/
    Skip to main content
    Advertisement

    At bedtime, my daughter asked me if guns existed 'in real life'

    Jessica Valenti
    Jessica Valenti
    I resent that I have to tell my daughter anything about guns. I resent that I have to be afraid for her
    bed
    A young girl reading a bed time story. --- Image by © Celia Peterson/arabianEye/Corbis Photograph: Celia Peterson/arabianEye/Corbis
    The night before the shooting at Umpqua Community College in Oregon, my daughter and I went through our normal nighttime ritual: we each tell each other our favorite part of the day, and then she can ask me any question that’s on her mind. Usually the question is along the lines of “how do teddy bears get made” or “can I have a treat tomorrow?” But that night Layla asked me a question about guns. And I couldn’t help but feel that there was no right way to answer, because all the answers are terrible.
    In her room, Layla has a picture of Martin Luther King that she brought home from school earlier this year, and so her question that night was about how he died. I don’t believe much in lying to kids, and Layla is getting bigger - so I told her the truth. And that’s when she asked, shocked, if guns existed “in real life.” It had never occurred to my five year old daughter that guns could be anything but fantastical - something found only in stories, like fairies or unicorns. If only.
    It only got harder from there. Layla wanted to know why, if guns hurt people, they were “allowed.” She wanted to know if only the good guys have guns, and if cops are good guys.
    The truth is that I resent that I have to tell my daughter anything about guns. I resent that I have to be afraid for her. In 2012, after the shooting in Sandy Hook Elementary School in Connecticut that left an unimaginable 20 children dead, my husband and I got a message from Layla’s daycare that they were starting lockdown drills. They informed us that these drills taught to the children would “become as familiar as our classroom naptime routines.” She was two years old at the time.
    The majority of advice I found online about how to talk to your kids about guns had to do with teaching your children that they live in a world where guns are everywhere, rather than questioning that reality. The NRA, for example, has plenty of tips for parents and lessons for children - complete with a cartoon character named Eddie Eagle. Something tells me Eddie doesn’t let kids know just how many of them get hurt every year thanks to the obscene amount of firearms in this country.
    How do I tell my daughter about that? How do I tell her that some people hurt children with guns, or that we live in a nation where people’s right to own a weapon that kills trumps her right to safety and a life free from fear?
    This is not the world I want for her - not the world I want for any child.
    My husband and I did the best we could that night explaining that guns were, in fact, real, and that despite the fact that they are dangerous some people still own them. I hope Layla wasn’t too confused or scared by this, and I hope she keeps asking us questions. But most of all I hope that by the time my daughter is grown, if her child has questions - she’ll be able to provide them with very different answers.

    comments (600)

    Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion.
    This discussion is closed for comments.
    We’re doing some maintenance right now. You can still read comments, but please come back later to add your own.
    Commenting has been disabled for this account (why?)
    1 2 3 4 7 next
    Loading comments… Trouble loading?
    • 0 1
      This discussion will close in a few moments and reopen in the morning (UK time). Thanks for your contributions.
      Reply |
    • This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.
    • 1 2
      Here in Europe, the civilised consensus is that a modern state has a monopoly on violence. Pushed to extremes, not even the police need to be armed. In other words, the ideal scenario corresponds to reality.
      Part of the US problem is appreciating that what they hold up as defence of their constitution is not, in fact, an ideal scenario. Only then, I suspect, will they begin to work on improving reality.
      There are two exceptions in Europe (neither of which is in the EU):
      - Switerland, the least centralised of any European country
      - Norway, the wildest of any European country, and equally least centralised.
      The first sees is people as a permanently-armed militia, but conditions of geography (mountainous, relatively small and land-locked) equate to permanent peace.
      The second sits on a wild frontier, and produced the worst episode of civilian violence outside of the terrorist attacks of various European independence movements.
      Reply |
    • This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.
    • 0 1
      Dear Ms. Valenti, you have already become part of the older generation. Sigh ...
      Reply |
    • 0 1
      I also resent reality for forcing me to confront it.
      Reply |
    • This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.
    • 3 4
      Why didn't you tell her guns are just glorified penises that all men feel compelled to carry around and shoot at each other to prove their manly manhood? Is that not what you believe?
      Reply |
    • 5 6
      lol guns exist in real life? shut up next you'll be telling me knives, poisonous snakes, drowning, getting run over by a car, bears, cancer, pneumonia, knuckledusters, axes, ebola, lions, aggressive dogs, drinking bleach, isis, plane crashes, nail bombs and clowns exist too.
      Reply |
    • 2 3
      My parents taught about firearms (Inc bows) at around 8-9 I already knew they were real but I learnt initial safety and how to respect them in the same way you would respect a knife or fire. My school taught Mr more at 13+ and I have always treated any firearm or person carrying with sensible respect. I am from the UK but believe the only thing more dangerous with a gun is someone with a gun who doesn't know what it's capable of.
      Reply |
    • 4 5
      My 5 year old asked me to tell him, again, how to make sure his firearm was safely handled while removing the ammunition, before I locked it away until our next trip to the range.
      quelle différence!
      Reply |
    • 2 3
      Just put her in front of the TV and let her watch Inglorious Basterds. She'll figure it out. She's a smart kid.
      Reply |
    • 2 3
      I told my kids they're just like cars. They're dangerous, ubiquitous, unregulated, and people use them for self-defense, to overthrow governments, and sometimes to mow down people they hate because they feel like they have no future in this country where survival has become exponentially more difficult in recent decades due to manipulation of the economy by business and political leaders.
      Reply |
    • This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.
    • This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.
    • This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.
    • 2 3
      'Asked me if guns EXIST'. come on Guardian. Basic grammar
      Reply |
    • 5 6
      The other day my daughter asked me how come people weren't allowed to keep guns to protect themselves when so many criminals have guns to hurt people with. I felt resentful that I had to answer her, because all the answers were terrible. "If people break the law and buy guns illegally," I said to her, "the other people who abide by the law and don't have guns just have to put up with that."
      "But what about if the bad man threatens us with a gun?" she said, incredulously.
      "We can't protect ourselves."
      This game is fun.
      Reply |
      • 0 1
        Except of course more people die as a consequence of the absence of gun control than as a consequence of it, but don't let awkward facts get in the way.
        Reply |
      • 0 1
        Ridiculous. You wouldn't have to protect yourselves if BOTH sides had sufficient weapons regulation to protect BOTH sides. I simply do not understand this insane obsession Americans have that a gun is a necessary thing to have! We have proper regulation in the UK and we don't have an issue with people committing mass shootings on a regular basis. It's so fucking simple to see the correlation! Your daughter has more right to life, than you have to own a gun!
        Reply |
    • 2 3
      I struggle to see how owning a gun is culture, however I am British. I am grateful that I live in a society where guns are not widely available or held. The evidence speaks for itself: fewer people die when guns are not available, e.g. Australia and the UK. Maintaining the right to keep guns just seems absurd in the face of this.
      Reply |
      • 1 2
        You think it would be reasonable to go around this country with 330 million citizens, over 3 million square miles and collect guns?
        Our lax gun laws do allow more cowardly murders but Americans will never give up their guns.
        Reply |
    • 2 3
      well i for one am shocked, not only did valenti not spout her usual misandry, but i agree with her...America is one fucked country
      Reply |
    • 4 5
      How many kids do you know who would ask this question "do guns exist in real life" none. The young today are inundated with movies and the 'News'.....taking it in stride...no they do not ask this question.
      Reply |
      • 0 1
        True enough, I am a little confused that the article seems to suggest the daughter asked about how Martin Luther King died and that's what started the conversation.
        If this was the case, it would seem easier to say that he died because what he believed in was dangerous to powerful people, it would probably be a better answer as well as avoiding the gun issue.
        Of course if you want to talk about guns, you can always do so.
        Reply |
    • 0 1
      It`s absolutely ok that a kid asks questions. and yes we should prepare our children to adult life and explain things. Moreober i do agree with @Jake321 that we should protect our kids. In order to keep an eye on them we should track their locations by using different types of parental control apps..
      Reply |
    • 1 2
      I couldn’t help but feel that there was no right way to answer, because all the answers are terrible.
      How about:
      Gun were invented by Patriarchal men.
      Why?
      Like everything the Patriarchy does, to oppress women.
      So, men mostly shoot women?
      No, mostly they shoot each other.
      Why?
      By which point, in my scenario, I have fallen asleep. The little one kisses me fondly on the cheek, pulls up the covers, turns off the light, and wanders off to bed to ponder the Many Paradoxes of Patriarchy Theory.
      The point being, of course, (and to widen it beyond gun crime) in the UK men kill twice as many men as women; in the US, it is 3-4 times as many; in South Africa, it is seven times as many.
      Reply |
    • This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.
    1 2 3 4 7 next
     
    SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone. See the Facebook Help Center for more information.
    SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone. See the Facebook Help Center for more information.
    desktop
    0%
    10%
    20%
    30%
    40%
    50%
    60%
    70%
    80%
    90%
    100%