I did provide reasoning for my opinions and my theories, but you ignored them

You were asked for opinions and theories, and several times you gave the reason "I'm not Mashima" and "Just because it could happen". No one ignored your reasons because you never gave any legitimate ones. It wasn't even possible to call what you said a theory after the "explanation" that you tried to give.

The first time was a joke, but my second opinion was a legit opinion.

You're first "explanation" was saying "I'm not Mashima, it's not my story.", and you even tried to defend that statement, by saying a theory doesn't need to have a legitimate explanation. Which one is it? Did you give an explanation or do you not need explanations?

You still ignored it and kicked me anyway.

No one ignored a single comment you posted. We read every single one of them, and then tried to get you to explain your "theory". You actually ignored the chat in it's entirety half the time, after we asked several times for a real explanation or for actual depth into the "No More Magic 'Theory'", so hypocrisy apparently doesn't matter at this point.

You never enforced nor introduced that rule before that instance.

Spidey has said several times, that the rules of the Skype Chat are the rules of the sub. He's sent them many times and even told users directly about them. When someone spammed images, they were told. When someone is disrespectful, Spidey broke it up and warned them. That's how the chat worked. When someone caused problems, or was disrespectful, or just was being outright terrible, of course Spidey is going to act on it. The chat was stable for a decently long time, with everyone respecting each other, knowing where they stood, but this issue threw it off the deep end and created a problem that wasn't solvable without consequences. If that doesn't spell out K-I-C-K-A-B-L-E, then I don't know what does.

Also, I didn't know that you could prove an opinion wrong.

Ok, so saying Edolas still has magic is an opinion? Ok. So when you say that, and then say you remember the arc in full, that's an opinion. Spidey had sent you several images, to which you layered on new things that made no sense, such as "There could be another Anima somewhere". None of it made sense.

• I don't really get why this is a thing or why you're lying and trying to defend yourself.
• Everyone in the chat agreed that what happened that night was completely out of order and should never occur again.

It was complete chaos, and:

I said stuff in the Fairy Tail skype chat before an excuse was found to kick me.

As I stated before, nothing was an excuse. what occurred was an issue that had to be solved. The bottom line is that you had stirred up the chat, angering most people, and even causing disrespect to others. You made up an ending for the series, and then tried to justify it without any sort of explanation. If that's your idea of a joke, none of us found it anywhere near funny. The icing on the cake was how whichever direction we went, it turned into more and more "theories" about Edolas, or Tenrou, or Mavis, that had no relation to your initial statement of "I want the series to end where there is no magic anymore."

• Dissing the mods and then using your kick from the Skype chat as justification is childish and shouldn't even be considered a mature debate as to the enforcement of rules on the sub. Don't involve the Skype Chat when that issue was handled perfectly by Spidey and the other moderators. Leaving this issue for them to finish up, since I don't mod the sub.