if you think "historial accuracy" is important to this, you must be really dense. there is No historical or plot driven reason why tanjiro's earrings are designed with the r/ising sun flag. historical accuracy is not relevant in this case.
-
- Show this threadThanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
ive muted this post but man.. stay mad
i, for one, appreciate the production team for officially modifying the earring designs for other countries. and look, the official merch also has the modified version! ♪┌|∵|┘♪https://twitter.com/insatiablejudge/status/1170680149035163649?s=19 …
Show this threadThanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
i realize that i made mistakes on my part with this post, especially for lumping se asians with east asians, and i apologize for that. ive been informed that this is something se asians have dealt with before, and my privilege as a korean american blinded me in that regard.
Show this thread -
next time, i wont try to include that, unless se asians overwhelmingly ask, and ill rt their posts to share their direct thoughts instead. i wasnt trying to speak over se asians, but in the end i did, and i apologize.
Show this thread -
but regardless, even if you are east/se asian, and dont feel uncomfortable with the design, please know that many do. and for this reason the earrings were modified for other countries. but if you assumed i was white/rich, even when you looked at my bio, you should take a closer
Show this thread -
look at yourself. not every opinion that collides with yours is from the mouth of a white person. my original point still stands, the earrings are hanafuda, but specifically the sun design, because of the hill + circle. its clear resemblance to the RS motif is the issue.pic.twitter.com/qpzbVh3SQp
Show this thread -
im not saying the mangaka had any ill intentions, especially since the japanese arent taught of the flags' controversy, its use as an official flag, and as a cultural icon. the RS flag has a horrific history and my main goal is to bring attention to it, not completely censor it.
Show this thread -
the jp studio HAD to agree to make the modification a reality, they understand that the design is uncomfortably similiar to the RS motif. as a korean i appreciate their efforts to do that. i dont want to censor history, but if theres a canon alternative, why not use it in an
Show this thread -
effort to be more sensitive to those that feel uncomfortable? again, this post was a suggestion, and im sorry many felt that i was attacking people who already used the original, but its important to know the horrific history. empathy is an important factor in the anime, why
Show this thread -
fight those who feel upset over the use of a design that bears clear resemblance to a flag that was used to colonize east and south east asia? ive learned a lot from this experience and i hope that you guys can understand my original stance and my mistakes. thank you.
Show this thread End of conversation
New conversation -
-
- This Tweet is unavailable
-
sorry to say this, but i think its because of the lack of knowledge on your part on japanese aggression in south east asia. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_colonial_empire … unfortunately japanese war crimes are not taught nearly enough. the design is hanafuda, but incorporate the ri/sing sun motif.
-
My grandfather took part in the Bataan Death March and my grandmother was in mainland China during WWII Guess what, I still like this rising sun motif Getting outraged on behalf of other people is some real tiresome shit, please go outside
-
My grandmother's entire family was uprooted from their home in Nanking due to the massacres and occupation. They still face the trauma of broken relationships and suffer the lasting impacts of the horrors that happened. Guess what, some of us are outraged on behalf of our own.
-
That's a tragedy, but my grandmother's family went through that too. Yet I'm not about to make out this particular usage of the rising sun motif to something it isn't. Just because it was used in wartime Japan doesn't mean every instance of it has the imperialist sentiment.
-
Do you feel the same way about nazi flags? We're not the ones who gave that flag the connotations it has, we're not responsible for respecting its current form. If Japan doesn't want to associate it with imperialist sentiment, then they shouldn't have commited atrocities under it
-
Since you love to make one hell of a reach, here's one of mine. Your pfp is a cosplay of you as Asuka Soryu Langley. The Soryu is a Japanese WWII carrier. Do you condone Japan's atrocities during WWII?
-
I can like a character and its design and the story it takes place in while recognizing its problematic elements. Not to mention her story is one of the exploitation of violence and the individual and its resulting eventual breakdown of personhood.
- 4 more replies
-
-
-
I personally don’t believe it’s based off the rising sun flag at all :”/ it doesn’t have red lines, it’s not dead center, and it’s already based off of hanafuda cards (gambling cards) specifically the set where there is a hill and a sun is rising behind it.pic.twitter.com/isah84oy7R
-
just an fyi: Rising Sun Flag was made during the Edo Period (1603–1868 CE) Hanafuda cards were first made in during the Tokugawa Shogunate (aka Edo Bakufu) Demon Slayer takes place in the Taisho Period (1912-1926)
-
it is entirely possible that the earrings are based off the Rising sun flag, but you have to remember the the anime is is technically being historically accurate. Is it still offensive? Yeah.
-
BUT I think the context of the earrings is what matters. It was a family heirloom passed down from his dad. It represents Family to Tanjiro.
-
Yes I totally agree with this! Thank you for correcting me / adding onto things I’m personally v bad at history in general and I just knew that we have hanafuda cards in our attic that my mom kept so I was like Maybe those?
-
She didn't correct you. They are hanafuda and they are flowers. You can tell by how the white arcs like petals. You were right to think it wasn't the rising sun.pic.twitter.com/ywlpCjbv0U
-
Oh wow it actually is a flower! That’s r cute
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.