Login Register
Logout

Manchester United players baffled by Van Gaal substitutions

Ashley Young for Marcus Rashford was one change that did not pay off for Man Utd manager Louis van Gaal at Spurs.

Manchester United players are baffled by Louis van Gaal's substitutions as the Dutch manager continues to struggle to influence games through his changes.

Van Gaal introduced Ashley Young for Marcus Rashford at half-time in the weekend defeat at Tottenham in a move that was widely derided by United supporters.

The impressive Timothy Fosu-Mensah had to come off injured for Matteo Darmian in the second-half and Van Gaal also withdrew the ineffectual Juan Mata for Memphis in the second-half.

A source told M.E.N. Sport: "Players haven't got a clue what the f**k his substitutions are all about."

Van Gaal has made 33 half-time substitutions during his time in charge of United - 25 were tactical and eight were enforced by injury. United have won 13, drawn six and lost 11 of those games.

Van Gaal's substitutions have baffled United's players
Van Gaal's substitutions have baffled United's players

In recent weeks, the United manager has had a tendency to make tactical substitutions involving full-backs. Darmian replaced Marcos Rojo in the win over Watford, Fosu-Mensah replaced Darmian at West Brom, Darmian came on for Guillermo Varela in the FA Cup draw with West Ham, Antonio Valencia and Darmian replaced Varela and Rojo against Liverpool, Valencia and Fosu-Mensah came on for Rojo and Darmian at City, while Fosu-Mensah replaced Rojo at the pause against Everton.

Van Gaal's substitution struggles have worsened this season, having watched Marouane Fellaini, Adnan Januzaj and Ashley Young emerge to influence games in his first United campaign.

Rojo has been substituted twice in recent weeks
Rojo has been substituted twice in recent weeks

His in-game management has drawn regular criticism from United supporters who were impressed by Van Gaal's impact at the 2014 World Cup.

As Netherlands manager, Van Gaal memorably replaced Jasper Cillessen with Tim Krul prior to the quarter-final penalty shootout against Costa Rica. Krul saved two penalties as the Oranje recorded a rare shootout triumph.

However, in the semi-finals, Van Gaal's decision to start Nigel De Jong against Argentina proved costly. He substituted defender Bruno Martins Indi before De Jong, fit again after limping off nine minutes into the last 16 tie with Mexico, departed on the hour mark.

Van Gaal thanks Tim Krul after beating Costa Rica
Van Gaal thanks Tim Krul after beating Costa Rica

With penalties looming, Van Gaal sent on Klaas-Jan Huntelaar for Robin van Persie, scuppering his initial plans to send on specialist Krul, and Cillessen conceded four spotkicks as Argentina won 4-2.

In United's FA Cup quarter-final defeat to Arsenal last season, Van Gaal made two half-time substitutions which contributed to their elimination. He replaced the injured Luke Shaw, having risked him despite not being fully fit, and made a tactical change by bringing Ander Herrera off for Michael Carrick as 10-man United lost 2-1.

Comments

Premier League News

Journalists

Neal Keeling
Chief Reporter, Crime, Salford, Fire Service
John Scheerhout
Crime
Charlotte Cox
Wythenshawe, Airport
Yakub Qureshi
Education, Religion
Dean Kirby
Health
Jennifer Williams
Politics, Local government, Trade unions
Paul Britton
Defence, Bury, Bolton, Wigan
Dan Thompson
Investigations
Chris Osuh
Court
Pete Bainbridge
Breaking News
Richard Wheatstone
Blackley, Cheetham Hill, Crumpsall, Collyhurst, Harpurhey, Openshaw, Moston, Newton Heath, Ancoats, Clayton, Gorton, Ardwick
Amy Glendinning
Moss Side, Hulme, Whalley Range, Longsight, Rusholme, Levenshulme, Burnage
Chris Slater
North and East Manchester
Emily Heward
Digital Journalist
Emma Flanagan
Digital Journalist