//
Quickread
×
Like what you're reading?
Never miss a thing with the HuffPost Crime newsletter!
  Sign me up for The Morning Email, too.
Newsletter may include personalized content. Learn more.
SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone. See the Facebook Help Center for more information.
SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone. See the Facebook Help Center for more information.
Huffpost Crime
  • Like
    Like
    444k444k
  • Newsletters
    Get CrimeNewsletters
  • Huffington Post Search
    Search The Huffington Post

Men Sentenced To Longer Prison Terms Than Women For Same Crimes, Study Says

Posted: Updated:
Shutter stock
Shutter stock
If you're a convicted criminal, the best thing you can have going for you might be your gender.
A new study by Sonja Starr, an assistant law professor at the University of Michigan, found that men are given much higher sentences than women convicted of the same crimes in federal court.
The study found that men receive sentences that are 63 percent higher, on average, than their female counterparts.
Starr also found that females arrested for a crime are also significantly more likely to avoid charges and convictions entirely, and twice as likely to avoid incarceration if convicted.
Other research has found evidence of the same gender gap, though Starr asserts that the disparity is actually larger than previously suspected because other studies haven't looked at the role of plea bargains and other pre-sentencing steps in the criminal justice system.
A 2009 study suggested the difference in sentencing might arise because "judges treat women more leniently for practical reasons, such as their greater caretaking responsibility."
Past studies have also found that minority men are, on average, given longer prison sentences than white men convicted of the same crimes.

Also on HuffPost:

Close
Prison Breaks: They Made A Run For It
1 of 12
(AP Photo/Michigan State Police)
  • Michael David Elliot
    In this surveillance photo from a Middlebury, Ind., gas station provided by the Michigan State Police is Michael David Elliot who escaped from the Ionia Correctional Facility in mid-Michigan Sunday, Feb. 2, 2014 after creating a hole at the bottom of the two perimeter fences and crawling through, according to authorities. Elliot was serving a life sentence for fatally shooting four people and burning down their Gladwin County house in 1993.
  • Ronaldo Silva
    Ronaldo Silva allegedly broke out of a Brazilian prison by dressing in drag in April 2012. He was caught less than an hour later by a cop who noticed that he was walking funnily in heels. Read more.
  • Tiffany Hurd
    Tiffany Hurd, 36, actually allegedly commited a jail break-IN. She was nabbed in July 2012 trying to hop a barbed-wire fence to enter Butler County Jail in Ohio. Read more.
  • Philippine Jail Break
    Eleven prisoners, including bandit leader Datukan Samad, allegedly hacksawed their way through the iron grills of Maguindanao Province Jail in July 2012. Read more.
  • Kansas Jailbreak
    This picture shows 3 of the 4 inmates who allegedly escaped from a central Kansas jail in April 2012. Murderer Santos Carrera-Morales (center), kidnapper Eric James (left), assault convict Alberto Barraza-Lujan (not pictured) and aggravated battery convict Drew Wade (right) were all eventually discovered in Nebraska by authorities. The incident raised questions about prison security. 3 of the 4 prisoners allegedly drove away from the jail in a Nissan Altima. Read more.
  • Bobcat Break-In
    Sometimes furry critters want to join the convicts. In July 2012, authorities removed a bobcat crawling around the roof of the Monroe Correctional Complex in Washington. Check out the animalicious video here.
  • Cortez Hooper, Quincy Stewart
    Murder suspects Hooper and Stewart allegedly escaped from a jail in Arkansas in May 2012. The pair reportedly used a hacksaw to break the bars on the windows of their second-story cells and smashed a pane of glass. Authorities say they pushed their mattresses out the window to soften their landings. The two were discovered by authorities shortly thereafter. Read more.
  • Failed Jail Break Plot
    Donald Kohut and Justin Heflin were charged with plotting to help murderer Christa Pike escape from prison in March 2012. Pike was convicted with her then-boyfriend of the 1996 slaying of Colleen Slemmer. The motive for murder was believed to stem from a love triangle. Pike and Tadaryl Shipp carved a pentagram into Slemmer's chest and then stabbed and beat her to death, according to authorities. Read more.
  • Suitcase Prison Plot
    In July 2011, Maria del Mar Arjona, 19, allegedly tried to sneak her inmate husband Juan Ramirez Tijerina out of prison in Mexico in some luggage. Read more.
  • Armin Christian
    Armin Christian, 65, was found in May 2012 after fleeing prison in South Carolina 31 years ago. Christian was reportedly living in Rhode Island as a handyman under a new name. He was originally sentenced to 11 months in prison for failing to pay child support. Read more.
  • Man Got Out To Get Off
    Even inmates can get horny. In March 2012, murder suspect Arien L'Italien allegedly left his cell and wandered over to the women's inmate block, in order to have sex with Karla Wilson. Authorities spotted L'Italien as he was crawling back to his cell. L'Italian and Wilson were both then transferred to different areas of the facility. Read more.
  • Next
Share
Tweet
Michael David Elliot
In this surveillance photo from a Middlebury, Ind., gas station provided by the Michigan State Police is Michael David Elliot who escaped from the Ionia Correctional Facility in mid-Michigan Sunday, Feb. 2, 2014 after creating a hole at the bottom of the two perimeter fences and crawling through, according to authorities. Elliot was serving a life sentence for fatally shooting four people and burning down their Gladwin County house in 1993.
Advertisement
Share this
close
Current Slide

Suggest a correction

Around the Web

 
Click here to view Conversations

Conversations

Add a comment

 

.
 
.
.
.
  • The Dude-bro Consortium
    Crickets from the feminists because feminists only concern themselves with equality when women aren't getting enough cushy, high-paying jobs.
    • Rew Power-Branfield · Top Commenter · Dublin, Ireland
      Men get longer sentences because of patriarchy. Patriarchy views women as 'weaker' and 'non-threatening', thus leading to shorter sentences. Also, in a patriarchal society, women are expected to be the primary caretakers and bare the burden of most of the childcare and domestic work:

      A 2009 study suggested the difference in sentencing might arise because "judges treat women more leniently for practical reasons, such as their greater caretaking responsibility."

      Being seen as weaker and being expected to do more childcare/housework is not a 'female privilege'. This is just another example of how, yet again, patriarchy harms men too.

      Feminists are fighting against these notions which will contribute to more equal sentences in the future.
      Reply · Like
      · 24 · Edited · September 4, 2014 at 6:35am
      .
    • Chad Bryant Kaskaske · Top Commenter · University of New Mexico
      Rew Power-Branfield "This is just another example of how, yet again, patriarchy harms men too."

      yes, and feminists are silent about it. That's why we need MRA's to stand up for men because men's problems are ignored and trivialized by feminism. Feminism needs to fix all of women's inequalities first. Which is fine. Just don't tell me I need feminism or other nonsense. You can be women's rights activist and I'll stick men's rights activism. Not that I do much anyway.
      Reply · Like
      · 50 · September 24, 2014 at 1:59pm
      .
    • Michael Connell · HACC - Lancaster Campus
      Chad Bryant Kaskaske then what is your Men's rights Movement doing about it, you can read the study and see the recommendations. I'm sure a leading MRA website like a voice for men you could see articles arguing for these or at least discussing some of the reasoning offered in the discussion segment of the paper.

      oh wait
      http://www.avoiceformen.com/?s=prison+sentences
      Reply · Like
      · 4 · September 27, 2014 at 9:40am
      .
     
    .
    .
    .
    .
  • Mike Williams · Top Commenter · English Teacher at 개원초등학교
    Is it just me, or is "because of patriarchy" becoming eerily similar to duckspeak in 1984?
    • William Braddell · Top Commenter · CSS at Inland Revenue Department
      It most certainly isn't just you.
      Reply · Like
      · 4 · February 13 at 2:21am
      .
    • Women against women against feminism
      We have to keep repeating it because people like you continue to blame feminists for the status quo we are trying to change. What you're actually saying is, our movement hasn't gone far enough yet, so it's our fault. Obviously feminists aren't going to argue that women should receive harsher sentences, but we are not exactly pushing for men to receive them either. If you want to go out and try to get men's sentencing made more lenient, then go for it, but don't expect us to do your work for you.
      You can't have it both ways. Do you want women in the armed forces? Then you have something in common with feminists. But if you don't, then don't complain that way more men are killed in combat than women. Same thing as the imprisonment stuff. You can't just pick and choose examples of inequality and then go, ha, feminists, this is why the world doesn't need you. In fact, it's why the world DOES need feminism. Without feminism, the men's rights movement would NEVER have come into existence. I wonder why that is exactly? If men have always been so disadvantaged as compared with women, then why didn't they start a movement FIRST to fight for their rights? Maybe because their rights on the basis of GENDER - not as individuals, and not according to the class they were born into, but by pure virtue of gender, have never been threatened. Ever. There is not one right that women have in society that men have never had.
      Reply · Like
      · 1 · April 20 at 9:55pm
      .
    • Ken Francis · Top Commenter · Ottawa, Ontario
      Women against women against feminism No one is asking you to do anything for us (unlike HeforShe). But it would be great if feminists would stop issuing bomb threats when men and those who care about them gather to talk about the issues that complicate or threaten their lives. Thanks.

      #womenagainstfeminism
      Reply · Like
      · 2 · May 3 at 5:18am
      .
     
    .
    .
    .
    .
  • Matt Cash · Top Commenter · Electrician at New Mexico Tech
    Can I say that my male privilege is checked at this point?
    • Christopher Siebert · University of Wyoming
      Those men get free meals and a roof over there head. That's privilege right there, especially when you consider the percentage of homeless that are womyn, oh, wait. PATRIARCHY!!!!!
      Reply · Like
      · 17 · November 8, 2014 at 7:05pm
      .
    • Marty Russell Woodcock · Top Commenter
      Christopher Siebert Yet, if women were being treated as brutally as men, in the "legal" system, feminists would be up in arms. Equality only works one way in a feminist mind.
      Reply · Like
      · 9 · January 7 at 7:00am
      .
    • Derek Taylor · OSG at Royal Mail, but don't tell anyone.
      Marty Russell Woodcock I would agree, since there is even a campaign in Scotland not to build a new female prison. Since they think more community service would be better.
      Reply · Like
      · 3 · January 27 at 12:22am
      .
     
    .
    .
    .
    .
  • Adeola Tobi Ola · Top Commenter · The University of Sheffield
    Where's that male privilege when you need it?
    • Gemma Baloo · Top Commenter · Swindon
      Just ask the Afganie guys who beat a women to death and filmed it - with boy children there too as apparently its fun for all the guys
      Reply · Like
      · March 24 at 9:47am
      .
    • Ken Francis · Top Commenter · Ottawa, Ontario
      Gemma Baloo Nice strawman.
      Reply · Like
      · May 3 at 5:19am
      .
     
    .
    .
    .
    .
  • Bledi Lalollari · Top Commenter · St. Louis
    Could This Be the fabled Female Privilege We Hear So Much About? Why I Think It Is!
       
      .
      .
      .
      .
      • Gemma Baloo · Top Commenter · Swindon
        Ahh but you men have already proven you can't be trusted with it
        Reply · Like
        · March 24 at 9:47am
        .
      • Reinou van Veen · Top Commenter
        Gemma Baloo "you men"? you are more horrible to men than men have ever been to you...
        Reply · Like
        · 1 · April 16 at 7:15am
        .
      • Ken Francis · Top Commenter · Ottawa, Ontario
        Gemma Baloo you prove that misandry is the foundation of feminist practice.
        Reply · Like
        · May 3 at 5:20am
        .
       
      .
      .
      .
      .
    • Northern Iggy · Top Commenter
      Warren Farrell's book "They Myth of Male Power" documented this 20 years ago. Feminist organizations like the National Organization of Women (N.O.W.) have ACTIVELY quashed and undermined reporting of these events. No... feminism is not interested in righting this wrong, because it favors women. Feminism is a special interest lobby group for women, nothing more. It's high time people start calling it what it really is.
         
        .
        .
        .
        .
      • Gustavo Suhett Helmer · Top Commenter
        Feminists, Fighting for increasing male imprisonment (specially black men) and reducing female incarceration and then clamming "patriarchy" when those facts are highlighted.
        Feminism must be the greatest tool of patriarchy them (but it's probably the other way around, while feminism is actually a tool of traditionalism).
           
          .
          .
          .
          .
        • Scott Radcliff · New Fairfield High School
          I agree with you , but -- Holy Cow -- let's dead honest -- women want it too It's Everything to both Sexes. It's Who we Are. Don't you agree?
             
            .
            .
            .
            .
          • Rob William
            The Roland Dow case in New Hampshire testifies to this, they both committed the same crime and the male gets 26 to life while the female is eligible for parole in 2 months from now
            • Gemma Baloo · Top Commenter · Swindon
              Jessica Linscott, 25, is already serving a prison sentence in connection with a 2012 assault case involving her 3-year-old son. New Hampshire authorities are now focusing on Linscott's former boyfriend, Roland Dow, 28, whose trial begins Tuesday in Rockingham County Superior Court in Bentwood, New Hampshire. Dow is accused of severely beating and burning Linscott's young son, who is now five. - 2years after convicting her they are now bothering to follow up on him, both should be sterilised
              Reply · Like
              · March 24 at 9:50am
              .
            • Reinou van Veen · Top Commenter
              Gemma Baloo research has shown that women are far more likely to abuse and hurt children, scientific fact ♥
              Reply · Like
              · 2 · April 17 at 11:44am
              .
             
            .
            .
            .
            .
          Advertisement
          Video ansehen
          Thema des Tages
          Stylische Unikat-Schuhe vom Designer
          [ X ]

          This ad has been carefully matched to your interests by Turn, Inc. on behalf of the advertiser. The ad was selected for you based on your browsing activity to provide a more relevant and useful advertising experience.

          Privacy Controls by Ghostery, Inc.

          Suggested For You

          These stories are recommended for you by Gravity.
          The recommendations may include stories from our other publisher partners, some of whom pay to include their content here.

          FOLLOW HUFFPOST

          HuffPost Crime
          Like
          Like
          You like this.
          .
          You and 444,728 others like HuffPost Crime.444,728 people like HuffPost Crime.
          • Júlia Frazão
          • Mark Thomas
          • Uda Sin Amit
          • Paula Kubiak
          • Oleg Masalov
          • Carol Scullion
          • Cat Robinson
          • Zeenat Nisar
          • Katie Grove-Velasquez
          • Prince Adi

          Use this form to alert a HuffPost editor about a factual or typographical error in this story.

          Notify message
          * Required
          * * .
          .
          * What kind of error is this?
          .
          * What is the correction? 0 count
          .
          * Type the words below so we know you are not a cyborg


          .
          Thanks for your report!
          0%
          10%
          20%
          30%
          40%
          50%
          60%
          70%
          80%
          90%
          100%