/u/tocitus and /u/georgie_best asked me if I could do a /r/soccer version of this thread. Ironically, this might not be the best time for it, since the confirmation might be coming up... Anyway, after a few hours of research here it is guys.

P.S. The ““Pogba is overrated” comment karma” thing is just a sum of upvotes and downvotes of all the comments in that thread that said that Pogba is overrated. It goes down when someone says it sarcastically.

22 Jan 2014 - Pogba ‘disgusted’ with Ferguson “Now he's the best young midfielder this season” - /u/SuaveRico “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

30 Jan 2014 - Pogba sensational goal v Udinese “Obligatory Wow I bet United fans really regret getting rid of him...” - /u/AndrewDiceClayOven “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

31 Jan 2014 - Pogba can juggle blindfolded too! “Such class. United must regret this one! This is exactly the kind of skill they need!” - deleted user “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

02 Apr 2014 - Opinions on Paul Pogba? “He has the potential to be the best player in the world. The ability he posseses for his age is frightening” - /u/NB0608sd “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: -2

03 Apr 2014 - Pogba skill and pass “At this point I just have to laugh when my fellow United supporters try to say we're better off without him.” - /u/wvufan44 “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

27 May 2014 - Pogba’s 1-0 goal against Norway “Pogba can defend, he can dribble, he's an aerial threat, he's fast, he can shoot, he can pass. He's going to be a scary, scary player in the future. Only 21, my god.” - /u/dats_just_gr8 “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

08 Jun 2014 - Pogba to Man Utd? “not going to happen, pogba doesnt like united, juventus are currently in a better position than united” - deleted user “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: -14

04 Sep 2014 - Pogba great roulette vs Spain “zidane.....” - /u/Negrodamus06 “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

22 Sep 2014 - If you had to pick just one in your team, you take Pogba or Verratti? “Pogba and it’s not even close.” - /u/IneoIx “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

07 Jan 2015 – How likely is that Pogba will go to United this summer transfer window “He definitely wouldn't have spent so much time since slating the club and it's previous manager who is a hero at the club. Sure he may move from Juve one day, but it'll be to Real Madrid or maybe PSG if they really pull out all the stops to get him.” - /u/alpha1028 “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

28 Jan 2015 – Pirlo: Pogba will never return to Manchester United “What about if Juve draw Man Utd in the Champions Lea... nevermind” - deleted user “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a 02 May 2015 – What makes Pogba so good / desirable “First of all his age and perceived potential, he's still only 21 and he's already considered one of the best midfielders in the world and the ability of changing a game on his own when he's on his day. He's quick, technical and has a strong physique, his weakness is his defensive game.” - /u/improb “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

17 Jun 2015 – Marotta: “Real wants Pogba? Maybe for Cristiano plus cash...” “It's also clearly sarcasm ” - /u/eldankus “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: +24

28 Feb 2016 – Paul Pogba doesn’t want to go to the Premier League, he prefers La Liga “Yea, well, who wouldn't? He already knows what it's like living in Manchester.” - /u/baraksobamas “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

18 Apr 2016 – Marotta: Pogba will stay with Juventus for years “People said it from the first year that Pogba would leave Juve soon. They said it the year after, and the year after that. He's still here though. ” - /u/Sputniki “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

20 Apr 2016 – Pogba’s recent form “There was one guy who kept insisting that sanches on Benfica is better than Pogba lol” - /u/UncleWittgenstein “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: -112

07 Jun 2016 – Di Marzio: Real Madrid want to sign Pogba “He's simply saying that florentino is thinking about making an offer for pogba, but he doesn't want to meet the obscene price we are asking for him. Nothing new” - /u/Mistermarzoc “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

08 Jun 2016 – Mark Ogden: Manchester United have moved into pole position to sign Pogba “Lol Bulshit...” - /u/aman27deep “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

09 Jun 2016 – Marotta: “Pogba leaving? Not happening, we’ll keep him.” “Their midfield will be strong with Pogba Pjanic” - /u/DellMB “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

10 Jun 2016 – Di Marzio: Whilst Real Madrid are serious over Pogba, Manchester United could also step in. United is making a small step towards a possible deal for Pogba. “Pogba’s not moving” - /u/1hive “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

29 Jun 2016 – L’Equipe: Manchester United have opened discussions with Juventus about Pogba “I’m just happy we are trying” - /u/Entrepreneur_Girl “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

04 Jul 2016 – Romano: Man Utd had talks with Raiola for Pogba, yes. But... Juve want to keep Pogba; is going to ask €120M; Paul ask €12M/season. Not easy! “That's at least 50% more than he's actually worth IMO, but I've always felt he was just a tad overrated, even when we were going after him. He's a great player who I would love to have, and would hate to see go to United, but I just don't think he's on that level.” - /u/TomShoe “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: +143

19 Jul 2016 – Di Marzio: Mino Raiola has requested a meeting with Juventus to present United’s first official offer “GUYS YOU'RE MAKING IT REALLY DIFFICULT FOR ME TO MANAGE MY OWN EXPECTATIONS HERE.” /u/tocitus “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: +594

4 hours ago: Romano: Juventus will accept Man Utd bid for #Pogba, last details and will be official. €110M (around 100 after tax), MU will pay Raiola's % #MUFC “Thank god it's over, have fun with Raiola Manchester United. He's gonna stir shit up within 3-4 years ” - /u/FockOffMate “Pogba is overrated” comment karma: n/a

There you have it, I got tired near the end of it. I may add some other relevant links later in case people like this. Peace.