Next

Summary

The problem is they can access paywalled images, videos and blogs by simply clicking on the thumbnail in the gallery widget or by viewing the gallery and then clicking the thumbnail.

NOTE: Canary mode is turned on.

See for example on https://www.minds.com/bhayward Image https://www.minds.com/media/977926766784184320

Steps to reproduce

1. Go to the channel for your primary account.
2. Click "Attach" and upload an image.
3. Click "Post".
4. Edit the post.
5. Put it behind a 1 token paywall.
6. Log out and log in to your secondary account.
7. Visit channel for your primary account.
8. Scroll down to the image gallery widget.
9. Click "View More".
10. Click on the thumbnail for the image.

Platform information

• Windows 10 / Chrome (Version 73.0.3683.86)
• replicated Manjaro / Chromium

What is the current bug behavior?

When you post an image, video or blog and then put it behind a paywall, it is still visible in your image/video/blog gallery for other users.

What is the expected correct behavior?

If you put an image/video/blog behind a paywall after you already posted it to your channel, it shouldn't be visible and accessible to users who do not meet the paywall threshold for that content. Either that or it should appear for other users but behind the paywall mask and I think both you and other users should be able to filter the image/video/blog gallery by paywalled content. Perhaps just add a button called "Exclusive Content" at the top of each gallery.

Relevant logs and/or screenshots

Video

https://imgur.com/yRzqylz

Possible fixes

(If you can, link to the line of code that might be responsible for the problem)

added 1 - High P - Media P - Newsfeed T - Bug labels

added to epic &15

Tested on wrong subdomain.

@benhayward.ben please confirm this bug

changed milestone to %sprint: Funny Frog

added S - Backlog label

changed weight to 2

Yeah it is @markeharding just replicated Manjaro / Chromium

Please post links and populate this ticket

It's populated already, the steps but I've added in my evidence of it.

changed the description 3 times within 3 minutes

@benhayward.ben I don't see a single link above

changed the description

2 images and a video up there, the video is quite hidden though. Included a link to my test profile where you can see the issue occurring

Lets put as many links in as possible. Which images should be behind the paywalls? Where are there respective newsfeed links?

assigned to @edgebal

changed title from (bug): When you post an image, video or blog and then put it behind a paywall, it is still visible in your image/video/blog gallery for other users. to (bug): Retrospectively paywalled posts do not apply the paywall to attachements

@edgebal - I think we need to ensure that if a paywall is added in on edit (for an already existing post) that we sync the paywall with any attached entities.

I think we may be confusing two issues here @markeharding

This one, is that the content still shows in the gallery without a filter. e.g. here

The arrows are pointing to the same entity - that post, that when unlocked is a randomly picked image of a phone, is visible to any user who does not pay me.

Ok well we still need links so we are on the same page. The steps imply that this only happens when a post is edited retrospectively and not at the time of creation.

changed the description

Yep, just tested to confirm, this is only happening on edit. Updated with links to the image and profile where you can see it happening.