Next

• If I remind a post and make no comment, all engagement should carry over, and I should receive no rewards
• If I remind a post and make a comment, no engagement carries through and I get all rewards
• If I remind a remind that had no comment, it should still carry all engagement and you get no rewards
• If I remind a remind that had a comment and also make a comment, then it's a new post and I should get all rewards
• Remind to group option
• Monetize, Boost, Schedule, NSFW, Hashtag options
• Be able to remind comments (This will not happen. Comments are secondary entities that need parents).
• Updated design (more information needed).

@jotto141

changed the description

changed the description

Under no circumstances should a reminder receive more points than the OP.

This might be a dumb question...

How is a remind any different from a P2P boost with the exception of the OFFER?

@jotto141

added to epic &81

changed title from (feat): remind upgrades to Remind proposals

added Status::Validation scoped label

added Priority::2 - Normal Product::Newsfeed scoped labels

added Type::Refactor scoped label

changed the description

This is a major refactor that requires careful consideration, especially to older posts that could loose comments with this changes.

Issues

• Reminds older than the day this change is deployed will loose their comments. Merging is too complicated and not viable.
• Votes and metrics have been changing the base counter of the entities (https://gitlab.com/minds/engine/blob/master/Core/Votes/Counters.php#L118). This means that all reminds we are setting to not inherit counters post this change will be reduced immediately and this might cause concern for reminders with historic posts
• Reminds are separate entities in all scenarios, and the votes are denormalised on the entities for performance. It's going to take a significant effort and refactor of the way we treat entities and denormalisation to ensure that the I have voted on this like actions are synchronised.

changed time estimate to 1mo

I am not going to provide any comments about the first four bullet points for the moment (due to wanting to think about them further and being interested in other users opinions about these elements).

However, I am really happy about the possibility of having posts being reminded to groups (this is something that I have personally been wanting to see for a while now).

It's a pity that it won't be possible to remind content with existing comments remaining intact (but I do appreciate that this could be overly complicated to implement and maybe something to further work on over the course of 2020).

I want to clarify the monitisation and scheduling elements. Will it be possible to schedule the publication of reminded content and how will the monitisation element work within the context of reminding content (as an example, will it be possible for the content creator to have the ability to request a wire if a user decides to remind the creators content)?

If you guys are thinking to do something with the option of keeping comments on the remind:

You could call it a recursive reminds, and just have a check-box on the remind post window.

All people will do is leave a 'space' for a comment, and the OP will be robbed of their effort by receiving no reward.