Been seeing quite a lot of fallacies while arguing in the comments section (although I'm sure this can't be helped since most of you guys are probably 13 years old):

1. Rooney made the winning assist, so therefore if he didn't play, United would have lost. No, someone else could have made the assist. Or not. We'll never know.

2. Rooney has a bad first touch/slows down the attack, so therefore if he didn't play, we would have won by more goals. Again that's just dumb logic.