Ralph Morgan 1933, 1938-1940 Eddie Cantor 1933-1935 Robert Montgomery 1935-1938, 1946-1947 Edward Arnold 1940-1942 James Cagney 1942-1944 George Murphy 1944-1946 Ronald Reagan 1947-1952, 1959-1960 Walter Pidgeon 1952-1957 Leon Ames 1957-1958 Howard Keel 1958-1959 George Chandler 1960-1963 Dana Andrews 1963-1965 Charlton Heston 1965-1971 John Gavin 1971-1973 Dennis Weaver 1973-1975 Kathleen Nolan 1975-1979 William Schallert 1979-1981 Edward Asner 1981-1985 Patty Duke 1985-1988 Barry Gordon 1988-1995 Richard Masur 1995-1999 William Daniels 1999-2001 Melissa Gilbert 2001-2005 Alan Rosenberg 2005-2009 Ken Howard 2009-2012