Men, we’re better than porn

by Stephen Bick
Like
Like
You and 15,179 others like this.15,179 people like this. Sign Up to see what your friends like.
The Tab isn’t the only thing you close when your mum walks in
This Caesarian Sunday, many men showed their solidarity for women with teal ribbons indicating their support for Cambridge for Consent.
That night, a good number of them went home and masturbated to videos of women being subjected to physical and verbal abuse by men.
What’s wrong with this picture?
A lot of men in Cambridge are feminist and proud. They condemn the idea of sexual violence.  Of sex without consent.  But what no one wants to talk about is that a good number of them are addicted to porn.  And what they do says more than what they say.
I should know. I was one of them.  It would be hypocritical of me to condemn others for watching porn given the years I was addicted to it.  In fact, most men watch porn – and it’s a gendered phenomenon.  The NUS tells us that only 8% of male university students in the UK have never watched porn – as compared to 50% of women.
I thought it was just me and pixels on a screen.
I go incognito when I need to read TCS.
I go incognito when I need to read TCS.
The reality is that porn is a lot more than that.  It contributes to a climate of sexual violence. Even mainstream porn is full of women being physically and verbally abused:  a 2008 study showed that 88% of scenes in the most popular porn films contained physical aggression and that 95% of the victims of aggression responded either neutrally or with pleasure.
In most of the porn we watch, women are getting beaten up, and they’re happy about it.  We fight to stop violence against women in Parker’s Piece and clubs.  But we don’t bat an eyelid when it’s on our laptops.
It shouldn’t surprise us that we are influenced by what we watch.  Studies have found that exposure to even non-violent porn is correlated with a greater likelihood of accepting rape myths, of using coercion or alcohol to get sex, and of viewing dominant or abusive relations as the norm.
It reinforces gender inequality – women are reduced to their bodies.  And not even their whole bodies.
Porn test: if you see boobs instead of a two-headed person, you have a problem.
Porn test: if you see boobs instead of a two-headed person, you have a problem.
As the Polish philosopher Karol Wojtyła put it: “The problem with pornography is not that it shows too much of the person, but that it shows far too little.”
Porn presents women as objects to satisfy men.  It reinforces the lie that we have a right to sexual satisfaction from women whenever we want it.
But what I don’t understand is why we’re settling for porn in the first place. Sex is amazing precisely because it is an act of knowing and loving someone else.
We don’t have sex just because of the biological urge: it’s part of being human. We need to be connected to other people.
But porn is nothing like sex. It makes us lonely and harms our relationships with women.
Gee, if only I hadn't watch all that porn, I might be able to look a woman in the eye.
If only I hadn’t watched all that porn, I might be able to look a woman in the eye.
It gives us unrealistic expectations that our sexual partners couldn’t possibly meet.  It doesn’t celebrate our sexuality. It cheapens it. We sell it off for a joyless orgasm.
We’re like kids who think the wrapping paper is the real present.
Many porn users find it harder to be aroused by a real person.  Some can’t even maintain an erection without porn.
We settle for porn and pass it off as something you just do.  But we actually know it’s wrong.  That’s why you draw the curtains and wait for your roomie to leave.
If any of the above resonates with you, there’s help. Russell Brand – yes, really – has promoted a new website, Fight the New Drug, which gives information on how porn harms your brain, your relationships and the world.
Sexual liberation doesn’t mean we should accept without questioning anything that involves sexual pleasure.
The world needs men who don’t just think equality, but live it.  If you’re complacent about your porn use, you’re not a feminist.
Do you want to write for The Tab? Click here to sign up.
  • Cam Polack
    I enjoy how Pope John Paul II has been relegated to merely a ‘Polish Philosopher’.
  • hmm
    I watch horror films, but have no inclination to commit murder.
    Can our tastes in viewing not be kept separate from our desire towards action?
    • different
      I think there’s a difference between watching a horror movie (or watching a sexual violence scene in game of thrones) and wanking over one
    • alex
      I see what you’re saying but i think it’s more of a cultural thing. Like on an individual level perhaps there’s not much inclination, but on a societal level where any non-feminist porn is still the norm then i think he has a point
  • Feminist
    “Sex is amazing precisely because it is an act of knowing and loving someone else.” Is it? Really?
    Yeah you really have not understood the politics of porn here. Please stop giving us feminists a name as being stuck up and sexless. I watch shitloads of porn. Used well it’s a safe theatre for fantasies.
  • Sasha Grey
    Clearly the important point is that the sex in porn is entirely voluntary- both male and female actors choose to participate, and get paid well for what they do. In fact, porn actresses usually get paid more than their male counterparts! Most performers in the professional, regulated porn industry really enjoy what they do, and do it out of choice.
    • alex
      Of course you’re right there will be many actors who do enjoy it, but many people are trafficked into and exploited into porn
      • Sasha Grey
        All the more reason to make sure the porn industry is properly regulated and commercialised, and not left to dodgy underground websites/revenge porn etc.
    • But
      Just because the production of porn is voluntary – or at least it is some of the time – doesn’t mean it’s a good thing for the people who watch it or the kinds of attitudes that are produced in society.
  • AS
    Yes- Pornography creates an overall climate in which exploitation of women is both tolerated and tacitly encouraged.
  • This is so
    Horrifically heteronormative. What about gay porn??
    • Wrong point
      The writer is basing his article on his own experiences, since he hasn’t commented on this, I presume he doesn’t have experience of it. It would therefore seem more offensive to comment and get it wrong?
    • https://soundcloud.com/aloysiusmusic Aloysius
      What about women who watch porn?
  • Tom
    Haha. Tough sh*t feminists. You dug your grave, now sleep in it.
  • But…
    “If you’re complacent about your porn use, you’re not a feminist.”
    Thanks for telling us what feminism is, cis white male!
    • Spot on
      Preach, sister. Stephen is white, cis, hetero, male scum – and he needs to learn that only non-white trans women are the ones allowed to use the word ‘feminism’.
      • But…
        cool strawman mate
        All I’m saying is that Stephen, as a cis white male, should realise it’s really not his place to be defining feminism.
        • Come on, seriously ?
          This kind of comment is the one that makes men feel less welcome in fighting for feminism. Saying that someone can’t define one aspect of feminism even though they’ve been defending it wholeheartedly is just wrong.
          • Siobhan
            Look it’s simple. Feminism is OUR safe space, it’s a FEMALE safe space. Men are welcome to be allies, but they can NOT begin to define any aspect of feminism. They must learn that this is perhaps the only time in their overprivileged lives that they should not speak first.
          • Feminist
            Feminism is not for you. It is not something to be defined by male voices. It’s a reaction against the fact that far too much of the world is already dictated by men, and if you want to support feminism then you support it on the terms of the people it is relevant to, and you recognise the very real reasons why giving them a voice in their own movement is important.
    • ergusto
      I’m pretty sure this article is aimed specifically at men. It uses the pronouns ‘we’, and ‘us’ literally all the way through to indicate that this is a problem that men, specifically, need to deal with (author is male). I would agree with you that women don’t need men to define feminism for them, but I don’t think it’s such a stretch for them to point these things out to each other.
  • Greg Hill
    If you need another way to channel those hours you’d normally spend fapping in front of your faptop, may I heartily recommend a gym membership?
    The Homerton gym, which I built with my own bare hands, will help you even out those biceps after years of chronic masturbation addiction.
  • TPJ
    I don’t have time to watch porn. I’m too busy with under-21s training.
    • 4th Year
      It’s…it’s been so long, TPJ. We thought you were dead, but like the phoenix thou hast arisen!
  • Pauleen
    I heartily agree. Porn is all about exploitation of women – utterly disgusting. Men who watch porn (especially white cis men) are misogynists, living out their male power fantasies through the medium of porn. This unfortunately then filters into their everyday life, feeling that they are entitled to women and feelings of rampant misogyny. This culminates in what we see today; rape culture rife at our university with 1 in 3 females raped and over 80% victims of sexual assault.
    Obviously the solution is a university wide ban on all porn sites and all porn videos. Male students must have their laptops thoroughly searched upon entry into the university, alongside mandatory weekly consent and gender awareness classes. Only then can we work towards ending rape culture.
  • brb
    Having sex with curtains open and roommate watchingwatching
  • CHAD THUNDERCOCK
    GUESS IM NOT A FEMINIST THEN.
    LETS REVERSE SUFFRAGE.
  • BDSM =/= Abuse
    I agree that a large amount of porn is unpleasantly exploitative, but you really need to draw a distinction between abuse and aggression. Being into BDSM in a consensual context is totally and completely different from abuse, and it’s offensive to equate the two – both to BDSM fans and abuse victims. If both people are into it, there is nothing wrong with a bit of violence in sex, let alone aggression.
    You need to read your studies more carefully, too. From your link:
    “Exposure to nonviolent hard‐core pornography displayed no association net of the other variables.”
    It’s also pretty bad, as others have pointed out, that you totally disregard gay people in your article, probably because they don’t fit in well with your argument. Or does the porn gay men watch harm their relationships with women? Do lesbians have worse relationships with themselves after watching porn?
    It’s a boring oversimplification to say that porn is exploitation of women by men. That is often the case, but a bit of research would show you plenty of porn made by and for women – or porn that doesn’t involve women at all.
    Overall: 2.ii. Well-meaning but offensive.
    • Gay porn watcher
      Male gay porn is just as much about the domination and humiliation of the feminine as straight porn. The act of penetration is often seen to be painful in gay porn and about asserting the masculinity of the penetrator through his dominance of the emasculated penetrated. This plays into the cultural narrative of women as inferior and the feminine as humilating, so yes gay porn does harm women without even showing them.
      As for BDSM, I don’t mean to suggest there is anything wrong with it when practised safely and consensually, but I do think it is the product of a misogynisitc society. Physical violence against women is fetishised because it reproduces the dominant/submissive gender roles of our culture in a way that is not accepted openly. BDSM can exist with women in dominant roles and men in submissive roles, but this is eroticised through its inversion of the normal gender roles and so merely goes to strengthen the norm. That some people play into and eroticise their own subordination does not mean it is not a problem – people are a product of their culture and sexuality is a part of that.
      You’re right, the jury is still out on whether erotic imagination plays into societal conduct, but just ask yourselves whether you think there is something inherently sexual about subjugating women or whether it is the product of a culture that teaches us the superiority of masculinity over femininity but conspires not to admit it publicly. To my mind, whether or not it directly increases rates of violence, mainstream porn entrenches these values of dominance and subservience which are at the core of women’s oppression.
    • BDSM = violence = bad
      There’s nothing wrong with a bit of violence in sex – let alone aggression? Tell that to the victims of violence carried out by porn-watching men. Studies make it clear that violent porn makes you more likely to see dominant or abusive relationships as the norm. Tell it to the women who are subject to abuse in the making of this pornography. Consent might mean that something ought not to be criminalised. But it doesn’t mean that it’s good.
      And you need to avoid the selective quotation, too. If you’re going to talk about BDSM, at least lift a quote from the study that’s relevant to it. From the link:
      “Multivariate analysis indicated that the strongest correlates of sexual coercion and aggression, as well as rape proclivity, were exposure to hard‐core violent and rape pornography.”
      The reason why he doesn’t talk about gay people in his article is because there’s a whole other dynamic involved in other types of pornography – and he’s speaking from his own experience of pornography – and he’s speaking about the type of pornography on which there’s been done the most research.
      The vast majority of porn is not feminist porn. It is not lesbian porn, nor is it porn that doesn’t involve women at all. The vast majority of porn on the internet is made for the pleasure of men at the expense of women. It’s entirely fair to talk about porn as a gendered phenomenon that by and large is geared towards poorer attitudes to women.
      Overall: low to mid 2.ii. Valiant cries of ‘offensive!’ but clearly a pawn of the patriarchy.
  • didn’t read the whole article
    had a wank instead
SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone. See the Facebook Help Center for more information.
SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone. See the Facebook Help Center for more information.
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%