I was looking through Reddit late last night when I came across this: https://www.reddit.com/r/agnostic/comments/62cq1b/what_a_deal/

Here's the breakdown of why it's bad:

1) I created man and woman with original sin

Original Sin was the result of Adam and Eve eating the fruit from the Tree of Knowledge. God didn't create us with Original Sin.

2) Then I destroyed them for sinning

We're still capable of sinning today. It just doesn't matter because Jesus died. The verse they're referring to said that God saw that man had become fully and completely wicked. Their inclination was to evil all the time.

3) ...I will kill myself as a sacrifice to save you from the sin I gave you in the first place

Again God didn't give us sin.