Keyboard shortcuts are available for common actions and site navigation.
You can add location information to your Tweets, such as your city or precise location, from the web and via third-party applications. You always have the option to delete your Tweet location history. Learn more
What the hell is happening between #Hungary and #Ukraine, why are diplomatic tensions rising dramatically?
Thread for CEE&Hungary watchers, and for journalists covering the topic!https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-45753886 …
It all started last year with Ukraine’s new education law requiring more Ukrainian language education for minorities who previously had much bigger autonomy. This ‘reform’ is a tool of Ukrainian nation-building&was primarily aimed at restricting Russian language education.
Collateral damage occurred as Polish, Romanian&Hungarian minorities were affected as well. Poland&Romania managed to solve the situation with Ukraine through negotiations but Hungary went berserk instead. Here’s a very good summary in English by @OSW_eng:https://www.osw.waw.pl/en/publikacje/osw-commentary/2018-08-14/ukraine-hungary-intensifying-dispute-over-hungarian-minoritys …
In retaliation, Hungary started blocking UA’s EU&NATO ascension. This was a clever move by Orbán to put Hungary back on Washington’s radar and elevate his profile. Suddenly, top US diplomats had to meet Hungarian counterparts to mediate, something that hasn’t happened in years.
Meanwhile, it became obvious that Russia is meddling in Transcarpathia. Pro-Kremlin Polish fascists & later an Ukrainian national with Transnistrian ties carried out arson attacks against a Hungarian minority center.
Our @VSquare_Project investigation: https://vsquare.org/zakarpattia-western-ukraine-burning-how-russia-sets-fire-to-the-eus-external-border/ …
With Russian efforts to incite ethnic tensions in Transcarpathia&Hungary's blocking of Ukraine’s NATO ascension, the million dollar question is whether Budapest & Moscow are coordinating their moves against Kyiv or not. It’s a popular theory, but without direct evidence (yet).
Despite Transcarpathia being a multi-ethnic region, minorities used to live together in peace. Now nationalism is on the rise thanks to both government’s actions, and of course, thanks to Russian efforts.
The topic even caught the @nytimes’ attention:https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/05/world/europe/ukraine-hungary-ethnic-languages.html …
Meanwhile, US diplomacy had to reprioritize their agenda in Hungary. Solving the HU-UA dispute is now on top of the list (@ceuhungary’s case is the other top priority question). There is less energy for previous concerns about media freedom, rule of law&human rights issues.
However, it is Ukraine that seems to be more interested in escalating the dispute right now, fueling Poroshenko’s struggling election campaign with nationalistic topics. As a result, Budapest is rumored to be considering the idea of throwing their support behind Yulia Tymoshenko.
And there is room for escalation. Hungary’s newly appointed ambassador to Kyiv is unable to start his job as his agrément hasn’t been accepted since mid-Summer. On the other side, Ukraine wants to appoint a new honorary consul in Hungary, but Budapest is not giving acceptance.
Given Viktor Orbán’s low acceptance among Western leaders, his shady pro-Russian ties and #Hungary’s relative isolation, Ukraine is in much better position in terms of international support. Funny that even Orbán’s strongest regional ally, Poland is more likely to side with Kyiv.
The most serious question, however, is what will happen to the poor people of Transcarpathia, the ones that have the most to lose. The most worrying example was when Ukrainian nationalists attacked Hungarian speaking Roma people and killed a young man.https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-44593995 …
What is also worrying is that Ukraine started harassing Hungarians holding dual citizenship. It is not allowed by law to have dual citizenship in Ukraine, but there is no penalty for it either. Now authorities are prosecuting some Hungarians for treason.https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/10/treason-hungary-ukraine-dispute-language-laws-181005085254585.html …
Slovakia banned dual nationality early this decade in response to Hungary offering passports to SK minorities in the south of the country. Related ?
Same Tools by mr Orban to get the same result! Stronger nationalist support at home
Plausible.
Mr Orban is a disruptor, and I'm sure Mr Putin is a fan, so @anneapplebaum's guess might not be far off.
I believe Putin is offering Orban the Ukrainian carrot. Last year he offered Romania the southern region populated by ethnic Romanians. He doesn’t like Ukraine whole.
a little wish from russia to block any better relation between two neighbouring country... bad relationships inside europe the better for russia :(
Well, Orban has said (and I support him) that Hungary doesn't want migrants and that they "do not want to mix" (become multicultural). Is it shocking that Ukraine feels likewise? It has every right to advance its own culture within its own borders. Support national sovereignty.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.
spanyi@asu.edu
