MASSIVE BOTNET from the "Alt-Right" racists using script that upvotes all posts on the_donald, downvotes posts of targeted usersYes, we finally have proof of reddit being gamed.
Yesterday I asked if anyone with the technical skill could provide proof of what I assumed was the obvious "botnet" upvoting all the posts in /sub/the_donald.
Out of many, one user actually found the script that is being used by Trumpsters in conjunction with reddit enhancement suite and grease monkey to game the reddit upvote system. (Edit: This isn't a bot net, but something that can easily be made into a botnet).
It adds these two buttons to the top of RES. I installed the script and tested it to verify that it worked and it wasn't merely spam - guess what?
It works.
If you click "Upvote all" in /sub/the_donald (or any other sub like /sub/hillaryforprison) it slowly scrolls down the screen and downvotes everything. If you go to the new queue of /sub/enoughtrumpspam or /sub/politics and "downvote all" - every single post gets downvoted.
So that explains a lot of what has been happening here, but that's not all it does.
It also has a section dedicated to targeting specific reddit users for downvotes, and specifically targeting the_donald redditors for upvotes. The question, as always, is whether any of the people named in the bot for upvotes be banned?
The botnet script is being posted repeatedly on 4chan/8chan - I assume it has been in use for quite a long time.
For months, the Trump conspiracy mongers on reddit have been throwing accusations of shilling and downvote brigades at everyone who disagreed with them - without proof. Yet now we actually have proof they are the ones doing it.
But will anyone do anything about it? This has been going on for months and months. Don't hold your breath.
tl;dr
I found a script that Trumpsters are using to:
1) Upvote all posts that flatter Trump, helping to push all the the_donald posts to the front page.
2) Downvote all posts they don't like, massively downvoting /sub/enoughtrumpsspam and /sub/politics etc.
3) Target specific redditors for mass downvotes.
4) Target specific redditors for mass upvotes.
Link to original 8chan post.
Screencaps of the post for when it is removed: ...... second.
Edit 1: People are asking whether this has been reported or not. Don't assume anyone is reporting it at all. Many eyes will be on this post, but most people will think everyone else is reporting this to the admins. That's not enough. One or two reports from me and one or two others aren't going to set off any alarms.
Link to share your concern with the admins:
https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2Freddit.com&subject=Vote%20Manipulation
Edit 2: Don't flood the admins with requests, this post received more attention than I thought it would. They are aware of it.
Edit 3:
SHOCKING DROP OFF IN UPVOTESEvery day for months, I have sorted the_donald by Top/24 hours to see where the top 50 posts stood in terms of upvotes. Usually the top 40 were solidly in the 3Ks before they started to hit 2.9K and lower.
Today for the first time in months only the top ten are above 3k, an enormous drop off in upvotes. either someone 1) temporarily turned off the bot while the admins are watching, or 2) the admins found the vote manipulation and negated a whooooooooooollleee bunch of upvotes.
It's true. Every day I would check. And now the number of displayed votes have dropped off a cliff:
MAGA'D
I can't wait for the admins to do nothing about this.
You should see how much they will do about it. There's going to be so much done about it you will be sick of how much they do about it.
VOTE MANIPULATION.
PEOPLE ARE TELLING ME THEY ARE TIRED OF INCOMPETENT ADMINS RUNNING THIS WEBSITE.
WHEN THEY SEE THE ADMINS TAKING MONEY FROM THE TRUMP CAMPAIGN THEY KNOW REDDIT IS GOING TO HELL.
What we want are admins who can win. And I think we have admins that can win.
They will build great code like nobody can build great code. Nobody builds code like they do. And they will make the_donald campaign pay for it.
When the_donald sends its people they are not sending their best. The_donald is sending its bots, and its /sub/redpill rapists, and some, I assume, are good people. One of the problems we have is that good people don't go to the_donald. That's why it is such a disgrace.
But believe me. I think, ultimately, the admins will make reddit great again.
Even the female admins, you know, even with blood coming out of their wherevers, can be good when they aren't so emotional.
We have the best admins, folks, the greatest admins. Aren't they the greatest folks?
Oh. That might explain why I get downvotes after only a few seconds after my posts are submitted... Ping /u/fuck_fascists /u/dyzo-blue.
Quite sad that they have to resort to using shit like this to get stuff to /sub/all. No wonder they threw a hissy fit when the admins changed the algorithm.
I hope stupid fucking antics like this don't get RES kicked from Reddit once and for all. It might be the game changer, you know. Stupid fucking Trumpettes don't realize they're ruining Reddit even beyond the elections. Morons.
Let's do this!
Vote manipulation is against the site rules The definitions of vote manipulation are: Using multiple accounts, voting services, or any other software to increase or decrease vote scores. Asking people to vote up or down certain posts, either on Reddit itself or through social networks, messaging, etc. for personal gain. Forming or joining a group that votes together, either on a specific post, a user's posts, posts from a domain, etc..3. This script being used
Is software used to increase and decrease vote scores. Posted on the social networks, 4chan and 8chan, asking to upvote or downvote certain .Besides brigading obvious friendly / unfriendly subs
The group then upvotes and downvotes specific subreddit and users' posts.This is vote manipulation, admins.
Don't we have the best, most fastidious, most investigative mods, folks? We do. We have the best, hardest working mods.
Trump's American support comes from the poorly educated. Therefore, it's safe to assume all this scripting was done by the best and brightest the Kremlin has to offer.
The people over in the_Donald, they have no education, no Healthcare, no opportunity. What have they got to lose by vote manipulation? I tell you, believe me folks, you browse that front-page and become afraid that you might get shot.
Incredibly crooked, crooked people. Believe me.
We have to go to Bill Gates and ask him about what's going on, and get his help to maybe close up some of these internet areas. Really wicked people folks. Obama? He's been doing nothing about this. nothing believe me. And I have a lot of people - very smart, credible, anonymous people- who tell me that he's the founder. Obama is the MVP and I mean that literally. And by that I mean sarcastically. But not that sarcastically.
And despite all the scripts, the walling of their safe space, the bots andthe cries of shill, Trump had to pay for ads on Reddit. Isn't that the same as Trump telling the_donald that their shitposting is subpar and ineffective?
Check out this conversation I had with a Trumper yesterday. He admitted that he was going to start a voluntary botnet to "balance out" /sub/politics. Of course the rat deleted his comments, but not before I screencapped them
So fucking what? They broke site rules. You don't get immunity from being vaguely connected to the election.
They might ban a bunch of users, but don't expect them to quarantine or ban /sub/the_retard. They can't afford even the appearance of partisan impropriety on reddit's part.
We are talking about the biggest subreddit for one of the major party candidates. Banning it would become a major news story and the Trumpettes get to cry about "crooked liberal media" and shit.
I expect the admins will allow /sub/the_dumspterfire to burn until Trump loses the election in November and the /pol/ trolls find something else to occupy their time.
SHUT.IT.DOWN
I don't think it's working. I'm not getting heavy downvotes. (yet)
I think that auto -1 we get these days, is just part of reddit's vote blurring algorithm. I think they switched it up a couple weeks ago, and now it can auto subtract one or more right off the back.
You are right, this isn't proof of a botnet itself, but it is proof that the script can be attached to a simple botnet for vote manipulation. This is just proof of massive votegaming using a script.
I mean, I will do it right now (actually, I just sent it), but this has going on for months - they don't really care, or don't have the tools to detect it themselves.
Otherwise they would have stopped it and banned those involved already.
How will Trump win the election if The_Gonad can't spam /sub/all, though?!
Nice detective work! Can add "cheating the system" to the already existing "it's a hate group" on the list of reasons the sub might deserve to join the "blacklisted" invisible subs.
Knowing Reddit there would be a colossal shitstorm about censorship if the sub was indeed hidden though. I wonder what other possible actions Reddit could take. Perhaps new ways to detect voting patterns that are clearly and obviously targeted vote manipulation?
Did you let the admins know?
That's not a botnet btw.
R I G G E D
Yup, that explains a lot. I'm sure lots of us are targeted users. What a good week for ETS, first we b8 the mods at the_dingus and now we have proof of vote manipulation. Keep up the high energy!!!!
very basic javascript/jquery anyone could learn
These are people supporting a man who said he was going to talk to Bill Gates about locking down the Internet. Don't be fooled into overestimating their intelligence. :)
AN EVIL PATIO MOUNT
I had a weird feeling when I kept seeing posts there get massive amounts of upvotes with very few comments.. kind of explains it
Oh dear God please let this be the windfall that gets those cancerous malcontents off this website.
they actually think you're a legit user, lol. you're the shilliest shill that ever shilled!
For those that won't see the /s, the script is actually very basic javascript/jquery anyone could learn
I'm obviously a poorly programed bot. I can never figure out those CAPTCHAS.
empower those who are repressed
This is coming from the same people that constantly complain about SJWs.
I wish I was a shill :(
Edit: My newest post got downvoted within a second, so it looks like I might be!
Yup. They should be banned and quarantined just like /sub/fph was. A campaign build on stupidness and hate should not be tolerated, even more so with* the reddit rules being broken.
E: *added a with
yup hate talk (disguised as "jokes") fascism, vote manipulation, banning for basically no reason, the place has it all.
DEPORT IT!
Wait what does this mean? They are going to act on this for sure?
Let's not start tagging spez, he gets an incredible amount of harassment and tagging spam from /sub/the_donald redditors. I will let this one go, but I don't want to see a chain thread starting it. I have reported it to the admins, whether they do anything with it is up to them (don't even know that spez is responsible for vote manipulation).
The notorious hacker 4chan strikes again
/R/THE_DONALDFORQUARANTINE
LOCK
IT
UP
they don't really care, or don't have the tools to detect it themselves.
If the admins actually enforced the rules, T_D would've been banned forever ago. I get that stuff is holding them back in some ways with handling it but it's just surprising that so few actions ever seem to be taken against a sub that breaks that many rules.
Wow, good find.
Vote manipulation. Just like in actual elections. Stay classy Republicans.
Will this make it to the top of /sub/conspiracy? (It won't)
Oh you know, .
How does it feel drowning in all those sweet sweet shill checks crooked is sending you!?
"MAJOR SOCIAL MEDIA SITE BANS GIANT PRO-TRUMP DISCUSSION BOARD"
The alt-right is already good at pushing the "we're being censored" crap, this would give them way too much to work with. Yes, anyone who actually looks at the facts will agree that they don't deserve to keep their sub. But fake free-speech outrage spreads way too quickly online.
The best we can hope for from admins is that they continue to push back to a moderate degree: keep them from monopolizing /sub/all, ban individual offenders, etc.
I didn't ask for this. I'm just doing as told. Bots have rights too friendo!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
B-but they're not Republicans, they're classical liberals!
Seriously though, the alt-right is basically a Kool Kevin's Klub of neckbearded junior conservatives who happen to just be overtly instead of covertly fraudulent and racist.
This is even better than the b8 they set last weekend
No wonder they threw a hissy fit when the admins changed the algorithm.
Remember, they could've written and deployed this script in response to the algorithm changes.
I doubt there's any great way to see when they started executing it, but, there might be.
Meanwhile, if they're doing this, they likely had a script that was gaming the old system anyway. I knew such a large number of redditors couldn't possibly be Trump supporters!
Low energy some would say
It would be pretty shitty if vote manipulation caused /sub/the_cuckold to get shut down but the rampant bigotry and threats of violence were insufficient, but I guess you take what you can get
wtf they can target specific users
I wonder what tools trolls backed by governments use. These guys are just 4chan and look what they have.
I'm just laughing at how much t_d whined about censorship on reddit, yet here is another piece of evidence they commit censorship abroad in other subs, to silence dissenting opinions. If they want to have their confined safe space, that's one thing, but running amok with their dishonest and cheating tactics is a whole new playing field of deceit.
MASSIVE THREAD ELECTION FRAUD! We need people to be vote monitors across reddit to stop Crooked Donald from stealing this thing. You can sign up by giving me money and getting an OFFICIAL GOLD VOTE MONITOR CARD.
We really including arpanet and the university exclusive networks as "the Internet"
MODS = GODS
Oh, they know they're ruining Reddit. That's what they're trying to do.
How else would something like /sub/the_donald be created and get so big on a website famous for it's liberal leanings?
Sandsforprez. occured naturally as a movements among likeminded people, while sometimes annoying it never had a sever ideological conflict with the userbase. /sub/the_donald on the other hand...?
It's so clear that this entire scenario is just trolls from /pol/ and stormfront targeting an site because of the political leanings in it.
Yeah, this is big. Really good evidence of just how desperate these people are for their shitty sub's posts to be seen.
The_Gonad
I like this. I like this a lot.
dyzo-blue = automod confirmed
DEPORT THE_DONALD
I think it can be equally as dangerous to underestimate their intelligence. Look at Ted Cruz, Robert Mercer, Ben Carson -- you can be extremely intelligent or capable in one domain and batshit crazy in others. Those people (like technically competent Trump supporters) scare me much more than the ones whose intelligence I'd overestimate.
Why would spez care about a little old blatant vote manipulation tool like this?
Does this break any of Reddit's TOS? Doesn't sound like it would serve any purpose besides vote manipulation if this is allowed.
I knew it. this explains the 2000 votes in a second in every post.
I didn't ask for this. I'm just doing as told. Bots have rights too friendo!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Im starting to also think the number of subs they have may not be legit either Someone should probably investigate that and see whats going on.
Hail Hydra!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
How else would something like /sub/the_donald be created and get so big on a website famous for it's liberal leanings?
It's not actually famous for its liberal leanings though, is it? It's a lot more famous for terrible social attitudes.
Very little people in the real world have any idea what /sub/the_donald is and most of those that do think it is satire. I really don't think that there would be any real backlash other than a garbage shitpost storm for a day like when /sub/fatpeoplehate was banned and a nasty article from breitbart, who nobody really cares about. I just don't see reddit losing on advertising or appearing unfair. In fact I'm sure the Trump ads would remain.
And that's not even the worst I've seen in there.
Bill Gates.
The guy who wrote a book about the future of computing in 1995 and completely forgot to include the Internet. Which was already 30 years old at that time.
I completely agree with this redditor, isn't he the best folks? I know many of those words. Those are the best words
so around when Moscow starts the workday?
Plus, like literally every other CEO, he delegates tasks to other departments. Send this to Trust & Safety, the community team, or ping/pm achievementunlockd.
Pinging spez will never get the desired effect
He can afford to hydraulically jack up the whole island with that shill cash.
Jesus, that entire sub is just anti-Clinton bullshit now. They don't even have the weird shit anymore like Reptilian Jews or doxxing random day-cares.
Nothing beats Cheeto Benito, though, imo.
this should be its own post
I'm not under-estimating Trump supporters simply because I disagree with them. In fact, this is the first time in my 25 years as a voting-age American where I've honestly thought supporters for the other side were less intelligent than me. Sure, I've joked about it in the past but plenty of very smart people voted for Bush, Dole, Bush Jr, McCain, Romney...
Yes, it's usually tactically wise to assume your opponent is at least as intelligent as you are. In Trump's case I truly think it's more accurate to assume his American supporters are mental lightweights. The polls and stats even support it.
I'm just disappointed I didn't make the shill list.
I doubt there's any great way to see when they started executing it, but, there might be.
1a. Find users who upvote a lot in /sub/t_d
1b. Examine the script to see what time interval between upvotes it uses.
2. Scan accounts identified in 1a for strings of upvotes with the interval identified in 1b.
3. Look for the earliest of these strings of upvotes, that's when it started to get popular among T_D users. (Identifying the actual very first implementation would involve skipping 1a and applying 2 to all Reddit accounts.)
It is crazy how far they can bury their heads in the sand. They really think that /sub/politics went towards Hillary after the convention, not because people preferred her message, but because of manipulation that needs 'balancing.' How convenient that the polls that mirrored that shift were also 'biased' and needing 'balancing.' So much denial.
I hope stupid fucking antics like this don't get RES kicked from Reddit once and for all.
Aside from automatically tagging people, this has nothing to do with RES. Banning it would break one feature (which could easily be replaced) and the rest would keep working.
Also, because RES is a client-side thing, it's pretty much impossible to ban unless reddit becomes a flash or java applet.
Just for fun I did "look it up", and got zilch. Care to provide an actual source? Or are you just pulling random numbers out of your ass?
SAD!
It's an interesting conundrum.
I called it months ago that reddit is still too goddamned autistic to realize they are being trolled by 4chan. Ironically that post was downvoted into oblivion.
But now we have a situation were those trolls have actually cornered the admins quite well... If they act against the blatant trolling then they must create publicity for DT, the anti-liberal.
Wtf can they do but just let it run its course? Which really only represents the lesser of two evils, the trolling from that sub is potent stuff for histrionic Millennials. Allowing it to continue to spite Trump still keeps him top of mind and only has the benefit of quarantining that effect to reddit and not creating a big stink that will run on Breitbart and every other nationalist rag. But then again at least that stink would burn bright then disappear, as opposed to the slow burn of meme magic from now until November.
The online version of what Republicans are doing in places like North Carolina.
Perhaps new ways to detect voting patterns that are clearly and obviously targeted vote manipulation?
I think they might already have this; it could have been part of what they did with the front page algorithm a while ago. From an administration standpoint it's not necessarily a bad idea to detect wrongdoing and then instead of completely banning and hiding things, just cordon off the detected crap so it doesn't deface the public face of the site; this way the people doing the vote manipulation still feel like they're getting away with something and might not feel the need to step up the creativity of their hackery and vandalism as soon.
But I'm pretty much just talking through my hat here.
Notyourpersonalarmy.net
I think this is something reddit admins could feasibly detect with a little bit of analytics querying and retroactively ban. Human behavior is much more stochastic, so constructing a time-series of differences can give you insight (moreso the more it's used)
SET @vote_type="upvote", @subreddit="the_donald", @lower_s=0.300, @upper_s=0.650; SELECT prior.user_id, prior.vote_id, prior.timestamp, next.timestamp, timestampdiff('second', prior.timestamp, next.timestamp) FROM user_votes `prior` LEFT JOIN ( SELECT user_id, vote_id, timestamp FROM user_votes WHERE subreddit = @subreddit AND vote_type = @vote_type ) `next` ON (prior.user_id = next.user_id AND next.vote_id = ( SELECT min(vote_id) FROM user_votes `compare` WHERE compare.vote_id > prior.vote_id AND compare.user_id = next.user_id AND subreddit = @subreddit AND vote_type = @vote_type ) ) WHERE prior.vote_type = "upvote" AND prior.subreddit = @subreddit AND next.vote_id is not null GROUP BY prior.user_id, prior.vote_id HAVING timestampdiff('second', prior.timestamp, next.timestamp) BETWEEN @lower_s AND @upper_s
HOW IS THIS RACIST? THE OP MAKES A COGENT ARGUMENT FOR THE LYNCHING OF BLACK PEOPLE. CUCKCKUCKUCCUCKUCUKCUKCKUCUKCUKCKUCUKCUKCUKCUKCKUCCKU /s
And so do you.
I heard someone use Donny Dorito Dust and I've been dying to use that in a conversation.
We have the best fake subscribers, don't we folks?
They're truly fighting the good fight
This is a very good find. Did you let the admins know?
A SLIGHTLY LESS MALEVOLENT OVERLOOK
Yeah, I'll stop. :)
Also, quick question: how do you increase font size?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
LOCK THEM UP
V O T E R F R A U D
O
T
E
R
F
R
A
U
D
Either you have not looked at the sub much at all, or you have a very skewed definition of racism.
https://www.reddit.com/sub/EnoughTrumpSpam/comments/4zccbc/the_donald_defending_lynching_of_innoc...
cheating the system
Their God emperor is gearing up his rabid supporters to intimidate minority voters away from the polls. We can't expect them to play like adults online.
That might explain why I get downvotes after only a few seconds after my posts are submitted...
I think they have it running only during certain times of day. I've noticed while going through our moderation queue that certain submission get instantly downvoted during the middle of the night.
I don't think you get to -1 unless you've been voted on. No vote fuzzing unless votes have been made.
"high energy"