/
    Skip to main content
    Advertisement

    Gender inequality is a problem men created – now they have to help fix it

    Jessica Valenti
    Jessica Valenti
    Men need to step up and actually help women out at home and at work. We need them to take active responsibility for their faults
    feminism
    Women still bear the largest burden of child care across the world. Photograph: Beyond Fotomedia GmbH / Alamy/Alamy
    In the ongoing national conversation about work life balance and domestic parity between men and women, there’s a phrase that’s not quite as popular as “having it all” or “leaning in” but is important just the same: this is not just a women’s issue.
    Sheryl Sandberg has encouraged men to get involved in advocating for women’s equality at work and at home, academics have pointed out that men’s participation is necessary for real change and earlier this year in his State of the Union address, President Obama said: “It’s time we stop treating child care as a side issue, or a women’s issue, and treat it like the national economic priority that it is for all of us.”
    It’s true; child care, housework, balancing work and home life - these are issues that men absolutely need to care about and take action on. But not just because it benefits them to, or to do so as a favor to help women out. Men need to get off the bench and do something because gendered domestic disparity is a problem that they created. It’s only fair that men fix it.
    This is one of those truths that’s tricky to say because feminists are so often working hard to make the movement’s messages palatable. We don’t want men to feel alienated and pointing a finger can feel counterproductive.
    But repeating “this is not just a women’s issue” over and over simply has not worked. For years feminists have argued that work life balance and the unequal division of labor in the home and with children is a family issue. Nothing has changed.
    This isn’t to say that men haven’t gotten involved, many have. But we need more than men’s grudging participation - we need them to take active responsibility. In the workplace, where they can do more to fight for equal pay and against discrimination, but also in the home.
    Years ago, before we were married, my husband Andrew ran a reading group - it was comprised mostly of young progressive-minded men in their 20s. One day they were discussing an article about the disproportionate care labor women do, for kids and elders, and the group was all in agreement: this was unfair. They talked about legislation and policy changes that could help. But when Andrew asked how many of them expected their future partners to do the majority of child care, the room got silent - and then defensive.
    All of these young men who considered themselves progressive and were willing to talk about political change, were completely unwilling to let go of the idea that their personal lives might be impacted in any way for the cause. I don’t think this is an unusual attitude on either side of the aisle.
    So yeah, maybe it’s time we weren’t so polite about this particular battle. The kind of change that these problems require - lasting change, change that’s both systemic and personal - requires more than men’s “support”. Women didn’t choose to make less money, bias does that. Women didn’t choose to be the default care giver, socialization does that.
    Women didn’t create this problem. Men did that.

    Brought to you by:

    About this content

    comments (654)

    Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion.
    This discussion is closed for comments.
    We’re doing some maintenance right now. You can still read comments, but please come back later to add your own.
    Commenting has been disabled for this account (why?)
    1 2 3 4 14 next
    Loading comments… Trouble loading?
    • 0 1
      Lol the deletion of one of my comments tells me that Ms Valenti does indeed have a Nanny to look after her kids : )
      Reply |
    • 1 2
      An interesting article. Do I believe that men should be doing more housework? Yes. However, I believe that the reason for this is that more women are choosing careers rather than motherhood, hence there being no wage gap in the under 40's. In that context it makes sense to split the housework 50/50.
      However, if a woman chooses the motherhood route, why shouldn't she take on more of the housework, after all the husband will need to be working his a*** off to make ends meet.
      When I chose a career over motherhood I got to demand a 50/50 split of housework. Until you make that choice, you can't make demands.
      Reply |
    • 2 3
      Why do women spend billions on makeup (and other things like skirts which don't afford the protection of trousers/pants)
      If that isn't socialised oppression of women, after all men forcing them to put on fake faces - then what is it? Could it be an indication that women think and behave differently from men?
      Why don't women just stop using makeup? Why don't men start using makeup?
      Reply |
    • 0 1
      Bigger fish to fry
      Reply |
    • 1 2
      A lot of angry misogynist virgins abusing anything supportive female in the comments.
      Reply |
    • 1 2
      it was comprised mostly of young progressive-minded men in their 20s
      As the Guardian style guide notes:
      The one thing to avoid, unless you want people who care about such things to give you a look composed of, consisting of and comprising mingled pity and contempt, is "comprised of"
      Reply |
    • 3 4
      It's just so annoying that all the other papers are worse than the Guardian. Sigh...
      Reply |
    • 6 7
      "Men need to get off the bench and do something because gendered domestic disparity is a problem that they created. It’s only fair that men fix it."
      A couple of years before you were born, a woman called Jessica punched me in the face. It's only fair that you apologise.
      Reply |
    • 5 6
      That progressive reading group sounds like loads of fun. More entertaining than the pub or the football game, I bet.
      Reply |
    • This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.
    • 6 7
      Men need to step up and actually help women out at home and at work
      struggling with this. How are we supposed to help women out at work without appearing unequal?
      'oh you are a woman, you can't carry that. here, give it to me' ?
      Reply |
    • 7 8
      Men did that.
      What is this "men" you speak of, and why am I responsible for its actions?
      Reply |
    • 2 3
      I rather think gender imbalance is an issue created and maintained by society. Its true that many men don't see it as their problem and so do disproportionately become part of the problem, but to say 'men did that' is an unhelpful blame game.
      I understand the frustration, perhaps we can say that more men need to step up to the plate on this issue? I know it sucks having to be polite, to take the high road and keep focused on the ultimate goal.. but you cant win an argument if your opponents feel so attacked they stop listening to you.
      Reply |
    • 9 10
      Like Sandberg before you, I never see the full details of your child care arrangements, your joint income, your assets etc. If you supplied that information I could then share mine to explain why I work 60+ hours a week and my wife looks after the house and children. In an ideal world it would be 50/50 but in reality to make the most sensible choices with the resources available. I don't feel guilty about this but you should for making the assumption that it's got anything to do with gender imbalance.
      Reply |
      • This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.
      • 0 1
        I work 60+ hours a week and my wife looks after the house and children
        With respect, I feel you may have missed her point. Your situation is a pretty reasonable sharing of duties, imo. What she's getting at, or rather who she's getting at, are those men whose wives also work full time yet the men do not do their fair share of domestic chores. And, more to the point, it is not 'helping'. In your case, anything you do would, I would suggest, BE helping, as you have sorted out the responsibilities in the way you have. However, all too many women (and men) talk about husbands 'helping' when they, the women, work just as many hours outside the home as their husbands do.
        Reply |
    • 7 8
      Different biological roles are what has shaped our society structure. This is why there is consistency among virtually every culture that has ever existed regarding gender roles. There wasn't a meeting where men just decided roles.
      Reply |
      • 0 1
        Irrelevant point. If you chose to share the roles in the traditional way, then there's no problem. The point is when BOTH husbands and wives go out to work (their choice!) yet one does not do their share of domestic work.
        Reply |
      • 0 1
        This is true, and I don't think you're wrong for saying it, however, biology is not destiny. Living in extremely technologically based society, we can and we have transcended many biological limitations imposed on human societies for its first 150-200 thousand years. Change won't happen overnight, but it can happen.
        Reply |
    • 0 1
      It is simply about sharing. Whether between siblings, couples, friends or colleagues.
      Reply |
    • This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.
    • 7 8
      Isn't the obvious place to start in evening out domestic responsibility to campaign for equal access to children upon divorce?
      Reply |
    • 2 3
      It is rather ironic that under an article arguing that men should do more of the parenting, many of the comments use the term 'mother' or its variants to describe the childcare role.
      If you exclude us in the very language, how do you expect us to feel welcome in the role?
      Reply |
    • 4 5
      Your article is dangerous, Jessica, you go from men not washing enough forks to women are not natural care givers when it comes to children. If you were a family lawyer you would see how rare it is for women to let go of custody of the her children. I believe you either don't have children, or if you do, you are just following orders, to come up with an article such as this. Yes, Jessica, women are the carers in the same way the majority of mammals are. In fact, for this very reason, women are more dependent on men then your boss would like you to admit. Your article is pure social engineering.
      Reply |
    • 3 4
      If men help it's seen as being patronising "women don't need men thank you"...etc.
      If men don't help it's seen as them not being helpful, gender imbalance etc.
      Reply |
    • 1 2
      For some reason im reminded of a story concerning Rick Parfitt of Status Quo ...One of his many wives was pregnant and her waters had broken ....she asked him to take her to the hospital ...Ricks response ? " You're jokin , Fulhams playin at home today "
      Wife had to phone an ambulance to take her ...
      Proper lad ... : )
      Reply |
    • 1 2
      Young educated women are finally out earning young men reflecting decades of harder work at school . Therefore young men must start playing a more dynamic role if they want to live with their partners in a more equal partnership than when the man held the purse.
      Reply |
    • 1 2
      I think this article underemphasises the revolutionary change required to achieve the stated goal. It's going to take more than some husbands agreeing to do more housework.
      Reply |
    1 2 3 4 14 next
     
    SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone. See the Facebook Help Center for more information.
    SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone. See the Facebook Help Center for more information.
    desktop
    0%
    10%
    20%
    30%
    40%
    50%
    60%
    70%
    80%
    90%
    100%