コンテンツにジャンプする
自分のsubreddit
announcementsArtAskRedditaskscienceawwblogbookscreepydataisbeautifulDIYDocumentariesEarthPornexplainlikeimfiveFitnessfoodfunnyFuturologygadgetsgamingGetMotivatedgifshistoryIAmAInternetIsBeautifulJokesLifeProTipslistentothismildlyinterestingmoviesMusicnewsnosleepnottheonionOldSchoolCoolpersonalfinancephilosophyphotoshopbattlespicsscienceShowerthoughtsspacesportstelevisiontifutodayilearnedTwoXChromosomesUpliftingNewsvideosworldnewsWritingPrompts購読管理
  • フロント
  • -すべて
  • -ランダム
 | 
  • gadgets
  • -sports
  • -gaming
  • -pics
  • -worldnews
  • -videos
  • -AskReddit
  • -aww
  • -Music
  • -funny
  • -news
  • -movies
  • -books
  • -history
  • -food
  • -philosophy
  • -television
  • -Jokes
  • -Art
  • -DIY
  • -space
  • -Documentaries
  • -Fitness
  • -askscience
  • -nottheonion
  • -todayilearned
  • -personalfinance
  • -gifs
  • -listentothis
  • -IAmA
  • -TwoXChromosomes
  • -creepy
  • -nosleep
  • -GetMotivated
  • -WritingPrompts
  • -LifeProTips
  • -EarthPorn
  • -explainlikeimfive
  • -Showerthoughts
  • -Futurology
  • -photoshopbattles
  • -mildlyinteresting
  • -dataisbeautiful
  • -tifu
  • -OldSchoolCool
  • -UpliftingNews
  • -InternetIsBeautiful
  • -science
もっと »
badhistory badhistory
  • 注目
  • 新着
  • 上昇度
  • 論争中
  • トップ
  • ゴールド
  • wiki
  • スポンサードリンク
参加されますか?数秒でサインイン または アカウントを作成できます。|
  • 日本語

use the following search parameters to narrow your results:

subreddit:subreddit
「subreddit」で投稿を探す
author:username
「ユーザー名」で投稿を探す
site:example.com
「example.com」から投稿を探す
url:text
URL内の「文章」を検索
selftext:text
自分の投稿コメント内の「文章」を検索
self:yes (or self:no)
自分の投稿を含む(または除外する)
nsfw:yes (or nsfw:no)
閲覧注意とされた結果を表示する(もしくは表示しない)

e.g. subreddit:aww site:imgur.com dog

詳しくは検索FAQを参照

高度な検索: 投稿者や、subredditで……

パスワードをリセットする
Submit some bad history

badhistory

登録登録解除46,578 人の登録者

~85 人のユーザーが現在閲覧しています

Badcademics Association Member

August Moratorium: Lost Cause/States' Rights, Hitler/Nazi/Wehrmacht Apologia, and Confederate flag history

Badhistory is a place to facepalm and discuss the particularly dire sorts of history that we encounter on a day-to-day basis. Although we primarily focus on Reddit, history from anywhere is welcome whether it's from school, tv, books, real life conversations, movies, or anything else.

This means that we sometimes do serious discussions on trivial topics! If it's got badhistory in it, it's fair game. This includes (but is certainly not limited to) topics as diverse as 5 minute YouTube clips, Disney animated shows, and even the odd pornographic film. We are also aware that these things are fiction and are intended to entertain, but being entertainment doesn't give it a free pass on badhistory!

Rule 1: No voting in linked threads. Brigading may result in bans and deletions of linked threads. /r/badhistory is not your personal army, so don't come running for reinforcements when in a discussion on reddit. To help prevent brigading, links that don't use np (as in 'np.reddit.com') will be deleted by Auto-Moderator until they are fixed.

Rule 2: No current (post-Cold War) political badhistory posts, or comments. Discussion of politics within a historical context, and badhistory by current political figures are allowed. The discussion of modern politics, however, is not allowed.

Rule 2a: Badhistory comparing current political figures or events to the past are not allowed. Check /r/panichistory, /r/godwinslaw, /r/badpolitics or /r/conspiratard to see if your post should go there.

Rule 3: Blatant conspiracy theories should be posted to /r/conspiratard. However, we do not wish to discourage the posting of bad history that is an underlying part of a conspiracy theory. Please use your best judgment and apply the "reasonable person" standard when unsure.

Rule 4: Please remain civil and show respect for the other people of /r/badhistory. Don't insult others or use racist or bigoted language. Use of derogatory slurs, accusations of mental illness or disability, etc., will lead to removal of the comment and a possibly a warning or ban if deemed appropriate. Wheaton's Law (Don't be an ass) is the guiding principle behind this rule.

Rule 5: Please remember to include a description of why your submission is bad history. If no explanation is included with the post, the post will be removed until one is included. Explanations are necessary even if the bad history seems obvious. These are the minimum requirements for an acceptable R5:

  1. A quote from the person or group perpetrating the badhistory. No link dumping allowed.
  2. A quote from an appropriate source directly refuting the badhistory, or your own explanation of why the selected quote is badhistory. Simply leaving a link and saying "Here's the explanation" isn't enough. Quote the pertinent parts of the refutation in your post.

Sources for answers can come from a variety of places.

  • Many common bad history tropes can be found in our Wiki.
  • Also check the /r/AskHistorians FAQ for even more great answers.
  • Wikipedia can be used for basic fact checking
  • Another reddit comment (assuming that the reddit comment is a good one of course)
  • Books you've read, as long as you name the specific book.
  • Even documentaries that you've watched can be a good source, as long as you name the specific documentary.

Posts submitted without these bare minimum requirements will be removed until they're updated.

/R/BadHistory Wiki


Badhistory Best Of


/r/BadHistory reviews/criticisms of movies, art, and other media


/u/NMW on second-option bias in history education.


The /r/BadSubHub IRC (Follow the rules!)


/r/badhistory Inside Jokes (All praise the Volcano and Edward's time machine)


Cards Against History - The BadHistory CAH set


Similar subreddits

  • /r/Anachronism
  • /r/AskHistorians
  • /r/BadIRC
  • /r/BadArtHistory
  • /r/BadHistory2
  • /r/GodwinsLaw
  • /r/HistoryNetwork
  • /r/bad_religion
  • /r/badlinguistics
Kai_DaigojiProducer of CO2 が作成コミュニティができてから 2年
モデレーターにメッセージを送る

調停者

  • Kai_DaigojiProducer of CO2
  • TurnshroudPresident Raiko is literally Sozin
  • Georgy_K_ZhukovLend Lease? We don't need no stinking 'Lend Lease'!
  • ShroudofTuringSuccess Nixon
  • caesar10022O'Reilly, Bill. Killing Christians: How Muslims Are Genocidal
  • Samuel_GompersPaid Shill for Big Doughboy.
  • smileyman
  • turtleeatingaldermanAcademo-Fascist
  • cordis_melumLiterally Skynet-Mao
  • AutoModerator
  • ...他に 4 です。 »

subscribe to our newsletter

_('thanks for subscribing')

get the best of reddit, delivered once a week

×

40
41
42

DiscussionMindless Monday, 03 August 2015 (self.badhistory)

AutoModerator[M] が 14時間前 投稿 - stickied post

  • 220個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

•
•
•

Your friendly dictators reminding you about some R&R (self.badhistory)

smileyman が 11分前 投稿 - stickied post

  • 4個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

1
65
66
67

1844 - A year in which Baha'i was not founded (self.badhistory)

Quouarthe Weather History Slayer が 5時間前 投稿

  • 28個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

2
73
74
75

Great moments in how your "satirical" comic annoys me (self.badhistory)

Quouarthe Weather History Slayer が 1日前 投稿

  • 164個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

3
138
139
140

Those who reject Climate Change aren't the only type of denialists rampant in Australia: Denying the Stolen Generations (self.badhistory)

ManicMarineSemper Hindustan Super Omnes が 1日前 投稿

  • 91個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

4
333
334
335

A preview of my comprehensive reading of "Killing Patton," in which Bill O'Reilly is wrong. Warning: This will hurt your brain. (self.badhistory)

kmmontandonGoing bowling in the Alamo's basement. が 2日前 投稿

  • 114個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

5
66
67
68

Media Review"What am I supposed to do with it? Stick it up my ass?" Bad computer history in Deutschland 83 (self.badhistory)

smileyman が 2日前 * 投稿

  • 39個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

6
140
141
142

On the topic of things that are no longer on the moratorium (self.badhistory)

Quouarthe Weather History Slayer が 2日前 投稿

  • 89個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

7
45
46
47

MetaAugust Moratorium: Lost Cause/States' Rights, Confederate Flag history, and Hitler/Nazi/Wehrmacht Apologia! (self.badhistory)

Quouarthe Weather History Slayer[M] が 2日前 投稿

  • 44個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

8
22
23
24

DiscussionSaturday Studies, 01 August 2015 (self.badhistory)

AutoModerator[M] が 2日前 投稿

  • 25個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

9
209
210
211

"Yes, artillery was very new [in 1914] . . .The Germans were so successful with it against the French. . .that the other armies of Europe hastily clamoured to build their own through fear of being the next victims, with no obvious defense against such tactics. It was the A-Bomb of its era." (self.badhistory)

elos_Literally the Treaty of Versailles が 3日前 * 投稿

  • 95個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

10
14
15
16

MetaBadhistory Universalis Episode 2: The Christian Dark Ages Strike Back will return at UTC 1900, approximately 12.5 hours from this post. (self.badhistory)

ManicMarineSemper Hindustan Super Omnes が 2日前 * 投稿

  • 4個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

11
271
272
273

Have you heard the good news! Nazi Germany still exists! (self.badhistory)

GodHatesCanada が 3日前 * 投稿

  • 122個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

12
127
128
129

"Oh, really? The Native Americans had a vast first world civilization, industry, welfare systems, military forces, and legal systems? Sorry, I'm not a sociopath so I don't believe keeping the world a nature preserve for the stone age is the best thing for humanity. " (self.badhistory)

neveranerevarine が 3日前 * 投稿

  • 92個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

13
191
192
193

DiscussionAre there any widely accepted historical facts or interpretations that aren't necessarily bad but you consider highly improbable? (self.badhistory)

hborrggI hear that Islam was spread by Curved Swords. Curved! Swords! が 4日前 投稿

  • 342個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

14
185
186
187

A look at my AP US History textbook, "The American Pageant": Minor historical inaccuracies; pompous, awkward, and confusing choices made by the authors; and very, very purple prose (self.badhistory)

TemporaryCritic が 4日前 * 投稿

  • 169個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

15
25
26
27

DiscussionThoughts for Thursday, 30 July 2015 (self.badhistory)

AutoModerator[M] が 4日前 投稿

  • 124個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

16
207
208
209

The reason Christianity flourished in ancient Rome is because the Romans didn't really practice religion seriously, and anyway the new Christ mythology was the same as the old. (self.badhistory)

The_vert が 5日前 * 投稿

  • 154個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

17
122
123
124

The Documentary HELLSTORM (self.badhistory)

whatismooElders of Zion 2, Jewgalectric JewgaJew: Part I, The Jewening が 5日前 * 投稿

  • 150個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

18
202
203
204

Bad History in r/badhistory: Late Antiquity and the Making of the Islamic World (self.badhistory)

shlin28 が 6日前 * 投稿

  • 71個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

19
305
306
307

NINA (No Irish Need Apply) Emeritus Professor stakes an article on induction, gets schooled by high schooler's google fu. (self.badhistory)

ryhntyntyn<--- hates this sub. が 7日前 * 投稿

  • 178個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

20
32
33
34

MetaAugust moratorium voting! (self.badhistory)

Quouarthe Weather History Slayer[M] が 7日前 投稿

  • 90個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

21
35
36
37

DiscussionMindless Monday, 27 July 2015 (self.badhistory)

AutoModerator[M] が 7日前 投稿

  • 307個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

22
245
246
247

Clash of Civilizations, revisted: "Islam is and always has been a threat to the safe existence of civilised culture." (self.badhistory)

TiakoTevinter apologist, shill for Big Lyrium が 8日前 投稿

  • 436個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

23
338
339
340

"It was Adolph Hitler who hated Jews, not the National Socialism movement. Hitler popularized the movement and corrupted it with his hatred of the Jews." (self.badhistory)

DraewaJewish Neo-Nazi in a deep identity crisis が 8日前 * 投稿

  • 125個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

24
68
69
70

Media Review[Media Review] America Unearthed S1E01: American Maya Secrets (self.badhistory)

AnthonyNiceAgent of Big Smithsonian が 8日前 * 投稿

  • 41個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...

25
58
59
60

DiscussionSaturday Studies, 25 July 2015 (self.badhistory)

AutoModerator[M] が 9日前 投稿

  • 107個のコメント
  • シェアする
loading...
続きを見る 次 ›
  • 情報
  • ブログ
  • 情報
  • values
  • チーム
  • ソースコード
  • 広告を載せる
  • 採用情報
  • ヘルプ
  • サイトのルール
  • よくある質問
  • ウィキ
  • redditエチケット
  • 透明性レポート
  • お問い合わせ
  • アプリとツール
  • Alien Blue iOS アプリ
  • reddit AMA アプリ
  • mobile beta
  • 各種ボタン
  • <3
  • reddit gold
  • redditストア
  • redditgifts
  • reddit.tv

本サイトを利用すると、利用規約およびプライバシーポリシーに合意したものとみなされます。 . © 2015 reddit inc. All rights reserved.

REDDIT and the ALIEN Logo are registered trademarks of reddit inc.

π Rendered by PID 1050 on app-212 at 2015-08-04 02:07:28.859129+00:00 running dc83615 country code: JP.