The Soapbox: Did Fatphobia Enable Jared Fogle’s Predatory Behavior?

Audra Williams / August 24, 2015
share
837
56
1
0
0
Quick, what is literally every single thing you know about Jared Fogle? My guess is that it is:
  1. He lost a lot of weight by eating Subway sandwiches, and
  2. He was recently arrested on charges of raping children.
It seems like a lot of people are having a hard time marrying those two realities. It is as if the first fact makes the second even more shocking than it would be otherwise. Because in our culture, the most morally pure thing a person can do is lose weight.
A few years ago, the infamous then-Mayor of Toronto Rob Ford was embroiled in a Venn Diagram of scandals involving crack cocaine, alcoholism, racist comments, conflict-of-interest charges, graphic sexual comments about his colleagues, and overall incompetence. As these issues were exploding around him, he explained how he was going to regain his credibility:
“The only way people are going to respect me, to bring back my image, is if I lose weight,” he said. “The rest falls into place.”
This attitude was echoed in the mainstream media. Even though cocaine use and alcoholism are linked with weight loss rather than gainNational Post Editor Jonathan Kay insisted,“If Ford shows up at election time having dropped a bunch of clothing sizes, many of us might be inclined to believe that he’s dropped the booze and crack as well.”
The same redemption arc plays out with celebrities. Tabloid punching bag Snooki appeared on the cover of Us Weekly smiling and repentant after losing 42 pounds, next to a heavier picture of herself with an opaque spray tan and duckface. After Paula Deen’s use of racist language became public, she resurfaced 35 pounds lighter and shilling a new low-fat cookbook.
No matter who does it, or what their methods are, weight loss is is consistently described as “inspiring” or “a triumph.”
So when Jared Fogle first appeared on the scene in 1998, having lost 245 pounds through eating at Subway, he was given a hero’s welcome. Over the next 15 years, he appeared in 300 commercials, earned over 15 million dollars, and established his own not-for-profit foundation to fight childhood obesity. But did he even try to hide his predatory behavior? I mean, the guys told a female reporter that he found middle school girls “hot,” and asked for video footage of her own children.
At the same time this was going on, Fogle was considered a wholesome and positive role model for everyone. And since his foundation focused on “child obesity,” he was given steady access to children across the country. Because how could anyone who had successfully reduced his percentage of adipose tissue be anything but a fantastic guy?
This deification of those who lose weight is a natural offshoot of fatphobia. This attitude towards weight and a person’s character starts really young, with small children not wanting to play with “the fat kid.” As that fat kid grows up, they will earn tens of thousands of dollars a year less than their thinner counterparts, and suffer possibly life-threatening misdiagnoses as a result of anti-fat-bias present in many doctors.
Favoring thin people over fat people has been happening for ages (although certainly not for all of history), but it is rapidly getting worse. There is a constant media frenzy about an “obesity epidemic,” in spite of evidence that such a thing doesn’t exist:
“The average American’s weight gain can be explained by 10 extra calories a day, or the equivalent of a Big Mac once every 2 months. Exercise equivalents would be a few minutes of walking every day.”
There is no link between body size and morality, full stop. Reinforcing the opposite is dangerous for all of us. It creates a situation in which Chris Christie can let a citizen die in a manufactured traffic slowdown, then lose 85 pounds, and be declared “fit enough to be President.” It also let Jared Fogle walk into a Subway with a pair of giant pants, and walk out headed towards nearly 20 years of fame, fortune, and credibility.
Audra Williams first connected to another computer via a modem in grade 7, when she dialed into a local BBS and got in her first internet argument. She’s been online ever since, talking about feminism, politics, and culture, while attempting to achieve the credibility and confidence of a mediocre white man. Follow her on Twitter at @audrawilliams.

Comments

We were unable to load Disqus. If you are a moderator please see our troubleshooting guide.
Avatar
Join the discussion…

  • in this conversation
⬇ Drag and drop your images here to upload them.
        Media preview placeholder
        Log in with
        or sign up with Disqus or pick a name
        ?

        Disqus is a discussion network

        • Disqus never moderates or censors. The rules on this community are its own.
        • Your email is safe with us. It's only used for moderation and optional notifications.
        • Don't be a jerk or do anything illegal. Everything is easier that way.
        By signing up, you agree to the Disqus Basic Rules, Terms of Service, and Privacy Policy.
        By posting, you agree to the Disqus Basic Rules, Terms of Service, and Privacy Policy.
        • Avatar
          EmSpeaks 4 hours ago
          The horror surrounding Fogle is not so much "How could someone who lost a lot of weight do these terrible things?" but more "How could someone who seems so harmless and likable and average be capable of this?"
          The belief that weight loss = morality is definitely harmful and definitely too common, but I don't think that's what's going on here. I think the shock about Fogle is that he had a public persona of being an "average guy" ("I'm just like you: I've struggled with my weight and I like sandwiches!") while committing horrible crimes and breaking numerous social and moral taboos.
            see more
            • Casagordita a day ago
              Not exactly the same thing--I wasn't hurting anyone but myself--but I've seen how fatphobia can blind people to how screwed up somebody is, as long as they're losing weight.
              When I was 19, I went on an extreme liquid protein diet, ate no solid food at all for six months (with my doctor's blessings!), and rapidly lost over 80 pounds. Besides all the physical complications I had from the malnutrition, I developed some pretty bizarre and destructive psychological problems and behaviors. I didn't eat any of it, but I spent every night down the hall in the shared kitchen in my dorm, baking goodies and giving them away to my neighbors. I started stealing cookbooks from the campus bookstore--the only time in my life I ever shoplifted. I was also developing a pretty significant drug problem, and between that and my crazy all-night baking marathons, I didn't make it to very many of my classes. By the end of that semester I had to drop all of them to avoid failing everything. And yet...almost everybody I knew kept going on and on and on about how great I was doing, how wonderful it was that I'd lost all that weight, what a fabulous change for the better, etc. etc. My boss at my job on campus (who'd hired me in the midst of all this for a really competitive and responsible job, who was somebody I admired and considered a mentor) told me that she'd never seen such a dramatic, positive change in a person. Nobody could see past the weight loss--not to my dry, pasty-white skin, my hair that was falling out by the handful, my constant nausea and fainting spells, or the fact that I was hanging on by my fingernails, threatening to make a mess of my life in a dozen different ways, close to a breakdown, physically and mentally.
              Eventually I ended the diet, gained a lot of the weight back really fast (and the rest of it, and then some, eventually). I got back in school and started doing better there (funny how actually going to class will do that). I gave up the obsessive baking and the shoplifting. My drug problem hung around for a few more years, but I did manage to cut back for a while. But all the attention and the glowing praise that I'd been getting went away pretty fast, as soon as my waist size stopped dropping. Most people who knew me then probably thought they were too polite to say anything to my face, but I'm sure they were shaking their heads and telling each other how sad it was that I'd fallen off the wagon and couldn't sustain all that wonderful, positive change. They never had a freakin' clue.
                see more
                • Avatar
                  Marty 2 days ago
                  Was he REALLY arrested on charges of "raping children". I think you chose your words in such a way simply for shock value*
                  *not saying this to excuse his disgusting behaviour.
                    see more
                    • Molly Spurgeon 3 days ago
                      I dont know that I arrived at exactly the same conclusion, but I. AM glad to see someone mention this because I was wondering myself why people seemed especially shocked by Jared 's secret (besides the obvious fact that its generally shocking anytime anyone is this horrific) when we know literally nothing about him other than his sandwich diet. I wasnt any more shocked by this discovery than I would have been if he wasnt the face of a sandwich chain. Hell, look at the head of Jimmy Johns. And dude's just got that creeper vibe about him too. Why are his lips always wet & his eyes always creeping?! Blechhhh
                        see more
                        • jovan1984 3 days ago
                          This question in the title is a whole lotta nope.
                          Fogle was always a skeevy, predatory dude. Men like this can be spotted even before they get famous. I say he was doing this even before he touted his weight loss regimen.
                          Terry Richardson, Bill Cosby and Woody Allen ring a bell?
                            see more
                          • Tiffanie Drayton 3 days ago
                            Very interesting take on this whole Jared Fogle mess! You definitely have a point.
                              see more

                              Join The Frisky Weekly Romp

                              Thank you for signing up for our newsletter. You will receive a confirmation shortly.
                              SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone. See the Facebook Help Center for more information.
                              SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone. See the Facebook Help Center for more information.
                              0%
                              10%
                              20%
                              30%
                              40%
                              50%
                              60%
                              70%
                              80%
                              90%
                              100%