全 17 件のコメント

[–]Token_Why_BoyINTP 7 ポイント8 ポイント  (0子コメント)

Following the theme of INTPs represented as robots/cyborgs, Legion from Mass Effect 2 is about as cardboard cutout INTP as you're ever going to see. ME3 had a different writing team so it may not hold up there, but ME2's Legion is unquestionably INTP.

[–]mirrorconspiraciesENTP 6 ポイント7 ポイント  (2子コメント)

I definitely thought Violet. ISTP is also a strong possibility, though. Dammit, I should give them a reread now. :D You totally echo my thoughts on the siblings. (Thank god someone else thinks Alice is INTP. I think movie!Alice has a stronger case for ENTP but definitely not book!Alice.).

Milo OMG I totally forgot about him! That was my favorite movie. I really think he could be INTP, actually, thinking back.

How about Luna Lovegood? I fully subscribe to her being INTP rather than INFP.

Edit: Also, Arthur Weasley!

[–]owlsymbolismseverely depressed ENTP, pretty much INTP[S] 1 ポイント2 ポイント  (1子コメント)

YES. (You will notice a lengthy comment to follow. I am procrastinating, mind racing, with an essay on the mental back-burner. Hooray for distractions! I'll make it in time, though.)

Alice, naturally, tries to live up to Si/Fe expectations and standards, but just keeps spiraling out. She overthinks, makes connections, gets upset about them, and loses focus and energy on her conversations. She needs to keep her hands on the wheel to stay outgoing. She's very Ne-ish, and she tries hard, but her Ti just wins.

I recall loving Atlantis, and when I went to look for clips and stuff to reference, I could feel the gravity of the nostalgia rabbit hole pulling me in. That, and Treasure Planet. Loved that Verne-ish sci-fi style both had. So I just had to quickly write something down and close those tabs before I went for full rewatches. :)

Oh, forgot to add in Luna. I really need a reread. Book Luna was definitely more thinker-y, in true Ravenclaw spirit, the core of which is very INTP radiating outward. (Charms is the best subject, too! I'd major in it. Physics + programming, to get stuff to move for you. It's the ultimate work-smarter-not-harder class.) But I don't recall if she was really absolute on the Ti side. It's not a clear, hard sell. Movie Luna, which is the fresher memory on people's minds, now intermingled with the original idea, was much closer to the line, and had some INFP-ness about her.

This sends me on a spiral of doubt and confusion and it's a total internet landmine character to bring up. Like how Sherlock Holmes (books, duh) uses all the f-in' perceiving functions, or how Jack Sparrow thinks like an ESTP but acts with the chatter and loosey goosey mannerisms of an ENTP. There are some unclear answers, places where one cannot go without taking hits. So I took Luna off the list to comment on, and forgot before submitting the post.

So my Si records are fucked and I can't find half the books. I'll find a way. arrr.

[–]mirrorconspiraciesENTP 4 ポイント5 ポイント  (0子コメント)

Hehe. I read an interesting argument that directly compared Luna and Hermione's reactions to Umbridge in her office in OoTP. It basically boiled down to the way Luna is distracted and distant in the face of injustices - even issues she has feelings on - while Hermione is the one who displays Fi traits. Just a specific instance, anyway.

I always got a Ti-vibe from her. She's so dispassionate about everything, and has the typical kind but cool/detached demeanor (opposing to the inner warmth of the INFP).

[–]FerretMadINTP 1 ポイント2 ポイント  (0子コメント)

Gandalf could be INTP in the books.

[–][deleted] 1 ポイント2 ポイント  (0子コメント)

This is excellent! Thank you.

Suspected additions: Jeff from Curb Your Enthusiasm. In contrast to Larry David (who seems to me a fairly clear ENTP and in many ways the show is about his struggles with his tert Fe and inf Si), Jeff is a restraining force, questioning Larry's reasoning, but never misunderstanding it. Seems to display inf Fe, especially in interactions with (ENTJ) wife Susie, whom he passively humors. A non-stereotypical example.

Mr. Bennet in Pride and Prejudice also comes to mind. Contrast his wry detachment with his wife's strong Fe in the first chapter (it seems a pretty good example of a failed INTP-ESFJ dual relationship, incidentally).

Edit: also, common mistype I see is David Mitchell's character from Peep Show. While Mitchell himself is INTP, the character is ISTJ.

[–]HateKnuckleINTP 1 ポイント2 ポイント  (0子コメント)

Milo is an interesting one. On paper he seems like a great fit. We see him frantic and disorganized. Unloading information that he's gathered in great detail. Practically obsessed with his own ideas.

It's probably the subject that I don't identify with. Sure ancient civilizations are cool and all but I don't see the intricate theories or deep relations a supposedly isolated super developed civilization would hold.

All I can say is that anyone who wants to claim him as INTP gets a pass because I can't tell them no.

[–]overpoweredgingerINTP 0 ポイント1 ポイント  (0子コメント)

Taylor Hebert from Worm is astoundingly INTP if we're being honest.

[–]everythingisunknown -1 ポイント0 ポイント  (0子コメント)

Potentially Hank Moody from californication. Definitely more extroverted but I can see the INTP resemblance at times