Next

Summary

After completing several days worth of tests I have noticed that live chat activates (ie. voting and commenting within the live chat facility) are not being reflected within the users contribution score report (ie. minds.com/wallet/tokens/contributions) and am wondering if this is an oversight

As an example, within the notification page (minds.com/notifications), I have counted 19 votes being received so far today, however according to the contribution score report, I have only received 10 votes (from within comments that have been left on posts and votes for the actual posts and blog articles).

Steps to reproduce

Enter a comment and vote on another users comment within a live chat session. Wait for a short duration and then check the contribution score report

Platform information

Browser interface, end-user platform neutral.

What is the current bug behavior?

See above (live chat based comments and votes not being reflected within contribution score).

What is the expected correct behavior?

I am presuming that all user activities should be reflected within the contribution score.

Relevant logs and/or screenshots

Note the number of votes and especially the number of "xxx voted up your message in yyy conversation" based notifications within the following screenshots.

changed title from (bug): Live chat activates are not reflected within contribution scores. to (bug): Live chat activates are not being reflected within contribution scores.

changed title from (bug): Live chat activates are not being reflected within contribution scores. to (bug): Live chat activates are not being reflected within contribution scores

changed the description 3 times within 9 minutes

@ottman @jotto141 is this an oversight, bug, or intentional?

This is a good catch if true, and it may be possible that the group owner is receiving the credit. Can you check? Can you also recommend how the rewards should work ideally? Should the group owner get any credit?

@ottman, I can confirm that the resulting credit is not going to the group creator due to the fact that when creating the MCOSI group, I created a specific account / channel for MCOSI use only (which is the actual owner of the corresponding group). When adding comments to the MCOSI group live chat, I only use my own account / channel and the resulting comments do not get reflected in either my own or the MCOSI account contribution scores.

added Priority::1 - High Product::Platform Type::Bug scoped labels

I've flagged this high priority, if you feel it's urgent @ottman feel free to escalate.

Sounds good. We will get this into a near-term sprint. Thanks @medworthy