全 3 件のコメント

[–]ThaddelSchäbiger Lump 1ポイント2ポイント  (2子コメント)

Discipline alone, however, rarely suffices to explain conformity; on the contrary, when administered in disproportionate doses, and especially in conscript armies, it may well cause rather than prevent mutiny.

I'm not sure, but could you use the 1918 mutiny in Kiel and beyond as an example for this point?

[–]commiespaceinvaderI'm Victor who writes all the history[S] 2ポイント3ポイント  (1子コメント)

Kiel not so much because the mutiny broke out when it became clear that the soldiers were ordered to their deaths but a perfect example would be the mutiny on the Potemkin in 1905 when officers tried to force sailors to eat food riddled with maggots by threatening harsh disciplinary measures including shooting them.

I am certain though that you could find several examples of this in Germany at the end of WWI and it goes right into what the Soldatenräte demanded in many places.

[–]AstrogatorThere is only one Guderian, and Rommel is his prophet. [スコア非表示]  (0子コメント)

The harsh disciplinary responses to the mutiny that was at first confined to Ist and IIIrd Squadron exacerbated and catalyzed the response of the sailors when back in port, though - and in the following events, the demands of the sailors were mainly directed at the tight discipline that governed their lives.