The Chair Thrown 'Round the World
A Las Vegas reporter's second-hand claim Bernie Sanders supporters threw chairs at a Nevada convention was widely reproduced by other news outlets.
Claim:
Angry Bernie Sanders supporters threw chairs during an adversarial Nevada Democrat convention in May 2016.
WHAT'S TRUE:
Video captured during the Nevada Democrats' convention depicts a man briefly picking up a chair before placing it back down without throwing it.
WHAT'S FALSE:
Despite extensive YouTube, Periscope, and photographic documentation captured by supporters of both Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders, no available images document anyone's throwing chairs at the Nevada convention.
Example:
[Collected via e-mail and Twitter, May 2016]
Origin:On 14 May 2016, Democrats held a third-tier convention in Nevada, the events of which were, by all accounts, adversarial. Supporters of Bernie Sanders claimed that rules were adjusted and schedules changed without notice, while supporters of Hillary Clinton claimed Sanders supporters were violent and obstreperous and resorted to throwing chairs.
Much of the initial reporting came from local journalist Jon Ralston, who live-tweeted events as they occurred at the convention on 14 May 2016. While Ralston didn't report at the time that chairs were being thrown at the convention, he later tweeted that:
Hey, Berniebot chair-throwing truthers: It happened. People saw it, inc. one journo who was there and reported it. https://t.co/J4XMWy3mGs— Jon Ralston (@RalstonReports) May 17, 2016
The chair-throwing claim was repeated across election coverage. In an interview with MSNBC's Chris Matthews and Rachel Maddow, Democratic National Committee chair Debbie Wasserman Schultz repeated, in concert with video footage of a man holding a chair aloft, the refrain that Sanders supporters had been throwing chairs at the convention:
The video shown during that segment was credited to the YouTube account of a "Bud Meyers," but we viewed Meyers' uploaded footage from the 14 May 2016 convention and were unable to locate the clip that included the image credited to him by MSNBC. The only relevant video we could locate on his YouTube account was a clip mocking (rather than confirming) the chair-throwing rumor:
The only intact footage that matched MSNBC's claim and imagery shows a man of unknown affiliation briefly lifting a chair before placing it back down without throwing it:
RT this! NO chair throwing at #nvdemconvention - guy picks chair up, puts it down, they HUG it out. #TeamBernieNV pic.twitter.com/mBZmEeg1T5 — BernieForThePeople (@Bernie4People) May 17, 2016
The chair-throwing story was reported as fact not just by MSNBC but by news outlets such as the
New York Times, the
Associated Press, and
CBS. MSNBC's account opened as follows:
Thrown chairs. Leaked cellphone numbers. Death threats spewed across the Internet.No, this is not the work of Donald J. Trump supporters, some of whom have harassed critics of the presumptive Republican presidential nominee. It was angry supporters of Senator Bernie Sanders who were directing their ire at the Nevada Democratic Party — and its chairwoman, Roberta Lange — over a state convention that they think was emblematic of a rigged political system.
The
Times's article also led with the claim of chairs thrown by violent attendees and included reports of chaos among the ranks of Sanders supporters:
Raising the prospect of lasting fissures in the party, Senator Bernie Sanders rebuffed pressure to rein in his supporters after they disrupted a weekend Democratic convention in Nevada, throwing chairs and later threatening the state chairwoman in a fight over delegates. The uproar comes as Hillary Clinton is struggling to turn her and the party’s attention to the fall.Mr. Sanders’s supporters showed no sign of backing down. In interviews, several threatened to disrupt the party’s convention in Philadelphia in July with protests and nonviolent disobedience over a nominating system that they say has treated Mr. Sanders unfairly. In emails, on social media and on websites, his supporters have traded advice about protest tactics and legal services in case of mass arrests.
Jon Ralston tweeted about the purported chair throwing activity despite having left the convention early, but he didn't initially clarify that he was not an eyewitness to the alleged incident:
Convention ended w/security shutting it down, Bernie folks rushed stage, yelling obscenities, throwing chairs. Unity Now! On to Philly 2/2 — Jon Ralston (@RalstonReports) May 15, 2016
Subsequent tweets between Ralston and another reporter suggested that Ralston's assertion about chair throwing was, at best, second-hand, as Ralston inquired whether the other reporter had obtained video of the event:
@atdleft You get video?— Jon Ralston (@RalstonReports) May 15, 2016
As far as we know, no video documenting such claims has yet surfaced, but coverage of the chair-throwing fracas continues unabated.
At least one outlet held their own reporting to account when Ralston's came under question. NPR ran with Ralston's second-hand assertion about thrown chairs, but their ombudsman later pegged Ralston (who did not witness the chair-throwing) as the sole source behind the widely-repeated claim and
admitted that no evidence had been produced that anyone had thrown chairs:
[O]ther outlets, including The Associated Press, also reported that chairs were thrown. While I have no reason to doubt that reporting, in the extensive video posted on social media in the aftermath of the convention I've so far found none of a chair being thrown. One video shows a chair being lifted in the air. Other videos do show angry Sanders supporters rushing toward the stage and shouting obscenities.I asked Beth Donovan, NPR's senior Washington editor, to respond to the concerns. She wrote, "Several members of our staff watched live video that showed a man brandishing a chair. Nevada analyst Jon Ralston, who was in the room and over time has been a very reliable source, reported that a chair was thrown. We okayed using and sourcing his reporting." But, she added, "When Ralston's reporting came under question, we adjusted our language," by not repeating the word "thrown." Instead, Keith's report this morning referred to "physical skirmishes." (It also quoted Nevada Sen. Harry Reid as referring to "violence," which he did, indeed, do.)Donovan went on, "So, was there violence? There was pushing, shoving, and screaming, a chair was brandished and a great deal of hostile and obscene language used. Several editors and reporters saw and heard the video live and later. People on the ground described it as violence. It doesn't seem a stretch to me."Donovan and I disagree on this; "violence," which NPR more often uses to describe events in war zones, seems too strong a term to me based on the evidence I have seen so far. And the politics team's own decision to avoid the word "thrown" renders this online-only introduction to Keith's piece misleading, unless other eyewitnesses come forward to clarify the events[.]
Last updated:
19 May 2016
Originally published:
19 May 2016
Alcindor, Yamiche. "Bernie Sanders Facing Pressure Over Supporters’ Actions in Nevada."
The New York Times. 17 May 2016.
The New York Times. 17 May 2016.
Jensen, Elizabeth. "Fact-Checking NPR's Reports on Vegas 'Violence'."
NPR. 18 May 2016.
NPR. 18 May 2016.
Raju, Manu. "Reid Blames Sanders' 'People' for Nevada Convention Chaos."
CNN. 16 May 2016.
CNN. 16 May 2016.
Rappeport, Alan. "From Bernie Sanders Supporters, Death Threats Over Delegates."
The New York Times. 16 May 2016.
The New York Times. 16 May 2016.
Rindels, Michelle and Nicholas Riccardi. "Nevada Democrats: Sanders Campaign Has Violent Streak."
Associated Press. 16 May 2016.
Associated Press. 16 May 2016.
Associated Press. "Security Concerns End Nevada Democratic Convention."
16 May 2016.
16 May 2016.
Kim LaCapria is a New York-based content manager and longtime snopes.com message board participant. Although she was investigated and found to be "probably false" by snopes.com in early 2002, Kim later began writing for the site due to an executive order unilaterally passed by President Obama during a secret, late-night session (without the approval of Congress). Click like and share if you think this is an egregious example of legislative overreach.
