Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.

Start by marking “Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality” as Want to Read:

Other editions

Enlarge cover

Rate this book

Clear rating

1 of 5 stars 2 of 5 stars 3 of 5 stars 4 of 5 stars 5 of 5 stars

Open Preview

Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality

by Eliezer Yudkowsky

4.38 · Rating Details · 8,033 Ratings · 799 Reviews

Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality is a work of alternate-universe Harry Potter fan-fiction wherein Petunia Evans has married an Oxford biochemistry professor and young genius Harry grows up fascinated by science and science fiction. When he finds out that he is a wizard, he tries to apply scientific principles to his study of magic, with sometimes surprising resu ...more

ebook, 2007 pages

Published March 14th 2015 by hpmor.com & fanfiction.net

More Details... edit details

Get a copy:

Or buy for

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality, please sign up.

Lists with This Book

Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality by Eliezer Yudkowsky

James Potter and the Hall of Elders' Crossing by G. Norman Lippert

James Potter and the Vault of Destinies by G. Norman Lippert

James Potter and the Curse of the Gatekeeper by G. Norman Lippert

Harry Potter FanFiction

178 books — 320 voters

Three Worlds Collide by Eliezer Yudkowsky

Rational Fiction

87 books — 65 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)

filter | sort: default (?) | Rating Details

Dec 10, 2011 Elius rated it it was amazing

Shelves: favourites, 2012-books, fantasy, psychology, humor, young-adult

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. Imagine Harry Potter being replaced with a Harry Potter with combined talents of Ender Wiggins, Artemis Fowl and Yagami Light and put him in world much darker than Rowling envisioned. Yep, that's what this book was. No Ron or Hagrid to distract you, this is a Machiavellian Harry who manipulates people to his own ends, with powers the Dark Lord knows not, and the ambition for world domination (or, as he would call it, world optimization)

It is a HUGE book and still ongoing. Took me three days stra ...more

flag 118 likes · Like · see review

Feb 18, 2012 Eddie rated it really liked it

AI researcher and decision theorist Eliezer Yudkowsky probably woke up one day and asked himself a single question: what would have happened in Harry Potter’s first year in Hogwarts, had he not been such an insufferable idiot?

You might not have considered him to be an idiot in the first place, but as the book progresses and the new Harry makes his way around Hogwarts, facing the same problems and situations, it becomes impossible to ignore the oh so logical and natural way he handles them this AI researcher and decision theorist Eliezer Yudkowsky probably woke up one day and asked himself a single question: what would have happened in Harry Potter’s first year in Hogwarts, had he not been such an insufferable idiot?

You might not have considered him to be an idiot in the first place, but as the book progresses and the new Harry makes his way around Hogwarts, facing the same problems and situations, it becomes impossible to ignore the oh so logical and natural way he handles them this time. It really makes one wonder what was going through his head in the original version and feels like a direct critique of Rowling. It made me wonder how I managed to ever take the original seriously (might have something to do with me being 8 at the time).

In Eliezer’s version of the story, Harry is a child prodigy; Highly intelligent and educated well beyond his years in the sciences and the methods of rationality, he is well equipped to handle anything the magical world can throw at him and then some. But this Harry also has a dark side and we get to know him better as he struggles to find balance in himself.

The differences in this parallel universe don’t end with Harry, though. His adopting parents, Petunia and Prof. Michael Verres-Evans, are happily married and treat him as they would their own flesh and blood. Ron and Hermione remain mostly the same, although genius Harry obviously prefers to interact with the hard working book-worm and quickly decides that a boring, average ginger is simply not worth his precious time (speaking of time... no, I won’t ruin the surprise). A cunning and manipulative Draco Malfoy and a powerful yet cynical Prof. Quirrell take on larger roles, in quite unexpected ways. We also see much more of Dumbledore (who’s actually read The Lord of the Rings, seeing as every muggle student ever to come to Hogwarts thought that gifting him a copy was an original idea).

It seems important to note that magic is also treated a little bit differently, especially by a scientific Harry, who sets out to test and understand it, thus restoring order to the seemingly shattered laws of physics. Naturally, things don’t go according to plan and at times he is forced to improvise.

The book started out pretty well, with some laugh out loud scenes as Harry finds out about magic for the first time (see quote below). As I read the first few chapters I kept waiting for the level to drop, for the premise to exhaust itself, for my enthusiasm to subside, but 300 pages in and hungrily reading on, It was clear that I’ve stumbled upon something great and that the story is safe in the deft hands of Eliezer Yudkowsky.

Quote ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
“You turned into a cat! A SMALL cat! You violated Conservation of Energy! That's not just an arbitrary rule, it's implied by the form of the quantum Hamiltonian! Rejecting it destroys unitarity and then you get FTL signaling! And cats are COMPLICATED! A human mind can't just visualize a whole cat's anatomy and, and all the cat biochemistry, and what about the neurology? How can you go on thinking using a cat-sized brain?”
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The book is funny, at times hilarious. The premise is well executed as Eliezer draws from his vast experience as a rationalist and lets us take a look at genius minds at work; we all know how hard that is to pull off. Methods of Rationality really hits its stride around chapter 5 and according to the author if you haven’t taken to it by chapter 10, then that’s a good time to call it quits (and rethink your interests).

From the get-go, different decisions create chains of cause and effect that send the book in pretty different directions (like Harry finding out almost immediately that he’s prophesied to battle against the dark lord). Other scenes repeat almost word for word, like the first potions lesson with Snape (only this time, Harry refuses to play the victim and stands up to him, in a rather spectacular fashion).

As the story progressed, I found myself engrossed in the plot, invested in the characters and generally unable to put the book down. It is not flawless and at times Eliezer’s inexperience as a novel writer shows, but overall this is as good as it gets. Come for the premise, stay for the story and along the way let the message of rationality rub off and enlighten you. I’ve rarely been as inspired to study, as in love with science or as driven to succeed as when I’ve read this book.

https://eddiesmo.wordpress.com/catego... ...more

flag 81 likes · Like · see review

Jul 10, 2012 Sarah rated it it was ok

I wanted to like this, honestly. When I stumbled upon it and read that description, I figured it was going to be brilliant. So naturally it wasn't. The author leaves a note saying if you don't like it by chapter five, wait until chapter ten, and if you still don't like it by then, get out. That's exactly what I'm doing.

This isn't the first book (so to speak) where the idea is wonderful but it's executed horribly. For starters, the writing is a bit sloppy at times, and when I say at times, I mean I wanted to like this, honestly. When I stumbled upon it and read that description, I figured it was going to be brilliant. So naturally it wasn't. The author leaves a note saying if you don't like it by chapter five, wait until chapter ten, and if you still don't like it by then, get out. That's exactly what I'm doing.

This isn't the first book (so to speak) where the idea is wonderful but it's executed horribly. For starters, the writing is a bit sloppy at times, and when I say at times, I mean every single second of this made my head hurt because it was painful to read. You can also swap painful with boring, because more than anything, that's all I got from it. Harry is even more of an arrogant little jerk who spends his time proving that he has to be right. He talks down to everyone, throws around words bigger than he is, and ultimately makes himself look like an ass with his attempts at humor. I should not hate an eleven-year-old this much! But I couldn't help it, and I think the biggest reason why is because he never once acts like an eleven-year-old.

I wasn't even interested in wherever the plot was going. I'm assuming there's some world-domination crap that could probably be interested if it was more realistic (I know it's the wizarding world, but you know what I mean!), but I got tired of listening to Harry mock the world the original Harry loves so much. Even McGonagall makes cracks at "being locked up in a cupboard for ten years," and more than I was appalled at that bad attempt at a joke, I was a little surprised that the author would write the characters so badly. The ironic part is that the start of chapter eleven (which I reached when I decided to call it quits) includes an author's note saying "in which everyone else in the wizarding world remains the same but only Harry's character is changed). Because really, from what I've heard that comes from the story later on, every character is different. Every character is like one asshole hipster of the original. Original Harry loved being a Seeker? Smart Harry thinks Seekers completely ruin the point of the sport.

This was so infuriating and painful to get through, and I only made it through ten chapters. I only gave it two stars because I adore the idea of the story. I could sit here for a while and tear this story apart, but I have better things to do with my time. ...more

flag 57 likes · Like · see review

Sep 10, 2012 Xi Xinghe rated it it was amazing

Recently I've been wondering just what exactly I wanted from literary fiction. Surely I did not expect life-changing epiphanies, at least not from every single book. But neither did I want my books be merely means to cheap escapism, which I had, perhaps mistakenly, long associated with genre fiction. Somehow I seem to be asking both too much and not enough, and therein lies the reason for my inability to rekindle the kind of pure unadulterated love I used to have for reading. No longer can I sim Recently I've been wondering just what exactly I wanted from literary fiction. Surely I did not expect life-changing epiphanies, at least not from every single book. But neither did I want my books be merely means to cheap escapism, which I had, perhaps mistakenly, long associated with genre fiction. Somehow I seem to be asking both too much and not enough, and therein lies the reason for my inability to rekindle the kind of pure unadulterated love I used to have for reading. No longer can I simply pick up a book with a fancy cover and devour it like a fat kid with a Macdonald's burger. Now my books have to be interesting but not too fantastical, philosophical but not overly pretentious, and preferably famous but hopefully unfamilar to people my age. Structures should to be organic, voices have to be genuine and reviews must be glowing. Years of reliance on the "award-winning" shelf at the library have turned me into a spoiled and picky book reader. Perhaps not yet a book snob, but definitely approaching that territory. A book vegan, perhaps.

Yet sometimes despite my pickiness, I would find a book that by all accounts I should hate, but cannot help but love anyway, like a cheeseburger you bought because you were in a rush, but turned out to be your best meal of the day. Below is ostensibly a review for such a book, but really is a love letter to my favourite "book" at the moment.

Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality is the first piece of fan-fiction I have ever read, and never in my life did I expect myself to fall head over heels in love with a wall of text posted on a website that is also home to thousands of pages of Harry/Draco erotica. To those of us that grew up with Rowling's books, the Harry Potter series was our heathen bible, our first novel, and the source of some of our fondest childhood memories. That someone by the name of "lesswrong" dared to "improve"on a book so loved and sacred in the eyes of its fans is nothing short of blasphemy. A fan-fiction that dared to attempt to surpass its original! It seemed like arrogance of the highest level, and I felt like God looking down upon the Tower of Babel.

Yet from the very first chapter, HPMOR felt like no ordinary tribute or parody. It was a truely original reimagining of a world that was already exceedingly familar to any casual consumer of popular culture, let alone a fan. At first, the differences between Eliezer Yudkowsky's universe and Rowling's may seem superficial. The basis of the story can be summed up by the HPMOR website's tagline, "Petunia married a professor, and Harry grew up reading science and science-fiction." Imagine, for a moment, that Harry was never an orphan, and grew up in a loving family into a well-adjusted, confident, if not a little eccentric 11-year-old. Imagine again, that Harry actually knew SCIENCE before encoutering magic. The result is a surprisingly different story from the original.

Without the insecurities and emotional baggage that accompanied the original protagonist, there is greater room in the story to explore the world around Harry, rather than to dwell on the inner turmoil of Harry himself. At the same time, the new, precocious Harry can now employ all the tools of rationality to discover, dissect and manipulate the magical world around him. He is no longer a passive observer in a strange, scary universe, but rather an active explorer from the get-go, more like a college student touring a new country, than a child transferring to a new school. While the new Harry is perhaps a less relatable character for real 11-year-olds, he is much a more interesting character for the adult reader. Harry's mix of cynicism and wide-eyed wonder felt genuine and appropriate, while at the same time providing us with an alternate view of the magical universe from a scientific point of view.

The other great divergence of HPMOR from the original lies in the tone of the story. The original makes clear the moral standing of each character(except in the very last book), including the much beloved Snape, whose true nature was eventually revealed. HPMOR never allows its characters to fit comfortably into explicit moral brackets, with the difficulties of seperating "good" from "evil" as one of its central themes. None of the characters are safe from moral ambiguity, not Harry, not Hermione, not even Dumbledore(who *spoilers* admitted that he may very well become the next Dark Lord after the fall of Voldemort) Yet in this grey alternate universe, we feel the anguish and joy of each character more acutely there ever before. Because the reader can now see how there are no easy choices for any of the characters, the plight of the characters feels more tragic. And with true victories few and far between, when a character does manage to come out ahead in an impossible situation, the accompanying euphoria is truly uplifting.

Ironically, this more gritty and realistic universe provided a much more optimistic world view than that of the original. Compared to original's utopic depiction of magical Britain, HPMOR, by making clear the deficiences of a pre-industrial, logicless society, puts muggles and wizards on a much more equal standing. In this world, nothing is perfect, not even magic. That muggle scientists have achieved what even wielders of magic have deemed impossible is testament to the strength of our spirit of enquiry and discovery. Some have found such overtly humanist elements in the story to be naive and unrealistic. But I found it to be an effective counter-weight to the over-adulation of magic as the answer to all of humanity's problems, needs and wishes. Yudkowsky allows his readers to immerse in this fantastic world, but also remembers to remind us that in many ways, we can already do magic.

...more

flag 43 likes · Like · see review

Mar 21, 2013 Toby Toldya rated it did not like it

Great idea; terrible execution. In fact, I think the summary is completely misleading. While some scenes had me laughing out loud, I spent most of my time cringing or raising one eyebrow or the other; HPMOR is saturated with Yudkowsky's blatant disdain and a condescending tone.

Characters are, for the most part, wildly out of character. Harry completely fails to act like an 11 year old boy, and reads like a thinly-veiled, sociopathic self-insert. Draco is also worrying sociopathic, even beyond t ...more

flag 37 likes · Like · see review

Mar 26, 2014 Amanda rated it did not like it

Shelves: ebook

I wanted to love this book, I really did. I mean, the premise itself was what got me hooked. I'm sure we've all thought that there was something to be desired in the Plausibility and Possibilities department of the original Harry Potter series, so I jumped at the idea of a realistic story inspired by the methods of rationality! Turns out it wasn't inspired by it so much as it was drowned by it. Spoiler Alert: I didn't finish the book. Yudkowsky left a note about how the series hits its stride at I wanted to love this book, I really did. I mean, the premise itself was what got me hooked. I'm sure we've all thought that there was something to be desired in the Plausibility and Possibilities department of the original Harry Potter series, so I jumped at the idea of a realistic story inspired by the methods of rationality! Turns out it wasn't inspired by it so much as it was drowned by it. Spoiler Alert: I didn't finish the book. Yudkowsky left a note about how the series hits its stride at chapter 5, and "if you still don't like it by chapter 10, give up." So I followed his advice. I'll try to summarize why I did so:

1. Harry Potter is a little shit. And you know it. I thought long and hard about whether or not this was truly a bad thing, and I think I'm still convinced that it is. Asshole should have a reason for being assholes. They either contrast the good in others, serve to advance the plot, or provide a more interesting POV (i.e. we WANT to hear stories from their POV). This Harry is none of those. He's unnecessarily entitled, and his manipulation skills are both highly romanticized and very Gary-Stu-esque. I don't want to be anywhere near this kid, let alone hear his mind-cogs turn.

2. This story was less about Harry Potter than it was about the awesomeness of 'being rational'. I may have had a biased foundation because I knew the author was from Less Wrong. But, I tried to keep an open mind, and I have to say that my opinion didn't stray much from my initial impression. Speaking as someone with a long career in the STEM field, I still don't understand this infatuation some people have with rationality. Humans weren't meant to be cool, calculating and logical probability machines. Emotions are a part of our everyday lives; it plays a part in almost all of our decisions, and it's been indisputably advantageous in the evolutionary sense. So why is it that this story is absolutely dripping with contempt for any method of reasoning that strays beyond that of the 'scientifically sound'?

To sum it up, science is all about keeping an open mind. So why am I being pounded with the idea that 'the rational way is the only way'? That any decisions made based on emotions or feelings deserve to be scorned to the highest degree?

3. The writing was not much more than mediocre. Yudkowsky would be better suited to writing about hypotheses and experiments than about fictive people. Even McGonagall felt flat and one-dimensional. This was mitigated in no part by all of Harry's impressive (and very tedious) references to all sorts of logical and mathematical theorems. It was too much. It was boring. And dull (ironically). I don't want to keep reading about why Harry wants to do this, how he'll do it, and what it does for his ominous plans for the future. I want to know more about this alternate world, its characters and their interactions with each other. I wanted a work that was rich in the culture of an alternate world, and ended being served dish after dish of Harry's bland Mind-Porridge.

I wish I could better express how horrified I was at this blatant love song for rational thinkers. I've encountered too many people in my academic career who valued rational thinking above everything else in their lives, and falsely equate it with a sign of superior intelligence. This book is just another iteration of those fantasies, only longer. ...more

flag 31 likes · Like · see review

Jan 02, 2012 Rajiv rated it it was amazing

Update: 15 March, 2015

OMG! It's over. It has been a wild ride, one of the best I've ever been on. The ending was satisfying in ways I cannot express. Yudkowsky has wowed, amazed, and blown minds through this epic, and I can't wait to read more of his work in the future!

--

I have never felt the need to take fan fiction seriously. They are, at best, exercises of creativity in a predetermined world, and the best of them usually do not stray too far from the established lore. As it stands, “Harry Pot Update: 15 March, 2015

OMG! It's over. It has been a wild ride, one of the best I've ever been on. The ending was satisfying in ways I cannot express. Yudkowsky has wowed, amazed, and blown minds through this epic, and I can't wait to read more of his work in the future!

--

I have never felt the need to take fan fiction seriously. They are, at best, exercises of creativity in a predetermined world, and the best of them usually do not stray too far from the established lore. As it stands, “Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality” is the only exception – it has hooked me in so deeply that I just cannot get out of the fascinating world that its author, Eliezer Yudkowsky, has created.

If you have always felt that Rowling’s characters, and vision of Hogwarts and magical Britain were lacking then you weren’t the only one. They always felt absurd to me as well, lacking coherence and sense in a world that exhibited elitism towards ordinary human beings and looked down at science. The ignorance they displayed is appalling. Yudkowsky addresses these issues with his fantastic fan fiction that offers a whole new take on this universe.

The world remains the same, but with some major differences. Petunia, finally showing some sense, has married a professor at Oxford after she took a ‘beauty’ potion from her sister. Together they raise Harry Potter with love and affection, instilling in him an undying love for rationality and scientific inquiry. Harry is a child prodigy who is acerbic and downright pedantic at times, but brilliant nonetheless. He is a combination of the qualities of Artemis Fowl and Yagami Light (Death Note), displaying intelligence and wit simply unheard of in an eleven year old boy. He is joined by Hermione, who is instantly marked as his rival and romantic interest, and Draco, who is charming and a smart social manipulator. Ron and Hagrid are blissfully absent since they do not have anything to offer in Yudkowsky’s vision of magical Britain; both characters become part of the scenery and do not play any essential roles.

The storyline involves a lot of political maneuvering, social manipulation, being extremely clever, and copious amounts of rationalism. It results in an extremely funny story where Snape gets taken down a notch, Dumbledore is shown to be an clumsy strategist, and McGonagall remains forever flustered by everything that happens around her. Oh, and Harry is a Ravenclaw.

It is a fun and easy read that gets complicated at times. This is due to the fact that Yudkowsky writes about advanced topics such as Bayes’s Theorem, cognitive bias, and artificial intelligence, among many things. The simple but academic writing style makes these topics clear and accessible. The plot is intriguing and the author somehow manages to fit ‘rational’ ideas into every other chapter while still remaining captivating. The story is highly didactic, aimed at teaching you the abovementioned concepts, among other things, while at the same time pokes fun at the goofier bits of the original series. Yudkowsky is also adept at generating tension that drives the story forward.

That is not to say that the writing isn’t without its flaws. Yudkowsky dumps a lot of information on the reader at times, which slows the story down to glacial speeds. The info dumps are especially pronounced at the beginning, but diminish as the story picks up. This also means that external characterization is relatively sparse. However, their internal thought processes are laid out by the author, offering us insight into what makes them tick. In fact, it works better than you might think, though it’s not for all types of readers. Although the final work is concise and well-presented, it still lacks the polish that published works have. That can be fixed in the hands of a capable editor though, who can organize and trim it down to a more enjoyable read than it already is.

“Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality” is still an ongoing project that has 77 chapters as of today (January 18, 2012). It took me about eleven days to absorb it all. It has reintroduced me to rational thinking and changed my outlook towards the world. This ‘book’ simply cannot be recommended enough if you want to have a terrific time while broadening your horizon by learning about science, philosophy and rationality. ...more

flag 24 likes · Like · see review

Mar 22, 2012 Kevin rated it liked it

I can't decide if this was really good or really bad. As a novel (or the majority of a novel) it was pretty terrible. As fanfic it seemed pretty good (to me, which doesn't mean anything, because I am not the kind of guy that reads fanfic at all). I guess I'll go with three stars which seems to say both of those things at once.

Concept that I like: take 11-year-old Harry Potter, about to enter Hogwarts. Make him an incredibly astute and science-minded young boy, and then see just how he'd react to ...more

flag 22 likes · Like · see review

Jan 12, 2011 Nick rated it it was amazing

Shelves: top

This is the funniest thing I have ever read. I have never read something this funny before. It was extremely difficult to do anything except read it until I had "finished" it, and now it's hard to do anything but think about it and wish there was a lot more of it for me to read.

I guess I'll just read some of his rationalist essay series instead!

flag 21 likes · Like · see review

Mar 02, 2011 Douglas Summers-Stay rated it it was amazing

Shelves: fantasy, science-fiction

Imagine if Ender Wiggen were put in Harry Potter's place, and the cunning of other characters upgraded in a similar way. Yudkowsky is a gifted writer, and he plays off the tropes of fanfiction and the idiosyncrasies of the world of Hogwarts in a way that transcends the genre. The books is at times laugh out loud funny, touching, inspiring, and always very smart. Writing fanfiction in order to get more people to read your blog about obscure logical fallacies!? You'd have to be a genius to actuall ...more

flag 18 likes · Like · see review

Nov 25, 2012 Teresa rated it it was amazing

Shelves: fiction, humor, fiction-best-of-best, epistemology

HPMOR (as it's known to fans) is the perfect book for nerds: funny, clever, rife with allusions to other great nerdly works, and yet seriously capable of teaching something real. In this case, the real value-add are principles of reasoning that can lead to better decisions by genuinely emotional, non-Spockian humans in real life.

Shockingly, this story also has a plot. It runs roughly parallel with the HP canon, but the relationships are different and the entire arc of the Potter stories seems d ...more

flag 14 likes · Like · see review

Jan 20, 2012 Jayesh rated it it was amazing

Shelves: fantasy, favorites

Eliezer has completely turned the story around with a fabulous mixture of real science and JKRverse. The book is peppered with real life use of rationality , Bayesian Logic and psychology. It’s quite a learning experience, especially if you look up the bits you don’t understand.

flag 13 likes · Like · see review

Nov 12, 2012 Surya rated it did not like it

Shelves: fantasy, didn-t-finish, fanfic

I wanted to like this fanfic. As a mathematician and an atheist I should have liked this fanfic.

I didn't. The writing is poor (even for fanfic) and the characterisation worse. The author has turned Harry Potter into the most unsympathetic and unlikeable child I can possibly imagine - which I would guess from his bio is also a blatant Mary-Sue.

Should have been called Harry Potter, the Snotty Little Git.

flag 12 likes · Like · see review

Jan 31, 2014 Richard rated it it was amazing

Recommended to Richard by: Elliot Reed

Shelves: fantasy, bizarre, cognition, fantasy-magic, scifi-hardscience, scifi-fantasy

This is an enormous fan fic version of the first book in the Harry Potter series, rewritten portraying Harry as a hyperrationalist.

Not worth five stars as a work of fiction per se, but fascinating enough to get bumped up to amazing because of several other factors:

• Folks with mildly compulsive rationalist and/or scientific leanings often have trouble with the nonsensical goings on of magical worlds. Occasionally Yudkowsky nails this so well that I was laughing convulsively. That the author som This is an enormous fan fic version of the first book in the Harry Potter series, rewritten portraying Harry as a hyperrationalist.

Not worth five stars as a work of fiction per se, but fascinating enough to get bumped up to amazing because of several other factors:

• Folks with mildly compulsive rationalist and/or scientific leanings often have trouble with the nonsensical goings on of magical worlds. Occasionally Yudkowsky nails this so well that I was laughing convulsively. That the author sometimes over-indulged in this, and very often got too preachy about aspects of the world that aren't perfectly is probably the biggest flaw here as a work of fiction. Sadly, folks that already know what the fundamental attribution error is, or disdain television news because they understand the availability cascade, and can discuss Kahnemann's System 1 and System 2 at length — well, the choir can get tired of the preaching. And the folks that don't already know that stuff are unlikely to suddenly find the lectures worthwhile, because they really interfere with the flow of the novel. If you enjoyed Rowling's original series, and have at least a passing familiarity with some of that nonsense I just listed, you should take a gander at this.

• Dark, dark, dark. Rowling's book is targeted at young adults — or younger, actually. Yudkowsky's Harry thinks Ron Weasley is too dumb to waste time from day one, so we quickly learn that Harry doesn't tolerate fools. The author seriously engages the question of whether Rowling's bad guys actually have sensible grievances, but are perhaps simply more realistic about moral complexity, as Harry sometimes (but not always) is. Thus, Draco Malfoy becomes a very major character. One of my biggest peeves with most fantasy is the characters go through life-threatening situations yet seldom suffer. Yes, Rowling killed some secondary characters, and kinda killed one major character, but too little too late, really. "What part of suicide mission didn't you understand?" is a line I keep hoping to hear, and I'm happy to say Yudkowsky seems inclined to address that — although you might not enjoy some of the consequences.

• Startlingly good characterizations. Harry becomes in many ways a more complex and layered persona than in the original, and Yudkowsky's Draco is far, far more interesting than one would expect. The adults benefit a little from examining their reactions to the more nuanced Harry, but suffer by being confronted by a child with the mind and experiences that no child could reasonably have attained. The exaggeration of this here actually illuminates a trope that is too common: by privileging a character with knowledge and skills far beyond what a reasonable person could anticipate, those others can too easily be portrayed as idiots. But this is itself unreasonable — expecting children to be merely children is rational for humans, with their limited cognitive capacity. Kahenem's Subconcious System 1 thinking is an evolutionary adaptation that lets us think more efficiently, albeit frequently at the expense of accuracy. Anyone constantly trying to use System 2 ratiocination to overcome the cognitive traps evolution which has planted in our brains will suffer persistent ego depletion, and won't be able to function.

• There are some plot developments here that are much more intriguing that what I remember from the canonical series. Probably the best is the long-term project that Harry convinces Draco to address with respect to House Slytherin, which swaps out Rawling's simplistic social world and puts in a much more nuanced and realistic one.

This is like an insightful cover version of a great song (like William Shatner's punked up version of Pulp's "Common People"); it adds something new without detracting from the original. If you are interested in seeing how the Harry Potter series can be subverted, converted, diverted and perverted into something delightfully new, assuming you hit the target audience criteria, then check it out.

Oh — this isn't in print or published; it is effectively an on-line ebook. Aim your ebook reader or web browser at http://hpmor.com

Oh, and it has nothing at all to do with this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zbdvo... ...more

flag 11 likes · Like · see review

Mar 20, 2012 Alliana Vivares rated it it was ok

Alright, my first complaint is that it should warn readers that it contains sensitive issues. I almost choked on the chocolate I've been eating when I read Draco's nonchalant threat of rape. I mean, hello? Isn't he still eleven? And okay, maybe there are lots of open-minded eleven-year-olds in the world but saying that to an almost complete stranger is too much! Harry was very close to being bad here; it made me wonder what that idiot Petunia had been teaching him. He is rude to his elders, whic ...more

flag 11 likes · Like · see review

Jul 20, 2012 Valerie rated it it was amazing

Harry Potter + science + philosophy = slightly mind boggling + very entertaining

All of the above is true.

However, whether or not I have truly read this fan fiction is a different question. In one sense, I have read it. In another, I have not. The reason for my discontinuity can easily be explained. I have read all of this work that exists up to this point in time. However, this book is far from complete.

In any case, though, I will accept that I have "read" this book because I can't be "current ...more

flag 10 likes · Like · see review

Sep 03, 2013 Hannah rated it really liked it

Okay, so this gets tricky.
The first, say, ten-fifteen chapters were AMAZING. I was cracking up (I snorted my soda at pretty much the same times Harry hacked up his Comed-Tea) at the many absolutely hysterical moments that come up when Harry is a complete brilliant jerk with negligible people skills (he has them in theory- probably because he read about them- and he can manipulate, but otherwise...).
Then, by about chapter 15 (maybe not til chapter 20) I just started getting bored. The writing wa ...more

flag 8 likes · Like · see review

Aug 09, 2013 Faysal Subhani rated it it was amazing

Shelves: favourites

Simply Brilliant. Arguably one of the best books I have read so far. Definitely better than the original Harry Potter itself. It's not meant to be a spoof, but an espousal of the author's philosophy of rationality. This book is so realistic, even though it's based on magic. It makes you reflect on life. Above all, it keeps you guessing till the very end because the author refuses to categorize characters in the book as being good or evil. And the best part is, the book is free to download from h ...more

flag 10 likes · Like · see review

Nov 04, 2016 Jenn *The Crimson Dark Lord Scribe, House of Slytheread* marked it as to-read

Shelves: fan-fiction

I swear I've read this fanfiction before.

Guess what I might do this weekend?

flag 9 likes · Like · see review

May 27, 2012 Adam Smith rated it it was amazing

Shelves: favorites, reading-challenge-2015, fanfiction

At the time of this review the story is 103 chapters, and counting, long (longer than the actual books), and still within the timeframe of the first book. Set to end March 2015.

An alternate world where the role of Harry Potter is played by a somewhat sociopathic Sheldon Cooper. Instead of marrying the repugnant mr. Dursley, Harry's aunt Petunia married a respected physicist resulting in Harry being raised in a loving environment where knowledge is praised and making the most of your life an acce At the time of this review the story is 103 chapters, and counting, long (longer than the actual books), and still within the timeframe of the first book. Set to end March 2015.

An alternate world where the role of Harry Potter is played by a somewhat sociopathic Sheldon Cooper. Instead of marrying the repugnant mr. Dursley, Harry's aunt Petunia married a respected physicist resulting in Harry being raised in a loving environment where knowledge is praised and making the most of your life an acceptable goal. Harry approaches the wizarding world armed with the best weapons logic can provide; it's not long before Harry's confusing concepts of science and rationality turn the wizarding world upside down.

This monster of a fanfic is brilliant; in terms of sheer size and detail. The author has taken god knows how long applying scientific principles to the whimsical world of Harry Potter. Harry spends a good deal of time holding his head as the rules of the universe turn against him (apparently, the world does really want you to say 'wingardium leviousa').

Throughout the 85 chapters I've read so far, there have only been a few occasions where I've been pulled out of the story (such as when Harry starts preaching atheism to Dumbledore for an unbearably lengthy time) and only one real example of someone acting out of character (with Goyle pausing to question Quirrel's martial arts skills before attacking).

Now, I'm not sure if this story has improved my rationalizing skills or not, but it is definitely worth reading in it's entirety. It's fun to see how a reasonable person would deal with the inconsistencies in the Potterverse, even if the scientific theories do come across as a little dense in some places. Looking forward to seeing where this story goes from here.

Update to chapter 103:
This is the second time I have read to completion. The ending of the story is scheduled to go live in mid-February, I look forward to reading it.

This story is still epic. It does take a serious dark turn between where I last finished and this point. I can't wait to see how it'll end.

***Reading Challenge 2015: A book with more than 500 pages*** ...more

flag 8 likes · Like · see review

Jun 05, 2011 Jack rated it liked it

Shelves: fantasy

A fun take on the Potterverse from someone obsessed with all the ways that humans fail to behave in ways that make sense - for a rather strict meaning of "make sense". Leaving aside the usual fights over the legitimacy of fanfic in general, the big question is how much Yudkowsky's Potter is an idealized author stand-in (a "Mary Sue", or "Marty Stu" in the parlance). My answer: Quite a lot, but not fatally. On the minus side, this Harry Potter talks and thinks quite a lot like someone in his late ...more

flag 8 likes · Like · see review

May 30, 2012 Isabelle rated it did not like it

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.

flag 8 likes · Like · see review

Sep 06, 2012 Eric Herboso rated it it was amazing

Shelves: hard-fantasy, fanfiction, rationality

Not only is this the best fanfiction I've ever read, it is among my favorite novels of all time, and so far I've only been able to read up to chapter 85.

This is a reimagining of the canonical novels of Harry Potter where the main character is extremely rational. Although he is a preteen, this version of Harry Potter has a mind on par with an extremely gifted 18 year old, and it shows. His nemesis, Voldemort, is similarly increased in intelligence by a dramatic amount. The Tom Riddle of this fanf ...more

flag 7 likes · Like · see review

Mar 26, 2014 Steve rated it it was amazing

I will keep this review brief and to the point. First off, all the negative reviews come from people who are either too stupid to understand it or are too in love with the Potterverse to accept something better. Keep that in mind.

Written with a magical version of Ender Wiggin, Harry Potter is a child genius who is skilled in the ways of science and (Yudkowsky's brand of) rationality. Naturally, Eliezer toys with all the loopholes of Rowling's original works, and adds far more depth to the chara ...more

flag 7 likes · Like · see review

Apr 26, 2016 Anastasia Antonova rated it it was amazing

Я сделала это! 2007 вордовских или 25700 эпабовских страниц. Я уже не помню когда такие марафоны в последний раз делала.
Произведение стоит читать, и стоит не боятся его отнюдь не маленьких размеров. Оно сможет вас удивить. Запутать, насмешить, но да, в конечном итоге очень удивлить.
Стиль написания автора приятный, хоть и пестрит научными словечками, понять некоторые из них поможет разве что гугл.
Персонажи ушли от канона на столько далеко, на сколько это вообще возможно. Семимильными шагами. Н Я сделала это! 2007 вордовских или 25700 эпабовских страниц. Я уже не помню когда такие марафоны в последний раз делала.
Произведение стоит читать, и стоит не боятся его отнюдь не маленьких размеров. Оно сможет вас удивить. Запутать, насмешить, но да, в конечном итоге очень удивлить.
Стиль написания автора приятный, хоть и пестрит научными словечками, понять некоторые из них поможет разве что гугл.
Персонажи ушли от канона на столько далеко, на сколько это вообще возможно. Семимильными шагами. Но именно поэтому читать было интересно, трудно предугадать последствия чьих-либо действий.
У Гарри Поттера была Харизма. У Драко Малфоя была Харизма. У Невила Лонгботема была, чёрт подери, ХАРИЗМА. У Ро, увы, такого не было. Но и ее первоисточник хорош. Автор данного фанфика уделил внимание очень многим второстепенным персонажам, сделав их необычайно интересными и подающими надежду. Их действия было предугадать легче, но и они вносили приличный вклад в развитие сюжета.
В фанфике много загадок. Если вы любитель подобного - добро пожаловать, все 2007 вордовских страницы ждут когда вы их прочитаете.
О переводе: русский перевод хороший. Он не так давно был выложен до конца, и сейчас проходит вычитку. Переводчики передавали игру слов (автор её явно обожает) как можно точнее, а если не было возможности: оставляли сноску с объяснением в чем была вся соль.
Определённо, когда-нибудь я сяду и перечитаю Методы рационального мышления. Зная чем все закончится, я буду обращать внимание на малейшие детали, выискивая лазейки и подсказки автора.

Итоговая оценка: 10 из 10 ...more

flag 6 likes · Like · see review

Feb 26, 2014 Nente rated it it was ok

Shelves: dnf, yeah-right, read-original

Quite fun, but lots of wishful thinking by the author.
I never thought I'd say this, but Rowling is way more realistic! True, she made lots of irrational mistakes, some of which are taken up in this fic (such as the purchasing power of a Galleon, stupidity of Quidditch rules, and rules of magic - Rowling just never bothered to make up a consistent set, the only thing she could do was to write "they took a lot of complicated notes on Transfiguration"). And people in Rowling's books do not act logi ...more

flag 6 likes · Like · see review

Mar 17, 2015 Eivind rated it it was amazing

Shelves: favorites

This book is flawed in many ways. It's too long. The protagonist is (in periods) being too annoying. It strains suspension of disbelief pretty regularly, and it's a pity that boys/men hold the 3 most important positions.

Despite these flaws, there's no way I can give this book less than 5 stars. There's just too much that is hilariously good fun, and it's just too skillfull in spearing many of the more silly aspects of the original HP-series, yet it does so good-naturedly and with respect and ki ...more

flag 6 likes · Like · see review

May 03, 2011 Besha rated it liked it

Shelves: 2011

I read this simultaneously with Bruce Sterling's Distraction, and they’re a bit intertwined for me. They both feature male protagonists who are special by birth—Oscar Valparaiso is a clone with extrahuman abilities, Harry Potter is The Boy Who Lived And Was Then Raised To Be Rational. They both involve a lot of political maneuvering, interpersonal manipulation, and being terribly clever. They’re both quite funny.

This is a web serial, reimagining JK Rowling with a single point of divergence: Petu ...more

flag 5 likes · Like · see review

Aug 06, 2011 J. rated it really liked it

First novel-length fanfiction I've read all the way through to the end. Linked via http://www.metafilter.com/105731/Reme... --comments on the fic start about halfway down the page.

Our what-if here is: what if Aunt Petunia had begged Lily to magic her a better life (via, primarily, beauty), and Lily had done so? Petunia marries a brilliant professor instead of Vernon Dursley, and Harry grows up loved and educated instead of abused.

So: Harry is a Ravenclaw, and a prodigy, and intends to approach ...more

flag 5 likes · Like · see review

Nov 28, 2015 Oksana rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

*порада: сприймайте цю книгу як щось повністю самостійне і не пов'язуйте з справжнім ГП, щоб не розбити дитячих уявлень про чарівний образ :)
це щось зовсім інше, захоплююче і неочікуване, безумовно варте уваги любителів фантастики. для покоління, яке виросло на книжках Джоан Роулінг і якому Еліезер Юдковські допоміг знову зануритись у цей раціоналістичний, розібраний на більш зрозумілі дрібниці, світ. я навіть не знаходжу потрібних слів, щоб описати цей фанфік..часом він взриває і виносить мозок ...more

flag 5 likes · Like · see review

« previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 … next »

new topic
Discuss This Book

topics	posts	views	last activity
The Sword and Laser: Harry Potter & The Methods of Rationality spawns non-profit to teach cognitive rationality!	9	117	Apr 19, 2012 04:35PM

Readers Also Enjoyed

Genres

Fantasy

386 users

Fiction

184 users

Fan Fiction

86 users

Philosophy

56 users

See top shelves…

About Eliezer Yudkowsky

From Wikipedia:

Eliezer Shlomo Yudkowsky is an American artificial intelligence researcher concerned with the singularity and an advocate of friendly artificial intelligence, living in Redwood City, California.

Yudkowsky did not attend high school and is an autodidact with no formal education in artificial intelligence. He co-founded the nonprofit Singularity Institute for Artificial Intelligence ( ...more

More about Eliezer Yudkowsky...

Books by Eliezer Yudkowsky

A Girl Corrupted by the Internet is the Summoned Hero?!

Harry James Potter-Evans-Verres and the Methods of Rationality (Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality, #1)

More…

Share This Book

+ Share on your website

Trivia About Harry Potter and ...

15 trivia questions

More quizzes & trivia...

Quotes from Harry Potter and ...

“I only want power so I can get books.” — 129 likes

“World domination is such an ugly phrase. I prefer to call it world optimisation.” — 113 likes

More quotes…

title link	preview: Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality
avg rating	preview: Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Goodreads rating: 4.38 (8033 ratings)
small image	preview: click here [close]
med image	preview: click here [close]
BBCode	[url=https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/10016013-harry-potter-and-the-methods-of-rationality?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_book][img]https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1293582551l/10016013.jpg[/img][/url] [url=https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/10016013-harry-potter-and-the-methods-of-rationality?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_book]Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality by Eliezer Yudkowsky[/url]

See a Problem?

Preview — Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality by Eliezer Yudkowsky

Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality

Friend Reviews

Reader Q&A

Popular Answered Questions

Lists with This Book

Community Reviews

new topic
Discuss This Book

Readers Also Enjoyed

Genres

About Eliezer Yudkowsky

Books by Eliezer Yudkowsky

Share This Book

Share on your website

Trivia About Harry Potter and ...

Quotes from Harry Potter and ...