あなたは単独のコメントのスレッドを見ています。

残りのコメントをみる →

[–]justcool393 304ポイント305ポイント  (8子コメント)

Hi everyone answering these questions. I have a "few" questions that I, like probably most of reddit would like answers to. Like a recent AMA I asked questions in, the bold will be the meat of the question, and the non-bolded will be context. If you don't know an answer to a question, say so, and do so directly! Honesty is very much appreciated. With that said, here goes.

Content Policy

  1. What is the policy regarding content that has distasteful speech, but not harassing? Some subreddits have been known to harbor ideologies such as Nazism or racist ones. Are users, and by extension subreddits, allowed to behave in this way, or will this be banned or censored?

  2. What is the policy regarding, well, these subreddits? These subreddits are infamous on reddit as a whole. These usually come up during AskReddit threads of "where would you not go" or whenever distasteful subreddits are mentioned.

  3. What actually is the harassment policy? Yes, I know the definition that's practically copypasta from the announcement, but could we have examples? You don't have to define a hard rule, in fact, it'd probably be best if there was a little subjectivity to avoid lawyering, but it'd be helpful to have an example.

  4. What are your thoughts on some people's interpretation of the rules as becoming a safe-space? A vocal group of redditors interpreted the new harassment rules as this, and as such are not happy about it. I personally didn't read the rules that way, but I can see how it may be interpreted that way.

  5. Do you have any plans to update the rules page? It, at the moment, has 6 rules, and the only one that seems to even address the harassment policy is rule 5, which is at best reaching in regards to it.

  6. What is the best way to report harassment? For example, should we use /r/reddit.com's modmail or the contact@reddit.com email? How long should we wait before bumping a modmail, for example? 6. Who is allowed to report harassment? Say I'm a moderator, and decide to check a user's history and see they've followed around another user to 20 different subreddits posting the same thing or whatnot. Should I report it to the admins?

Brigading

  1. In regards to subreddits for mocking another group, what is the policy on them? Subreddits that highlight other places being stupid or whatever, such as /r/ShitRedditSays, /r/SRSsucks, the "Badpire", /r/Buttcoin or pretty much any sub dedicated to mocking people frequently brigade each other and other places on reddit. SRS has gone out of it's way to harass in the past, and while bans may not be applied retroactively, some have recently said they've gotten death threats after being linked to from there.

  2. What are the current plans to address brigading? Will reddit ever support NP (and maybe implement it) or implement another way to curb brigading? This would solve very many problems in regards to meta subreddits.

    1. Is this a good definition of brigading, and if not, what is it? Many mods and users can't give a good explanation of it at the moment of what constitutes it. This forces them to resort to in SubredditDrama's case, banning voting or commenting altogether in linked threads, or in ShitRedditSays' case, not do anything at all.

Related

  1. What is spam? Like yes, we know what obvious spam is, but there have been a number of instances in the past where good content creators have been banned for submitting their content.
  2. Regarding the "Neither Alexis or I created reddit to be a bastion of free speech" comment, how do you feel about this, this, this or this? I do get that opinions change and that I could shit turds that could search reddit better than it does right now, but it's not hard to see that you said on multiple occasions, especially during the /r/creepshots debacle, even with the literal words "bastion of free speech".
  3. How do you plan to implement the new policy? If the policy is substantially more restrictive, such as combating racism or whatnot, I think you'll have a problem in the long run, because there is just way too much content on reddit, and it will inevitably be applied very inconsistently. Many subreddits have popped back up under different names after being banned.
  4. Did you already set the policy before you started the AMA, and if so, what was the point of it? It seems like from the announcement, you had already made up your mind about the policy regarding content on reddit, and this has made some people understandably upset.
  5. Do you have anything else to say regarding the recent events? I know this has been stressful, but reddit is a cool place and a lot of people use it to share neat (sometimes untrue, but whatever) experiences and whatnot. I don't think the vast majority of people want reddit to implode on itself, but some of the recent decisions and remarks made by the admin team (and former team to be quite honest) are quite concerning.

[–]LvL99OnionKnight 2ポイント3ポイント  (0子コメント)

People consider /r/watchpeopledie a terrible offensive subreddit? is it not akin to /r/MorbidReality but to a greater extent?

[–]FakeyFaked 4ポイント5ポイント  (1子コメント)

Brigading is a separate issue and probably shouldn't be talked about in regard to content.

[–]CSMastermind 0ポイント1ポイント  (0子コメント)

I think he's pointing out that the existing rules are selectively enforced to censor only the things they don't like. So the new ones will likely be selectively enforced as well. At this point Shit Reddit Says could probably post a live stream of them doxing and intimidating people and I'm sure they'd be allowed to continue as a sub.

[–]stopscopiesme 5ポイント6ポイント  (1子コメント)

you went way easier on them than you did on us in our ama!

[–]justcool393 5ポイント6ポイント  (0子コメント)

well i gave you snarky questions as well. i didnt give circlejerk questions to them ☺

[–]Yoinkie2013 0ポイント1ポイント  (0子コメント)

I have nothing to add, just wanted to say well done for being so prepared for this AMA. Let's see if any of these get answered.

[–]Brenbren25 0ポイント1ポイント  (0子コメント)

Hah - I thought this was an SRS post when I saw the size of it. Good questions.

[–]BaneWilliams -2ポイント-1ポイント  (0子コメント)

Re #2 in Content Policy.

As I've stated before.

As a psychopath and an erotophonophile, I'm particularly glad many of those subs exist. It's subs like those that act as release/mitigation valves for people with my condition, and there is a frighteningly large number of us in existence.

I feel if things like that prevent people from going out and doing it in real life, then that is excellent and should be promoted.