1902, 46 lodges, 2,209 members.
 
        This, in
brief, brings the story of Pythianism in this grand domain down 
to date.  The
fifteenth annual convention will be held in Mitchell, commencing 
June 1, 1904.  This
order contains among its membership a large number of the 
most active and influential men in the state.  In closing. I will quote the 
language which I used officially in communications to the
subordinate lodges and 
the grand lodge, while an officer of the order:
 
        The Order of
Knights of Pythias has a glorious history and a splendid 
literature.  I am
profoundly impressed with the idea that the principles of 
our order should become living realities in the daily life
of its membership.
 
The Order of Knights of Pythias is
the most distinctively American 
fraternal organization and as such entitled to our greatest
adoration.  We admit 
men upon the broad platform of good morals and right
living.  It aims to make 
every Knight a true man, a good citizen. It is one of the
great factors tending 
to the successful perpetuity of our glorious republic.  In noble deeds and 
practical work Pythianism is today helping to make a better
history for our 
nation, for the world, for humanity. As it seeks to instruct
the mind in regard 
to the solemn obligations of life, to develop the moral and
social virtues, it 
is one of the great human institutions of the age, one of
the grand forces 
arrayed against evil, seeking the present and future good of
the human race.  
'As long as there are tears to wipe away, sufferings to
alleviate, orphans to 
educate, widows to care for, and the weak to protect, our
noble order will 
exist, moving onward and upward in its high and holy
mission, with noiseless 
step. like the rush of an angel's wing.  Its foundations are laid in God's 
eternal truth and love.' "