Ah, the wardrobe malfunction. It seems like such a mainstay in modern pop culture that we can barely remember a time when it didn’t exist—and yet, prior to Janet Jackson’s 2004 Super Bowl performance alongside Justin Timberlake, the phrase didn’t even exist.
The incident, which ended up with Janet’s entire right breast being exposed to hundreds of millions of people, was scandalous at the time. But these days, with paparazzi as prevalent as they are the wardrobe malfunction is relatively common.
MORE: 8 Relatable Times Beyoncé Proved That She Was Totally Human
Ahead, check out 29 of the most NSFW celebrity wardrobe malfunctions in recent memory.
A version of this article was originally published in February 2017.