• Home
  • Mail
  • Flickr
  • Tumblr
  • News
  • Sports
  • Finance
  • Celebrity
  • Answers
  • Groups
  • Mobile
  • More
Yahoo
    • Skip to Navigation
    • Skip to Main Content
    • Skip to Related Content
    • Mail
    News Home
    Follow Us
    • US
    • World
    • Politics
    • Tech
    • Science
    • Odd News
    • ABC News
    • Yahoo Originals
    • Katie Couric
    • Matt Bai

    Op-Ed: Why Elizabeth Warren is no longer the darling of the left

    Jordan Chariton
    CNBCJanuary 17, 2017

    Regardless of Chuck Schumer and Nancy Pelosi's titles—and to the comical dismay of corporate, establishment Democrats—Bernie Sanders has become the defacto leader of the Democratic Party.

    Sunday in Warren, Michigan put an exclamation point on the sentence, as Sanders, alongside Schumer, brought out 8,000 people on a bitterly cold winter day to fight against Obamacare repeal.

    Even the establishment media is waking up—granted a year too late.

    "That's the future of the Democratic Party," Joe Scarborough, echoing Mika Brzezinski's sentiment, said on Morning Joe Monday. "He sounds just as relevant today as he did a year ago."

    So, as the mainstream media opportunistically tries to Feel The Bern after ignoring Sanders when it mattered (both CNN and MSNBC recently held primetime town halls with him), you know who's become less relevant?

    Senator Elizabeth Warren .

    The one-time progressive rock star—who activists tried to summon to run in 2016 with hopes of bringing down Hillary Clinton—has already made moves that many inside the Beltway believe are a precursor to a run in 2020.

    But, much to the shock of genius corporate journalists who continue to live in their alternate, elitist bubble and obsess over Donald Trump's tweets rather than the endless struggles of working people, the progressive movement has soured on one if its past heroes.

    A majority of progressive voters and activists I spoke to during my campaign reporting were disgusted with Warren's cowardice during the Democratic Primary, where she dodged on endorsing the most progressive candidate to run since FDR.

    The firebrand, anti-Wall Street Senator was wildly popular in her home-state of Massachusetts, but she decided not to endorse Sanders before the Super Tuesday primary. Sanders lost Massachusetts by less than two points, causing progressives to believe the state—and momentum—would have gone to Sanders had Warren endorsed and campaigned with him across the state.

    Larger than her Massachusetts mistake, Warren's choice to passionately campaign for Clinton—the antithesis of all she proclaimed to stand against during her meteoric rise isn't a fact progressive Sanders aficionados will simply forgive and forget.

    Furthermore, Warren—along with the corporate media—was inexplicably MIA during the fight against the Dakota Access Pipeline, saying nothing as thousands of unarmed, peaceful Native Americans and environmental activists were illegally arrested and shot at with tear gas, pepper spray, rubber bullets, freezing water, and grenades by de facto oil police in North Dakota.

    Like her decision to conveniently endorse Clinton when Sanders was mathematically eliminated, Warren finally chose to speak out against DAPL on the same day the Army Corps of Engineers denied a crucial permit for the pipeline's completion.

    This kind of calculated, Johnny-Come-Lately progressivism doesn't cut it for the millions of progressives looking to rally behind a leader as the road to 2020 narrows.

    So, the time for choosing is upon Warren. She must decide: what do I truly stand for? Right now, there's a large swath of the progressive movement that's no longer sure.

    She must choose between being a strong progressive who largely ignores political calculations in favor of fighting for workers and minorities, or continue serving as a one-trick pony that steals the show by yelling at bankers during congressional hearings, but isn't trusted by the movement to do much more.

    Warren must decide if she is going to stand out as a progressive leader on issues that go beyond Wall Street and the rigged economy—such as ensuring clean water and safety for the people instead of unfettered profits for the oil companies.

    If Warren chooses the progressive path, she'll still need to explain her dubious choices during the 2016 election and beyond.

    But if Sanders decides against running in four years, Warren—in a political climate with a jarring scarcity of true progressive leaders—could have a chance to climb back up the progressive ranks and possibly serve as the movement's best chance to finally take the White House.

    The clock is ticking.

    Commentary by Jordan Chariton, a political reporter for The Young Turks, reporting on the presidential campaign trail. He can be seen on TYT Politics. Before TYT, Jordan was a reporter for TheWrap and TVNewser. Follow him on Twitter @JordanChariton.

    For more insight from CNBC contributors, follow @CNBCopinion on Twitter.



    More From CNBC

    • Top News and Analysis
    • Latest News Video
    • Personal Finance

    What to Read Next

    • Mark Zuckerberg is suing hundreds of Hawaiians to protect his 700-acre Kauai estate

      1956 messages3%67%30%
    • Rick Perry and Al Franken have an oops moment during confirmation hearing

      18 messages0%65%35%
    • ‘Flip or Flop’ Star Tarek El Moussa Blasts ‘Irresponsible Media’ Over ‘Fake News’

      835 messages6%62%32%
    • #2 of 10 Most Popular News Galleries of 2016: 9/11: Then and now - 15 years later

      900 messages4%57%39%
    • Mnuchin hearing begins with Senate squabble over joke

      23 messages7%55%38%
    • Trump ready to sign executive actions on Day One

      1122 messages8%68%24%
    • Teen Who Was Kidnapped as a Baby Knew About Abduction, Court Records Say

      164 messages5%62%33%
    • While Drama Swirls, Olivia Munn Stuns in Yellow Gown

      258 messages6%77%17%
    • #8 of 10 Most Popular News Galleries of 2016: Deadly attack at Istanbul's Ataturk Airport

      901 messages10%13%77%
    • Veterans Urge McCain to Vote No on Tillerson Nomination

      5 messages0%90%10%
    • President Trump and the end of the American Century

      4526 messages7%58%35%
    • EpiPen competitor Auvi-Q comes back Feb. 14 with a pricing scheme that will blow your mind

      72 messages4%75%21%
    • Trump sweeps into Washington with a wave and a salute

      580 messages10%68%22%
    • #10 of 10 Most Popular News Galleries of 2016: Stunning images from the 2016 National Geographic Nature Photographer of the Year contest

      180 messages17%69%14%
    • Tim Ferriss Morning Routine

    • The Rock Brings 15-Year-Old Daughter to the People’s Choice Awards – Then Jokingly Drops the F-Bomb During Acceptance Speech

      258 messages7%72%21%

    Obama commutes 330 drug sentences on last day as president

    Mike: Hope they track the 1,715 to see how many become repeat offenders.

    Join the Conversation
    1 / 5

    664

    • Obama at final press conference: ‘We’re going to be OK’
      Yahoo News

      Obama at final press conference: ‘We’re going to be OK’

      In the hourlong question-and-answer session, Obama also defended the news media, which Trump likes to bash, and listed the political and social issues that would lead him to speak out after he leaves the White House to his successor. There were no questions about Syria, North Korea or the Iran nuclear deal.

      • In farewell press conference, Obama says ‘new cyber age’ will require new tools
        In farewell press conference, Obama says ‘new cyber age’ will require new tools
        GeekWire
      • Obama's final presser gives nod to press freedom
        Obama's final presser gives nod to press freedom
        USA Today
      4,356Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Scott Pruitt on climate change: ‘My personal opinion is immaterial’
      Yahoo News

      Scott Pruitt on climate change: ‘My personal opinion is immaterial’

      Pressed by Democratic senators for his views on the causes of climate change, the Trump administration’s choice to run the Environmental Protection Agency insisted at his confirmation hearing Wednesday morning that his “personal opinion” was “immaterial” to how he would do his job. Democrats on the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee questioned Oklahoma Attorney General Scott Pruitt closely on his history of suing the agency he has been nominated to lead, his statements questioning mainstream climate science and his close ties to the oil and gas industries. Republicans were much friendlier, mostly lamenting the impact of regulations on fossil-fuel industry jobs, something Pruitt promised to take into account.

      • Trump's Cabinet Pick Ryan Zinke Supports Scrapping Obama's Arctic Drilling Ban
        Trump's Cabinet Pick Ryan Zinke Supports Scrapping Obama's Arctic Drilling Ban
        Good Morning America
      • How Trump's EPA Pick, Scott Pruitt, Has Favored State Over Federal Authority on the Environment
        How Trump's EPA Pick, Scott Pruitt, Has Favored State Over Federal Authority on the Environment
        ABC News
      1,047Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Suspect in Florida officer's killing released from hospital
      Associated Press

      Suspect in Florida officer's killing released from hospital

      An affidavit, filed with the Orange County Clerk of Courts a day after 41-year-old Markeith Loyd was arrested in an abandoned home, shows authorities want to make sure he remains in custody, as is customary for a fugitive facing murder charges. Loyd was arrested Tuesday night after a manhunt that lasted more than a week. Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi said Wednesday that President-elect Donald Trump had a phone conversation with Clayton's husband.

      • Orlando Police Officer Shooting Suspect In Custody
        Orlando Police Officer Shooting Suspect In Custody
        International Business Times
      • Watch live: Orlando police discuss capture of Markeith Loyd
        Watch live: Orlando police discuss capture of Markeith Loyd
        Orlando Sentinel
      509Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Gambia's President-elect to be sworn in at embassy in Senegal -officials
      Reuters

      Gambia's President-elect to be sworn in at embassy in Senegal -officials

      Gambia's President-elect Adama Barrow will be sworn in at a ceremony in the Gambian embassy in neighbouring Senegal on Thursday, diplomatic sources and party officials said. Then we can make arrangements for him to go back to Gambia," Isatou Toure, a senior Barrow aide, told Reuters.

      • As Election Winner Is Sworn In, 2 Men Now Claim To Be President Of Gambia
        As Election Winner Is Sworn In, 2 Men Now Claim To Be President Of Gambia
        NPR.org
      • Gambia state of emergency as it happened: Entrenched President clings to power as military intervention looms
        Gambia state of emergency as it happened: Entrenched President clings to power as military intervention looms
        International Business Times UK
      1Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Teen Abducted 18 Years Ago Says She Will Have '2 Moms,' but Still Loves Accused Kidnapper
      Inside Edition

      Teen Abducted 18 Years Ago Says She Will Have '2 Moms,' but Still Loves Accused Kidnapper

      “I love her,” 18-year-old Alexis Manigo told Inside Edition. Manigo said she had a “fantastic” and “normal” life while living with Williams, who she believed to be her mother. While she is learning about her biological family, Manigo says she will still recognize Williams as her mother.

      • Suspect in 1998 kidnapping of newborn Kamiyah Mobley is back in Jacksonville
        Suspect in 1998 kidnapping of newborn Kamiyah Mobley is back in Jacksonville
        The Florida Times-Union
      • Alexis Manigo: Teen kidnapped as newborn says she has no hate towards woman who raised her Gloria Williams
        Alexis Manigo: Teen kidnapped as newborn says she has no hate towards woman who raised her Gloria Williams
        CBS News
      88Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Failed MH370 Search Reveals the Secrets of the Sea Floor
      Popular Mechanics

      Failed MH370 Search Reveals the Secrets of the Sea Floor

      The deep-sea sonar search for Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 may not have found the plane but will reveal more about how land beneath the Indian Ocean formed over millions of years and where oil fields could lie. National geoscience agency Geoscience Australia will soon release detailed sonar mapping of 120,000 square kilometers (46,000 square miles) of seabed that was searched for the wreckage of the Boeing 777 that vanished with 239 passengers and crew on March 8, 2014. The unique information about plate tectonics would interest geoscientists as well as oil and gas explorers, said Australian National University marine geologist Neville Exon, who has advised Geoscience Australia on the sonar data.

      • Australia on the defensive offers hope of new MH370 hunt
        Australia on the defensive offers hope of new MH370 hunt
        AFP
      • MH370 and 5 Other Unsolved Aviation Mysteries
        MH370 and 5 Other Unsolved Aviation Mysteries
        ABC News
      37Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Japan hotelier's Nanjing Massacre denial sparks tourism boycott calls
      Reuters

      Japan hotelier's Nanjing Massacre denial sparks tourism boycott calls

      By Elaine Lies and Megumi Lim TOKYO (Reuters) - A Japanese hotelier's denial of a 1937 massacre by Japanese troops in the Chinese city of Nanjing has prompted Chinese social media calls for a boycott of travel to Japan, threatening tourist arrivals days before the Lunar New Year holidays. The furor erupted over books by Toshio Motoya, the president of Tokyo-based hotel and real estate developer APA Group, which contain his revisionist views and are placed in every room of the company's 400-plus APA Hotels. In one, printed in English and Japanese and entitled "The Real History of Japan", he says the "Nanking Massacre story" was "impossible", blaming looting and killings on members of a branch of the Chinese military who had shed their uniforms.

      • Japan hotelier's Nanjing massacre denial angers China
        Japan hotelier's Nanjing massacre denial angers China
        BBC News
      • Japanese hotel chain under fire from China over WWII massacre denial
        Japanese hotel chain under fire from China over WWII massacre denial
        Newsweek
      35Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Many Iran firefighters feared trapped in building collapse
      AFP

      Many Iran firefighters feared trapped in building collapse

      Rescue workers in Tehran were desperately hunting for firefighters trapped under the rubble after a fire Thursday led to the collapse of Iran's oldest high-rise, the 15-storey Plasco building. Officials had yet to confirm if anyone had been killed, but Tehran mayor Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf told state television that between 20 and 25 firefighters were thought to be inside when the building fell. Three people were pulled alive from the rubble and taken to hospital, the head of Tehran's emergency services said, according to the ISNA news agency.

      • Iran shocked by deadly fire, collapse of Tehran high-rise
        Iran shocked by deadly fire, collapse of Tehran high-rise
        Associated Press
      • Iconic Tehran high-rise collapses in flames, reportedly killing 30 firefighters
        Iconic Tehran high-rise collapses in flames, reportedly killing 30 firefighters
        The Week
      67Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Horrifying Video Shows Woman in Crosswalk Being Run Over and Dragged by School Bus
      Inside Edition

      Horrifying Video Shows Woman in Crosswalk Being Run Over and Dragged by School Bus

      Startling surveillance video posted to Twitter this week shows a woman in New York being hit by a school bus, which then runs her over.   The victim was crossing a Brooklyn intersection when she was struck by a yellow mini-bus. She suffered non-life-threatening

      • ‘Thank God I’m still alive’: Woman survives being run over by bus
        ‘Thank God I’m still alive’: Woman survives being run over by bus
        New York Post
      • NYPD Now Says It Issued Summons For Bus Driver Who Nearly Killed Brooklyn Woman
        NYPD Now Says It Issued Summons For Bus Driver Who Nearly Killed Brooklyn Woman
        Gothamist
      114Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Trump’s team says he’s ‘troubled’ by Chelsea Manning commutation
      Yahoo News

      Trump’s team says he’s ‘troubled’ by Chelsea Manning commutation

      WASHINGTON, D.C. — Incoming White House press secretary Sean Spicer said President-elect Donald Trump is disturbed by President Obama’s decision to commute the prison sentence of convicted leaker Chelsea Manning. “I think the president-elect is troubled by this action,” Spicer said during a Wednesday news conference at Trump’s presidential transition team headquarters. Spicer was also asked if Trump wanted to see WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange make good on a promise to allow himself to be extradited to the United States if Manning was given a deal.

      • Trump's 48-hour inauguration schedule
        Trump's 48-hour inauguration schedule
        USA Today
      • With agriculture pick, Trump rounds out his cabinet
        With agriculture pick, Trump rounds out his cabinet
        AFP
      1,716Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Photos of the day — January 17, 2017
      Yahoo News Photo Staff

      Photos of the day — January 17, 2017

      Impoverished Indian children watch a performance as part of advocacy against child labor in Allahabad, India; women loyal to the Houthi movement parade to show support to the movement in Sanaa, Yemen; and dogs are blessed by a priest outside San Anton

      19Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Virginia man convicted of 2006 slaying of family is executed
      Associated Press

      Virginia man convicted of 2006 slaying of family is executed

      Ricky Gray was pronounced dead at 9:42 p.m. following a lethal injection at the Greensville Correctional Center in Jarratt. Gray showed no emotion as he was walked into the execution chamber wearing blue jeans and handcuffs. Gray was condemned to death in 2006 for the murders of 9-year-old Stella Harvey and 4-year-old sister Ruby, and sentenced to life in prison for the slaying of their parents, Bryan and Kathryn Harvey.

      • Virginia inmate executed despite arguments against drug 'cocktail'
        Virginia inmate executed despite arguments against drug 'cocktail'
        Reuters
      • Virginia executes Ricky Gray for killing family in 2006
        Virginia executes Ricky Gray for killing family in 2006
        UPI
      2,002Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Reuters

      Arab Israeli and policeman killed in suspected car ramming attack in southern Israel

      Police in Israel said an Arab Israeli on Wednesday rammed his car into a group of policemen in the southern Negev region, killing one before being shot dead, though a rights activist who was present disputed it was an attack. Police spokeswoman Merav Lapidot said the suspect was a local teacher who "surged towards the forces intending to kill" and that riots erupted after he was shot.

      182Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Teen abducted as newborn still loves only mom she's known
      Associated Press

      Teen abducted as newborn still loves only mom she's known

      An 18-year-old woman abducted as a newborn from a hospital in Jacksonville, Florida, says she still loves the only mother she has known. Manigo met with her birth parents, Craig Aiken and Shanara Mobley, last weekend in Walterboro, South Carolina, where she was found earlier this month. "I feel like I do owe them that, to give them a chance, you know, get to know them," Manigo said.

      • Teen Abducted at Birth Breaks Her Silence, Defends Alleged Kidnapper: 'I Will Always Love Her'
        Teen Abducted at Birth Breaks Her Silence, Defends Alleged Kidnapper: 'I Will Always Love Her'
        Us Weekly
      • Teen stolen as baby still loves 'mother'
        Teen stolen as baby still loves 'mother'
        CNN
      203Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • When presidential inaugurations go very, very wrong
      National Constitution Center

      When presidential inaugurations go very, very wrong

      As Constitution Daily counts down to Inauguration Day,  we look back at three presidential ceremonies from the 1800s that ended very badly. Mobs descend on Jackson’s White House. For example, there were constant rumors that Abraham Lincoln would be killed at his 1861 inauguration.

      150Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Spate of strong earthquakes hit snowbound central Italy, one dead
      Reuters

      Spate of strong earthquakes hit snowbound central Italy, one dead

      By Philip Pullella ROME (Reuters) - A series of strong earthquakes hit snowbound central Italy on Wednesday, a region devastated by deadly tremors last year, killing one man and forcing schools and rail links to close. Much of the area had already been abandoned after last year's earthquakes. Prime Minister Paolo Gentiloni said soldiers would help rescue teams get to the affected villages.

      • WATCH: Four earthquakes in four hours in an already devastated Italy
        WATCH: Four earthquakes in four hours in an already devastated Italy
        Salon.com
      • 'Catastrophe' in central Italy on day of four big quakes
        'Catastrophe' in central Italy on day of four big quakes
        BBC News
      19Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Senegal troops move into Gambia as new president sworn in
      AFP

      Senegal troops move into Gambia as new president sworn in

      Senegalese troops entered The Gambia on Thursday in support of its new President Adama Barrow, who took office demanding loyalty from his own armed forces in a tense standoff with his defeated rival. Barrow was sworn in at The Gambia's embassy in Dakar, although longtime leader Yahya Jammeh has refused to step down despite international pressure following his December election loss. Dressed all in white, 51-year-old Barrow waved to crowds at the ceremony that anointed him, seeking to end the 22-year rule of Jammeh, who has not been seen but is believed to be still in Banjul.

      • Adama Barrow inaugurated as President of Gambia amid standoff with predecessor Yahya Jammeh
        Adama Barrow inaugurated as President of Gambia amid standoff with predecessor Yahya Jammeh
        International Business Times UK
      • Senegalese troops say they'll cross the border if Gambia's ousted president doesn't step down
        Senegalese troops say they'll cross the border if Gambia's ousted president doesn't step down
        Business Insider UK
      5Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • US Park Place Equestrian Team Gets Ready for Inauguration
      ABC News Videos

      US Park Place Equestrian Team Gets Ready for Inauguration

      ABC News' Charli James stops by the National Mall in Washington, D.C to chat with the riders. From the Washington monument behind me and I am here with officer Jack evil and his horse. Guinness I'm they are part of the United States park police mounted.

      7Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Obama commutes Chelsea Manning’s sentence
      Yahoo News

      Obama commutes Chelsea Manning’s sentence

      President Obama has commuted the 35-year prison sentence of Chelsea Manning, paving the way for the Army intelligence analyst turned high-profile leaker to be freed on May 17, the White House announced Tuesday. Manning was on a list of 209 commutations and 64 pardons released Tuesday, though they may not be Obama’s final acts of clemency before he leaves office at midday on Jan. 20. Edward Snowden’s name was not on the list.

      • Paul Ryan Rips Chelsea Manning Decision as 'Outrageous'
        Paul Ryan Rips Chelsea Manning Decision as 'Outrageous'
        Newsmax
      • Now's A Good Time To Listen To Thurston Moore's Homage To Chelsea Manning, 'Chelsea's Kiss'
        Now's A Good Time To Listen To Thurston Moore's Homage To Chelsea Manning, 'Chelsea's Kiss'
        UPROXX
      10.8kReactions. Click to view reactions
    • Skin Medication Can Be Lethal for Pets, FDA Warns
      LiveScience.com

      Skin Medication Can Be Lethal for Pets, FDA Warns

      A cream used to treat skin cancer and abnormal skin lesions can be lethal for pets, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) warned today. The agency said the medication, called fluorouracil, can make pets sick, and even kill them in some cases. "People using this medication should use care when applying and storing the medication if they are also in a household with pets, as even very small amounts could be dangerous to these animals," the FDA said in a statement.

      2Reactions. Click to view reactions
    • Obama commutes 330 drug sentences on last day as president

      664 messages6%69%25%
    • PETA calls for ‘A Dog’s Purpose’ boycott over video showing alleged abuse

      905 messages7%57%36%
    • Protesting the Dakota Access pipeline

      2083 messages4%61%35%
    • Presidential Inauguration Day Safety Tips

      11 messages0%82%18%
    • ‘Monster Mom’ Sentenced to 43 Years in Prison for Killing Her 11-Year-Old Daughter

      2184 messages4%60%36%
    • Foreclosed mall once valued at $190M is auctioned for $100

      1333 messages2%81%17%
    • Trump retains 50 key Obama aides (for now)

      716 messages6%69%25%
    • Warplanes pound Aleppo – Dozens dead

      1624 messages4%63%33%
    • Sneak Peek at 'They Also Ran' Gallery of Presidential Losers

      4 messages0%75%25%
    • Alibaba founder Jack Ma has a brutal theory of how America went wrong over the past 30 years

      1843 messages7%68%25%
    • The colossal price to fly a pair of B-2 bombers to hit two ISIS camps in Libya

      68 messages3%75%22%
    • Help
    • Privacy
    • Suggestions
    • About our Ads
    • Terms